News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by rtpg on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:50AM (#19771374)
There are huge deductions for your primary residence

This tax thing is an issue for people with multiple homes. Considering the set of people that concerns I wouldn’t cry too much over it

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by PunchTornado on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:13AM (#19771510)
exactly, every country should implement high taxes for second homes.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by chiph on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:24AM (#19771591)
What about the people owning homes as investments, or as part of their retirement plans? You can argue that a lake house would be taxed because it's lived in part of the year (weekends), but what if the owners put it on AirBnB after the children go off to university and the family isn't enjoying it together anymore?
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by zanny on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:47AM (#19771719)
Housing is a basic necessity, using it as an investment allocates scarce finite resources to you when you don't need it while consuming limited supply thus reducing the available stock for those that do.

The business of buying and selling houses on the flip isn't particularly bad (though it's often predatory and rent seekish) but hoarding property to either rent or just squat to take advantage of the appreciation said hoarding does to drive up prices is evil. Especially when you consider how the entire perverse and unsustainable economic model of endlessly and perpetually rising property values against inflation causes substantive suffering while governments will bend over to preserve it since the landlords are the wealthy interests they want to appease to stay in power.

There are much less amoral, much more productive, and much less predatory ways to grow wealth. Whenever anyone looks at residential property as an infinite profit machine it is a failure of the society to produce productive & positive investment options for that wealth.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by snowwindwaves on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:52AM (#19771752)
There is loads of cheap housing in USA and Canada - just not in popular places. Anyone moaning about the price of real estate should check to make sure they aren't trying to live in one of the most desirable places to live on the planet.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Benjamin_Dobell on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:06PM (#19771867)
How far should people be expected to commute from these less diserable locations to their place of employment?

Localities with an abundance of cheap housing tend to have significantly higher unemployment rates[1],

[1] https://research.stlouisfed.org/publications/employment-rese...

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by pdimitar on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:29PM (#19772016)
Let's include pressure to work remotely in the whole equation.

I see no reason why humanity must crowd trample each other in tiny metropolitan areas when there are so many affordable -- and likely more beautiful -- places to live in.

Have basic infrastructure in place, internet excluded, and the problem is solved.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by ajmurmann on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:54PM (#19772173)
The have been several studies that showed that cities foster innovation and living in larger cities leads to faster increase in income. It's also cheaper for society as a whole to provide good infrastructure in one place rather than spreading it out. Unfortunately we are currently hiding that cost and people living in cities are subsidizing the costs of roads and other infrastructure for people in low density areas.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by pdimitar on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:17PM (#19772304)
I would seriously question those studies. You should probably add the increased stress and the lack of leisure time that make people mentally unhealthy.

I am also seriously not okay with the implication that the cities support all other areas. That's extremely questionable.

Lastly, don't forget there have been studies proving fat is bad and sugar is good. Never discount the vested interests that know how to convince people. Apparently you have been influenced by a study.

Not saying you shouldn't believe anything, but maintain a healthy skepticism, please.

I live in the only true big city in my country and truthfully, people are in general happier everywhere else in the country. At least they say so and sound like it.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Aeolun on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:04PM (#19775516)
I don’t think the fact that cities support the surrounding countryside has been very controversial since the 1500’s.

It kind of makes sense. If 10% of the surface area needs 90% of the resources, they are going to be easier to provide than for the remaining 90% of the area (mainly because spreading things like doctors, hospitals and supermarkets around to serve a few hundred people is not easy).

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by ajmurmann on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:33PM (#19775636)
Just utilities and roads alone are a massive cost that makes spread out living enormously costly and I pay as much for it living in a high rise building without owning a car as I do living somewhere in the suburbs or the country side with utilities and roads running very far to reach my lot. strongtowns.com is full of information on how we subsidize suburbs and rural living.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:43PM (#19772850)
> I see no reason why humanity must crowd trample each other in tiny metropolitan areas when there are so many affordable -- and likely more beautiful -- places to live in.

This is an incredibly disingenuous argument. You use "must" as if the opposing side is the one forcing people to live a certain way, but it's actually your side that pushes for strong regulations limiting population density even when people do want to live in a big city.

Nobody's suggesting banning living in rural areas or small towns. But regulations as they currently exist work to push people from living in big metros where the good jobs are. That's not the market, that's incumbents using government power to dictate lifestyles for their neighbors and potential immigrants.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by pdimitar on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:13PM (#19773065)
Well to be fair, I have no "side" in this. I am saying that there are a lot of incentives for people to crowd in metropolitan areas.

As a resident of a country that only has one big city -- the capital -- I see this all the time: people just have no future elsewhere and come here even though they sacrifice quite a lot and the overall gain might not outpace all the negatives.

