News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by rscho on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:47PM (#19828833)
What if higher education did its job and actually delivered skilled people instead of offering "the best campus experience"?

Edit: to make myself clear, I absolutely think universities should focus more on thinking than doing. That is not a valid excuse for focusing on campus experience and the like.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by agent00f on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:14PM (#19829046)
Higher ed in form of universities aren't meant to be trade schools. Their purpose is to produce thinkers instead of technicians, which unfortunately industry isn't well equipped to utilize.

Also, parroting political talking points about snowflake kids and such doesn't provide any value, even if draws support from a certain type of crowd.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by Aeolun on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:20PM (#19829095)
I don’t think university is very well equipped to produce either thinkers or technicians.

Right up until you get to your postdoc is seems like you’re mostly playing ‘guess the right answer’ with your professors.

It’s great for another dose of slightly more specialized basic knowledge, but it’s not going to prepare you for anything after that unless you stay in academia.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by agent00f on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:29PM (#19829163)
The point of assignments and such is to guide students through the thought processes useful to understanding material in depth. It's arguably true that some students can get by via guessing or whatever, but the disservice is mainly to themselves. Might as well pay someone to do the work for you.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by rscho on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:20PM (#19829089)
Absolutely, I agree. Thing is, practicals should make students, well... practice a lot. So if a university produces great thinkers and average workers, I'd say that it achieved what it was set for. If a university produces great thinkers and dismal workers, then that university does not exist.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by nafey on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:19PM (#19829086)
Perhaps more cynically the job of universities is not to train students but to rank them. If you are the top of the class at some ivy league school there is a likelihood of you being good a good paper shuffler at mid level management position
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by bhl on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:01PM (#19828937)
What if we stopped relying on higher education with its high tuition fees to produce skilled workers, and instead focus on community colleges and K-12 education?
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by fjsolwmv on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:17PM (#19829063)
What if Universities were as low cost as community colleges, as they are in most of the economically developed world?

High tuition colleges only exist prey on low-talent people trying to buy fake credentials. Anybody talented enough to learn from a college what they can't learn at a lower priced college, can get a scholarship to that college.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by agent00f on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:22PM (#19829104)
All education is inherently time/resource consuming and thereby expensive.

What many are proposing here is expending that into trade schools/edu, which I suppose makes sense for what most coding consists of. But what's most revealing is this insistence on the public shouldering that burden instead of employers who reap the benefits investing into the training.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by rscho on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:04PM (#19828957)
I also agree with that. We could also ask parents to actually educate children, but it seems that's too much to ask.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by fjsolwmv on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:18PM (#19829074)
It is, when we insist parents work two fill time jobs to feed, clothe and house their children.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by rscho on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:37PM (#19829224)
It's your job as a parent to make your kid fit for school. And by that I mean a kid that knows to listen, respect others, and learn. Even poor people can do that.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by TomMarius on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:50PM (#19829890)
What if we made open source (including content) online university?
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by maxerickson on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:51PM (#19828857)
Academia has never seen itself that way.

It's pretty stupid that a 4 year degree is turning into a checkmark credential. It's a lot of time and effort to invest into something you aren't particularly interested in but need to get some job where the time and effort put towards the degree don't mean a lot.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by Kaveren on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:14PM (#19829041)
How is this your takeaway from the article? Anyone moderately intelligent is capable of learning most topics traditionally taught in higher education on their own, even if they use the same learning resources that colleges typically do for the topic.

The argument of the article is very clearly that prospective employees should be judged based on skills, not degrees. It doesn't matter if higher education improves. This still holds.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by fjsolwmv on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:19PM (#19829083)
Why do schools exist in the first place, if almost everyone can just learn on their own?
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by Kaveren on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:41PM (#19829251)
To answer your point when talking about colleges, people like being spoonfed because they are lazy. This is why video tutorials for, say, programming are so popular, and why you see people ask about how to learn programming from scratch for the millionth time, when answers are a search engine entry away.

