frankly, tracking seems to be a primary purpose of the portal tag. it takes the imperative away from the user so that the server can make the decision about what you see and how intrusive it can be. the point seems to be to shift control to google.
I honestly don't see how the server gets any more "power" than it already did.
We already have enough issues with tracking pixels, but now we'll have to worry about multiple sites worth of trackers (which I'm sure google will do their absolute best to obfuscate behind the background network call and other sandboxing shenanigans)? No thanks.
(and you can be sure that anyone that dosen't allow google to "portal" their pages will be damnatio memoriae'd into oblivion on results pages)
Uncharitably, this probably just gives Google more ability to track/control your interaction with sites that it links you to.
These already exist. You can do <link> prefetch now ...
But I THINK they are doing preload now as well so the DOM can be pre-cached.
I mean you could do it on your own site but most people try to make sites FASTER not slower.
I still don't grok the main advantages of Portals though.
> Furthermore, portals can also overwrite the main URL address bar, meaning they are useful as a navigation system
Isn't this already possible with iframes and target="_top" / target="_parent"? You can also use the <base>-Tag inside the iframe.
> The advantage over using Portals over classic links is that the content inside portals can be pre-loaded while the user scrolls through a page, and be ready to expand into a new page without having the user wait for it to load.
What? What about the vast majority of links that appear in-line, in text (think Wikipedia). What about the increased bandwidth usage for pre-loaded pages I don't intend to visit? What about the obvious tracking issues? What about the further increased difficulty for users to even tell which page they are actually on, if the transition to another page is now smooth and not clear-cut?
This article makes it seem like <portal> magically removes all the security concerns people had for decades with iframes, which imho is not the case at all.