News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by electromagnetic on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:17PM (#1985130)
I like the symbolism that Anon has become. Simply put Anon is the anger and frustration of millions (acted on by the few hundred) and is having real effects.

If Anon is taking down Mastercard and Visa, then perhaps our governments will start obeying their own laws instead of trying to manipulate companies into compliance. Or at the very least, our companies might actually question whether obeying the government is in their best interests.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by tzs on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:24PM (#1985156)
> Simply put Anon is the anger and frustration of millions...

And the idiocy of millions, considering that one of their "bank" targets (PostFinance) isn't a bank. It is a money transfer service operated by the Swiss post office for Swiss residents only. Assange is not a Swiss resident, so they closed his account, and are returning his money to him.

> If Anon is taking down Mastercard and Visa, then perhaps our governments will start obeying their own laws instead of trying to manipulate companies into compliance. Or at the very least, our companies might actually question whether obeying the government is in their best interests.

Let's see--obey an anonymous group of DDOSers, who at most can cause you a short term outage until you add more capacity, or obey the government which has the full power of the state behind it and can actually stop your business and seize your assets...this one is a no brainer.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by electromagnetic on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:31PM (#1985742)
Yes, because the US government only managed to get 63% voter turnout would dare to seize the assets of credit card companies when it would be pissing off 80% of its voters. Given that the US has over 5 credit cards per capita, it's relatively safe to assume that the 80% of households with a credit card literally translates into 80% of voters have a credit card as in it would be an insta-lose at the next election to be "the party that knocked out credit cards for a month+"

Furthermore there are [3 (65% visa, 30% MC)] billion credit cards used outside of the US. If MC/Visa's assets were seized, the US would be under global shit for fucking up the global economy that it wouldn't even have to reach consumers in other countries before all hell broke loose.

What do you think the global repercussions of half the western world being unable to buy anything with credit for even a day?

Sorry, but it's a no brainer not to obey the government when they're making rice paper thin threats and to not even consult your legal department on the matter. Now they're dealing with genuine losses from their online payments being down for trying to brown nose the US government.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by rimantas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @04:02AM (#1986702)

  Yes, because the US government only managed to get 63%
  voter turnout
Isn't it backwards? Should be 63% of voters got the government they voted for.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by electromagnetic on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:00PM (#1989863)
Voter turnout is the percentage of people who commit the act of voting for any party. 63% of eligible voters in the US voted.

Obama only managed to get 33.3% of eligible voters to actually vote for him. But got 52.9% of general vote.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by travisp on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:22AM (#1987274)
Yes, but instead of seizing MC/Visa's assets, the government can treat the companies unfairly in arbitrary antitrust lawsuits, not protect the companies from unjust foreign action, and pass regulations that limit the abilities of the companies to earn a profit. None of these would piss off 80% of voters, but could be significantly damaging to Mastercard and Visa.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by mcantelon on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:18PM (#1985349)
>Assange is not a Swiss resident, so they closed his account, and are returning his money to him.

The timing was coincidentally close to many other "spontaneous" corporate actions against Wikileaks.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by derefr on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:38PM (#1985417)
Sure, because somewhere inside PostFinance, a conversation roughly like this occurred:

Boss: "Hey, everyone's talking about this Assange guy's financials—do we have anything to do with that?"

Clerk: "I'll check. ...huh! We have him in our books as a client!"

Boss: "But he's not even Swiss! Good thing we noticed, I guess."

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by electromagnetic on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:38PM (#1985753)
His account was opened legally when he was in the country, but closed because he wasn't at that time a resident. This strikes me as a rather absurd policy on how to hold an account given that you'll have to be closing down temporary residents accounts and reopening them whenever they exit or enter the country.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:00AM (#1987222)
A significant portion of Swiss residents spend only half of the year in Switzerland: they don't clear their postal accounts every month. ;) They close it when they realize you don't really live in Switzerland, even half-time.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by praptak on Thursday December 09, 2010 @04:30AM (#1986771)
Prelude:

Government representative: "Hey, nice company, wanna keep being friends with the govt?"

