News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:30PM (#1985738)
Every mob claims to be operating for some sort of community justice. Sometimes that results in innocent lynchings.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gloob on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:55PM (#1985947)
Every government claims to be operating for the greater good. Sometimes that results in tyrannies.

I think this discussion might just be getting lost in the generalities of such statements, though. Do you have a more specific point to make?

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @11:33PM (#1986045)
Totally independent of any issues regarding Wikileaks and DDoS attacks, I was reacting to Alex3917's statement:

A mob is just a group of people. If we are ever going to have a free, just, and rational society then by definition the mob is going to have to support freedom, justice, and rationality.

That's not true. 'Mobs', specifically, are unruly assemblages and more often irrational, unjust, and freedom-destroying. A mob doesn't have to be brought around to righteous thinking for society to function; it has to be dissolved, and stop acting like a mob. Ideally this is when its smartest members wake from an angry emotional trance and choose to become other kinds of 'groups of people' that work better for rational and just aims. But sometimes it's when adults say, enough is enough, and apply hard force against the mob.

Actual mobs sweep tyrants into power, either populist tyrants, or reactionary tyrants. The framers of the US Constitution understood this, at least.

Let's not fetishize the idea of mobs as any mass action in the name of some murky form of 'social justice'.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by jacquesm on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:12AM (#1986140)
> Actual mobs sweep tyrants into power

They've removed them as well. See "French Revolution", Romania, Albania and a bunch of others.

Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:05AM (#1986315)
Open rebellion against government forces isn't quite a mob, despite some similarities.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gloob on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:26AM (#1986374)
This is getting close to being a No True Scotsman type of situation. I'm reasonably sure that mobs were present during the French revolution, for instance.
Re:Anonymous in The Economist by gojomo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:44AM (#1988042)
Indeed it is approaching 'No True Scotsman' hair-splitting, and that's unfortunate, but shared definitions are important for discussion. My objection is to the watering-down of 'mob' to mean any 'group of people', including those who have the noblest aims. A 'mob' is not a 'movement', nor is it a 'rebellion' or 'revolution'.

It's angry people breaking rules and doing unfocused damage with the exercise of raw bulk power. That we can cherry-pick a few examples where similar action caused (or more likely, just correlated with) beneficial change shouldn't make 'mob' a positive-connotation term for the 'group of people' that via its 'support' determines whether society is 'free, just, and rational'.

We should prefer to rely on free speech, elections, courts, legislatures, voluntary assemblies, armies and even 'well-organized militias' over angry anonymous 'mobs'.