News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by galonk on Thursday April 25, 2019 @02:37PM (#19751195)
These home server boxes never include self-hosting email. Is it because anyone running their own SMTP is assumed to be a spammer?

It's annoying because hosted email services are strangely expensive. Oh, they'll let you have multiple email addresses for a low rate, but as soon as you want multiple mailboxes (which is just a separate directory as far as the server is concerned), suddenly I'm paying way way more.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by jasode on Thursday April 25, 2019 @02:45PM (#19751281)
>These home server boxes never include self-hosting email. Is it because anyone running their own SMTP is assumed to be a spammer?

Yes, that's part of the issue. Because many home computers got infected by viruses to become bots sending bulk spam, email sourced from residential ip addresses became "guilty until proven innocent".

Even the recent $499 "home email appliance" such as Helm[1][2][3] for private encrypted email ends up using a centralized service such as Amazon AWS for the routing of email packets.

>Oh, they'll let you have multiple email addresses for a low rate, but as soon as you want multiple mailboxes (which is just a separate directory as far as the server is concerned), suddenly I'm paying way way more.

If you don't need business-class type of email service ("business" meaning Outlook sync, shared calendars, 99.999% uptime, etc), then the cheapest way I found for multiple mailboxes is a shared hosting plan. E.g. I pay $49/year for 5 website domains that includes email hosting with unlimited mailboxes. Not just unlimited addresses/aliases but mailboxes. Shared hosting is way cheaper than the $144/year that Rackspace charges for just 5 mailboxes.

[1] https://thehelm.com/

[2] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/12/review-helm-personal...

[3] TWIS also had a 1 hour discussion with Helm's CEO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1BhOreZKXPA

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by jlelse on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:53AM (#19755139)
I recently switch to mailcow-dockerized on a cheap 3€/month VPS and it works perfectly. I can create as many mailboxes as I want (until the disk is full) and also have as many domains / email adresses connected. It's really awesome and way easier than I imagined.

Mailcow: https://github.com/mailcow/mailcow-dockerized/

My blog post: https://jlelse.blog/thoughts/2019/mail-server/

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by extra88 on Thursday April 25, 2019 @06:57PM (#19753302)
> Not just unlimited addresses/aliases but mailboxes

Yes, Dreamhost shared hosting includes this.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by Jesus_Jones on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:46PM (#19751806)
helm was $300 for a time - $100 a year service fee after. I see they are now showing out of stock. And they started to add other services, including hosting some services on it with nextcloud.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by cjm42 on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:11PM (#19751507)
I use Pobox Basic ($20/year) + AllMail ($10/domain to forward all addresses at that domain) [1].

Mail for [email protected] goes to Pobox, which forwards to [email protected] (my home server). My server is configured to send all outgoing mail through Pobox's servers, which avoids the problem of people blocking residential SMTP.

[1] https://www.pobox.com/pricing

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by ggm on Thursday April 25, 2019 @07:44PM (#19753589)
I am another longtime @pobox person. However, I recently got told that its held up as a source of spammy mail, is characterised by many other SMTP speakers as a problem.

pobox is now owned by fastmail. They are an Australian company and for other reasons (crypto nation state issues) are not always suitable, but technology wise are very smart.

I'm sticking with my @pobox identity, its possible fastmail offer better domain-centric mail forwarding options for you noting the AU crypto law issue.

(in case its not clear, pobox and fastmail are in the same "space" but appear to operate independently)

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by DenseComet on Thursday April 25, 2019 @02:42PM (#19751255)
Its usually because residential IPs block port 25 so a mail server would not even be able to receive mail
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by scarhill on Thursday April 25, 2019 @02:55PM (#19751373)
I know that residential ISPs block outgoing port 25 because of the spam issue. Is it common for them to block it incoming as well? You don't really need outgoing port 25 to run your own mail server.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by progval on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:18PM (#19751565)
> You don't really need outgoing port 25 to run your own mail server.

You do need it to send mail

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by dredmorbius on Thursday April 25, 2019 @05:12PM (#19752556)
Directly, yes, but not via a smart host, which is how most SOHO mailservers (where used) are configured.

It's not quite a full-fledged, full-privilege system, but it continues to provide major benefits over Webmail or client-based (POPS, IMAPS) configurations.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by allset_ on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:20PM (#19751582)
You definitely need outbound port 25/587 if you want to send email to others.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by scarhill on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:38PM (#19751728)
You need an outgoing mail server, but ISPs provide those, and typically don't block port 587.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by m463 on Thursday April 25, 2019 @08:52PM (#19753933)
Yes. Some allow it after a shibboleet phone call.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by captn3m0 on Thursday April 25, 2019 @04:36PM (#19752264)
Migadu has unlimited domains and unlimited mailboxes. They just ask for sensible outbound email (anything less than a few thousand per day)
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by galonk on Thursday April 25, 2019 @05:03PM (#19752485)
Thanks! It could be what I've been looking for!
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by mindslight on Thursday April 25, 2019 @07:50PM (#19753626)
Hosting incoming SMTP requires doing network config at the provider level - stable static IP, port 25 unblocking, and static DNS.

Needing to host outgoing SMTP is an anachronism. It's only needed since client IPs are often considered dirty, so hosting it on your home connection can't fix that!

FWIW if you just don't want the responsibility of securing an Internet-facing server yourself but don't mind some config otherwise, you could sort email yourself with fetchmail+procmail or the like.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by penagwin on Thursday April 25, 2019 @05:57PM (#19752881)
At least in my experience, residential networks aren't worth bothering with for email.

It's all about reliability - I need my email to work at all points in time. I can't deal with ISPs blocking the port, not to mention everything will flag your emails as spam because it's coming from a residential IP.

If you're selling a commercial offering then you're going to need to fix those issues, otherwise, why wouldn't you pay for a "standard" solution that solves those issues for you?

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by jstanley on Thursday April 25, 2019 @06:34PM (#19753125)
> not to mention everything will flag your emails as spam because it's coming from a residential IP.

In my view, this is the recipient's problem, not the sender's.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by losteric on Thursday April 25, 2019 @07:07PM (#19753366)
Yes, it is - the recipient solves the problem by flagging your emails as spam.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by microcolonel on Thursday April 25, 2019 @09:14PM (#19754032)
Generally residential connections block outbound port 25, because of the spam issues that were caused by compromised computers in decades passed.

Also, I ran an email server at home when I was a teenager, the availability of the server was less than I wanted, so I've had to move that email service elsewhere. I suspect relatively average people would have a very hard time operating a satisfactory email service at home even if all of the SMTP stuff is perfectly reliable and foolproof.

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by Alekss on Thursday April 25, 2019 @10:18PM (#19754303)
In case your are interested, the YunoHost project includes a fully-functional mail stack out of the box (modulo the DNS records which you must set in your registrar according to the recommended DNS conf provided by YunoHost ;))
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by holri on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:39PM (#19751738)
Freedombox has a mail server planned.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by Flip-per on Thursday April 25, 2019 @05:29PM (#19752691)
Does it? Do you have more information about that?

I occasionally contribute to the project, and afaik the general opinion is that mail servers would be too tedious and error prone exactly because of this problem. Did I miss something?

Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by holri on Friday April 26, 2019 @12:44AM (#19754910)
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by Flip-per on Saturday April 27, 2019 @12:54PM (#19766437)
Apparently I really missed it, see also https://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox/Roadmap2019 It will be interesting to see how well it works.
Re:The FreedomBox enables you to control your view of the in... by wnevets on Thursday April 25, 2019 @05:33PM (#19752716)
thehelm.com advertises on twit.tv and they claim in the advert to work around those issues