News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by colejohnson66 on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:27PM (#19724493)
While noble in its intentions, if flipping the roles is seen as discrimination (no all female boards), it’s discrimination.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jakelazaroff on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:47PM (#19724604)
This is pretty easy to word neutrally: "No boards where every member has the same gender."

Is this really a problem, though? Do we really expect a situation in which men are systemically prevented from being board members?

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by sdinsn on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:31PM (#19725105)
> Do we really expect a situation in which men are systemically prevented from being board members?

I mean, this law sets requirements on board members genders. So I wouldn't think it's much of a stretch.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by belorn on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:31PM (#19733108)
Sweden made a similar law for sport clubs. 37% of board members are women, 63% are men. Yes, there are boards that is dominated by women.

One of the ten largest sports, horse riding, has a national board with 23% men and 77% women. In the same top ten category, ice hokey has 82% men and 18% women.

Football and Swimming, 56% men and 44% women. Skiing, 50% and 50%. Gymnastics, 44% and 56%. Golf and bandy, 57% and 43%. Athletics 60% and 40%.

Those are the top 10 in the area which my government though was so bad it needed to implement affirmative actions in order to correct it. 37% sounds few but in reality, only two are considered gender segregated and it is one female dominated and one male.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by FakeComments on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:07PM (#19724722)
How about we just don’t pass sexist laws because we’ve somehow told ourselves that this particular instance of institutional sexism is okay?

We’re already having enough trouble getting people to accept Title IX protects male students, after 40 years of females being the majority in student populations.

I’m not nearly as optimistic about the outcome of intentional sexism as you.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jakelazaroff on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:40PM (#19724911)
I'm not sure we could enact any policies that don't look like institutionalized sexism, though. As the Parable of the Polygons [1] shows, merely removing bias from a system isn't enough to break down structures that are already in place. We need to actively de-bias. Board seats are a zero-sum game, so that means we have to take some seats from men to give to women.

This is a good faith question! It doesn't seem to me that there's any real way to remove bias against women without adding bias against men, but I'm genuinely curious as to how we might do so.

[1] https://ncase.me/polygons/

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by FakeComments on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:50AM (#19725917)
Board seats are literally not a zero sum game: we can make more in any of several ways.

It troubles me that you’re factually mistaken on basic things like that — new board seats come into existence literally daily, to which every indication shows women are free to compete — but expect me to take your arguments seriously that we should institute bigotry at the highest levels.

No, get your facts straight first.

You’re also trying to respond to empiric failures in the real world with parables and abstract highly simplified models, which is somewhat silly: the decayed state of gender and race relations in the US and elsewhere is due to the sexist and racist policies enacted to “fix” things, and somewhere between 1990 and 2000 started stepping backwards decades of progress, with the situation the worst it’s been in a generation by 2020. Forcing the final steps of integration has been shown time and again to foster generation-scale resentment and undermine healing, particularly through forcing every interaction to be viewed through the lens of base racial or gender tribes. It literally teaches people to be bigots all over again.

A rotten tree bears rotten fruits: I don’t believe you can cause a good outcome through institutional bigotry, and I challenge you to show me it works. It’s certainly been tried enough it should have produced positive results — show me those, and not a cheap game.

Also, yes, merely removing bias in a dynamic system that shows a strong reversion to the mean on generational scales is enough to remove historical bias within just a few generations — a fact that comes directly from analysis of system dynamics and differential equations. Notice that if you drop the bias below 10%, there’s absolutely no problem — it just sort of wanders over long time periods.

To me, you merely seem a fiddler: someone who knows very well that debiasing works on the 3-4 generation scale, you’re just not willing to wait a century because you believe you’re smart enough to use evil for good, and are willing to risk sure progress based on that belief.

I think that’s reckless and immoral.

Reckless because you’re endangering something important — the fixing of gender and race relations in society; and immoral because you’re knowingly doing harm and discriminating, out of some very strange logic that’s making the world “better”.

Your model also has massive failures as a mechanism to explain social situations: it doesn’t, for instance, explain why Asian immigrants have thrived. Were the interned and destitute Japanese incomparably better off than other groups? If not, how does your model explain their recovery and integration compared to other groups?

What the puzzle actually seems to say is that if people have a preference you don’t like, you feel entitled to overrule them because you know better, and your global vision for society is better than the emergent one from individual choices. (The conclusions really seem oriented around forcing people to integrate when their natural tendencies would have them live in more or less homogeneous clusters.)

It’s tyranny gussied up with math: look at how if people have wrongthink preferences, we need to overrule them via force and targeted discrimination for the greater good!

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jakelazaroff on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:08AM (#19725997)
Sure, you can make more board seats and allocate them specifically to women, but then you're back to square one. Check out the debate on this not-zero-sum attempt by a YC investor to teach women to program [1].

I can't really find anything that indicates that merely removing bias (which hasn't happened in corporate America, mind you; we're several steps behind that) is sufficient to break down power structures long term. If you have a source, I'd love to see it!

With regard to the polygons simulation, I think you misunderstood it: once they're segregated, they remain so even if you drop the bias to zero. Active de-biasing is necessary to re-integrate them.

