Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by ehsankia on Friday May 10, 2019 @05:39PM
(#19882500)
How is prefetching taking the imperative away about what you see? You can click or not click. As for "tracking", the website could already ping as many servers as it wanted in the background, it's not like it can do anything new here.
I honestly don't see how the server gets any more "power" than it already did.
Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by tbirrell on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:11PM
(#19882743)
If I go to foo.com, I generally expect that bar.com, baz.com, and qux.com are not also loading.
We already have enough issues with tracking pixels, but now we'll have to worry about multiple sites worth of trackers (which I'm sure google will do their absolute best to obfuscate behind the background network call and other sandboxing shenanigans)? No thanks.
Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by ehsankia on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:44PM
(#19883655)
As you mention, foo.com could just as well have pixel trackers/scripts from bar.com, baz.com and qux.com. Nothing about portals makes it any more or less of an issue than it already is.
Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by throwaway2048 on Friday May 10, 2019 @10:12PM
(#19884081)
Its completely different because now baz.com gets control over foo.com in an invisible way just by virtue of "linking" with a portal.
(and you can be sure that anyone that dosen't allow google to "portal" their pages will be damnatio memoriae'd into oblivion on results pages)
Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by ehsankia on Friday May 10, 2019 @10:20PM
(#19884109)
baz.com doesn't take control over foo.com, and it's not invisible. You click on a link and the domain changes, it's as old as the internet itself. The only difference is that the new page will be embedded into the old one, instead of there being a clear cut transition.
Re:Google launches new “portal” HTML element
by chronicler on Friday May 10, 2019 @10:57PM
(#19884247)
Everyone seems to have just jumped into the 'Google is evil' bandwagon without even putting thought into it.
frankly, tracking seems to be a primary purpose of the portal tag. it takes the imperative away from the user so that the server can make the decision about what you see and how intrusive it can be. the point seems to be to shift control to google.