Boss: "Sure."

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:57AM (#1987215)
The Post Office is actually a Government-owned company.

I keep saying that Swiss is a socialist country (the main assets are government-controlled, health and welfare are compulsive, minimum wage is astronomic) but no one believes me… and I'm the only Swiss around.

However, I don't think there was any US interference: Switzerland is a fiercely autonomous country (with a whiff of xeno…-scepticism). There most likely were sincere about discovering that he wasn't seriously considering to stay and discontinued service only for that: banking in Switzerland is like cooking in France — don't try to make sense of it, do as you are told, and admire in silence.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by loewenskind on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:39AM (#1987803)
Wtf? Switzerland is more free market than the US. The people still hold most of the power, there aren't many mega corps that own everything. There are lots of "mom and pop" businesses around.

Switzerland is a wonderful coctail of free market capitalism and social responsibility toward it's citizens. Would you think it were more "capitalist" if there were a Walmart every thousand meters and all small businesses were dead?

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:10PM (#1989898)
You are confusing two distinct things: socialism is a type of capital accumulation (capitalism, therefore) that considers that essential assets of productions should be government owned, or controlled. Anti-trust is a classic, albeit minimal socialist law; it is also coherent with populism. Anti-trust is necessary as the last control in a free capitalist market, but is rather contradictory with private property being absolute. Other notable economic system around property include Saint-Marc doctrine (a man can steal to feed his family if its his last resort, that has been extended to land expropriation after peasant revolts), financial capitalism, or Rhine capitalism, where the means of production are family-owned, but social ties between owners offer a conventional control and can be used to enforce standards (like paternalism).

The last one is the system described in Karl Marx's The Capital It's also slightly incoherent with free market, because properties can't be exchanged freely: the community of owners have a say, albeit implicit. The best current example of that is Silicon Valley, where Arrington can sell TechCrunch to AOL, but still has to pull up a couple of stunts to prove his editorial independence; or where the value of your start-up is dependent on PG's impression of you being a nice guy. It's usually a very efficient system, especially with innovation, but it is quite “unfair”: winners are not always the absolute best (well, they tend to) but generally make orders of magnitude more money. It's acceptable in SV because most people have enough money to eat, and those who own redistribute it, but it wasn't so acceptable when the children of Rothshild's workers starved.

Free market, vs. planned economy are system that consider production. You can have a planed economy with private ownership (France in the 70s) or free market with very strong control over workers benefits, like Switzerland. Because large corporation have far more responsibility (thanks to heavy State controls on the job market) Switzerland indeed has a lot of SMEs.

I have no idea why you asked you last question: it goes well beyond the usual straw-man.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by eru on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:42AM (#1987563)
Perhaps (neo-)corporatist might fill the bill better than socialist?
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by tzs on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:38PM (#1985420)
Probably someone tipped them off. What were they supposed to do then--make an exception for Assange because he's in the news?
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by newt on Thursday December 09, 2010 @05:09AM (#1986858)
make an exception for Assange because he's in the news?

because Swiss banks are so rigorous about closing the accounts of third-world tinpot dictators?

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:13AM (#1987251)
Those are not the same type of accounts: usually, tinpot dictators have “anonymous” accounts, where the local regulation is that you are not supposed to notice who owns it (but yet, you still recognize him as the owner).
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by kmfrk on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:25PM (#1985162)
Anon is (a) digitized mob mentality. No reason to commend it.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by Alex3917 on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:17PM (#1985345)
A mob is just a group of people. If we are ever going to have a free, just, and rational society then by definition the mob is going to have to support freedom, justice, and rationality.

