News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by andreilys on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:44PM (#19822918)
A similar case can be made for Chinese tech companies, many of whom are actively complicit in human rights violations [1] [2].

Yet EU countries like Italy have no qualms about supporting the geopolitical aims of China, inevitably strengthening the position of the Chinese tech companies. Which should come to no surprise given their close ties to the communist party [3] [4].

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-01/alibaba-b...

[2] https://www.thestar.com/news/huawei/2019/03/27/canadas-partn...

[3] https://www.ft.com/content/5d0af3c4-846c-11e8-a29d-73e3d4545...

[4] https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/02/tech/china-tech-communist-par...

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by markdown on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:51PM (#19822967)
> A similar case can be made for Chinese companies, many of whom are actively complicit in human rights violations

Snowden showed us that US companies routinely do this, with FISA forcing them to participate just like the Chinese Govt does to Chinese companies. Also, US law only protects the human rights of US citizens, while non-citizens get their privacy invaded routinely (in contravention of Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights).

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by andreilys on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:28PM (#19823165)
US tech companies routinely aid the government in systematic ethnic cleansing [1]?

Also last time I remember there being a showdown on privacy between Apple and the FBI, Apple refused their request to side-load software that would allow them to crack a terrorists phone. I can't imagine Huawei being able to refuse such a request from the Communist party.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/ethn...

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by Shivetya on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:40PM (#19823491)
well many of them have no problem using China for a manufacturing base and frankly how is that different from companies based there? I scoff at companies like Apple touting their concern for rights when they effectively turn a blind eye to China's behavior because the market is too valuable
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by markdown on Sunday May 05, 2019 @02:37AM (#19831509)
> US tech companies routinely aid the government in systematic ethnic cleansing [1]?

Perhaps you're responding to the wrong comment. This thread is about the invasion of ones human right to privacy.

As for the other point, the public show by Apple is irrelevant... of course they publicly refuse to cooperate with the FBI. FISA warrants are secret though and in any case, would have no ability to refuse an order from a FISA court.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by whynotminot on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:18PM (#19823917)
This false equivalence is incredibly, incredibly dangerous.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by vfclists on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:55PM (#19823800)
I guess unlike the EU China displays no interest in "flooding "Europe with illegal immigrants of incompatible cultures from third world countries.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by hungryhobo on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:17PM (#19823104)
Whataboutism
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ggm on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:39PM (#19823226)
A rebuttal which ignores the problem of moral relativism. Yes, it whataboutism. No,it doesn't mean it can be ignored. If our privilege is to critique the other and refuse to fix our own, we're all impoverished. Also, strong biblical roots to whataboutism in the mote/beam parable no?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by Mirioron on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:25PM (#19820937)
Maybe the EU and European countries could've fostered an environment where tech companies could've been successful as well?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by southerndrift on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:30PM (#19823450)
In 1985, chancellor Kohl stopped the German network that was on track to deliver 100M fiber connections to every home until the year 2000 [1].

They could have fostered an environment for tech companies, but at least Germany chose do something else.

[1] https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Missing-Link-Der-Kam...

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ggm on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:40PM (#19823233)
Wolfson. Olivetti. The EU fosters an environment where tech companies can be successful and then they're crushed by American market dominance because murica.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by jnurmine on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:34AM (#19825220)
Personal opinion: the biggest problem of Europe is the marketing, or rather the lack of it and its ineffectiveness.

USA completely owns this.

Just look at what the Silicon Valley media-integrated marketing machine can do. A complete fraud with unsubstantiated promises like Theranos raised 700M with a 10B valuation. Even though they had nothing, their visions became practically an established fact in world wide media, driven by articles like the one in Wired in 2014 ("This Woman Invented a Way to Run 30 Lab Tests on Only One Drop of Blood").

Europe needs to learn to "overpromise and underdeliver" as well. And they need an integrated way to push the message of shiny new stuff to blue-eyed technology media to amplify it into people's consciousness.

I don't mean to create frauds like Theranos. I mean to say (for example) you will drone deliver on-demand customized popsicles made on the orbit of Mars five years from now, and then end up mailing customized ice cream made in Denmark instead.

People might find the greatest product in the world organically, eventually, by getting fed up with the alternatives, but in the meanwhile those banging the drum the most may just end up cornering the market.

