News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by ben_w on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:47PM (#19655618)
In 2017, the USA had 37,133 motor vehicle fatalities, at a rate of 11.6 per billion vehicle miles driven.

I’m having difficulty finding a recent figure for how many miles Tesla autopilot has driven, but they reached over 1.2 billion by July last year.

3 deaths is 3 too many, of course, but it’s also 10.9 less than one should expect for 1.2 billion miles driven.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by Animats on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:08PM (#19655740)
The number of Tesla-related deaths is much higher than Tesla reports.[1] At least 4 in California, at least 11 worldwide. That article points out how low the death rate for large luxury cars is, too. Tesla is at about 4x the death rate for the luxury car industry.

[1] https://medium.com/@MidwesternHedgi/teslas-driver-fatality-r...

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by illumin8 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:23PM (#19656697)
The author of the article admits that his fund is short TSLA. I don't know why I would believe his data.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by btrask on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:08PM (#19656866)
Elon Musk is long TSLA so we shouldn't believe him either.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by emit_time on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:27PM (#19660555)
I would argue someone in a short position has more incentive to produce negative news than someone in a long position does to produce positive news.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by jayd16 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:28PM (#19656717)
Teslas are arguably sports cars more than luxury cars. You should really be looking at the driver statistics shouldn't you?
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by Animats on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:17PM (#19660813)
"Sports car" is just a marketing label now, says Road and Track.[1] Once a "sports car" was a little 2-seater with a roll bar and a 5-point harness. Not a 5-seater with a deluxe interior. Now, it's just a PR term.

[1] https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/a28225/sports-car-d...

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by jayd16 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:30PM (#19660869)
Perhaps, but they're marketing to different people and have clearly different driver populations and accident statistics even though the cars themselves are probably not much different.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by thesunny on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:02PM (#19656310)
This is a biased article.

I do like that the article does some analysis to deduce that the NHTSA-FARS data is incorrect for Tesla and they make several well reasoned arguments why. Then using other data sources, they try to extrapolate what the correct data might be.

The problem is that the Tesla data in the NHTSA-FARS database is lower than expected. Yet they are comparing the "fixed" Tesla data with the rest of the data in the database that they take at face value.

It goes to reason if the NHTSA-FARS data for Tesla is easily proven to be underestimated (i.e. there are actually more fatal accidents than shown) that the data for other car manufacturers and models are also underestimated.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by javagram on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:06PM (#19656619)
Their argument is the Tesla data is underestimated because, as a new and relatively unknown car manufacturer, Tesla is often miscoded.

It seems like these concerns are much less applicable to a BMW or other manufacturer of large luxury cars.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by tim333 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:36PM (#19655876)
That article is fairly damning.
Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by cle on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:47PM (#19656230)
I’m not convinced yet (and neither am I convinced of Tesla’s claims). You can’t make strong causal claims from observational studies. Run a real experiment and I’ll take these claims more seriously.

(For example, there are a ton of potential confounding variables that could be causing the difference other than the safety of the car, like demographic differences.)

The burden of proof is on the claimant, whether it’s Tesla claiming their vehicles are safe or skeptics claiming they’re not. Until then, neither adds much to the discourse.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by hellllllllooo on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:59PM (#19656296)
Until the onus is on Tesla to prove their claims, rather than cherry picking statistics for marketing, it's better to be sceptical of what they say about safety of an unproven emerging technology that they are emphasizing to sell more cars. Basically, Tesla needs to prove that this reasonable analysis is wrong because they are the people making the claims about safety.

They really shouldn't get the benefit of the doubt. The burden of proof is on the company selling a system to control a two ton vehicle travelling over 70mph.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by hellllllllooo on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:13PM (#19655783)
This is not an apples to apples comparison. Tesla autopilot only drives the easiest subset of what a human driver can do and has a human supervising it while it does it to catch mistakes. This paints a picture that is disingenuous.

It's like having a doctor that only accepts completely healthy 20 year old patients quoting their stats compared to the general population.

These cars are no where near being fully autonomous and the story that Elon is paining about this happening in a few years with the sensors in a Tesla and the current state of research is a fantasy. End of the day he's a car salesman so take it with a pinch of salt.

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by mcguire on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:31PM (#19656726)
What is the general vehicular fatality rate on roads and under conditions where Autopilot is usable?

"For instance, in 2007 0.54 people were killed for every 100 million vehicle miles driven on urban interstates, compared with 0.92 for every 100 million vehicle miles driven on other urban highways and arterials, and 1.32 killed on local urban streets."

http://freakonomics.com/2010/01/29/the-irony-of-road-fear/

Re:AI Podcast: Elon Musk on Tesla Autopilot [video] by bob33212 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:08PM (#19655748)
Musk references OP's attitude in the interview. Tesla gets about 100x attention on it is other car companies. How many people gave died in a Lexus in the past 5 years? And how many of those deaths could have been been prevented by Lexus making safety a higher priority?

A better question though is what is the regulator's responsibility to approve a new technology like auto pilot when we know the general public will ignore the statistics and focus on the tangible deaths?