News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by DevX101 on Friday December 03, 2010 @09:46AM (#1965959)
There's something oddly perverse about the concept of a neutron bomb. You drop a bomb on a city, to kill large amounts of people, but leave all the structures intact for conquering.

If I had a magic wand, I'd have all countries have military technology no more advanced than the Romans. I understand that there are situations that call for war. But when that time comes, the people should KNOW they are at war, and have to make the sacrifices in lives to engage in that war.

The neutron bomb makes it a bit too attractive to engage in and win a war from afar.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by CapitalistCartr on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:05AM (#1966305)
Having the military technology of the Romans didn't stop people from having as many wars as they could. Seeing suffering hasn't stopped people from having wars. Enthusiastically. The only technology that has put the brakes on men's passion for warring is nuclear weapons. This has been the most peaceful period in history.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by DannoHung on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:49AM (#1966506)
You don't think that has anything to do with armament imbalance? Put all the guns or all the swords or all the nuclear bombs in the hands of one set of people and sure you'll have peace from the de-armed populace... but you'd better do what the guy with the gun says to do.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by hasenj on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:49PM (#1966771)
> This has been the most peaceful period in history.

Not really.

Not for the middle east anyway.

Although I see your point about having nuclear weapons resulting in less wars. The USA and USSR never actually got in a direct war.

OTOH, if just one reckless leader decides to use nukes, just for once, it will probably start an endless nuclear war.

It's a double edged sword.

Wonder what would happen if every country in the middle east had them, or say, major countries (Turkey, and some Arab country).

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by salemh on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:49PM (#1967388)
No major powers have gone to war however. Stalemates of nuclear war and the lack of conventional warfare between capitalistic countries equates to this weird period in history that does not involve actual military expansion. Economic expansion is enough :D

http://www.dancarlin.com/disp.php/hharchive/Show-33---(BLITZ...

An interesting look at "Belgium should not be a country" meaning, pre-1950's, Belgium would be snapped up by an expanding imperialistic country.

http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/demowar.htm Lists of Democracies going to war..though I would differentiate this between "capitalistic" countries and war.

Points and counter-points: http://bnarchives.yorku.ca/205/01/20060806nb_cheap_wars_tikk...

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by foljs on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:00PM (#1967426)
<b>No major powers have gone to war however. Stalemates of nuclear war and the lack of conventional warfare between capitalistic countries equates to this weird period in history that does not involve actual military expansion. Economic expansion is enough :D</b>

Economic expansion built upon cheap resources for the industries of large powers and obedient world markets. I.e in war, coups, protectorates, old-style and new-style colonization.

And, when everything else fails, war between major powers themselves.

The same fallacies ("economic expansion will replace war") were uttered in late 19th century, we saw how that turned out. Btw, the market was no less global then.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by foljs on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:56PM (#1967414)
"This has been the most peaceful period in history."

Not by a wide margin. The US for example is at war every single year of its existence. Now, it might be peaceful in Chicago or Pensacola, but the same was true for those living in Rome when the romans wages wars worldwide.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jordan0day on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:23AM (#1966121)
I think this is a misconception. AFAIK, the neutron bombs that were built (by the USA, at least), still had yields similar to that of the Hiroshima bomb, or 10-20 kilotons. As the article points out, Cohen's idea was to have a smaller explosive yield, but we never accomplished that. So in reality, the infrastructure still would have been significantly damaged.

I think Cohen may have had the right idea in mind, though. Lots of people seem to think the idea of the neutron bomb is "we can kill all of them and then move into their houses!", but what was the last war the USA fought with the serious goal of attaining land? The Spanish-American war? I think Cohen honestly believed that in a war it would be better to just quickly kill all the people who would inevitably die anyway, hopefully quickly ending the war. Then the survivors could get on with rebuilding, and if their infrastructure required less rebuilding, well, even better. Obviously not waging a nuclear war at all was the best option, but who in the 1960's really thought we'd make it to 2010 without a nuclear exchange?

One thing Cohen probably didn't consider in his "moral weapon" argument, although in hindsight it's another bonus, is that a nuclear war waged through low-yield weapons would cause less dust to be kicked up and smaller fires, ultimately preventing the "nuclear winter" that others predict from a full-scale nuclear war. So if the USA and USSR blew themselves up, nations elsewhere (esp. southern hemisphere nations) would experience significantly less environmental damage.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by mcritz on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:52AM (#1966242)
Neutron weapons are deployed at higher altitudes and explode nearly vertically to the ground. This helps minimize the physical shockwave damage to the ground and maximize exposure to the Gamma-ray radiation.

Contrasting this, some weapons are intended to be detonated at an angle & closer to ground level. These combine to increase the physical effects of the explosive shockwave: overturning armored vehicles, weakening defensive structures, destroying rail & roadways, and knocking down cover.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jordan0day on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:39AM (#1966458)
According to the wikipedia entry:

"Although neutron bombs are commonly believed to "leave the infrastructure intact", current designs have explosive yields in the kiloton range,[13] the detonation of which would cause heavy destruction through blast and heat effects."