Not sure what's the way out, to be honest.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:23PM (#19773118)
I mean, there's a reason the good jobs tend to come out of those big metro areas: bigger populations make for stronger ecosystem/network effects. If you push policies deflecting people elsewhere, you're not just spreading out the prosperity, you're also reducing it in total.

And I don't think big cities have to be bad to live in. Vienna gets extremely high livability marks despite being the one big city Austria has. I currently live in Munich, and though our yard here is very small compared to the US standard, having a couple of parks within a block and a half (+ other nearby green space) makes up for it, even with a kid.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by pdimitar on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:39PM (#19774187)
Big cities don't have to be bad to live in... but they often are.

Sofia isn't anything special but it has quite beautiful neighborhoods which are of course quite expensive to live in.

Back yard? You only have that if you live in villages with like 2000 people. Our capital is so crowded that the real estate agents feel really proud to advertise 68m2 apartments with two small rooms and a tiny kitchen, it's that bad. Good views? Forget about it.

(I am considering moving out of Bulgaria to Vienna/Austria exactly by the way; but I'm for the moment too scared to do it.)

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Monday April 29, 2019 @09:29AM (#19778148)
> Back yard? You only have that if you live in villages with like 2000 people.

Having your own backyard is definitely a luxury in Munich, we have one because we're kind of at the outskirts and Google pays well (and as I said, it's quite small), but it's very common here at least for regular people to live in small apartment buildings (like 8-12 units) with a decent sized shared backyard. Especially if they're in a suburb of Munich, which still lets them access the job market there of course.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by shados on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:05PM (#19775521)
> that's incumbents using government power to dictate lifestyles for their neighbors and potential immigrants

As opposed to? People trying to force a change to the lifestyle of people already there in favor of their neighbors and potential newcomer? I mean, if you build a skyscrapper across the street, it will change people's lifestyle quite a bit...

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by ajmurmann on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:52PM (#19772161)
It still seems less than ideal to have people live in places that require long commutes or result in lower income jobs (likely meaning they could be more productive elsewhere) so that someone can accumulate investment properties in the more desirable areas? To me this seems like someone complaining that prices of vegetables and meat going up due to speculation and someone pointing out that rice and bread are still cheap.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:30PM (#19772781)
Another way of putting this is: there's lots of cheap housing where there's only cheap jobs to match.

It's a pick your poison situation, and it doesn't have to be. Singapore and Vienna are good examples of public housing programs, Tokyo is a good example of the market providing reasonable rent relative to how desirable/big/rich the area is.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by mistermann on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:22PM (#19771967)
Cheap is a relative term. What does the affordability ratio (price vs local available incomes) look like compared to historical norms? Are these places cheap on that basis, or only when compared to the insane prices in desirable places?
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by skybrian on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:58PM (#19772960)
This doesn't make sense. Housing that's being rented out is in use by renters. No property is being wasted. Taking properties off the rental market will drive rents up. What do you have against renters?

Vacant property is being wasted. Not too much of that, though.

Morally speaking, a housing market has much in common with a traffic jam or a crowded bus. Everyone takes up space, though some more than others. If you're living somewhere that housing is scarce, you're a small part of the problem, according to the space you take up. The only way to not be part of the problem is to move away.

It doesn't make sense to pick on some of the people in a crowd for making it crowded, assuming they're all taking a similar amount of space.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by CryptoPunk on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:12PM (#19772282)
>>Housing is a basic necessity, using it as an investment allocates scarce finite resources to you when you don't need it while consuming limited supply thus reducing the available stock for those that do.

Using it as an investment doesn't deprive others from using it. Using it as an investment means renting the property out to earn investment income on it.

And investing leads to that scarce resource becoming less scarce, through construction and expansion of housing supply.

Capital leads to abundance. Combating capital investments in housing leads to more housing scarcity. That's exactly what zoning restrictions and rent control do, and why some places have housing scarcity.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by chiph on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:37PM (#19772066)
This guy invested $30k in getting a (very) run-down home into decent shape. He had a tenant within a week of putting it up for rent:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Q8pf-Ad0w0

Not sure how his actions are evil or rent-seeking in any way.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by wvenable on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:45PM (#19772111)
> What about the people owning homes as investments, or as part of their retirement plans?

Housing as an investment does not benefit society.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by theparanoid on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:08PM (#19772257)
A significant percentage of people are not financially stable enough to buy a home and pay a monthly mortgage on time for 15-30 years. But they are able to rent.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by mjevans on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:04AM (#19775745)
You're assuming current prices in a distorted market. Since the distortions of regulation for various reasons can't (and including safety distortions, shouldn't) be removed, they should instead be managed.

