News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:28AM (#19808875)
Keep in mind all the crimes by US officials that Assange revealed. In my view many of those crimes committed by officials are treason, yet all have been swept under the rug.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by mavdi on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:38AM (#19809016)
None of the things he revealed can be classified as treason. War crimes maybe, treason no way. I also wonder why he never revealed any of Russia's alleged crimes in Ukraine or Syria. Just a thought.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by ivanhoe on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:05PM (#19809370)
Sorry, but this is a nonsense. I grew up in a country where people made it a national sport of justifying one side's crimes by arguing that the other sides (Croats/Serbs/Bosniaks/etc) committed the crimes too. That's just stupid. So what if he's concentrated on one side, does it make it a less of a crime? Should he have not publish it, unless he had an equal amount of dirt on Russians on hands in the same time (Syria and Ukraine haven't even happen yet in the moment of these US leaks)? And finally, if it's wrong to concentrate only on one side's wrongdoing, does it mean that all other reporters - who report ONLY on Russians for years now - are guilty the same way?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:41PM (#19811896)
You are overlooking the most significant item. Why was all the information in the war logs classified in the first place? The power to classify information is only legitimately used for very narrow purposes. The war logs show that the US government used that power inappropriately to deliberately deceive the American people about the war efforts.

The men and women of the armed forces risk their lives over these wars. The public funds them with taxation. The wars have cost as much as 7 years of a 50% tax cut for everyone earning under $500K. That is such a large number that any social program, any infrastructure challenge is dwarfed by it. The post 9/11 wars are the biggest financial fraud in the history of the world.

We found out thanks to Assange that our leaders hid information from us so that they could continue stealing our money to wage a war that was very different from what they claimed it was.

We place a great deal of trust in our leaders, and Assange showed that it was not deserved. Still, none of the leaders who did this have been brought to justice.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by ifdefdebug on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:40AM (#19809043)
Did he have access to data about "Russia's alleged crimes in Ukraine or Syria"?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by justinmchase on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:06PM (#19809391)
Wikileaks only publishes what is leaked to them.

They did publish the `Spy Files Russia` documents in 2017:

https://wikileaks.org/spyfiles/russia/

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by nisuni on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:43PM (#19809791)
Can we please stop using this talking point about Russia?

WikiLeaks publishes what they get (after verifying credibility). They cannot publish what is not leaked to them.

Also: they did publish things on Russia.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by dnautics on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:33AM (#19808957)
Treason has a specific definition in the us Constitution and it's a quite difficult bar to cross.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by danso on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:34AM (#19808968)
The Iraq War leak suggested war crimes, but not treason IIRC:

https://www.wired.com/2010/10/wikileaks-press/

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:36AM (#19808988)
Lying about the war crimes was treason in my view
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by matthewowen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#19809006)
"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:38PM (#19810372)
What better aid to our enemies than spending trillions on a futile war?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by gamblor956 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:03PM (#19810650)
Generally, spending too much money to bomb the shit out of your enemies is not considering providing aid to them....anywhere.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:06PM (#19810693)
You are assuming that the groups we are told are our enemies are actually enemies, and that they are the most significant enemies.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by gamblor956 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:53PM (#19811272)
I assume none of that. I know people who died in 9/11, people who died in Mumbai, and people who died in the San Bernardino shooting. I don't need to be told by anyone that the terrorist cowards behind those bombings are our enemies--that much was obvious from them bombing us.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:19PM (#19811587)
And you think the dollars spent on the wars have actually done anything to prevent future attacks such as the ones you mention?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Veen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:39AM (#19809034)
Your view is irrelevant unless you can change the law.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by roywiggins on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:40AM (#19809051)
Not just the law, the US Constitution.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by paulcole on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:44AM (#19809114)
Not necessarily if they can get on the jury and use jury nullification. Or make this concept more well known to people who may be on the jury.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:06PM (#19809384)
It's hard to use jury nullification to convict; it's usually used only to acquit. First, the judge won't usually allow charges that are outside the bounds of the law to even be presented to the jury. Second, even if the jury does convict of something outside the bounds of the law, it will almost certainly be overturned on appeal.

