News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by wnevets on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:33PM (#19853659)
>The sodium lamps use roughly the same amount of energy

That doesn't sound right, source?

edit: https://www.stouchlighting.com/blog/led-vs-hps-lps-high-and-...

Why would LEDs put Sodium vapor lights out of business? Sodium lamps have the worst color rendering of any bulb. They produce a dark yellow glow which is generally a very low quality light. Additionally, there are serious waste disposal issues with sodium lamps. In particular, they have been known to start fires in the event that the lamp is broken and the sodium metal is exposed. The sodium can catch fire even in the event that the lamp is broken on the ground. For this reason it is safest to break sodium lights under water and then to subsequently dispose of the destroyed bulb. Lastly, HPS and LPS lights are monochromatic, so they can mess with your color vision if you look at them for an extended period of time.

Perhaps more importantly, in the last few years LED efficiency has surpassed that of even LPS and HPS lights and its efficiency improvements are progressing at a much more rapid rate. The largest selling point of LPS and HPS lights is the cheap selling price, the high energy efficiency (low operating costs), and the relatively long lifespan. LPS and HPS still retain these advantages over most conventional bulbs but they lose on all three counts to LEDs. In some areas (e.g. lifespan) they are drastically inferior to LEDs. The extremely low maintenance and replacement costs with LEDs is actually a major cost benefit over the long term. LED lifespan can be greater than 100,000 hours (more than four times that of LPS or HPS). Having to purchase one bulb versus 3 or 4 bulbs over the course of time is a significant selling point for LEDs. The bottom line is that having lost their traditional advantage of being the most energy efficient bulb on the market, there’s very little reason to use a sodium vapor light when LED lighting is available.

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by sp332 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:38PM (#19853694)
The low color quality, specifically the very warm hue, is a feature for nighttime lighting. Blue light messes with sleep cycles of humans and animals.

The very narrow spectrum benefits astronomers because it's easy to filter out light pollution from low-pressure sodium lamps.

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by lhl on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @11:49PM (#19855718)
Just wanted to point out that the choice municipalities have made for street lighting is not really an LED technology limitation as much as different evaluation criteria.

For example, while sure, OSRAM advertises/sells street lighting LEDs that are broad spectrum (131 lm/W) [1] they also sell single-color LEDs like these amber ones that are actually even more efficient (141 lm/W) with an emission range almost entirely within 600-640nm [2].

This is almost as tight a range as LPS (which looks like about 580-610nm) [3], and it beats out HPS considerably [4].

[1] https://www.mouser.com/new/osram/osram-street-lighting-solut...

[2] https://www.osram.com/os/ecat/OSLON%C2%AE%20SSL%20150%20GA%2...

[3] http://www.flagstaffdarkskies.org/low-pressure-sodium-lighti...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-vapor_lamp#/media/File:...

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by lozaning on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:27PM (#19854412)
This was a big deal in Tucson for a while. It used to be that there was a city ordinance that mandated public outdoor lighting was all sodium lamps because it was super easy for the local observatory to filter out that one frequency of light.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by p1mrx on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:46PM (#19854556)
Warm white LEDs exist, with color quality exceeding that of sodium vapor in every way, but cities often use blueish LEDs because they're cheaper and more efficient.

Relevant Technology Connections video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIC-iGDTU40

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by jacobolus on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @11:00PM (#19855545)
As a person who has spent a decade as an amateur student of human color vision, let me state emphatically that “color quality” is a horrifically bad criterion for choosing nighttime street lamps. Nobody should be trying to read a book or critically evaluate photographs in the middle of the road at 3AM.

Street lamps should include as little short wavelength light as possible and should otherwise be as even (this means: use more lamps spaced closer and placed at lower height, diffused and shielded from the side) and dim as possible, so as to avoid causing distracting glare in people’s peripheral vision, and avoid causing high contrast between areas directly under the lamps and areas in shadow. Human vision is amazingly good at adapting to very low light levels. After adaptation, humans can navigate the environment by e.g. starlight, but at any rate can see just fine under sodium lamps.

But the way cities roll out LED street lighting is to put a small number of widely spaced very intense blue lamps high up in the air, not diffused and with little shielding from the side.

Every parameter has been optimized (pessimized?) for blasting away people’s night vision and causing enough glare to make seeing into the shadows all but impossible.

Extremely low color temperature LEDs would be fine, but don’t really have any especially great advantage over sodium lamps. (Except maybe for getting some government subsidy money?)

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by Zak on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @09:01PM (#19854948)
Warm white LEDs put out a broad spectrum. That's a feature for most illumination use cases, but it's hard to filter out of a telescope.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by notatoad on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @06:41PM (#19854105)
I thought the wider spectrum of light coming from LED streetlamps means they can be run at a lower brightness to provide the same visibility, which means less overall light pollution (less reflection back upwards) and less power usage.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by Jill_the_Pill on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @06:59PM (#19854226)
The little wild creatures don't appreciate that visibility. If the recent report on biodiversity loss bothered you, avoiding LED outdoor lighting is one easy action to take locally.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by notatoad on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:25PM (#19854402)
There's not a lot of biodiversity on the streets anyways, so that's not a big deal. but the little wild creatures do appreciate less light in the woods, which is what you get from less light pollution.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by lscotte on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:51PM (#19854582)
The light polution glow from cities can be seen from about 100 miles or so, so it's not a localized problem.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by benj111 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:10AM (#19857125)
How does this compare to a full moon?

I assume animals have evolved to deal with that.

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by Jill_the_Pill on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:18PM (#19863064)
Not all month long. They've found that frogs won't sing if it's too light, making it hard to woo a reproductive partner.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by remcob on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:11PM (#19854308)
> For this reason it is safest to break sodium lights under water [...]

This sounds like dangerous advice. Sodium reacts exothermically with water producing NaOH. In practice this means it will violently boil and splatter strongly alkaline lye around. (Source: this is how my high school chem prof lost some of his eyesight.)

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by Simon_says on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:57PM (#19854608)
Yea that didn't make much sense to me. Throwing sodium into water is a nice way to get an explosion.

https://youtu.be/SJVSj9maK6Q?t=223

Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by sebazzz on Thursday May 09, 2019 @01:30AM (#19865648)
Sodium is kept safe in oil.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by jedberg on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:48PM (#19853757)
FWIW, that website is from a company that makes money replacing streetlights with LED bulbs.
Re:Detroit’s LED streetlights going dark after a few years by wnevets on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:09PM (#19854292)
I just grabbed the first google result. I didn't notice anything suggesting HPS and LED energy usage was comparable.