News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by ainar-g on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:08AM (#19770128)
Would it be better to ask the mods to change the title to something like “US Living Wage Calculator”? I clicked expecting a worldwide view, and was a bit disappointed.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by hiisukun on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:42AM (#19770387)
I often find this with HN articles. Much like the .com domain, I continue to assume a likelihood of American-focus and allow myself to be pleasantly surprised when it is a global article, service or discussion.

Perhaps that's one of the best things about code/git submissions to HN - it's often so easy to apply them to any geographic region.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by jacquesm on Sunday April 28, 2019 @08:00AM (#19770638)
HN is SV first, US second, English Speaking third and world a distant fourth.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by mruts on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:05AM (#19770944)
What is a living wage? I live in Tanzania and people get by on $50/month and live in mud houses. All of these people are alive and have been for some time.

Similarly, I know some bums in LA whos only expenses are $5/gram weed. They live on the beach, chill in a tent, and are happy and alive.

People in Western countries have such a distorted idea what is a living wage it’s patently absurd. It includes a tv, netflix, a cell phone, a car, apartment, computer, etc.

Most people here in Tanzania would literally kill to make minimum wage in America. It would seem like paradise, a life of extreme luxury.

Americans are so myopic and don’t seem to appreciate how lucky all of them are. There’s no 99% in America: we all are the 1%.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by porky on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:09AM (#19770466)
1. US only 2. It seems that "living" does not include almost nothing beyond the immediate living requirements and it does not take into account times you cannot work, can't find job, or simply the fact that a person is a little more than her capacity to be a machine for someone.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by ebg13 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:25AM (#19770520)
> It seems that "living" does not include almost nothing beyond the immediate living requirements and it does not take into account times you cannot work, can't find job, or simply the fact that a person is a little more than her capacity to be a machine for someone.

This is very much what the US mentality on social care is like, so at least it's consistent.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by porky on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:58PM (#19772571)
And the fact you HAVE to save money, a lot of it, for the future.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by alok-g on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:26AM (#19769683)
The following is much more useful, and covers many more cities across the world:

https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/

Re:Living Wage Calculator by olcor on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:22AM (#19769846)
I’ve found numbeo to be practically useless for most cities I’ve been to and stayed. MITs calculator is much more accurate, especially if you are someone who doesn’t earn a high wage.

Most people aren’t going to stay in Greenwich village/SOHO/UES if they are in NY, or similar elsewhere. Prices reflected in the MIT calculator seem to take all areas of living into account, that too by county.

Edit: Numbers on numbeo seem to have improved a lot since the last time I saw them. Taking back my previous opinion, but I find both to be useful resources.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by taffer on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:55AM (#19770621)
> Most people aren’t going to stay in Greenwich village/SOHO/UES if they are in NY, or similar elsewhere.

You can change the assumptions in numbeo too, like for example if you plan to live outside the city center.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by alok-g on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:28AM (#19769861)
Hmmm. I found it to be a good reflection of where I've stayed. The data is sometimes lagging by a year or so.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by nabla9 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:50AM (#19769923)
Numbeo has reputation of being very inconsistent. For some cities and countries it's relatively accurate, for some others it's wrong or outdated.

It's partly due to their data collecting methodology. They rely on crowd-sourced user inputs and manually collected data. I also have doubt about their analysis methodology, it's seems very ad hoc and amateurish.

You should treat Numbeo with a grain of salt. It's honest attempt with small budget and better than nothing, but you can't treat it as authoritative source.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by fyfy18 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:44AM (#19770054)
Which is why companies shouldn't use it to base employees salaries on (GitLab I'm looking at you).
Re:Living Wage Calculator by Zenbit_UX on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:33PM (#19773176)
In general I don't like the approach of remote employers basing compensation off of the employees cost of living.

What happens at gitlab if you start off in SF then move to another city? You're a remote employee and are free to work wherever... Do they then demote your pay to reflect the new city or did you just game the system?

