Does this represent a shift in what you think is reasonable, or achievable, or just language tailored for the audience?
I don't think I've watered down my proposals, but I think choosing winnable battles is important now that the legislative wheels are turning. For example, I think a good way to get rid of behavioral ad targeting is to give publishers a way to demonstrate that they make more money by not doing it (like we saw with the NYT in Europe).
Do you feel any more or less optimistic about what's coming in privacy law, having done this?
Any part of the experience that was especially surprising?
Edit: wording.
I was ready for the questioning to be far more adversarial. That was a very pleasant surprise. Another surprise was the party imbalance—many of the Republican senators did not attend.
My sense is that the current direction in drafting privacy law is "GDPR lite", on the basis that 'everybody owns their data'. I don't think that framing works, but it seems to have captured many of the senators' imaginations. I believe the time pressure for regulation is coming from the California law, which will go into effect in 2020 unless pre-empted by Federal regulation.
In principle, the privacy issue cuts across party lines and could have a real bipartisan consensus form around it. In practice, we live in polarized times. I am not optimistic, but we have to try our best.
Much like how Equifax got away without punishment, nothing will be done for the entrenched data broker industry which has been invasively profiling consumers since before the internet was invented.
Where Faceboock mostly collects it's data via voluntary submission in exchange for a free service, traditional data brokers get their mitts on it without any consent. They are the real demons. I'm sure their people are working behind the scenes to keep the attention focused on Facebook so that legislative theater can make it look like something is being done without affecting their bottom line.
As we all know, click-fraud's a huge problem on the internet. Have you come across any recent numbers on click-fraud in the newspaper analytics? It seems like if your description is accurate, if I wanted more stories about a topic I could just have a botnet give those articles lots of views.
I'd welcome any other info, public or not so public, people care to share.
This video is edited so perhaps it's misleading, but I did not get that sense at all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-lMIGV-dUI
Edit: As mentioned below this is not from the same hearing. I interpreted skrebbel's praise more generally and the representatives in these clips didn't inspire much confidence.
This extends to your Tech Solidarity [1] work, coaching politicians and journalists... (Thank you for updating/clarifying your recommendations last month to keep it current!)
Your Tech Solidarity security guidelines are purely defensive in nature, while this testimony was much more proactive and forward-thinking... Have you given consideration to spending more of your time lobbying in favor of specific legislation or educating politicians about these topics on a longer term basis? You seem to have their ear, and could conceivably fundraise around these issues. (I realize the personal commitment it would require on your part - just curious whether you're thinking about next steps...)
In the meantime, are there things that average internet citizens can do beyond following the Tech Solidarity guidelines to both protect their own privacy and also support/advocate for progress on these issues? I can pretty easily block trackers, use 2FA, use HTTPS Everywhere, but as you've articulated in your testimony, what we really need is a sort of "herd immunity" like what vaccines attempt to achieve. How do we get there from here?
There are lots and lots of people working in this space worth following. One person in particular working on the California privacy law is Ashkan Soltani, and his twitter account (@ashk4n) is worth a follow. And I think no one thinks more deeply or incisively about these issues than Zeynep Tufekci. If you haven't read her book (Twitter and Tear Gas) it's fantastic.
I know it seems otherwise because of my fundraising work last year, but I really don't have strong connections to D.C. or any inside knowledge on what is on the regulatory agenda. Everyone I know in this space is kind of just winging it.
Focusing on tech solutions is a band aid to a systemic and structural problem that can only be addressed in law. That's why GDPR is good and why Congress grappling with passing privacy legislation is good.
It helps determine facts about the problem (What type of trackers are used? How widely? What changes when they're blocked?), which is critical for quality legislation.
Basically, a staffer on the committee found me online, was interested in my ideas, and asked for a phone call. A couple of days later, he scheduled a second phone call, this time including the committee chairman's staff from the opposing party.
I got a formal invitation to appear with about eight days' notice, along with a request for written testimony on specific topics. You pay your own way to get to D.C. for the hearing.
The testimony was due 24 hours before the hearing, so that staff had a chance to review it and plan their questions.
In the hearing, there is a two-hour block of time, and senators each get five minutes to ask questions, alternating parties, in order of seniority. Some of them want to know stuff, others want to read a statement into the record. You get a glass of ice water and a little countdown clock at your desk that tells you when the five minute blocks of time are up.
At the start of the process, the three witnesses each get a five minute opening statement. In my hearing, we had a former diplomat and expert on the GDPR, and someone from the financial industry. The hearings are open to the public and if you are in D.C., you should attend one! It is quite a spectacle!
I'm very thankful to Matt Blaze and others who wrote about what hearings are like, to help me prepare for this. And I am happy to answer questions in turn.