In the same way that the Encyclopedia Britannica gained fame by endorsing the cause of rationality, and in the same way that Wikipedia gained fame by endorsing the cause of free information, so too can anonymous gain fame as a mob that supports social justice. Anonymous has a lot of the characteristics of other populist uprisings, so I wouldn't be surprised if their (mostly) harmless civil disobedience today morphed into something more interesting in ten or twenty years. I'm not saying I support them, but it's worth keeping an eye on.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:30PM (#1985738)
Every mob claims to be operating for some sort of community justice. Sometimes that results in innocent lynchings.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gloob on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:55PM (#1985947)
Every government claims to be operating for the greater good. Sometimes that results in tyrannies.

I think this discussion might just be getting lost in the generalities of such statements, though. Do you have a more specific point to make?

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @11:33PM (#1986045)
Totally independent of any issues regarding Wikileaks and DDoS attacks, I was reacting to Alex3917's statement:

A mob is just a group of people. If we are ever going to have a free, just, and rational society then by definition the mob is going to have to support freedom, justice, and rationality.

That's not true. 'Mobs', specifically, are unruly assemblages and more often irrational, unjust, and freedom-destroying. A mob doesn't have to be brought around to righteous thinking for society to function; it has to be dissolved, and stop acting like a mob. Ideally this is when its smartest members wake from an angry emotional trance and choose to become other kinds of 'groups of people' that work better for rational and just aims. But sometimes it's when adults say, enough is enough, and apply hard force against the mob.

Actual mobs sweep tyrants into power, either populist tyrants, or reactionary tyrants. The framers of the US Constitution understood this, at least.

Let's not fetishize the idea of mobs as any mass action in the name of some murky form of 'social justice'.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jacquesm on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:12AM (#1986140)
> Actual mobs sweep tyrants into power

They've removed them as well. See "French Revolution", Romania, Albania and a bunch of others.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:05AM (#1986315)
Open rebellion against government forces isn't quite a mob, despite some similarities.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gloob on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:26AM (#1986374)
This is getting close to being a No True Scotsman type of situation. I'm reasonably sure that mobs were present during the French revolution, for instance.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:44AM (#1988042)
Indeed it is approaching 'No True Scotsman' hair-splitting, and that's unfortunate, but shared definitions are important for discussion. My objection is to the watering-down of 'mob' to mean any 'group of people', including those who have the noblest aims. A 'mob' is not a 'movement', nor is it a 'rebellion' or 'revolution'.

It's angry people breaking rules and doing unfocused damage with the exercise of raw bulk power. That we can cherry-pick a few examples where similar action caused (or more likely, just correlated with) beneficial change shouldn't make 'mob' a positive-connotation term for the 'group of people' that via its 'support' determines whether society is 'free, just, and rational'.

We should prefer to rely on free speech, elections, courts, legislatures, voluntary assemblies, armies and even 'well-organized militias' over angry anonymous 'mobs'.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jbooth on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:57PM (#1985294)
Even if the mob is right to be pissed?
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by SpikeGronim on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:42PM (#1985436)
"right to be pissed" and "right to attack 3rd parties illegally" are two very different things.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by Malic on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:23PM (#1985875)
History will determine who writes those books someday.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by mcantelon on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:53AM (#1986272)
Paypal, Mastercard, and Visa chose to, in effect, attack Wikileaks by suddenly suspending their accounts. If they want to collaborate on an economic attack against an entity that hasn't broken any laws it's isn't surprising that they find themselves also attacked.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by potatolicious on Thursday December 09, 2010 @02:22AM (#1986498)
So let me get this right: if you're not with us you're against us, if you're not supporting them you're attacking them, "collaborators" the bunch of them.

Where have we heard all of these before?

Empty, vacuous rhetoric, that's all this situation has come down to. I'm tired of hearing about WikiLeaks because it's polarized and made everyone rhetoric-spewing, logic-hating extremists. Everyone involved, and sadly to say, particularly the pro-WikiLeaks crowd, has been making grandiose, pompous speeches as if it's their last day on Earth and they're the President from the movie Independence Day.