You don't want a jury deciding to convict people for things that the law doesn't say is illegal. You really don't. That's way too close to mob rule, and that often doesn't get applied only to the people that you think it should be applied to. You don't want a jury deciding that what you did is treason, even though the law doesn't say that it is.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by dragonwriter on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:00PM (#19873318)
> First, the judge won't usually allow charges that are outside the bounds of the law to even be presented to the jury. Second, even if the jury does convict of something outside the bounds of the law, it will almost certainly be overturned on appeal.

And in between, if the charges are within the law but the judge feels a reasonable jury could not convict on them, he can (and presumably will) dismiss the charges either before or after the jury verdict; judges cannot toss a jury acquittal (or convict on their own without a jury verdict), but they can and do do the reverse.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by isoskeles on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:07PM (#19809406)
Wouldn't jury nullification be restricted to finding someone not guilty because some law is invalid. This would be the opposite, where we find someone "guilty" of "treason" because the jury decided treason is actually a broader crime that covers acts like lying about war crimes. Doesn't sound like jury "nullification" to me.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by vonmoltke on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:05PM (#19809365)
...then get the trial declared a mistrial, and possibly get held in contempt by the judge for violating their duty as a juror.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Veen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:49AM (#19809190)
Jury nullification is hard to pull off though. I'm not sure Assange would have the support he'd need to guarantee a jury finding in his favor (assuming he's actually guilty of what he's accused of).
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:07PM (#19809396)
paulcole wasn't talking about Assange being convicted, but rather those whom Assange exposed.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Svip on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:42AM (#19809089)
How can it be treason, when he's not a US citizen?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:43AM (#19809106)
I’m referring to the officials not Julian.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:44AM (#19809112)
Lying about a war for corrupt reasons surely qualifies.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by dragonwriter on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:14PM (#19810109)
No, it doesn't. It certainly qualifies as official malfeasance, but treason in the US is defined narrowly in the Constitution (as an express reaction against “treason” being expansively applied.)
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:40PM (#19810389)
What better way to give aid to our enemies than to conduct an expensive war on false pretenses and illegally classify information that would have likely led to public distaste for the war?

Imagine if the leaks showed that the officials wasted money in some other way such as taking gold reserves and destroying them in a nuclear explosion, or sending gold reserves to cronies in other nations. Theft is theft.

Our enemies arguably want us to waste money on unnecessary wars. The officials exposed by Assange were acting in concert with our enemies.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by gamblor956 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:06PM (#19810692)
What better way to give aid to our enemies than to conduct an expensive war on false pretenses and illegally classify information that would have likely led to public distaste for the war?

Giving money to our enemies would be a better way to give them aid. Or weapons. Or supplies. Or pretty much anything, really.

One thing which is not giving aid to our enemies is to fight a war against them, on whatever pretenses, which results in massive quantities of said enemy's soldiers dying. That's almost exactly the opposite of "aiding" our enemies.

You may disagree with the efficiency of our military expenditures, but inefficiency in prosecuting military action is not even remotely the same thing as providing aid to our enemies.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:11PM (#19810783)
You miss the point of my comment. The group our politicians call enemies may or may not be.

If we have actual enemies, we can be sure that they want us to waste as much money as possible on futile wars.

If we have actual enemies, we can be sure that they want our leaders to circumvent the Democratic process to steal money that could be spent on domestic programs or returned to taxpayers and instead spend it on pointless wars.

I’d we have enemies, we can be sure they want our leaders to spend billions making us hate, fear, and mistrust brown people, and crave strong man leaders over pluralism and liberty.

Assange revealed that our leaders are acting in concert with such enemies.

We can’t separate the lies from the theft. The lies about the war and the illegally classified info that the war logs revealed are what make the theft of resources possible.

All the lives lost are of course also a major issue but the theft aspect makes it easier to see what a sacrifice we were all forced to make to wage the wars.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by gamblor956 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:50PM (#19811228)
Literally everything you said is alt-right conspiracy nonsense.