I don't think the biggest problem is about salaries or luring in venture capital or the nature of legislation or density of microbreweries within a square kilometer or something like that. I think it is simply about marketing. (And this is not to say that other things play no role whatsoever)

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by viraptor on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:11PM (#19823625)
What specifically do you have in mind? I mean, it's easy to ask this in general, but what do you think needs changing?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by zamalek on Saturday May 04, 2019 @01:03AM (#19824563)
If they want EU citizens to enjoy the fantastic EU privacy protections via EU tech giants, they need to have a beneficial legislative ecosystem. GDPR needs work (as only the giants can afford more than zero breaches, which are an unfortunate reality for every company at some point) and their shiny new copyright law is outright fatal to startups.

EU legislation has a very clear message: start your tech company elsewhere.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by Mirioron on Sunday May 05, 2019 @08:46PM (#19836046)
I wholeheartedly agree with this. I think people don't quite understand the extent of GDPR. Hurting start ups and hobby projects that might make some money on the side means that you'll have fewer successful businesses down the line. It also means that you'll have fewer qualified workers.

The problem in the EU is that GDPR isn't the first such signal the EU has sent either. The cookie law was a signal that indicated that the EU regulates things without understanding what they're doing. The data retention act from over a decade ago was similar. I'm sure there were others even before that, but probably on a national level.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by m0zg on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:00PM (#19822668)
Venture capital and socialism (+overgrown, multi-level bureaucracies in the EU's case) can't really coexist. Nor can $200K+ US salaries coexist with $70K EU salaries for software engineers. So I wish Tusk good luck dealing with this one.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by djohnston on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:34PM (#19823195)
god the pay cut is so real :( .. hopefully the experience makes up for it, temporarily
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by johannes1234321 on Saturday May 04, 2019 @08:13AM (#19825953)
The "pay cut" is one-dimensional. In Europe I don't have student debt. In Europe I pay less for health care. In Europe I have more time of. In Europe I have better public infrastructure. In Europe I pay less for housing than the Valley.

Of course you can validate those things differently, but only looking on salary tells little.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by m0zg on Saturday May 04, 2019 @03:53PM (#19828871)
You don't pay that much less for healthcare. Remember, it's not the government that's paying for it, it's _you_ paying, with your taxes. The cost structure is different, that's true (European doctors also make a lot less, and US pharma companies subsidize non-US customers for some reason), but that doesn't matter with a typical US SWE salary.

And with a fat $200K+ paycheck student debt goes away in a few years, if you had it in the first place (substantial fraction of students receive financial assistance).

Best of both worlds: get your "free" degree in Europe, move to the US, make a killing. This, in short, is Tusk's problem.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by johannes1234321 on Saturday May 04, 2019 @05:56PM (#19829635)
> You don't pay that much less for healthcare. Remember, it's not the government that's paying for it, it's _you_ paying, with your taxes

Well, if I look at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_h... per capita is almost double to many European countries.

But even then comparison is hard, since treatments etc. differ.

> And with a fat $200K+ paycheck student debt goes away in a few years, if you had it in the first place (substantial fraction of students receive financial assistance).

If a European however, isntea dofnoayingnof debt has some money to invest there can be long term benefits (also Europeans often have better retirement funds)

All just to say that is complicated and comparison is hard. And true, it can financially be beneficial to get a good education in Europe and the go to make some money. Tusk's issue however is that digital world is important and US has a big leap and control.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by m0zg on Saturday May 04, 2019 @06:12PM (#19829721)
Sure, but as a SWE you're making 3 times as much and paying half as much in taxes. You have to take that into account when deciding which is better for you economically, and it won't be in Europe's favor.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by djohnston on Thursday May 09, 2019 @02:42PM (#19870941)
3x and .5x in US taxes are pretty hefty exaggerations, but I agree, financially you're better off working in the US. that being said, im moving to the UK for a year or two with the intent of traveling a lot through Europe, so there are other considerations that may sway your decisions :)
[dead]
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by outlace on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:50PM (#19822147)
But it also seems that the US produces new big tech companies in new sectors whereas Europe appears not to. Sure maybe there aren’t any viable Google or Facebook competitors, but the US produces Stripe, Airbnb, uber, etc.
[dead]
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by askafriend on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:50PM (#19822607)
I'm sorry but Taxis were a criminally poor, inefficient, and dangerous product before Uber came along. I'd like to see you argue in favor of Taxis, because there really aren't many good arguments or excuses for how they operated and really just squandered their own opportunity.

