Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by solveit on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:02AM
(#19754759)
That the crimes were committed when he was a minor, and that he grew up and channeled his interest into becoming a highly productive member of society (as demonstrated by his work including stopping WannaCry) would be a very good reason for a pardon I think. I'm not sure how much we actually disagree, but while we're talking semantics I'd say stopping malware in this context is a reason for a pardon.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by masonic on Friday April 26, 2019 @03:57AM
(#19755570)
I still can't believe it's legal to detain people for so long without a trial.
It isn't, unless the defense chooses to waive its right to a speedy trial for strategic reasons.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by asdfasgasdgasdg on Thursday April 25, 2019 @11:51PM
(#19754703)
> I still can't believe it's legal to detain people for so long without a trial.
At least if the article is to be believed, this is probably partially on the defense, in terms of filing a lot of motions and so on. Apparently there are "complex legal issues" that could have been appealed. Wrangling all that takes time.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by Zanni on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:27AM
(#19754868)
Crimes committed when he was ages 17-20, according to the article. He was only a minor for the first year.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by goatsi on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:28AM
(#19754870)
>or the fact that when the crimes were commited he was a minor
One of the charges he plead guilty to had him updating and still selling the banking malware in 2015, when he was 20, and was already acting publicly as a whitehat.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by chmod775 on Friday April 26, 2019 @05:51AM
(#19755954)
In many places you can be tried as a minor even after turning 18.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by nradov on Thursday April 25, 2019 @11:46PM
(#19754679)
Pardons can be issued for any reason, or no reason. They are entirely at the discretion of the executive
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by reitzensteinm on Thursday April 25, 2019 @11:57PM
(#19754734)
Parent was arguing whether or not a pardon should be made, not whether it could be made, which or more or less orthogonal.
Re:Marcus Hutchins Stopped WannaCry – He Deserves a Pardon
by jessriedel on Thursday April 25, 2019 @11:54PM
(#19754726)
That the executive has this power does not make it a good/just thing. Lowpro is discussing the latter.
Arresting him by waiting until he came to the US rather than issuing when they knew they wanted him should be a reason, or the fact that when the crimes were commited he was a minor. But being famous for stopping malware is no reason to pardon someone.
All the best to him though, I still can't believe it's legal to detain people for so long without a trial.