Stop. Just stop. Julian Assange is not the messiah and you are not delivering the the gospel truth of life, the universe, and everything. There is zero need for the amount of hyperbole, rhetoric, self-aggrandization, and more weasel words than I can shake a stick at.

Is this an important issue? No doubt, but polarizing speeches like yours aren't helping anyone. When you start using loaded words like "attack" and "collaborator" you've lost any semblance of credibility with moderates, and just come off as an extremist instead.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by mcantelon on Thursday December 09, 2010 @03:11AM (#1986594)
That's a lot of words and generalizations, but doesn't seem to explain why a corporation that chooses to aid in an unlawful attack should be pitied when they fall prey to an unlawful attack in retribution.

You seem to be of the opinion that suddenly suspending the account of an organization that hasn't broken the law is a neutral, harmless action.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bluedanieru on Thursday December 09, 2010 @05:16AM (#1986868)
Anybody who can remain moderate in the current climate basically isn't worth having on your side anyway.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bruceboughton on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:09AM (#1987243)
Au contraire, moderates are far more valuable to an extremist than extremists. As an extremist, your job is to convince the moderates. You will not do this if you appear to extreme.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bluedanieru on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:01AM (#1987650)
We're talking about 80% of the population here at least. It's pretty diverse. Perhaps some "moderates" may be folks who simply haven't heard the right argument. Yet we saturate the airwaves and internets with arguments every day, so while historically such people may have been more significant in number, I suspect their numbers have been steadily decreasing for some time. Most moderates are moderate for basically the same reason, that being that unless you are literally burning down their homes and starving their friends and families, they don't want to get involved. They might vote if they remember that day, although you can't count on them to figure out for whom, and they certainly have opinions, but they have better things to do than reason about them or articulate them to more than a superficial degree. They may occasionally get passionate about something but then they lose interest. In short, they have to be given a concrete, not an abstract, reason to care about anything.

Most people don't fly, so they don't care about the TSA.

Most people aren't Iraqis, so they don't care about Iraqi war dead.

Most people aren't Paypal, so they don't care about Anonymous.

Most people don't have much to say, so they don't care about the First Amendment. And they don't expect that anyone wants to search their home, so they don't pay too much attention to the Fourth, either.

And they're not rich, so they don't see how tax cuts for the rich are any of their concern.

I mean, we supposedly had this great national progressive moment in America not two years ago. Well, what happened? Would you say that the so-called leader of that progressive movement, Barack Obama, has spent too much time appeasing his base, and not enough time convincing moderates? (I'm not even sure what his base is anymore but let's pretend it's the left for the sake of argument.) His entire Presidency so far has been about trying to hog the center, while the Republicans spent the last two years nurturing the fears and hatreds of their most extreme and vocal supporters, while ceding as little ground as possible to the victors of 2008. So, who won?

So no, au contraire, I don't agree that the job of the extremist is to convince the moderates. His job is to basically leave them the hell alone, and outflank his opposition so as to relieve them of their hold on the status quo. Then, replace it with one of his own. The moderates will go along because they don't give a shit either way. In this case a good start would have been to get the Fairness Doctrine reinstated in the FCC by revoking the executive order of 1987, and hit the Right where it hurts. But now we're talking tactics.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bruceboughton on Friday December 10, 2010 @03:20PM (#1993010)
Actually, I think a lot of people take a moderate view on things because they recognise that the world is rarely black or white, but rather a full spectrum of shades of grey.

Of course, in saying this, I have to acknowledge that some people hold moderate views out of laziness (it's not black and white). Of course, there is probably an equal proportion of lazy extremists.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jamii on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:13AM (#1986337)
Perhaps not, but it is certainly interesting to study. Its a mob where all the members are anonymous, that has no leaders and yet manages to coordinate fairly sophisticated digital attacks. I'd love to grab a sociologist or two and throw in the vague direction of 4chan.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by TomOfTTB on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:36PM (#1985410)
Just out of curiosity, can you name a time when a Government has responded positively to this kind of attack? Where a protest has defied the law and the Government has reacted by giving the protesters what they want?