People who blow up Americans are our enemies. They brag about being our enemies online and in traditional media, at least until we blow them up using very expensive bombs. These wars were authorized by duly elected legislative representatives at the behest of multiple ideologically-opposing executive administrations.

One of these presidents was a black/brown man, who spent his time in office addressing racial tensions. The other, more recent president--the one inflaming racial tensions--received political assistance from Assange, who openly admits to choosing to spread DNC leaks harmful to Clinton and choosing not to publish any negative documents about Trump, despite having access to a plethora of such documents.

Assange revealed nothing, except that he's just as petty and partisan as everyone else, and just as capable of lies as the politicians he claimed he was trying to take down.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @03:27PM (#19811691)
It's bizarre to have my views characterized as alt-right.

> People who blow up Americans are our enemies.

The groups doing those things have been funded by the US government quite recently, and would likely not exist if the US government hadn't tried to meddle in the middle east decades ago.

> These wars were authorized by duly elected legislative representatives

Sort of. The wars would likely not have escalated if the information in the Iraq war logs was known earlier. The war logs showed that the US classified information about what was actually going on in the war so that the public would continue to support it. If the American people knew that it was a proxy war against Iran and that the US was abetting war crimes against former Baath party members, it is unlikely that the war would have continued.

> at the behest of multiple ideologically-opposing executive administrations.

If you think the major parties are in disagreement on war related issues you are not paying close attention. There are only minor points of disagreement.

> openly admits to choosing to spread DNC leaks harmful to Clinton and choosing not to publish any negative documents about Trump, despite having access to a plethora of such documents.

Assange's decision not to publish material related to Trump was based on it already having been widely published or based on its questionable authenticity. Do you really think that anything damning about Trump could have been kept secret? I think that sounds a bit like a conspiracy theory :)

> Assange revealed nothing

I'm not sure if you have read the war logs, but there was significant information revealed that should make the American people quite angry, both about the loss of life caused by the wars and the massive amount of money wasted on the wars.

The Iraq and Afghanistan wars have cost an amount equal to a 50% tax cut for all Americans earning under $500K for seven years in a row.

The amount of suffering caused by the misallocation of funds (which Assange helped expose) is monumental.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by gamblor956 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @06:19PM (#19813516)
The groups doing those things have been funded by the US government quite recently, and would likely not exist if the US government hadn't tried to meddle in the middle east decades ago.

This is not true at all, based on an even cursory understanding of the history of tribal and religious warfare in the Middle East.

Sort of. The wars would likely not have escalated if the information in the Iraq war logs was known earlier. The war logs showed that the US classified information about what was actually going on in the war so that the public would continue to support it. If the American people knew that it was a proxy war against Iran and that the US was abetting war crimes against former Baath party members, it is unlikely that the war would have continued.

This is even less true. The Iraq war was not a legitimate war, but had popular support from most of the electorate because 9/11 just happened. However, Afghanistan was a legitimate war, with popular support from both parties and the electorate, because Al Qaeda was actually located in Afghanistan. Al Qaeda was not, and never was, a proxy for Iran, nor was ISIS. Both groups were violently opposed to Iran on ideological grounds (and I mean "were" because they're both dead now).

Don't conflate one group of brown people with another. That's how the Iraq War happened.

If you think the major parties are in disagreement on war related issues you are not paying close attention. There are only minor points of disagreement.

I volunteered with a number of congressional campaigns of legislators opposed to the Iraq war and the subsequent extended occupation. I opened letters containing death threats targeting the candidates from budding alt-right idiots.

The disagreement between the parties over the war and the occupation was not minor. It was a wide gaping maw in many places where the two sides could not agree due to fundamental ideological differences. Hell, in 2008, the parties ran presidential campaigns with completely different positions on continuing the war. Obama intended to shift the war from Iraq to Afghanistan, McCain intended to continue the war in Iraq without moving into Afghanistan. Obama followed through--and was pilloried by the right for it until US special forces killed Osama.