What about the opposite case, a worker in India at gitlab moving to SF did they just lose a lot of money?

In general this cost of living approach to remote employment is a cop out to pay lower salaries and save money. Zapier offers bay area salaries to all remote employees and gitlab discriminates... Which would you want to work for?

Re:Living Wage Calculator by planetburgess on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:07PM (#19775529)
Zapier does indexed compensation by region. E.g. They pay employees in Asia less than employees in America. This is actually the worst of both worlds. They are paying over the market rate in some countries and under the market in others. Some of their employees are raking it in, others not so much. What's fair or desirable about that?
Re:Living Wage Calculator by esotericn on Sunday April 28, 2019 @08:04AM (#19770649)
A "living wage" is somewhat of a misnomer because as other posters have stated it indicates zero surplus.

Really, people have a "cost of living". Their wage only has to be at least that if they have zero capital.

The idea of basically everyone having zero capital as a default state is really kind of saddening.

Not withstanding that, I find the 'living wage' discussion centres around what people get for the minimum wage e.g. can they afford a small room, a studio apartment, a small house, etc.

Really it makes more sense to look at the absolute minimum living conditions and whether they have any surplus that will give them future negotiating power, or the ability to take time off work, etc.

It doesn't have to be that much, if you can live on 15K then on 22.5K you can bank half a year's expenses per year.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by 8077628 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:56AM (#19769770)
I agree this seems low. Both housing and additional expenses. How do I know if I'm the victim of an hedonic treadmill?
Re:Living Wage Calculator by function_seven on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:10AM (#19769809)
(Edited to add housing comment)

I agree the housing seems low. For my county, it worked out to ~$750 a month for a single childless household. I’ve never seen a rent that low around me. I assume shared living must be on the table for this.

As for the other living expenses, and whether you’re on a hedonic treadmill:

* How many meals a month are from a restaurant of any kind?

* How many of the following do you have paid subscriptions for? Cable/satellite, HBO, Showtime, Netflix, Hulu, etc.

* Do you set your thermostat to lower than 75°F/23°C in the summer, or higher than 65°F/18°C in the winter?

* Do you buy cars new? Or almost always have a car payment?

* Any microwave meals or individually packaged snacks?

* Alcohol on any semi-regular basis?

* Coffee that’s more than 25¢ a cup?

None of the above are (moral) value judgements, but they’re really easy to get accustomed to and not consider as discretionary items.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by apoph3nia on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:02PM (#19773347)
> None of the above are (moral) value judgements, but they’re really easy to get accustomed to

Playing economic limbo with constantly updating 'how low can you go?' data as the stick may be possible to get accustomed to, but isn't necessarily very fun. Especially when gameplay becomes long-term and repetitive.

I'm not judging your list of examples in particular, but I think you may be a bit off the mark as to why threads like this appear at all.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by TomMckenny on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:23AM (#19770331)
Certainly the housing values are far below current costs for California. [1]

I assume this is because the data is averaged over what _current_ residents pay which will be dominated by mortgages taken out well in the past and perhaps affordable rentals not on the market. This will bring the average far down.

Anyone moving to or inside of California today could not survive on the Living Wages listed. Even they assume some 2/3 of post tax income going to that lower averaged housing cost.

[1] for example

http://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/06001

vs

https://www.rentcafe.com/average-rent-market-trends/us/ca/al...

Re:Living Wage Calculator by mac01021 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:53AM (#19769931)
The "typical annual expenses" have a row for housing (as they should), in which the numbers are maybe interesting if you're interested in such things:

- Unsurprisingly, a single, childless adult has the lowest housing costs.

- A single adult with 1 child pays a lot more for housing, presumably because the child requires its own bedroom.

- Adding a second child has no effect on the housing cost, presumably because the two children may share a bedroom. I understand this, but it is interesting that someone who is willing to make their kid share a room is unwilling to share a room with their kid.

- 2 adults with no kids pay slightly more than a single adult (i guess they need a little more space, but can still share a bedroom?)