Uber is better on literally every single dimension.

Stripe is an international company that's facilitated by the internet.

[dead]
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by askafriend on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:40PM (#19822895)
You're aware of the Taxi lobby and borderline criminal interests and practices surrounding Taxi medallions right?

Not to mention that if you were black or lived in under-resourced areas, good luck getting a Taxi to stop for you or go where you need to go.

> The fact that the only way to improve upon the situation required a series of criminal conspiracies and attempts to obstruct justice that were never properly punished reflects very poorly on the country.

Isn't this an ironic statement given the actual history of how America was founded?

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by JeremyBanks on Saturday May 04, 2019 @11:22AM (#19826991)
> You're aware of the Taxi lobby and borderline criminal interests and practices surrounding Taxi medallions right?

> Yes, America's existing taxi system was also awful.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by arkades on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:06PM (#19823608)
NYC taxis are incomparably better to most European city taxis. It’s not in NYC that I came to appreciate Uber.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ComputerGuru on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:02PM (#19821264)
I'm not sure why the comments here are unusually toxic, but I think it is good to hear this. The EU tech sector has an opportunity to create customer-first text services with a strong focus on privacy and data portability, but it'll need some concessions and some support. There's no reason why the EU cannot replicate at least some of the success the US has had in the tech market, and even internally it has a large enough market to give rise to some healthy entities.

Of course these might be actually sustainable businesses and not startups playing the unicorn game with VCs, trading at impossible sky-high valuations instead of what they're really worth and without a vision for profitability, so whatever metric you use to calculate success should definitely take that into account.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by akersten on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:19PM (#19821407)
I don't think it's toxic to criticize the regulatory practices that have created the business environment that the article laments. Actually I think it's more than fair to do so. "Blunt" may be a better word to describe the comments here.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ajuc on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:30PM (#19821494)
In which way does regulation create the business environment that the article laments?

EU was always behind in internet stuff, even when there was no regulation.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by adventured on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:54PM (#19821687)
Indeed, Europe has been behind the US in tech since WW2. The lead the US acquired in the following ~20 years has proven impossible to overcome. It spawned so many various advantages that compound and build on each other (to say nothing of the single market of enormous size).

If they knew what they were doing, they'd start by massively increasing the pay for software developers across Western Europe. Software is why the US dominates global tech. 1.25 million software developers earning a median of $105,000 in salary.

Software is why Japan wasn't able to dominate tech, despite that being the near universal thought - that it was the inevitable outcome - in the late 1980s and early 1990s. They couldn't do software well, it's the difference between Apple doing the iPod and Sony flailing after the Walkman. It's also why Apple murdered Nokia, it's the software: the smartphone is about the software, not the hardware (which always drifts towards commodity, low value, low margin; Apple was focused on building a device that could effectively run serious software programs). The rise of Microsoft from 1975 to its eventual position as global tech titan by the time Win95 came out, charts the course of the US solidifying its position in tech via software margins. Most of the value gradually shifted from hardware to software, from the 1970s to the 1990s. The immensely profitable nature of most software pours an endless deluge of profit into the US tech machine (which is then used to keep expanding it and buying up global competition).

US cloud dominance is similarly all about the software, rather than hardware in the cloud (again, low margin, low value). It's why Europe can't compete with AWS. Imagine if the US tech dominance were dependent on competing in server hardware, black rectangle smartphones or PC boxes. The US would have entirely gotten its brains stomped in by now. Instead, the US moved upstream and got all the profit in the tech industry: it's all in the software margins.

It's the software, Europe. Pay your software developers a lot more if you want to compete.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by bjelkeman-again on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:09PM (#19822297)
It isn't really about software developers pay IMHO. I think it is about: a relatively poorly capitalised investment community (relative to the US); relatively (to the US) inexperienced VCs/accelerators; a splintered market with a variety of regulators, languages, rules, currencies, cultures etc; more conservative approach (not left/right politics) in politics and in business.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by NotSammyHagar on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:24PM (#19821930)
That arc of software history is recognizable to me. There are excellent devs all over and pretty much every large company has divisions with european offices with devs. There's something about the business of starting large software based enterprises that seems to work better in the us though.

