News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dTal on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:09AM (#19847699)
This just seems short-sighted more than anything. It doesn't sound like there's anything technically wrong with the extension (indeed I have often wanted just such an extension), it's merely that the "wrong sort" of people use it. Well, banning it will keep the "wrong sort" of people using it. If everyone jumped on the bandwagon and started using the extension as a generic comment section, then the bright light of day would cleanse it. Instead, by "suppressing" it, they have basically gone out of their way to create a breeding ground.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by madeofpalk on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:14AM (#19847732)
> If everyone jumped on the bandwagon and started using the extension as a generic comment section, then the bright light of day would cleanse it

Browser extensions aside, if we've learn anything over the past two years of 'Online', it's that this simply isn't true. You can't 'debate' hate speech away.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by Grue3 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:23AM (#19847768)
>You can't 'debate' hate speech away.

Surely you can. To believe otherwise is to believe that hate is logically sound. It's just that people's standards for what constitutes "debate" have lowered so much (thanks to Twitter and its ilk) that it no longer holds any persuasive power. Consider that most people in the West were extremely racist just a few decades ago. It didn't take free speech suppression to change this status quo.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by maeln on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:55AM (#19847927)
If you can surely debate hate away, it is extremely costing for your mental health.

My own experience is that, when doing it face to face it's more easy, you can really get through someone. People are less "protected" and have more emotional connection.

But on the Internet ? I stopped trying. Every time it's the same thing: People prefer to be 'trolls' and just throw insults and bullshit all day. Unless the person is actually willing to have a real discussion, it's almost impossible to "debate" anything. As soon as you are going to try to have a real argument, an horde will just "dunk" on you throwing colorful name all around.

It's sad but i stopped believing in the possibility of having any interesting argument on the internet if it is not amongst a small community or a very moderated one.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by Funes- on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @06:19AM (#19848024)
I don't think debating is ever a good means to change anyone's point of view on any given subject. Introspection, deliberation, and personal experience, on the other hand, are good means to that end.

Teaching by example is, to my mind, the best way someone can guide others to those personal endeavors, which are the only ones that can grant deep and lasting changes in our world views and beliefs.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by WAHa_06x36 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @09:11AM (#19849005)
And teaching by example also involves setting very clear limits on what is acceptable and what is not.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by teekert on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @12:03PM (#19850745)
I think this is one of those points where introverted people differ a lot from extraverted people.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dagw on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:31AM (#19847801)
Anybody who has done any amount of debating knows that the 'winner' of any debate is the person who is more prepared and better at the abstract skill of "debating", not the person that is 'right' in any meaningful way. As someone who did a fair amount of debating in school I'm confident I would have won/lost every debate I partook in in exactly the same way even if I was debating the other side of the argument.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by belorn on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:45AM (#19847889)
That implies that election is not about values or politics, but rather which candidate is more prepared and better at the abstract skill of "debating".

There is some major amount of cynicism to that world view, and I prefer to behave as if the world did not exist like that.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dagw on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:52AM (#19847919)
Far from it. I believe that values and politics are very important and specifically because of that we have to get away from overvaluing the traditional debate format which does nothing to effectively highlight either.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by belorn on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @06:01AM (#19847949)
So the obvious question is then, how do we change the debate format so that we can discuss hate speech away.

I don't think banning is a working debate format.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dagw on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @09:06AM (#19848976)
I wish the answer was as obvious as the question. Honest answer is that I don't know what will work.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by rincebrain on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:30AM (#19847800)
I believe the view being expressed is that you cannot necessarily reason someone out of a position they did not reason themselves into.

Confronting people who hold a belief for reasons that are not necessarily based on facts or logic can result in them doubling down instead of reconsidering their position.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by Guthur on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:27AM (#19857216)
And you can't debate the other side either without being called a bigot.

Look at the hatred Jordan Peterson gets, who by pretty much all measures is as reasonable a human being as you might expect to meet on average.

There are many online articles these days saying things like "yet another white male point of view" horribly generalizing all white males as the same and that is some how acceptable. It's no different that than me saying all black men listen to hip hop and have big hair. (I'm struggling to generalise but I'm sure the point is clear)

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by faissaloo on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @12:35PM (#19851051)
>To believe otherwise is to believe that hate is logically sound.

Not at all, people are simply not logical as much as we like to pretend we are.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by busymom0 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:20AM (#19847756)
> You can't 'debate' hate speech away.

Not sure what your definition of "hate speech" is but if it includes racism, then yes, racists can change their mind:

https://www.theguardian.com/global/2018/oct/08/the-white-sou...

