Tony Blair, George Bush and a whole slew of others have committed far worse crimes than to cost MC or PayPal a couple of hours of downtime and they're still walking around free and are nominated for all kinds of prizes. The sense of injustice the existence of something like Gitmo gives me is much stronger in comparison to the part of me that thinks that script kiddies should be brought to justice (or at a minimum stopped).
Besides this action having no net positive effect for WikiLeaks, the article cited above already pushes the notion that these attacks were in revenge for Assanges arrest and that is precisely the wrong signal to send.
Without the evil empire to play underdog to Julian Assange and WikiLeaks would be seen as a bunch of two bit hackers, now they are at the forefront of a movement that claims to want to improve society by enforcing greater transparency.
So I think equating the targets of these virtual sit-ins with any private organization, like a small start-up with 5 employees, isn't really telling the whole story.
The number of actors and / or actions are not the criteria by which this will be judged, but their intent.
The inevitable meta-argument that is going to result from me pointing this out will also be annoying and it will also prompt groans, but at least we'll be arguing about something relevant to Hacker News: whether "off-topic: most politics" actually means anything.
The American conservative element, endlessly on the wrong side of history, whose own policies have a great hand in fostering terrorism, whose own policies have brought the economy to its knees, absolutely needs its filthy little secrets.
Exactly how long do you want people to remain in milque-toast-mode before taking more direct action?
The two modern defintions are:
(1) "they should get off because they meant well/are good people"
and
(2) "they should get off because {x} is acceptable"
Which definition are we using here? If (3), what is {x} such that it is acceptable? Is it any DDoS? Any DDoS against a large organization? Please be precise so we can know what kind of DDoS are acceptable and which kind aren't going forward.
I think a lot of the issue stems with many people here having a conception of political change as being possible with very little conflict, and I don't think that's true.
There is no easy, polite way to pressure those with extraordinary power to act differently. And sometimes you have to do things that are illegal (like sit-ins, digital or virtual).
And when you do, you can recognize they are illegal, but partake in them anyways, and even fight your charges on moral grounds, and that makes your disobedience no less civil.
That makes sense only if MC, Visa, and Paypal have an obligation to help Wikileaks receive funding.
Do they? Why? Who else has that obligation? (Does discover have that obligation? How about Google Checkout?) How do we know?
1) Part of civil disobedience is pleading guilty to all charges in court. If you don't do this you're just a lazy 'poser' of a protester.
or
2) People that commit crimes as part of a protest shouldn't be allowed to defend themselves
Personally, I think there is nothing wrong with defending yourself in court and using the courthouse as a pulpit to further your civil goals (i.e. why the law is unjust, why you shouldn't be punished, etc).
I'm not sure how well it applies to this case, but civil disobedience in general is more than just "boys being boys".
This is against my feelings on how a state ought to be run and because of that I have decided to break the law. This affects me and nobody else. If there is a price to pay (fine, jail time) I will be the one paying it, nobody else. I think the big difference between civil disobedience and vandalism is that in the case of civil disobedience you are prepared to pay that price. In this case the moniker 'Anon' indicates to me that the people who are doing this at a minimum hope that they will get away with it without paying the price.
The dutch police are showing that that is not the case, it remains to be seen how eager and open the remainder of this group is to continue. If they sign each packet with their name then more power to them.
Sure we might feel some underdog sympathy for wikileaks right now, but the people doing these ddos attacks are the exact same people who ddos other sites and cost a ton of money every year. No free pass - civil disobedience is not free of consequences, and nobody should seriously suggest that launching a DDOS against a major corporation is "fair"
The article did have a nice quote directed at that point of view, though:
"There may be many times when protestors choose to go to jail, as a way of continuing their protest, as a way of reminding their countrymen of injustice. But that is different than the notion that they must go to jail as part of a rule connected with civil disobedience. The key point is that the spirit of protest should be maintained all the way, whether it is done by remaining in jail, or by evading it. To accept jail penitently as an accession to 'the rules' is to switch suddenly to a spirit of subservience, to demean the seriousness of the protest...In particular, the neo-conservative insistence on a guilty plea should be eliminated." --Paul Flowers
That being said, I am certainly against what's happening to Wikileaks and Assange. As I heard someone say earlier in the week: if this thing was happening in China and he was exposing that regime, he'd be called a hero.
Anon as an organism (no typo) is interesting. The fact that it is guided by the hive mind and not one in particular means it transfigures to good or bad depending on the general mood of the group. That is socially fascinating.
Getting the botnet itself was wrong.
Yes, getting a botnet is "premedidated and pure WRONG". But, believe it or not, it is also today's equivalent of what would have been an elaborate phone prank in the 80s.
The majority of these botnets are not run by organized criminals. They are run by adolescent nerds. I'd argue the same is true for the large majority of anyone involved with "Anonymous" in any shape and form. It's primarily a youth movement.
So, like with any other prank, I'm all for giving those kids a slap on the wrist (note how I didn't say "prison sentence").
However, to me the more interesting question in all this is a completely different one: Why do some of the largest organizations on the internet fail to protect themselves against a moderate attack like this?
It seems humiliating, to say the least, that a bunch of teenagers can take out Visa, Mastercard and Paypal at a whim. This could have been trivially prevented with technology and money. Thus, considering the impact it had, the first lawyer-word that crosses my mind is not "sue the kids". It's: Criminal neglience.
I see them all over mainstream sites posting comments "as" Anonymous and I can't help but wonder how ignorant or just plain stupid these people are. They can and will find out who uses these tools and you can bet Visa and Mastercard will use their enormous resources to make sure there is reparation or payback.