Also, I think China is coming for the us software industry's dominance. If they can figure out how to get around the worry of chinese govt access to external to china customers, chinese software companies could out compete the us, just like microsoft with windows beat out ibm maybe.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by Slartie on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:52PM (#19822978)
That "something" is the huge, relatively homogeneous, english-speaking and thus very "international-by-default" single market.

It's the one and only actual moat that the US has over Europe when it comes to developing huge corporations in the winner-takes-all online markets. Everything else (like better VC situation, more attractive environment for international talent) is just a result of this original moat and would have just as well developed the other way round if this one advantage had been on the other side of the Atlantic.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by belltaco on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:49PM (#19823532)
>If they knew what they were doing, they'd start by massively increasing the pay for software developers across Western Europe.

So the governments of Western Europe should just increase the pay for software developers?

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by tootahe45 on Friday May 03, 2019 @03:14PM (#19821365)
There's no reason Europeans can't just do it from a place where they get better access capital and a more business-friendly environment (unless the EU tries to stop this by creating a 'safe' website list like China, or penalizing US companies in other ways). One problem with firewalling Google, Facebook, is that the fines bring in more money than European tech.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by shmerl on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:47PM (#19821149)
EU officials are totally helping things with Article 13 and Co.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by rasz on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:07PM (#19821793)
For reference, _his party_ was pushing Article 13 in EU Parliament. September 12 everyone from PO voted for censorship:

  Michał Boni (PO)
  Jerzy Buzek (PO)
  Danuta Hübner (PO)
  Danuta Jazłowiecka (PO)
  Agnieszka Kozłowska-Rajewicz (PO)
  Barbara Kudrycka (PO)
  Janusz Lewandowski (PO)
  Elżbieta Łukacjiewska (PO)
  Jan Olbrycht (PO)
  Julia Pitera (PO)
  Marek Plura (PO)
  Dariusz Rosati (PO)
  Adam Szejnfeld (PO)
  Róża Thun Und Hohenstein (PO)
  Jarosław Wałęsa (PO)
  Bogdan Wenta (PO)
  Bogdan Zdrojewski (PO)
  Tadeusz Zwiefka (PO)

Final April vote pro censorship:

  Danuta Hübner (PO)
  Agnieszka Kozłowska-Rajewicz (PO)
  Barbara Kudrycka (PO)
  Julia Pitera (PO)
  Bogdan Zdrojewski (PO)
  Tadeusz Zwiefka (PO)
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by d33 on Saturday May 04, 2019 @07:54AM (#19825886)
I found it quite surprising and decided to double-check. This source doesn't seem to agree if I'm reading it right:

https://saveyourinternet.eu/pl/

Could you let me know where you have this information from?

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by rasz on Saturday May 04, 2019 @04:40PM (#19829243)
you are right, I was missing

  Danuta Jazłowiecka (PO)
so the final list is 7 for Article 13
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by d33 on Sunday May 05, 2019 @12:23PM (#19833529)
Either of us is reading it backwards - for example, Michał Boni is "green" in both "Vote on Possibility to Change the Final Text" and "Final Vote on Copyright Directive". Doesn't it mean he opposed it? Or is the first list of yours referring to a third voting, not mentioned on the website?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by rasz on Sunday May 05, 2019 @05:57PM (#19835333)
First list is "September 12 vote", the very first ACTA 2 one.

Just for reference, official PO party twitter posted this https://twitter.com/platforma_org/status/1015184834623365120 "No to ACTA" in July, and in 2012 Tusk (very same from main topic, head of PO) officially announced Polish position as "categorical YES to ACTA, nothing will change our mind" https://www.tvn24.pl/wiadomosci-z-kraju,3/premier-podpiszemy...

PO party is a Platform of corruption and lies, they used to change tune every poll/elections and are implicated in every major corruption scandal to date.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by wazoox on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:56PM (#19822205)
EU officials don't understand the current trade war. The US keeps coercing EU companies, buying them out by force (Alstom), pushing them out of markets (Iran), using extortion against EU banks, generally pressuring the EU in the position of an obedient vassal; but the EU doesn't get it, at all. That's a tragedy (for us Europeans).