I agree the intention of the weapon is to leave infrastructure intact... I just don't think that was ever really achieved.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by icegreentea on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:36AM (#1966438)
...I don't understand this concept of 'angle'. We don't really have an effective way of shaping a nuclear explosion do we? I mean, my understanding is that the blast effect of a nuke is a result of the xrays/gamma rays slamming into the air, and that nukes produce a nearly burst of rays in all directions.

If you mean that the resulting shockwave will be closer to vertical when it reaches given distance from ground zero, then that's just a function of geometry/height, not of any 'angle' during the detonation.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jasonkester on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:46AM (#1966493)
Actually, it seems like you do understand what he was talking about. You just haven't seen references to Nuclear Shaped Charges before.

Back in the day, lots of smart guys were working on ways to make nuclear explosions do interesting things. One of these things was to shape the explosion into something useful. Check out how they were doing it for project Orion:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsi...

So yeah, that's what he meant.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by mcritz on Tuesday December 07, 2010 @01:49PM (#1980066)
The angle of attack as related to the surface of the Earth. E.g. a perpendicular angle of attack means the weapon approaches detonation range from directly above.

Sorry for the confusion.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:21AM (#1966374)
Let's see, the last war the US fought in order to gain land (or at least resources and infrastructure) was ... Iraq! If it weren't for the political and international consequences, then Neutron Bombs would have been very useful in that conflict. The fact that the US won (!) but still doesn't have the spoils says more about the competency of my country's leaders than it does their intentions.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jerf on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:42AM (#1966478)
"fact that the US won (!) but still doesn't have the spoils says more..."

Or, in other words, you have a mental model of the purposes of the war which predicts certain actions, and then, when that model is falsified by virtue of your predictions failing, it's not that your model is wrong, it's that the leaders who were successful up to that point (despite, quite likely, your model not permitting that either) suddenly becoming stupid.

You've gone unfalsifiable.

(I'm calling this out because it's a pretty popular position. I'm not claiming the stated ends are necessarily exactly the true ends, either, but, actions speak louder than words. Putative motivations need to explain what actually happened, not what could have happened in a parallel universe.)

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:53AM (#1966527)
If you think you can model human activities with logic, or even self interest, well, I don't know what to say. Spend some time away from your models and read a little history. No assessment of history can be prove in the terms you are usedctovthinking in, much less within the lifetimes of the participants. That doesn't mean there is no value in discussing, and even arguing about motives, dreams, and delusions...
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jerf on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:04PM (#1966584)
Yes, you would think that, since you're trying to jam your models on top of history and then rewriting whatever is necessary to make it fit. Your process produces bad results. However, that is not because history is impossible to analyze, it is because you are doing it wrong. Examining history with open eyes and looking to actions over words is very educational, but requires you to drop a lot of preconceived notions and current political fads, which, I'm afraid, your point fell squarely into. (In fact if you really want to understand it you need to learn about the political fads of the relevant time as well, which turns out to be pretty decent inoculation against the fads of today.)

You may considering starting with the history of Europe, especially around the time of the domination of the Church. Most people are pretty dispassionate about it now, so we can actually have decent discussions without too much interference from modern political fads, we have a lot of information about it, and it provides clear examples of both the religious and secular authorities claiming their actions are about one thing (the will of God or the various rights of the secular authorities) when in fact the correct way to understand the situation is as a power struggle between the two with almost no real ethical concerns about their stated goals from either side. Without that understanding the period makes no sense and I can see why you'd claim history is some sort of weird nonsensical mess, but it really isn't that complicated, just immensely full of details. Actions, actions, actions.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:25PM (#1967493)
I don't have any models that try and explain history and I can't begin to imagine what a result of such a process might be. Stuff like Asimovian Psychohistory are fun to think about, but it is a fictional story telling device. And that's a hint. History and politics are storytelling. Often based on "true events" only as far as convenient to the storyteller.

To make any useful sense of history, or politics, or nearly any "soft" process, humans apply a variety of heuristics, some based on experience, and others on evolution, that frankly no one really understands. At least in the sense of a testable or prediction making model.

If someone makes a statement, or tells me a story, I have to examine the context and the past narrative of events in order to make a judgement about its veracity. The details of how that judgement come to pass are as unknown as the nature of natural language, and I suspect they are related.

In other words, my process doesn't get "bad" results, it gets no results. But I do get a heuristic that is somehow useful. Sometimes. Trying to argue about events like this, outside of the limited terms of those heuristics is pointless. How many angels _can_ dance on the head of a pin.

Instead, as in a courtroom drama (another story!), we look for means, motive, and opportunity. And then like any good jury, we apply our various and variable heuristics and come up with our own story.

Which is a guess.

Whether or not you believe the story I told, within the context of rather different discussion, is irrelevant, just as how you feel about the innocence of today's murder de jour is irrelevant. Unless you are on the jury. And the jury of history on this isn't born yet. Instead we are Rashomon like witnesses to contemporary events.

And speaking of irrelevant, this discussion has strayed from from its roots. While it's been fun, I'm done. Good day...

