News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:54AM (#19719893)
Sounds like VCs need a plagiarism detector for websites (think TurnItIn) to make sure their portfolio companies aren't blatant ripoffs.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by huffmsa on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:20PM (#19720709)
TurnItIn resells all of the data you submit to them. Any paper a student is required to sent to the service (it's not optional at schools where it's in place) is added to the dataset which they ultimately profit from, with nothing paid back to the students who own the original IP.

It'd be like YouTube using your videos for ContentId, but not having any avenue for you to profit from said videos. Oh and uploading to Youtube would be mandatory.

There was a lawsuit about this, decided on TurnItIn's side, but I still disagree.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:44PM (#19721599)
I wasn't suggesting they copy the business model, just the functionality. If it's all websites, there'd be no need to have a separate database.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by huffmsa on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:01PM (#19722298)
And I didn't think you were. My point is aside from the actual topic at hand.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by andechs on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:59AM (#19719964)
Just because something is a blatant ripoff, doesn't mean it's not a good investment. VCs are doing investments based on predicted ROI, not uniqueness. Lyft and Uber are extremely similar, but the particulars of the business are much more relevant to the investment opportunity.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:04PM (#19720015)
Sure, but neither of them was illegally copying aspects of the others' business. Business models are not protectable.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:16PM (#19720124)
illegal or not is for the court to decide.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:22PM (#19720172)
Are you suggesting that the article isn't describing an open and shut case, our that business models may in fact be protectable? As a former lawyer, I would say that neither of these is even a remotely close call (assuming the description is accurate).
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:16PM (#19720671)
Yes, that depends on how good are their lawyer argue it in court. Maybe they know something we don't.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:31PM (#19720268)
Technically, yes. But practically, in cases so blatantly obvious it is fine to draw your own conclusion.

In one court case - where a company I had a majority stake in was the plaintiff - the defendant basically had to admit that they copied the code and content of our website. Their defense: 'we did not copy it from them, we copied it from someone else' (without specifying what the 'someone else' was). Needless to say that did not end well, we were surprised they actually went to court but since this was in a country where the loser pays the court costs of the winner that did not overly bother me.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:18PM (#19720680)
Isn't that testament that their lawyer simply is not good?
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:26PM (#19720768)
Lawyers do not call the shots, clients do. So if a client wants to take a losing battle to court a typical lawyer will caution them but will not hand in their commission.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:33PM (#19720826)
No client want to lose. Maybe they choose the wrong lawyer? Maybe they shouldn't just use 'typical' lawyer. Especially for difficult case.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:36PM (#19720852)
That was about as unwinnable as they come. So no, that wasn't the wrong lawyer, that was simply the wrong client.

https://webwereld.nl/overheid/10591-webcamsites-bevechten-el...

(Dutch)

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:43PM (#19720930)
No case are unwinnable. At least not with that attitude. Look at the O.J. Simpson case for example.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:03PM (#19721782)
He lost the civil suit. And the only reason you bring it up is because it is exceptional. The general rule is that the courts tend to get it right but there are obvious (and glaring) exceptions.

The quality of your lawyer will help in the gray areas, and may get you a reduced sentence in case of a criminal affair but in general you will lose if you go to court with a case where you were in the wrong. It's not a perfect system but for most cases it works out.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:24PM (#19721975)
He win the criminal suit.

>And the only reason you bring it up is because it is exceptional

So you need exceptional lawyer.

>The quality of your lawyer will help in the gray areas

An exceptional lawyer will make seemingly black and white situation to looks like grey.

> in general you will lose if you go to court with a case where you were in the wrong

Sure, the point of court is argue that meaning of "wrong"

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:29PM (#19722027)
> He win the criminal suit.

You don't 'win' a criminal suit. The standards of proof in a criminal suit are different than the standards of proof in a civil one, because the punishment in a criminal suit is much heavier than in a civil suit (where the maximum is some monetary penalty, whereas in a criminal suit it is imprisonment or in some countries even death).

I really think your view of the legal system is somewhat theoretical, there is no such case that it can always be won given the right lawyer or argument.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by matz1 on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:56PM (#19722249)
He didn't get death penalty or imprisonment is a win to me.