Eu officials are completely bought into the free market ideology and "gentle commerce". Nowadays strategic companies are even sold to the Chinese, because "free markets". Morons. EU is inept, useless.

It's quite saying that Russia, with its limited means, limited population and GDP inferior to Italy, successfully kept its digital independence (mostly).

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by temp-dude-87844 on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:23PM (#19822419)
A lot of core EU policies are based the neoliberal "gentle free markets" model of the world, like the rules to privatize infrastructure, transport, and telecom. They're largely to allow an EU-wide market where protectionism applies at the level of the entire bloc and not at the level of individual countries, but they are easily taken advantage in an asymmetric setting. It's not unlike how US companies go into China to show growth, yet complain about the coercion and theft of their IP, as if these happenings weren't an open secret.

The US takes advantage of EU's tech landscape being worse paid, more regulated, and less nimble, and takes advantage of the difficulties of policing the interaction between users and Internet-delivered services.

China takes advantage of the naivete of the EU and the greed of the US. Other players, like Russia, UAE, and Qatar play a similar game, but unlike China they don't use hardware and software, but stick to property ownership and influencing hearts and minds.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by wazoox on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:00PM (#19822665)
Except that no protectionism at all happens at the EU level, because officials are completely clueless. Or bought-out, I don't really know. that's my point when I say that they're useless, toothless really.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by katanaman on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:08PM (#19823872)
Had the chance to live a few years in western Europe and I was shocked at the servility of the European institutions to the American interests.

In Europe nobody dares to criticize clearly and openly the ways of the US, not even the communists. No wonder Obama was a huge hit in Europe. Perhaps this explains why most Americans think of Europeans as a spineless and weak

I'm not leftist at all but I have to admit that Chavez had more balls than the whole western Europe

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by fithisux on Saturday May 04, 2019 @02:43AM (#19824847)
EU failed to gather participating countries in an equalizing force of progress freedom and wisdom. It transform to a hegemony like the first Athenean alliance. We failed to our targets and in the meantime,, the external empires got stronger and lesser democratic. We failed miserably. I believe in the European dream, but not with these European politicians. We have no relation to the universal human, we have transformed to consumer/money junkies a new generation of cyber aboriginals ta satisfy our inner appetite for quality with beads like 500 years ago. Shame on the homo universalis, shame on the European christians.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ycombonator on Friday May 03, 2019 @04:55PM (#19822191)
Tusk stuck between a rock (America FANG) and a hard place (China/ Huawei).
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by panpanna on Friday May 03, 2019 @01:48PM (#19820577)
"The European Union has been in the forefront of efforts to tighten control on how social media companies handle the personal data of consumers"

Yeah, that's why.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ahartmetz on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:55PM (#19821218)
That is really total rubbish. How could 1-2 year old regulations go back 30+ years to stifle the European "tech scene"? By the way, there is other technology than that which is used to sell advertising on the internet.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by sadris on Friday May 03, 2019 @05:28PM (#19822458)
European hostility to business rights in general is a much larger elephant in the room.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by dmix on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:20PM (#19823131)
Indeed anyone who has started a potentially global business quickly learns to avoid European markets for as long as possible.

Paying for lawyers, exploring utilizing local business networks to avoid headaches, and countless special edge cases is a great deterannce from offering services/products there... Let alone building actual companies and teams from there.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by repolfx on Saturday May 04, 2019 @09:48AM (#19826406)
It's a long standing and complex trend.

It's worth remembering that Silicon Valley got started way back in the 50s with Shockley's transistors. Then Microsoft in the 80s and Amazon, Google in the 1990s.

What was going on in Europe during these times?

For most of the 20th century continental Europe was a hotbed of dictators and extremists. The first half was dominated by two world wars that flattened everything. The second half saw dictatorships across all of eastern Europe that kept it impoverished, there were dictatorships in Spain and Greece and significant political instability and corruption for decades in Italy.

Britain, which came out of WW2 the strongest having been on the winning side, was nonetheless totally wrecked and worse still, the population concluded that the government must be pretty good at things due both to the victory and years of news suppression which prevented people learning about government errors (e.g. Exercise Tiger). So Britain became strongly socialist and remained that way until Thatcher in the 80s. The economic destruction this socialist environment wrecked was extreme enough that the UK had to go to the IMF for a bailout and was suffering things like electricity shortages during the worst periods of the 1970s. It was a place where even established businesses struggled to survive, so the idea of a startup culture or creating advanced tech firms was totally absurd - the government had given up even attempting to fix things and unions under the control of Marxists were practically shadow governments in and of themselves.