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by Veen on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:27AM (#19847781)
"You can't argue people out of their beliefs" is an acceptable generalization because it's mostly true. There are exceptions, but, for the most part, when a progressive talks to a fascist, for example, there is likely to be little movement in the beliefs of either. In fact, their views are likely to become more entrenched.

https://phys.org/news/2015-05-political-myths-entrench.html

Long-term conversation can and does work, but not the sort of hit-and-run debates that happen on social networks and forums.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by busymom0 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:37AM (#19847837)
I think this has to do more with teaching people proper debate and communication skills than simply banning a platform because you can't teach their users proper debate.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by WAHa_06x36 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:24AM (#19847770)
Yes, through long-term building of trust and deep personal relationships.

This is very, very different from an internet comments section, where it is basically impossible.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by busymom0 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:30AM (#19847798)
I would argue that internet comments section is exactly what's needed actually. Simply banning them away is basically hiding it under the rug. But that's not going to do anything productive. Banning them will now re-enforce their beliefs and now they will just go to another platform which will be an echo chamber of even more similar "hate" views. This brings up 2 problems -

1. Now we don't even know what they are talking about / planning some extreme crime etc 2. Those people are now only exposed to views which agree to their own points and not exposed to opposing views. So there's nothing which would even allow them to change their minds.

Humans aren't born racist / hateful. They learn it from the environment around them. By exposing them to more counter points, you can make them unlearn that hate too.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by WAHa_06x36 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:36AM (#19847834)
You say they learn if from the environment around them. This is exactly right, and this is exactly why you ban racists from your open platforms.

There will always be hardcore hateful people who hide deep in the pockets of the internet. The point is to not normalise them, not let them spread their hatred in public, and not to make people think that sort of attitude is ok.

They are exposed to counterpoints constantly, and it is not changing them.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by busymom0 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:44AM (#19847884)
> They are exposed to counterpoints constantly, and it is not changing them.

This is not correct. This very post's topic implies they aren't exposed to counterpoints. Banning them from every platform possible doesn't allow them to be exposed to counterpoints.

Allowing hateful people doesn't mean we are normalizing it.

Also the definition of "hate speech" is extremely vague now a days.

> You say they learn if from the environment around them. This is exactly right, and this is exactly why you ban racists from your open platforms.

So you are saying that not allowing these people on open platforms where they are exposed to counterpoints (let's say 5% bad + 95% good) so that they all jump to another platform (8chan for example) where they are exposed to an even higher saturation of bad (100% bad) is good? That's basically exposing them to an even worse environment now. That's exactly what's making this situation even worse. Every mass shooting etc was planned on those worse platforms (4chan, 8chan) etc.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dTal on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:32AM (#19847808)
Even if that were true, it would still be possible to drown it. Flood the extension used by racists with an Eternal September of normal people. This is how we deal with extremist views in the real world - allowing them to sequester themselves together is what leads to the amplification chambers. Banning the extension just means that the people who already care about using it will continue to do so, while new users are pushed away.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by DuskStar on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @10:22AM (#19849625)
> Browser extensions aside, if we've learn anything over the past two years of 'Online', it's that this simply isn't true. You can't 'debate' hate speech away.

When debating online, there's really two groups you need to keep in mind - the person/people you're debating, and the people reading the debate. Reading without interacting is generally accepted to be far more common than actually interacting, so that's probably the largest group. So even if you can't convince the person you're debating, you might be able to convince those who are just reading and don't have a strong attachment to either side.

Or you can give up, attempt to ban the badthink, and admit that your ideas do not have merit. Because that's what a lot of the watchers will interpret that refusal to engage as.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by viseztrance on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @03:31PM (#19852662)
Not many people have an argument be it in real life or online, where one changes the other's opinion 180 degrees. But at the very least your words plant the seeds of doubt. I think it's normal that changing a point of view that you've held for many years to take time.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by afiori on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:16PM (#19853516)
That is because of survivors bias, there will always be hate online, that does not mean it will be the same people.
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by WAHa_06x36 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:19AM (#19847755)
Why exactly would people want to share a space with racists, antisemites, and every kind of vile hatred? Why would you not go to place that does not accept that kind of utter garbage instead?
Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by jamsch on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @05:44AM (#19847886)
Don't you think that despite being uncomfortable with people that have opinions that you perceive as immoral, that banning them will only heighten their cause and become more radical?

It just seems evident to me that unpersoning them will force them in to a place that reinforces their own ideological biases which would make them more radical, and with being a social outcast, they'd have nothing to lose.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by dTal on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @12:01PM (#19850723)
Rome wasn't built in a day. It might be a wretched hive of scum and villany now, but as it gets picked up by more and more people, some of those people won't be quite as extreme as the average. Unless there was someone deliberately banning users who weren't extreme enough, over time the community would inevitably become more moderate (or more likely, shrink and die).

It's practically an axiom - in any community without iron-fisted moderation and gatekeeping, the original hard core will end up complaining about how great it used to be before all the normies invaded.

Re:Mozilla and Google Chrome Refuse to Support Gab’s Dissent... by beezischillin on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @11:12AM (#19850212)
Well, I don't use Twitter either.