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by jordan0day on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:36AM (#1966443)
Well, people can (and certainly will) debate about the purposes of the Iraq war until they're blue in the face, but I don't think anyone would argue that the USA invaded Iraq because Americans want to move there.

Perhaps I didn't state my point appropriately, but my argument was more directed at statements like the one by Kruschev that kwantam quoted.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:01PM (#1966572)
I understand your main point, I was just addressing the notion that a infrastructure preserving bomb would be of no tacticle use to the US. Strategically it IS of no use tovthe US, but that is another discussion...

That aside, the point of the bomb was not simply to keep land livable for the victors to homestead, but to preserve the infrastructure during a conflict, including large numbers of the civil population not located directly on top of an unfortunately tactical spot. Gotta have someone left to work those still standing oil rigs...

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by lukeschlather on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:18AM (#1966359)
Why, then, has no one ever used a neutron bomb in war?

From an evidence-based standpoint, guns, bows and the like make it far more attractive.

I'd also point out that civilization with Roman-era technology is impossible without slavery on a massive scale, slavery that must be fueled by war.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by ertyjhgvfdc on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:34AM (#1966429)
Because nobody with the technology has fought a large tank force in a region where they didn't want to destroy the surrounding country.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by kenver on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:29AM (#1966145)
Whenever I read about neutron bombs they always talk about how they're designed to kill tank crews/armored soldiers etc, but as you say the potential is there to kill everyone in a city with little infrastructure damage.

From the sounds of it they must be expensive and difficult to maintain though due to the half life of tritium (12 years) so hopefully there aren't many around.

I don't see how they can ever be called a moral weapon, if for this reason alone (wikipedia):

One significant drawback of the weapon is that not all targeted troops will die or be incapacitated immediately. After a brief bout of nausea, many of those hit with about 5–50 Sv of radiation will experience a temporary recovery (the latent or "walking ghost phase") lasting days to weeks.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by pmjordan on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:47AM (#1966217)
I wonder how they know this? Do they just assume that neutron radiation will cause the same radiation sickness as other types of radiation? Extrapolate from animal testing? Or have there been tests with humans?

My understanding was that the high-energy neutrons interacted with the hydrogen nuclei (singular protons) in the body, due to the extremely similar mass; conversely, ionising radiation, well, ionises molecules, that is to say, interacts with the electrons.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by Symmetry on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:54AM (#1966533)
From accidents in the early days of nuclear research and extrapolation. An example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demon_core
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by DougWebb on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:45AM (#1966490)
Explosive weapons aren't the only sources of neutrons. I imagine animals have been exposed in labs, and probably humans have been accidentally exposed too.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by varjag on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:15PM (#1966628)
Also, there were plenty of actual nuclear bombing victims to draw many kinds of statistics.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:07AM (#1966313)
The Walking Wounded become the Walking But Still Capable Of Fighting And Mad As Hell With Nothing To Loose Anymore Wounded...
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by varjag on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:20PM (#1966657)
This is not that kind of recovery. You still would lose your teeth, hair, fingernails, vision, be extremely weak, get massive skin wounds pretty quick and gradually rot down in painful agony. You may last a week or two at hospital bed, but would be not much of a soldier.

(moral weapon my ass)

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by commieneko on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:43PM (#1967545)
I think you misunderstand my point. The range of effects is a gradient. At some point in the late '70s early '80s, when the controversy was fast and furious, I read an article that indicated that depending on the size of the bomb and the size of the target (with this type of weapon the target is usually a group of soldiers of some type) you end up with a gradient of results ranging from dead to something like what you describe to something like I describe to people who'll die months to years later to those statistically unaffected.

The point of the article was that, from a tactical viewpoint, such a weapon could be as dangerous to the user as the target.

Of course if your use case is simply to clear out a bunch of civilians from their land of milk and honey and move in, then, well sure. YMMV. Cows and bees weren't immune to neutrons that last time I checked.

As to the morality of the weapon, well, let's just say that I'm glad that, for now, it doesn't seem to have many advocates.

Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by tomjen3 on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:30AM (#1966417)
That won't do you much good. The asyrians didn't need nuclear weapons to destroy Babylon. And they could hardly have done a better job with them.
Re:Father of Neutron Bomb, “The Most Moral Weapon,” Dies by InclinedPlane on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:45PM (#1967373)
You've got it backwards. Industrialization buts incredible power in the hands of the individual, see the damage that individual terrorists and crazies are capable of. And there's no way to take away that dangerous capability and keep an industrialized, mechanized economy and society intact. Anyone with the necessary knowledge and intent and access to home depot can build modern weapons (guns, bombs, and worse things).

But the plus side is significant. An agrarian population is a population that can be cowed by force. History is clear on this. When the bulk of the population are tied to farms they can be easily dominated by any militant group with weapons and a will to subjugate.

Keep in mind, the horrific practices of, say, the Nazis or the Fascists or the Stalinists or the Maoists were de rigueur in ancient times. This is not something I want to return to, no matter how imperfect modern times are.