Assange's decision not to publish material related to Trump was based on it already having been widely published or based on its questionable authenticity. Do you really think that anything damning about Trump could have been kept secret? I think that sounds a bit like a conspiracy theory :)

No, it was based on Assange's declared support for Donald Trump's presidency, and there is substantial evidence that Wikileaks coordinated its release of the DNC files with the Trump campaign to maximize political effect. Wikileaks was also known to have received leaked copies during the campaign of documents related to Trump's many scandals and refused to publish them until after Trump was sworn in.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @10:12PM (#19814903)
> history of tribal and religious warfare in the Middle East

Are you claiming that with no US involvement, Al Qaida would have received training and ammunition?

> This is even less true... <etc>

You are correct about the start of the wars, but keep in mind that cost estimates by GWB of the wars were a tiny fraction of what the cost turned out to be very quickly after the big statue of Saddam toppled. With every day that went by the gap between what was promised and what was delivered widened. This was the motive for concealing (through classification) information that would have made it obvious that the war had been sold on false pretenses and that it would turn out to be a much, much larger undertaking than anyone who supported it had been led to believe.

To some of your other points, if one assumes that the war will be effective and cost the lives of, say 1 US soldier and cost $1, then it would be a no brainer. When you increase the death toll, cost, blowback, or any other negative externality, the ROI changes and easily becomes negative. It was not just the post-9/11 hysteria that led to the war, it was the dramatic underestimation of the time, cost, outcome, and of course the utter falsehood of the nation building narrative.

> Al Qaeda was not, and never was, a proxy for Iran

I did not claim it was. Saddam was linked by the Bush administration to Al Qaida if you recall, and Iran had significant interest in what would happen with Iraq.

> Don't conflate one group of brown people with another

I have not done that, see above.

> I opened letters containing death threats targeting the candidates from budding alt-right idiots.

In a large population there will be extreme and largely incoherent views on both (all?) sides, and of course you would open some such letters. The letters have no connection to what the parties actually wanted/supported during that time.

> Obama intended to shift the war from Iraq to Afghanistan, McCain intended to continue the war in Iraq without moving into Afghanistan. Obama followed through--and was pilloried by the right for it until US special forces killed Osama.

The key word here is intended. Obama also intended to close Gitmo and stop some of the more egregious excesses of the Bush administration but actually did very little to remediate it, until just before he left office toward the end of his second term. Any Democrat would advocate a left of center position, any Republican a right of center position, both knowing that the centrist position was just fine and that the rhetoric would help win the election and nothing more. Obama's conduct in office is a case in point. Don't confuse the political fray and left vs right accusations with what is actually happening (or not happening).

> No, it was based on Assange's declared support for Donald Trump's presidency...

Assange stated that he found both candidates abhorrent, so I'm not sure how you can claim that he supported Donald Trump's candidacy. I think you are potentially getting some false information about Assange's sentiments about Trump. I followed his conduct closely during the 2016 campaign and while he did maximize the PR impact of the leaked emails, I view that as a budget PR strategy since he'd already had his organization decimated and needed to drum up some PR to get the material noticed by the rest of the press.

If you have followed Assange for a while you will know that he has no political interest in any nation -- he may have had a grudge against HRC after she joked about assassinating him, who knows -- but his conduct as a journalist is beyond reproach, especially considering the attack that he was under during most of it.

If, for example, the NY Times had continued working with him and providing support, the PR strategy would not have been necessary, nor would the hastily released (sub-optimally redacted) items have been released. But instead the NYT decided to act as an arm of the US Government and help spread the "Assange is a rapist" meme.

While I doubt Assange is a violent person, I don't know him personally. But I also care a lot less about his character around people he's sharing a bed with than I do about the information he revealed.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by atemerev on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:38AM (#19809021)
Which of his crimes looks like treason? He didn’t hack anything, his only “crime” is providing a publishing outlet.

(And yes, Assange is highly biased and anti-American, which is not good, but publishing leaks shouldn’t be a crime.)

