Re:California has a new law: No more all-male boards (2018)
by dragonwriter on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:10PM
(#19724737)
> While noble in its intentions, if flipping the roles is seen as discrimination (no all female boards), itβs discrimination.
You are overcomplicating things; making a legal distinction is discrimination on the basis used to make the distinction; this is overtly sex discrimination. Your mirror test isn't needed.
Whether it is permissible discrimination likewise does not depend on a mirror test, but on whether (at least, from the perspective of federal Constitutional jurisprudence, using the test that applies to sex discrimination) it serves an important government purpose by means substantially related to that purpose. Which a mirror test of the type you propose doesn't help answer, both because it doesn't answer it for the mirror case and because the mirror case won't be similarly situated compared to the actual legal test unless you mirror all of society, not just the policy.
You are overcomplicating things; making a legal distinction is discrimination on the basis used to make the distinction; this is overtly sex discrimination. Your mirror test isn't needed.
Whether it is permissible discrimination likewise does not depend on a mirror test, but on whether (at least, from the perspective of federal Constitutional jurisprudence, using the test that applies to sex discrimination) it serves an important government purpose by means substantially related to that purpose. Which a mirror test of the type you propose doesn't help answer, both because it doesn't answer it for the mirror case and because the mirror case won't be similarly situated compared to the actual legal test unless you mirror all of society, not just the policy.