The reality is legal system consist of human in various capacity, judge, lawyer, jury, even public opinion. Its all boil down to convincing these human. Given the right method or argument, you can convince any human. Sure some case are harder then the other but doesn't mean it impossible. Really really hard != impossible.

>there is no such case that it can always be won given the right lawyer or argument

What is your reasoning ?

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by ceejayoz on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:41PM (#19720366)
Deciding it on your own before the court battle might save you millions of dollars of your own invested money.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:57AM (#19719936)
We always check this sort of stuff for our customers, and more than once it has triggered.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:59AM (#19719963)
How do you do it? Just using Google on various phrases? Are you checking for your customers our on your customers? If the latter, why do you care (most vendors wouldn't).
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:05PM (#19720027)
> How do you do it?

We have a team of people that exhaustively search for players in the same space. The 'Google on various phrases' is more or less the gist of it, the more unique the better.

It's not an automated process so fairly time consuming.

> Are you checking for your customers our on your customers?

We do not check on our customers, we check for our customers. And usually pre-investment.

> If the latter, why do you care (most vendors wouldn't).

You are probably wrong about that, copying something verbatim will get you a C&D pdq in most cases.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:19PM (#19720147)
Thanks for clarifying! I'm still confused as to why a vendor would check on a customer or care if they're infringing.

I sell a SaaS reading product and don't care what my customers are using it to read, or whether their own websites our products contain any infringing content.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:28PM (#19720238)
> I sell a SaaS reading product and don't care what my customers are using it to read, or whether their own websites our products contain any infringing content.

What they are using your product for might very well turn into 'aiding and abetting', make sure your TOS is up to snuff and that you have it checked over by a lawyer to verify that if your customers do something illegal with your service you don't end up being on the hook.

As for the second, that might be a good hint that your customer is not above-board and will bear closer watching.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:35PM (#19720307)
I'm not sure I follow (and I'm a lawyer). If someone uses my chrome extension to research how to rob a bank, and then they go do it, what is the legal theory that puts me at risk? Is Google at risk because they're using chrome? Or the computer manufacturer?

Napster is one end of the spectrum, but I'm not sure how anything short of that is a legal risk. Are there cases or legal theories I'm unaware of?

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:43PM (#19720384)
There is a lot under 'SaaS' that you could use to further illegal schemes that do not fall under 'chrome extensions'.

Off the top of my head: anything payment related and two sided market places (money laundering, false binning), anything that allows large volumes of data to be moved around (copyright violation, child pornography, exfiltration of data from corporate networks), proxy services and spider services (DOS attacks, harassment, TOS circumvention and copyright violation) etc.

So nothing that would require legal theories, just the usual abuse of service.

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by gnicholas on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:10PM (#19720622)
> anything that allows large volumes of data to be moved around (copyright violation, child pornography, exfiltration of data from corporate networks)

So could Mozilla be on the hook if people used Firefox Send to do any of these things?

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by xenophonf on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:19PM (#19720701)
They could be on the hook, except the ToS of Firefox Send includes this language:

You hereby represent and warrant that your content will not infringe the rights of any third party and will comply with any content guidelines presented by Mozilla...

We may suspend or terminate your access to the Services at any time for any reason, including, but not limited to, if we reasonably believe:... you create risk or possible legal exposure for us...

You agree to defend, indemnify and hold harmless Mozilla [et al] from and against any and all third party claims and expenses, including attorneys' fees, arising out of or related to your use of the Services (including, but not limited to, from any content uploaded by you).

(https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/legal/terms/services/#se...)

Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:28PM (#19720784)
The indemnification bit is pretty much testimony to the fact that Mozilla also realizes the abuse potential of 'Send', but it may not work out well for them if they end up as the defendant in some lawsuit and the party breaking the TOS is penniless.
Re:Otonomo, with nearly $55M in funding, is cloning our product by jacquesm on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:14PM (#19720656)
That thought definitely crossed my mind when it was first announced. I sure hope they thought of that before releasing.