There simply isn't enough housing within the economic zone that jobs exist in; this needs to be fixed.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by A2017U1 on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:33AM (#19775845)
It's such a bizarre state of affairs in modern capitalist societies. These sorts of supply shortfalls are fixed in no time for every other type of product or service. Yet housing is that one thing which has so many vested interests throughout the population.

If any other basic need rose so much above inflation no one would consider it a positive for society.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by KaoruAoiShiho on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:37AM (#19771655)
They should invest their money elsewhere, like new enterprises, instead of homes as rent-seeking is a negative on society, not a productive activity.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by fbonetti on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:42PM (#19772093)
You’re confusing “contract rent” (an amount paid on a recurring basis for the temporary use of goods, services, or property) with “economic rent” (an amount that is paid on top of the “natural” price due to a distortion in the market). Rent-seeking refers to the latter definition of rent.

Renting property is not rent-seeking. Wielding the power of local government to prevent new housing from being built is rent-seeking.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by chiph on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:22PM (#19771964)
I think you're misusing the term "Rent Seeking". The important part of its definition is the manipulation of the social or political environment to gain financial advantage. It has nothing to do with collecting rent from a tenant.

An example of rent-seeking would be if I were a steel producer and I ask the government to impose a tariff on imported steel.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by conjectures on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:32PM (#19772391)
It is quite appropriate actually. Speculative property buying is very much about trying to capture wealth without creating any wealth.

C.f. also NIMBYism.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by mcguire on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:00PM (#19772583)
1. Speculative property buying provides liquidity to an otherwise exceptionally illiquid market.

2. You have literally just described the stock market.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by jodrellblank on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:37PM (#19772818)
1. given that it doesn't change the amount of property, how does it provide anything at all?

2. The stock market is exactly people trying to get rich without adding any value to the world.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by leakybit on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:26PM (#19773801)
Where do you expect tech workers to sell their RSUs?
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by conjectures on Monday April 29, 2019 @01:41AM (#19776095)
1. This hasn't been demonstrated. In fact, when there is a housing shortage in the areas considered that strongly hints that friction in housing purchase is due to other factors than being able to match a buyer with a seller. So the average dollar value of this supposed liquidity is likely to be miniscule compared to the average dollar value of the capital appreciation.

2. I'm not going to get bogged down refuting bad analogies here.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by mcguire on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:56PM (#19772550)
...aaaaand suddenly all of those people currently renting have nowhere to live.

(I swear, the Kantian Categorical Imperative should be taught in high school just for its entertainment value.)

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by snowwindwaves on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:49AM (#19771736)
What if I require some leisure time to recharge so I can go back to work and be fully Productive? I need a lake house to go and relax at. The couple provides use of their lake house for my vacation.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by sgc on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:11PM (#19771897)
That is higher risk and many, many people cannot accept it. They are in no position to lose everything on your dumb startup idea.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by formercoder on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:08PM (#19771885)
How can you state that rent seeking is a negative on society? How is it not just optimal capital allocation?
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by zzzzzzzza on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:21PM (#19772327)
production = rent + wages + interest

production - rent = wages + interest

when productivity grows but wages do not, that means the marginal contribution of any new worker is being entirely eaten by various forms of rent within the economy. Those who collect rent have no incentive to do anything but perpetuate their rent collection and most likely if they were to re invest their gains would probably reinvest them in either acquiring more rent or protecting their existing rent... which is why the government should be funded off of monopoly/pigovian taxes like the land value tax, or removing intellectual property deductions from the corp income tax, as opposed to income or consumption taxes - a philosophy known as georgism.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by snidane on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:53PM (#19772167)
What is usually meant by rent-seeking is more akin to rent-extraction. Here rent doesn't mean the monthly payment (lease) but an 'economic rent'. That is an income which is guaranteed by some distorition of current market conditions. Most often by some kind of monopoly. Eg. rents for pharma industry because potential competitors are not allowed to enter the market due to industry regulation. This allows the current players extract the guaranteed rent - monopoly income.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by luckydata on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:23PM (#19771972)
that's the literal definition of rent seeking.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by formercoder on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:15PM (#19772686)
Oh interesting that wasn’t a term I was actually familiar with. I thought we were just discussing the idea of purchasing property and renting it out.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by luckydata on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:23PM (#19779780)
well, that's also rent seeking. Some concepts in economics are not as straightforward as you would first think especially if not familiar with macro / micro concepts.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by snidane on Sunday April 28, 2019 @12:44PM (#19772107)
This is a good point. And that is why land taxation is preferred to property taxation.

Land ownership = people give you rights for exclusive use. So you pay them for the privilege

Property tax = another form of income or labor tax. Somebody put effort and energy into the building, proportion of which is taken away