Edit: are you seriously suggesting that e.g. race relations in the U.S. are due to affirmative action and not slavery, redlining, Jim Crow, ongoing police brutality, racial sentencing disparity, etc? If so, I think we're done here. FakeComments indeed.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19464269

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by FakeComments on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:24AM (#19726088)
Nope, I’m suggesting the change in the trend of race relations is due to affirmative action and other instances of modern institutional racism: it was on a 120-140 year upswing, then started crashing.

I also didn’t meant allocate them specifically to women: women should compete for new board seats, and based on the trends prior to sexist policies being implemented, that alone should be enough for discover equilibrium in a few generations — no need to randomly discriminate to force the result you believe should occur.

That static state of your game is purely an artifact of the game and doesn’t correspond to the real world in any meaningful analogy, because there’s other forces on movement than your unhappiness with the racial composition of your neighbors — why would I support you enacting bigoted policies based on what is literally toy fiction?

All that game concludes is if people aren’t biased, they won’t move because of their neighbors; but if they are, they will. Duh, you built that into the model.

That you’re putting that forward as a serious argument is genuinely frightening.

Also, you should be more specific what you mean by “break down power structures”, what specifically would that look like and what specifically do you mean by “power structures”?

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by adamsea on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:18PM (#19724796)
Intentional sexism has worked quite well for the patriarchy.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by dragonwriter on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:10PM (#19724737)
> While noble in its intentions, if flipping the roles is seen as discrimination (no all female boards), it’s discrimination.

You are overcomplicating things; making a legal distinction is discrimination on the basis used to make the distinction; this is overtly sex discrimination. Your mirror test isn't needed.

Whether it is permissible discrimination likewise does not depend on a mirror test, but on whether (at least, from the perspective of federal Constitutional jurisprudence, using the test that applies to sex discrimination) it serves an important government purpose by means substantially related to that purpose. Which a mirror test of the type you propose doesn't help answer, both because it doesn't answer it for the mirror case and because the mirror case won't be similarly situated compared to the actual legal test unless you mirror all of society, not just the policy.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by toomuchtodo on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:32PM (#19724519)
I hope they'll not mind someone identifying as trans to get on a board. You get what you measure, and you can hack around all sorts of discrimination.

Edit: To be clear, I do not support, encourage, or condone discrimination of any protected class. You should be able to discriminate by skill level, of course.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by lokedhs on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:50PM (#19724625)
I'm not sure many boards feel the need to hack around it. If you were to ask any all-male board why they don't have any women on it, I'm pretty sure a very small minority would be doing it because they intentionally want to keep women out.

I think most would simply say that it just happened. The number of boards who intentionally conspire to stay all-male is likely very small.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by PinkMilkshake on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:11PM (#19724749)
What about gender fluid board members? Will the company be compliant with the law on some days and not on others?
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jakelazaroff on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:36PM (#19724550)
You know, for all the worry about people "identifying as trans in order to do X" it seems to happen very infrequently.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by toomuchtodo on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:48PM (#19724613)
I'm not taking issue with it (ever, really, live your best life), especially when used to obviate quotas. I take issue with "good" discrimination efforts, never how someone identifies or their biological attributes.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jakelazaroff on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:54PM (#19725205)
Gotcha, I'm sorry I misinterpreted your position!

I mentioned this elsewhere in the thread, but I am (genuinely!) curious as to how we can actively prevent "bad" discrimination without using "good" discrimination. Board seats are a zero-sum game, far more men have them than women, so how can we give more to women without taking some from men?

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:58AM (#19728605)
> so how can we give more to women without taking some from men?

We don't, just like we don't have quotas for roles and say, "This role is being held open for a woman, person of color, or other non-white, non-male person". If it's an all male board, it's an all male board. If it's an all female board, same. You don't legislate discrimination because you feel like it's helpful. Equal opportunity, not equal outcome. No mandated quotas. If evidence is uncovered that discrimination is occurring (against any protected class), you pursue legal action against the corporation and its officers.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by baroffoos on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:51PM (#19724632)
I imagine you would probably have to have your gender legally changed before that counts which is more effort than hiring one female to sit in the corner to meet a quota.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by aeternus on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:05PM (#19724715)
The bill actually does cover this explicitly:

>(1) “Female” means an individual who self-identifies her gender as a woman, without regard to the individual’s designated sex at birth.

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by cco on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:04PM (#19725007)
Interesting, so if a female transitioned to a male while on a board where they were previously the only female member they would be fired and replaced?
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by dragonwriter on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:13PM (#19724762)
> I hope they'll not mind someone identifying as trans to get on a board.

You mean, “to avoid also appointing a woman to the board”, presumably.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by jeromebaek on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:29PM (#19724499)
Nope, you're confusing the syntactic definition of discrimination with the semantic definition of discrimination.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by colejohnson66 on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:48PM (#19724608)
No. Reverse discrimination is just that: discrimination
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by dragonwriter on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:16PM (#19724775)
All law is discrimination.

Some is impermissible discrimination, but the test for that isn't “would it be impermissible if reversed”, and not only because that would produce infinite regress with no answer, but because mirroring policy without mirroring social context does not result in mirror policies necessarily falling on the same side of the legal tests of impermissible discrimination.

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by torstenvl on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:44PM (#19724937)
But see Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Peña, 515 U.S. 200 (1995).

https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/515/200

Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:43AM (#19725892)
Sure, the standard is the same in either direction.
Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018) by maxander on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:32PM (#19724515)
I get what you’re trying to say, but I’m not sure there’s such a thing as the “syntactic definition” of a word.