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by kermitismyhero on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:51AM (#19809213)
I would argue that Assange only really became hostile to the American government after senior politicians and officials started calling publicly for his murder. If a US Secretary of State repeatedly and publicly commented about how it would be fantastic if you could be killed in a drone strike, wouldn't that make you rather unfriendly towards them?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by mrleinad on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:41AM (#19809062)
It's funny to label someone anti-american, when all they've done is expose america's crimes and ways of manipulating the rest of the world. Makes you think what does being pro-america mean.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:46PM (#19810458)
Exactly. Assange tried to help the American people learn about dishonesty and fraud committed by elected officials.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by droithomme on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:30PM (#19809646)
The guy you're responding to said "crimes by US officials that Assange revealed", not "crimes by Assange that US officials revealed". I misread it the first time too, but he meant the opposite of what you thought.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by posterboy on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:43AM (#19809099)
On second reading, I think OP meant the war crimes ("many of these") were treason. I don't know what was done, but I suspect that's not really true under a narrow definition.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by kickopotomus on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:00PM (#19809317)
Do you have a source? Where is your proof that he did not attempt to gain unauthorized access to a federal computer? Genuinely asking because that is the exact crime he is being charged with.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by justinmchase on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#19809424)
Rather, where is the proof that he did?

The burden of proof is on the accuser.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by kickopotomus on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:28PM (#19809634)
That is the entire purpose of a trial. The accuser brings forth evidence against the accused.

Assange is under federal indictment meaning that a grand jury was presented evidence and decided that it was enough to file charges. However, the parent comment claims that Assange is innocent.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by atemerev on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:50PM (#19809860)
The indictment formulation is “assisted with”. It is really vague; publishing results can be interpreted as assistance.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by kickopotomus on Thursday May 02, 2019 @04:50PM (#19812736)
No, it cannot be. Publishing, and only publishing classified documents is protected under the first amendment[1]. However, Assange helped Manning gain access to and procure the classified documents which is illegal.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._United_S...

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:46AM (#19809147)
My earlier comment was unclear. Assange revealed serious crimes by US officials.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by atemerev on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:52AM (#19809226)
OK, thank you for the clarification!
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by tdcbfdct3 on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:38AM (#19809023)
I'm having trouble finding any on The Hague's website

https://www.icc-cpi.int/Pages/cases.aspx

[dead]
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:50AM (#19809202)
Accusation of whataboutism is a thought-stopper.

What-about-X allows you to put things in perspective.

Things - including crimes (or alleged crimes) - don't exist in isolation.

It depends who they happen to (I wouldn't care much to punish the person who helped murder a dictator and bring democracy, for example), it depends if they help stop bigger crimes (I'd applaud the small guy that does a crime to bring down much larger criminals), and they

And even if an accusation is only checked in isolation by a court (though even courts take into account the larger context), we're not courts, we're people and we can see beyond the narrow confines and what's legal, to see what's good/moral/etc. Jean Valjean's conviction was "legal" too.

Without that, one is either purposefully pushing for your own agenda (our their own country's etc.), or getting lured into considering X alone, without anybody letting them consider its significance and bigger impact. They're then "straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel".

(That's also part of how "demonizing" someone works).

The knee-jerk condemnation of "whataboutism" is a legalist/moralist thought-stopper that kills all political thinking and nuance of society/world at large.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by bduerst on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:19PM (#19809533)
Complaining about whataboutism being called out is even more tangential and thought-stopping than actually calling it out.

Whataboutism is not a valid defense, it's a deflection in the form of a red herring.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:51PM (#19810517)
Not true. So called whataboutism is used to deflect a valid critique and defend an indefensible position.

I think people claim whataboutism because they lack an understanding of scope. Assange published secrets, ok. That is possibly a crime. But the secrets revealed far worse crimes.

Would you defend Jerry Sandusky by saying that an informant being convicted of shoplifting was the most important part of the Sandusky case?

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by bduerst on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:21PM (#19813089)
That's a self-serving hypothetical. I would not defend Assange by saying that some of the people whom he leaked documents about have not been prosecuted yet. The latter doesn't justify any defense.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:51PM (#19813326)
Why would you need to "defend" him in the first place?

Aside from the fact that big state and private powers want him out and accuse him, preferring radio silence on their deeds and crimes, I don't see him as having done anything bad at all.