In other words, if you look at the time that the USA was establishing startups like Intel that'd become huge tech firms, which then spawned generations of technically skilled VCs, Europe was mostly either actual communist dictatorships or so hard left that the idea of creating dynamic new businesses was a pipe dream. There was no environment in which to create the generations of successful entrepreneurs that America benefits from.

Interestingly, Germany did much better than Britain during this time because - having had their faith in government wisdom destroyed by the Nazis - Germany deregulated and experienced much better economic growth, despite having been cleaved in half by the Soviets. This sowed the seeds of German economic strength dominating the Euro today.

Things only really changed for most of Europe in the 1990s with the fall of the USSR, reunification of Germany and Thatcher's reforms having turned around the UK. But then Europe collectively decided that the right path into the future was to slowly merge together under a vast centralised bureaucracy centred in Brussels, one which had its roots in the Ventotene Manifesto, a document written by communists in the 40s. Remarkably, the EU to this day still has never really shaken a vague sense that communism was roughly in the right area. Its ultra-powerful unaccountable Commission President (Juncker) routinely makes statements like "when it gets serious, you have to lie" and he travelled to the birthplace of Karl Marx where he defended Marx's legacy:

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/karl-marx-jea...

The EU has historically often had former communists in its most senior positions and does things in ways that are reminiscent of the USSR (e.g. a Parliament that can't actually overrule the unelected parts of the government). No surprise that it takes an ambivalent view of business, especially successful American business, and largely defines itself as a defender of The People against Capital.

Combined with no culture of granting equity and we have today's situation.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ThrowawayR2 on Saturday May 04, 2019 @10:16AM (#19826576)
> The first half was dominated by two world wars that flattened everything [in Europe].

What about Japan's rise from a bombed out, defeated nation to a G7 economic power and world leader in electronics and automotives in the same time period?

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by repolfx on Saturday May 04, 2019 @01:23PM (#19827830)
Good question. I suspect it's like Germany and precision machinery/automotives.

Japan lost comprehensively enough to destroy any notion that their government was good, and had a huge US involvement in the rebuild. IOW they were rebuilt along US lines and, like Germany, benefited from the "loser's victory" in which they avoided a sharp turn towards big government.

During the same era the UK lost its own car manufacturing industry, with aggressive unions and general industrial malaise being the prime culprits.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by dfrage on Saturday May 04, 2019 @10:18AM (#19826594)
Exiting WWII Britain was fully competitive in computer technology, look particularly at the University of Manchester, home of the Williams Tube and many pioneering computers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_computers which Ferranti was barely able to move the needle in commercializing.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by repolfx on Saturday May 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#19827878)
The UK had a small but modern computer industry in the 1980s, via Acorn and the resulting ARM chips that are world-beating today. It also had firms like RIM, Sinclair etc.

Until ARM was sold to SoftBank it was the primary British high tech computer firm. Little known fact - ARM is one of the very few European tech firms that incentivised its employees with equity sharing. It was and still is standard for firms outside the USA to keep all equity for the founders and investors, with none for early employees.

It's hard to know to what extent Acorn struggled to compete with Apple because of Europe-specific factors vs just bad luck: Acorn computers were very slow to get FCC regulatory approval in the USA, and they had a failure in their supply chain at a critical moment that pushed Brits towards buying US computers instead. They sold 300k machines but could only get 30k from the factories. There were a few other problems that stalled their expansion, and all this was taking place in the context of a country going through a major recession as Thatcher ended a government policy of employment targeting to bring inflation under control (inflation hit 22% in 1980). In the end they never recovered - US firms grew too strong and outcompeted them, despite initially stronger technology. Given that Acorn and ARM showed the same cycle of former employees becoming entrepreneurs and investors themselves, it's possible if things had worked out a bit differently for Acorn it could have been the "British Apple" and seeded a British computer industry competitive with Silicon Valley. But - it didn't.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by dfrage on Saturday May 04, 2019 @02:45PM (#19828377)
How much of Acorn even having a chance is consistent with your correct as far as I know history of the British economy, with socialism only being (partly) rolled back by Thatcher? I'd also note that Apple et. al. were also subject to similar macroeconomic headwinds, although our inflation rate's peak was "only" 15%.