- 2 adults with 2 children have EXACTLY the same cost as 1 adult with 1 child?

- A third child seems to require its own bedroom.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by c22 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:53AM (#19770254)
A single adult with no children can rent a room in a house or apartment with other friends. A couple can do this too, but some of them prefer to have their own place so this skews the average a bit. Once you have a kid it's a lot harder to find people who want to live with you so you have to get your own place. This place is apparently big enough to support up to two adults and two children after which you need a bigger place.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by benj111 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:24AM (#19770009)
"it is interesting that someone who is willing to make their kid share a room is unwilling to share a room with their kid"

Kids sharing rooms is somewhat more acceptable than Adult/child sharing a room. Past babyhood anyway.

I suppose the problem is it all depends on genders and ages. A 5 and 6YO sharing is probably fine. A 16 and 17YO of differing genders not so much.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:06AM (#19769955)
> A single adult with 1 child pays a lot more for housing, presumably because the child requires its own bedroom.

I find this funny, because it takes several years before a child will stop actively expressing its preference _not_ to have its own bedroom.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by benj111 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:10AM (#19769962)
My 2.5yr old has never expressed a preference for sleeping in my room. He likes to come in first thing in a morning if that's what you mean?
Re:Living Wage Calculator by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:14AM (#19769974)
No, I mean sleeping in your room.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by Sutanreyu on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:18AM (#19769492)
I checked the stats for my current city and I have to question just how their calculating their housing costs... It's not even close to what's actually on the market at the moment.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by nraynaud on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:32AM (#19769531)
I just checked, I live in Phoenix, in maricopa county, I’m pretty sure lumping together people living in Maricopa, Phoenix and the suburbs is not valid, you can’t commute across the county, it’s not a single market.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by metaphor on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:17AM (#19770320)
A bit ironic but Maricopa, AZ isn't actually part of Maricopa County; it's in Pinal County.

EDIT: Also worth noting that it's a ~45-60 minute commute from Maricopa to Boeing in Mesa. I make an equivalent commute every weekday--at interstate speeds for 60% of the route--and don't even leave my city proper. The commute isn't as unrealistic as you might think.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by jmpman on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:19AM (#19778541)
Maricopa to Boeing is basically 1/4 across the city. Try commuting from Maricopa to Discover at I-17 and the 202. That would be an hour and a half to two hours each way.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by 8draco8 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:22AM (#19769672)
As stated above, this site was actually linked on HN in 2008, that's 11 years ago, I don't think they ever updated it with recent data.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by cmchien on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:41AM (#19769730)
Per this technical documentation link, the data is supposed to be current to 2018:

http://livingwage.mit.edu/resources/Living-Wage-User-Guide-a...

Re:Living Wage Calculator by dang on Saturday April 27, 2019 @04:57PM (#19767580)
Re:Living Wage Calculator by apoph3nia on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:41AM (#19769728)
The discussion is probably more relevant now than it was in 2008 re: expansion in the ridiculous 'gig economy' sphere since then.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by y4mi on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:24AM (#19770008)
Not necessarily. 2007 was a financial crisis which resulted in another tech industry crash, so lots of people were searching for new jobs at the time and couldn't get anything good
Re:Living Wage Calculator by gizmo686 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:19AM (#19769832)
Since others have commented that they found the expense low, I decided to check mine. In my particular county in Maryland (don't want to give the exact one for privacy reasons), the total expanses for a single adult match my experience almost exactly. Excluding retirement and other savings, the reported total expenses was with 20$/month of my experience.

