Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing
by bduerst on Thursday May 02, 2019 @12:19PM
(#19809533)
Complaining about whataboutism being called out is even more tangential and thought-stopping than actually calling it out.
Whataboutism is not a valid defense, it's a deflection in the form of a red herring.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing
by resters on Thursday May 02, 2019 @01:51PM
(#19810517)
Not true. So called whataboutism is used to deflect a valid critique and defend an indefensible position.
I think people claim whataboutism because they lack an understanding of scope. Assange published secrets, ok. That is possibly a crime. But the secrets revealed far worse crimes.
Would you defend Jerry Sandusky by saying that an informant being convicted of shoplifting was the most important part of the Sandusky case?
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing
by bduerst on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:21PM
(#19813089)
That's a self-serving hypothetical. I would not defend Assange by saying that some of the people whom he leaked documents about have not been prosecuted yet. The latter doesn't justify any defense.
Re:Julian Assange Appears in Court for U.S. Extradition Hearing
by coldtea on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:51PM
(#19813326)
Why would you need to "defend" him in the first place?
Aside from the fact that big state and private powers want him out and accuse him, preferring radio silence on their deeds and crimes, I don't see him as having done anything bad at all.
A state holding secrets is not worth of any defense. A state holding bad secrets of crimes and misdeeds even less so.
What-about-X allows you to put things in perspective.
Things - including crimes (or alleged crimes) - don't exist in isolation.
It depends who they happen to (I wouldn't care much to punish the person who helped murder a dictator and bring democracy, for example), it depends if they help stop bigger crimes (I'd applaud the small guy that does a crime to bring down much larger criminals), and they
And even if an accusation is only checked in isolation by a court (though even courts take into account the larger context), we're not courts, we're people and we can see beyond the narrow confines and what's legal, to see what's good/moral/etc. Jean Valjean's conviction was "legal" too.
Without that, one is either purposefully pushing for your own agenda (our their own country's etc.), or getting lured into considering X alone, without anybody letting them consider its significance and bigger impact. They're then "straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel".
(That's also part of how "demonizing" someone works).
The knee-jerk condemnation of "whataboutism" is a legalist/moralist thought-stopper that kills all political thinking and nuance of society/world at large.