News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by dugditches on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:21AM (#19651743)
Do cars even come without 'smart' options nowadays? As in, is it possible to buy a new basic trim car with a traditional radio/without a screen? That can be removed or replaced?

I just wonder if this 'smart tech' will become like when you find a CD changer in the trunk of a car. Except these smart dashes won't be easily removable/swappable like an old cassette deck.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by froindt on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:48AM (#19652425)
>Do cars even come without 'smart' options nowadays?

This will be much harder to find on new cars in the US. As our May 2018, all new cars are required to have backup cameras (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backup_camera#Mandates). Now that a screen is required, it's harder to financially justify putting in a head unit that includes physical dials. Instead we're stuck with crap like "find the button for volume on the screen, then tap it 15 times to adequately adjust it". I'm hanging on to my 2011 Honda Civic for the foreseeable future, and pray the UI won't suck on newer vehicles or find a basic trim 2016-2018 that doesn't do everything on the screen.

I appreciate the safety aspect, but hate the UI of every car I've interacted with.

Any recommendations for cars whose UI doesn't suck?

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by bonniemuffin on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:19AM (#19652845)
Even though my 2019 Subaru is covered in screens, it also has physical knobs and buttons for the volume, air conditioning, and changing between radio station presets. I usually find that I don't have to touch the touchscreen on an average car trip.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by sjwright on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:25AM (#19652595)
In the economy space, my vote is for the most recent stuff from Hyundai/Kia. Not the world's greatest system but the latest stuff is very responsive (i.e. no UI lag) and their implementation of CarPlay/Android Auto is fairly bulletproof. (Good quality touchscreen, well positioned for finger input, doesn't do anything too stupid to make CP/AA frustrating.)

In the premium space, BMW has always maintained a medium-high bar with recent iterations of iDrive. (There have been many revisions and trim variations of their system, but approximate rule of thumb for acceptable tech is 8+ inch screen, 2013 onwards.) It's not going to wow a UI nerd, but if you plan to own the car for multiple years, it's slick and effortless once you're familiar with it—especially as almost any menu item anywhere in the system can be programmed to one of the 8 or so preset buttons on the dashboard.

I therefore have dedicated buttons in my car for "Call my wife", "Trip computer details", "Open destination address book", "Spoken directions on/off", and "Begin navigating to home." And if you think that will get too complicated too quickly, BMW thought of that: each preset button has a capacitive sensor in them so if you place your finger on the button without pressing, the screen will remind you what that button is programmed to do. It's nice.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by RandomBacon on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:07AM (#19652507)
My 2015 Toyota Corolla has a screen for the backup camera, but it also has physical buttons. The digital and physical interfaces are pretty good. Because it's a Toyota, it will probably be reliable for a very long time, and because it's a Corolla, there will probably always be parts available.

If for some reason you get a trim level that does not have cruise control, it's easy to add: drill a hole in the steering console, mount the lever, and plug it in. The car is already programmed with the feature.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by hoorayimhelping on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:31PM (#19653966)
>Any recommendations for cars whose UI doesn't suck?

Get a steering wheel with controls on it if the manufacturer doesn't offer physical buttons on the head unit. I'd be super surprised if you couldn't put a higher trim Civic's steering wheel on a lower trim Civic. Look for part outs from totaled cars (the sport and SI trims are good places to look - kids drive them irresponsibly, and they have high end tech that is usually salvageable when the body gets totaled).

I'm fairly happy with my Subaru Impreza - it has the head unit described in this post. The physical knobs and seek buttons make up for the dusty, stragnely-sensitive-sometimes, strangely-unsensitive-other-times screen.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by joezydeco on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:48PM (#19654545)
Current Mazdas don't have a very complicated UI on their screens, and it's completely operable with the jogdial and buttons on the center console. In fact, the touchscreen switches off in software once the car is in motion.

The UI also doesn't control anything except the radio, navigation, and some system settings. All the climate controls are on separate knobs or buttons (I actually liked the physical dials for fan/temp on my old Mazda 3 Sport, the Tourings and above changed to electronic buttons and it's not as intuitive as the dials).

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by userbinator on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:29PM (#19654807)
Any recommendations for cars whose UI doesn't suck?

Anything before the late 90s? Buying an old car and then installing your own backup camera would be one possible way to get the useful features but not the annoyances.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by froindt on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:00PM (#19655039)
I've considered that. When I buy my best next car (hopefully 3+ years from now), I'd like to upgrade the model year for the marginal gain in safety. 2015 or so might be my target year.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by gambiting on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:32AM (#19651783)
Of course. A basic model of a Dacia Sandero or Duster comes with a basic FM radio and nothing else. In some markets the same can be said about more upmarket brands like VW - a new polo cannot be specced with a basic FM radio and no smart features in the UK for instance, but in Germany or Poland it can.

And in a lot of modern cars the head unit is replaceable even if the manufacturer didn't envision it as such because of course the market has produced replacements anyway - like on Mercedes cars the entire head unit can be replaced by a custom one with a larger screen and running Android while not losing any of the factory functionality. On Nissan's you usually get a full dash replacement for custom radios. Quick search in AliExpress uncovers custom head units for nearly any car in existence.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by Hamuko on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:08AM (#19652796)
>A basic model of a Dacia Sandero or Duster comes with a basic FM radio and nothing else.