Bad luck indeed, although looking at the details of e.g. the Acorn Electron which had that production bottleneck doesn't suggest they had significantly stronger technology at the time, pretty much all 6502 based stuff like their competition except for e.g. the also local Sinclair Research with its Z80 based systems. In the US market there was also the Z80 based and monstrously successful Tandy TRS-80, per Wikipedia significantly outselling the Apple II for a long period.

Tandy also had a huge retail network to sell its wares, it's Radio Shack stores were the place to buy random basic electronic stuff all over the USA. Per Wikipedia, in 1982 4,300 company stores and 2,000 independent franchises in towns not big enough for a company store. One reason I mention this is to ask, how big was it in the U.K. post-WWII until Thatcher? It became a very big thing the US in the 1950s, combining local capital and market focus with centralized and bulk product planning, technology, marketing, and often purchasing.

Hmmmm, Tandy also did a Motorola 6809 based "Color Computer" of some note, but its expensive/superior CPU prompted them to forgo things that made competing 6502 systems more popular, like built in sound and graphics for e.g. games. There was also a very American cottage industry style market in Z80 CP/M systems built around the S-100 bus.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by repolfx on Sunday May 05, 2019 @04:58AM (#19831849)
Radio Shack was pretty big in the UK. I remember them having stores when I was a kid.

I think the general macro-economic and social conditions may explain why Acorn was rare, whereas the US birthed many such companies. But then again, the UK has less than a quarter of the population of the USA, so presumably that right there should slash the number of companies.

I've also done a focus switch in this discussion, from all of Europe to just the UK. The rest of Europe was still very messed up outside of west Germany and the small northern states, either dictatorships, or just exited from dictatorship, or were France:

https://uramericansinparis.wordpress.com/2010/12/15/france-i...

West Germany gave birth to SAP in 1972, UK gave birth to Acorn and a few other small computer firms that didn't really make it, only SAP and ARM still survive and only one independent. I don't know of any big French tech firms from this era, but maybe there is one.

So I guess Acorn and maybe SAP are the exceptions that highlight just how dire conditions were in most of Europe at this time.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by AtomicOrbital on Saturday May 04, 2019 @11:41AM (#19827123)
yes however Britain squeltched its own computer scientists and engineers, Tommy Flowers in particular, immediately after WWII due to false concerns of military secrecy
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by dfrage on Saturday May 04, 2019 @12:54PM (#19827634)
That's not reflected by the historical record of the U.K.'s post war pioneering computers, which I provided just one link to.

Per Wikipedia Tommy Flowers couldn't get a bank loan because he couldn't cite his cryptoanalysis machines as proof he could do what he claimed he could do. "False concerns of military secrecy" when we were in an existential cold war with international socialism? That put so much of Europe under Soviet occupation?

Or the cited severe lack of funding mechanisms and other things necessary for commercial success, going all the way to the concept of doing stuff outside the aegis of the government which included the public University of Manchester? The latter could and did make numerous record breaking computers, going at least as far as the early 1960s Atlas, a competitive microsecond cycle supercomputer that was the first to page. But this didn't translate into commercial success.

Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by plandis on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:34PM (#19823714)
Of course he is, US is in a much stronger position than the EU in the technology sector. You think he'd be saying the same thing if Google, Amazon, Facebook, Microsoft, etc... acted the exact same but were EU companies? I doubt it.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by ga-vu on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:39PM (#19823223)
I'd be worried more by Chinese companies. At least you can sue US companies. You can't do the same with Chinese ones.
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by qnsi on Saturday May 04, 2019 @10:13AM (#19826556)
how often do you use apps created by Chinese companies?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by vfclists on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:59PM (#19823817)
Is that measly article worthy of posting to HN, or was it crafted especially for HN?
Re:EU's Tusk warns of risks in rise of U.S. tech giants by lazyjones on Friday May 03, 2019 @02:57PM (#19821242)
I'm sure the bureaucrats in charge of the EU will have great success with their "EU last" policy.

(apologies for cynicism by a disappointed European)