The housing category seems to assume that a single adult has a roomate though.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by jmpman on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:28AM (#19778617)
Is this calculator assuming you’re going to retire on Social Security? Just like having loose lending standards for college causes inflation, not requiring higher retirement savings simply drives up housing costs in regions with high demand.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by metaphor on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:44AM (#19770393)
I'm not following the logic behind the annual taxes row. It blows up with child #1, increases again but not nearly as much at #2, and blows up again at #3. Wouldn't having dependents reduce your tax liability? Is this some state tax mechanism? What am I missing?
Re:Living Wage Calculator by crobertsbmw on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:15AM (#19770490)
I think the taxes are based more on the income, which they are suggesting has to be more to still be livable. So even though you have more dependents, you are making more money (in order to be livable) and therefore paying more taxes.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by asah on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:42AM (#19770229)
Hmm. Same housing cost ($21,468/yr) in New York county, New York for:

- 1 adult, 1 child

- 1 adult, 2 children

- 2 adults, 1 child

- 2 adults, 2 children

Re:Living Wage Calculator by metaphor on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:05AM (#19770283)
What does $1,789/mo lease you in that area?

I suspect the data presumes 2 bedrooms: 1 room for parents, 1 room for children. The pattern is effectively the same regardless of state/county.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by gshdg on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:37AM (#19770559)
There are plenty of sub-$2k 2-BR apartments to be found in NYC. I’m not sure where you’d find one in Manhattan (New York County), though. They’re mostly in the less desirable (whether because of crime or commute time to Manhattan) outer-borough neighborhoods.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by bradleyjg on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:51AM (#19770606)
I'd look around the last two stops on the 3.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by gshdg on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:12AM (#19770970)
Even if there are a few, it’s weird to describe that as the cost of living in the borough if only 1% of the housing stock qualifies. You’re definitely not guaranteed to be able to find an apartment at that price.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by bradleyjg on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:20AM (#19771003)
Yeah, agree that's off.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by boshomi on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:51AM (#19769927)
If possible, please add median annual salaries and median wage.
Re:Living Wage Calculator by topmonk on Sunday April 28, 2019 @06:57AM (#19770435)
Isn't this a lot like Socialism? It's akin to deciding on the price of a pair of gloves based on what kinds of people need it, how much they would use it, how long before they need a replacement, etc.

But instead of gloves, we're trying to decide on the cost of labor.

I know I'm dancing around a thorny issue, but I don't think this idea works, in general. Why not just let the market decide?

Re:Living Wage Calculator by ebg13 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:09AM (#19770472)
> Why not just let the market decide?

The market decides on wage stagnation while costs keep increasing and profit goes exclusively to the upper class. For the vast majority of people, the market doesn't do a very good job.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by roenxi on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:26AM (#19770522)
A less-discussed issue with capitalism and socialism - it is completely possible for a clever and motivated person to work out what 'should' be in a specific or even a general instance.

The issue is that there is no before-the-damage-is-done mechanism to determine if a given person's assertions are correct or not, so any system that uses those assertions axiomatically will likely fail.

It isn't socialism for this Professor to point out what the living wage would be. If an employee (or employer for that matter) wants to use these figures when negotiating a wage that is hopefully good for everyone.

If the government is going to mandate minimum wages based on what Amy Glasmeier thinks is fair, it will turn out that she isn't very good at adapting to changing circumstances and the huge variety of personal circumstance that appears in practice. Mid-range case is she would become inaccurate (or corrupt!) after a few months or years and start setting wages too low or high. That would also be socialism and would also lead to bad outcomes vs. just letting people do what looks like a good idea to them.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by chrstphrknwtn on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:14AM (#19770489)
This is letting the market decide isn’t it? This calculator would have no region-specific wages if the USA were the kind of socialism (I think) you’re talking about.

Figuring out how much an individual (or family) needs to make to survive doesn’t need to say anything about the social, economic or political ideology. As far as I can tell it’s just saying “if you live here, basic survival costs this”

Edit: Italics formatting.

Re:Living Wage Calculator by lucozade on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:18AM (#19770497)
This isn’t trying to decide the cost of labour. It’s trying to put an approximate low band on the cost of living.

And the market does decide on the cost of living. This is attempting to quantify that decision into a practical metric.

Not sure why you’d think this has anything to do with socialism.