Because I can't. In every example I can think of the Government has doubled down on its crack down effort. I suspect we're only months away from a bunch of these people getting arrested for cyber-terrorism.

I suppose this sort of thing can be effective if the government crack down becomes so oppressive that the general public turns on them (See the Kent State Shooting). But that's a pretty destructive way to make your point.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by GavinB on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:53PM (#1985474)
a protest has defied the law and the Government has reacted by giving the protesters what they want

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cape_Town_peace_march

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_wall#The_Fall

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosa_parks#Her_Refusal_to_Move

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_Satyagraha

I think you make a good point--the reaction to an attack is generally a stronger counterattack, not reconciliation--but there are certainly counterexamples.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by Aaronontheweb on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:08PM (#1985518)
Just wanted to point out that the reasons for the fall of the Berlin wall were TREMENDOUSLY more complicated than just protestors complaining about it. Comparing the fall of the Berlin wall to a DDoS attack on MasterCard feels like a slap in the face to history.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by rapind on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @11:01PM (#1985960)
Most things are complicated. All I took from his reply was to say that protests have led to success in the past, and that the DDoS attacks are a form of protest (debatable).

I didn't see anything trying to belittle the fall of the Berlin wall. Drawing extreme conclusions like this reminds me of "Unamerican" arguments from a few years ago.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jacquesm on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:11AM (#1986136)
I think a reference to Solidarnosc would have been much more appropriate.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by TomOfTTB on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:34PM (#1985588)
You make valid points but I don't think they support your conclusion. I'll go down the list.

Cape Town Peace March, The Berlin Wall & Salt Satyagraha: In these cases the Government felt it didn't have a choice but to capitulate lest it be overthrown completely. The Cape Town article makes that point and in the case of the Berlin Wall the Government of East Germany did dissolve. But I'll happily add the caveat "where the government believes it is capable of doubling down on its efforts without being overthrown". Still doesn't change the point though (unless you seriously think Anon is capable of overthrowing the U.S. Government)

The same was true of the Indian independence movement. In the end the British Government didn't so much capitulate as it withdrew (which goes back to my first point of Governments doubling down until they can't anymore)

Rosa Parks : In my post I said it would work if you are willing to let the Government take a pound of flesh and that's exactly what happened in the case of Rosa Parks. Parks was arrested and convicted. People who protested in her name were beaten as well as being arrested and convicted. The very section you point to says that MLK's house was bombed and churches were burnt down.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:11AM (#1987247)
I think Anonymous want to force third parties to oppose the rule of law to government's “suggestions” — no political overthrow per se, but trying to force a judge to stand to the precedent of NYTimes vs. USA on Pentagon papers. “Victory” here would be to have some press (done — if a coverage worthy of Olympic games is satisfying) and a stable URL (done), or better: the 1st link on Google search and an active Facebook page where they can safely link to articles about Nobel prize, Obama's hypocrisy and PayPal reversal (done, done and done).
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jacquesm on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:09AM (#1986133)
> I suspect we're only months away from a bunch of these people getting arrested for cyber-terrorism.

You're an optimist.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by steveklabnik on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:35PM (#1985199)
It's the Ghost in the Shell. The Internet's collective id.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by w1ntermute on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:59PM (#1985662)
Reminds me of this post on Reddit from 2 years ago suggesting the exact same thing: http://www.reddit.com/comments/66cj2/hello_scientology_we_ar...
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by khafra on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:37AM (#1987329)
A particularly trenchant comment, coming from w1ntermute. I don't know if they make a better stand alone complex or temporary autonomous zone, though.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by Malic on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:19PM (#1985864)
Anon's actions are an attempt at inciting a stand alone complex? Yeah, I can see that.