A state holding secrets is not worth of any defense. A state holding bad secrets of crimes and misdeeds even less so.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by bduerst on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @12:46AM (#19855946)
I'm referring to the context of this conversation, and misusing whataboutism to defend assange.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by rorykoehler on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:35AM (#19808980)
So no one is uncovered and report crimes committed by nations because they created self serving laws? Sounds tyrannical.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:30AM (#19808910)
I’d have no problem with Assange being punished if the other journalists were, or if the government officials were.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Veen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:32AM (#19808942)
Assange is accused of a crime. Should he be forgiven because some other people are also accused of crimes?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:54AM (#19809254)
If all those other people are let go, then yes.

Doubly so, if they have done much more important crimes.

Triply so, if he helped unveil them.

Else it's not even justice anymore, it's courts used as an arbitrary instrument of coercion yield this or that power's convenience.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by TremendousJudge on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:38AM (#19809017)
In this case there's a bit of a conflict of interest, considering that he was the one who showed that the government accusing him committed crimes
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Veen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:41AM (#19809056)
That's why the judiciary and the executive are independent of each other.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:55AM (#19809262)
If they belong to the same country, and care for the same country's "national interests" they're not really independent of each other.

How about he gets tried to some global court?

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#19809011)
Should law enforcement focus on prosecuting a shoplifter who reported Jerry Sandusky’s crimes while ignoring Jerry?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by justinmchase on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:10PM (#19809434)
He should be forgiven because there should be an exception for whistleblowing.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by Veen on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:28PM (#19810272)
He’s not accused of whistleblowing. He’s accused of aiding in the theft of military secrets. And for obvious reasons, whistleblowing exemptions can’t apply to the military and secret services.
[dead]
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:57AM (#19809276)
One-liner slogans are not rebuttals either.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by dickeytk on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:43AM (#19809100)
stare decisis is (in common law countries)
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by idlewords on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:04PM (#19809357)
That is true, but also a non sequitur.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:41PM (#19810404)
I'm usually the first to call out whataboutism, but Assange is literally being prosecuted for exposing US crimes. The rape allegation is a real issue and shouldn't be swept under the rug, but it's actually the US that is doing that--he's not being extradited to Sweden to face sexual assault charges; he's going to the US to be punished for WikiLeaks.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by alwaysanagenda on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:36AM (#19808982)
He's the only one who could testify about the truth behind the DNC leak (Seth Rich) and the Podesta e-mails (phished). Neither were 'hacked' by the Russians.

With the Mueller investigation effectively over, it's time to turn the tables. Assange is a valuable asset in this endeavor.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by e1ven on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#19809003)
You realize you sound pretty far out-of-mainstream when you say things like that, right?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by justinmchase on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:34PM (#19809688)
There is multiple points of evidence that Seth Rich was in contact with wikileaks before his murder and was either leaking documents or intending to leak documents.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by akhilcacharya on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:39AM (#19809031)
In fairness to OP, this is effectively the Sean Hannity line so I wouldn't say it's "out of the mainstream" anymore.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by akhilcacharya on Thursday May 02, 2019 @11:38AM (#19809024)
You mean the investigation that proved that Assange attempted to weaponize the grief of a family for the gain of Russian political interests? That investigation?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by justinmchase on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:30PM (#19809651)
Actually, there was some evidence that Seth Rich was indeed in contact with Wikileaks. There is no confirmation that he actually was the source of any leaks but there were email exchanges with Assange on his laptop and he appeared to be _intending_ to leak at least.

This was according to Seymore Hersh, you can find audio of him describing Rich's involvement and other discussion on the topic.

To be clear, Rich's murder could have been a total coincidence and he could have possibly not been the source of any published leaks. Given that, it was not weaponization but a reasonable assumption on the part of Wikileaks to conclude that Rich had probably been assasinated.

Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by saalweachter on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:37PM (#19809729)
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing by akhilcacharya on Thursday May 02, 2019 @02:32PM (#19811023)
> were email exchanges with Assange on his laptop and he appeared to be _intending_ to leak at least.

This is the definition of fake news disseminated by the Russians and the Republicans that want to cover for them.

Source from the other link: https://www.npr.org/2017/08/01/540783715/lawsuit-alleges-fox...