The primary benefit of college is a degree. Networking is a secondary benefit, where the more elite the college the better opportunity is.

There is absolutely no difference in the quality of self-education in, say, computer science or mathematics vs. going to a top-tier college for it, given a motivated, moderately intelligent student.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by analognoise on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:47PM (#19829278)
Right, those people are lazy, which is why almost all of the people who complete MOOCs have previous degrees, and much ink has been spilled about "boot camps" that have better success re-tooling someone with a 4 year degree than someone off the street.

"I already had a bachelor's degree in Biology, it turns out I could learn to code!" - Huge shocker...

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by Kaveren on Saturday May 04, 2019 @05:06PM (#19829384)
My entire point is consistently that the point of college is a degree. It's completely sensible for the vast majority of people to go to college for the great economic benefits it provides in terms of job opportunities. This does not mean it offers any real learning benefit over self-education for a variety of fields.

Just take computer science, an easy one because of the abundant resources available through the Internet. There is absolutely zero gain, once again, for the moderately intelligent, motivated student, in terms of learning from going to a college vs. a motivated, well-thought self-study. Study plans are available online. Course syllabuses are available online. Textbooks are available online. Problem solutions are available online.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by ThrowawayR2 on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:03PM (#19829669)
> There is absolutely zero gain, once again, for the moderately intelligent, motivated student, in terms of learning from going to a college vs. a motivated, well-thought self-study.

One autodidact thinks: "No need to go to college and pay all that money; I can learn it all on my own". Some actually put in the effort to do so and do quite well in their lives.

Another autodidact thinks: "Holy ____, there are facilities, equipment, and educated experts here that I could never hope to get access to on my own! If I use my autodidact ability to take advantage of this huge concentration of knowledge resources, I can not only learn the basic stuff in the classes but a whole bunch of advanced topics besides." These people go on to work on what people refer to as "interesting problems" at FAANG-level technology companies and have fun doing it, not to mention being paid amazingly well.

Choose wisely, autodidacts.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by analognoise on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:12PM (#19829719)
/thread.
Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by analognoise on Saturday May 04, 2019 @05:52PM (#19829624)
One of my favorite quotes of Sir Francis Bacon:

"that whosoever hath his mind fraught with many thoughts, his wits and understanding do clarify and break up, in the communicating and discoursing with another; he tosseth his thoughts more easily; he marshalleth them more orderly, he seeth how they look when they are turned into words: finally, he waxeth wiser than himself; and that more by an hour's discourse, than by a day's meditation"

It is often paraphrased today as, "I learn more in an hour's discourse than in a day's meditation."

You're reinforcing my point: If all this information is out there, and the only people actually completing it are those who have already gone through a degree program... maybe this shit's relatively hard to learn on your own? Maybe there should be some kind of institution, where completing a course of study awards some kind of certificate... crazy talk??

It was said of of {Gauss, Newton, Euler - I forgot who} that he made his way by Euclid's Elements by simply reading until he did not understand, then thinking until he understood, then returning, until he had gone through the whole thing by himself. I am not Newton. Neither are you. Neither is almost anyone.

It turns out that learning is something of a team sport, and is best accomplished (for the vast majority of humanity) in some kind of structured environment, and that we respond better to people than to screens of videos. Who knew...!

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by Kaveren on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:05PM (#19829678)
> "If all this information is out there, and the only people actually completing it are those who have already gone through a degree program"

MOOCs are a complete waste of time. Boot camps are just a worse and cheaper version of college, in terms of learning. They both cater to those who refuse to read. People serious about learning on their own are not going to use MOOCs.

Discussion is available online about many topics. Your notion that someone has to be Newton to read through a book and understand it is ridiculous.

Re:What if we hired for skills, not degrees? by analognoise on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:11PM (#19829711)
Discussion...like the kind of discussion you'd have with a teacher, who knew the subject?

So we're back to having people fully involved, might as well just cut the crap and go to school.