Wrong. The basic model of a Dacia Duster doesn't even come with a radio. You need to upgrade from the Access (base) trim level to the Essential trim level to get a headunit.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by gambiting on Sunday April 14, 2019 @04:55AM (#19658262)
Well I guess for the purposes of this discussion that's even better then.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by SahAssar on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:38AM (#19652171)
Those cars still have a lot of computerized components though, right? It's just that the interface you see is mostly analog.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by gambiting on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:22AM (#19652319)
I'm not sure what you mean though. Like.....the throttle control is almost guaranteed to be digital, the dials use digital information bus to update speed and rpm even if they use analog dials......you cannot buy a car with a complexity of a Fiat Cinquecento anymore, yes, but I'm not sure if that's a bad thing.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by solarkraft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:28AM (#19651956)
Oh, cool! I had not expected this. This suddenly makes a lot more cars viable for me (if I was in the market for a combustion car).
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by tinus_hn on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:17AM (#19652559)
Depending on where you live new cars might well be required to have ‘safety’/tracking features so emergency services can be automatically reached if you are in an accident. Or if the police want to effortlessly and invisibly track you, of course.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by iliketosleep on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:50AM (#19653001)
> Or if the police want to effortlessly and invisibly track you, of course.

All we need now is integration of biometrics to start the vehicle, so they know exactly who the driver is. For our safety, of course.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by stallmanite on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:19AM (#19652846)
The safety is terrifying.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by Adamantcheese on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:33AM (#19651786)
It doesn't look like it. The cheapest new car I just looked at was a Hyundai Accent for $14k and it came with a touch screen infotainment system. Even a manual 2019 Nissan Versa for $13.4k has one. Seems like it's the new norm, like how radio became the norm in cars after some time. I bet people were complaining about that in the same way you are now.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by mikestew on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:19AM (#19653480)
I bet people were complaining about that in the same way you are now.

Old Guy checking in: no, they weren’t. They were saving themselves fifty bucks by checking the “No radio: -50.00” box on the form.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by code_duck on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:03AM (#19651888)
An AM/FM radio won’t become semi-obsolete and in need of a software update after 5 years.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by charliesome on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:14AM (#19651917)
As digital radio takes over and analog broadcasting is switched off, that AM/FM radio will indeed become semi-obsolete.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by code_duck on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:23AM (#19652110)
So will the car? I think i need to emphasize the context.

I’m responding to “Seems like it's the new norm, like how radio became the norm in cars after some time. I bet people were complaining about that in the same way you are now.”

In 1975, there was no danger your radio would become obsolete or outdated at anywhere near the speed that an awful touchscreen tablet built into your car in 2020 will. So, I’m not referring to buying a car now with an AM/FM radio. I’m not sure what one would use that for other than as an AUX input.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by Reason077 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:05AM (#19652261)
What makes a touchscreen obsolete? Sure, the UI will look old-fashioned in a few years, but so will the rest of the car. In both cases, they will still perform the functions they were designed to do.
Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by code_duck on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:26AM (#19652337)
The touchscreen is not the part I’m expecting to become obsolete (?).

Many of the devices in cars currently have bugs, poor interface, slow performance, and are generally inferior to modern phones. So, continuing to perform as they do now is not a relief.

It’s like having a phone from 2014 built into ... uh, your car. I’ve upgraded my real phones and tablets 3-4 times since then, despite that the old ones still functioned same as they did when new.

One example is that it’s difficult to pair iPhones with some cars from a few years ago. What happens when software updates make me unable to connect to the Bluetooth in my car? I doubt that Ford or GM is going to release a timely update.

You might ask: why do people upgrade computing devices that still function?

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by PorterDuff on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:03AM (#19653384)
I think I agree with you.

They're starting to put cars on the same obsolescence train as consumer electronics. This is on a device that costs a helluva lot more. I suppose that EVs have the same issue.

The parts situation is going to be interesting. Lacking standardized design and only a limited number of years of guaranteed (and high cost) replacements, it should be interesting in a decade. Cars a tough environment and I'm afraid that wrecking yards will see a lot of usage in terms of both cars become obsolete/unfixable and as sources of spare parts.

It's interesting that the original sin of pushing towards this situation is the mandatory backup camera. Once the screen and a tolerably fast embedded system get installed, cost reduction leads you to a monolithic place for car controls. The modern fascination with cell phones probably helps the population go along.

Re:Jailbreaking Subaru StarLink by code_duck on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:14PM (#19654704)
Right, what I’m trying to say is that the obsolescence schedule of tablets and the rate of development does not match hardware like cars refrigerators well. Large physical items like that with other primary purposes should last a decade or two, at least.

I would think the best solution for this is to have swappable, upgradable tablets. Maybe basic operations built in, and a dock for a tablet that you could change whenever.

For any of this to function well, the manufacturers either have to work closely with competent consumer software companies, or become one themselves. It reminds me of the situation where cell phone carriers are expected to update the ROM on your old android phone, and often don’t do so regularly, because they’re not competent software or hardware companies.