News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tunesmith on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:02PM (#19648942)
Sure, let's squeeze another drop of humanity out of conversing. Maybe it's because I'm a remote worker, but I don't mind the "hello" and "hey, are you available for a quick question?" stuff at all. I prefer it, I find it polite and collegial. I'm honestly surprised this bugs so many people. Maybe it's an indication that our working environments are asking too much out of us.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by zapzupnz on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:15PM (#19649079)
As the website suggests, those who still wish to say 'hello' can just integrate it into the same message as the question. There's no drops of humanity being squeezed out of the conversation, just the conversation being made more efficient to reflect the nature of the conversational medium.

Your example 'hey, are you available for a quick question?' could easily have the question directly after that in the same line. No less polite, no less collegial, but much more efficient.

Of course it bugs people, it causes us to sit and wait for something when it could have been given to us straight up. People don't have infinite amounts of time to devote to mere waiting. Perhaps it is because you work remotely that this isn't so much the case, but for busy IT help desks, dedicating screen space to a conversation with nothing useful in it for any period of time is both a waste of the user's time and the technician's.

Our working environments aren't asking too much of us. There's absolutely nothing strenuous about people learning to adapt their mode of conversation for the medium, especially to meet everybody's efficiency needs. As the website stated, it's altogether possible to keep the polite chit-chat in the same post as the question.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by nxc18 on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:27PM (#19649175)
You could just switch to some other activity while the colleague finishes typing their message.

With a very basic policy change to how you receive messages, you can totally avoid all inefficiency.

You also avoid supporting the transparent money grab of a website dedicated to a needless complaint that is 90% ads.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by geofft on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:30PM (#19649209)
The problem is I was already doing some other activity, and was interrupted. I'm happy to be interrupted if I can be helpful, I don't want to be interrupted when there's literally no point.

Also, many people seem to want to get a reply to their "Hello" before they type more, so you have to switch over to the chat tab instead of just ignoring the notification.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by aeternus on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:53PM (#19649377)
Exactly, there are so many articles showing how costly context switches are, especially for software developers. By saying hi in a separate message you are forcing the recipient to perform a completely avoidable context switch while also priming them for another.

A cordial greeting before an ask is mostly an empty gesture anyway. If you actually care how someone's day is going, ask in person or via a message with more substance.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by jeffbr13 on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:58PM (#19649413)
I agree! In a way...

I’ll see a “Hi!“ in a notification or followed by _x is typing_ then safely know that I can start slow context-switching out of whatever mode I’m in, start reviewing that block of work for check-in or noting the key takeaways to come back to, and start pre-loading whatever I was talking about with that person last, without the fear of “here’s a big block of text, please respond to it in kind (all right away)”. And more than that, I can also interrupt any incorrect lines of thought or rambling if it’s more rubber-ducking than a request, or turn it into more of a conversation than a message which can read “please do this” and a reply which says “um... let me get back to you”.

I don’t know about you, but a large technical question or “hey can you... X Y Z” generates much more uncertainty than a chat between colleagues, even if the format is only different. Hell, modes of communication are a thing, we’d be as well use each one for its strengths.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by mstade on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:10PM (#19649507)
> The problem is I was already doing some other activity, and was interrupted.

About a year or so ago I came up with a solution to this problem: turn off all notifications. I don't revive notifications for emails, chats, texts – anything except phone calls. That's the only thing. I also have a notice in my chat status at work, and wherever else it makes sense: "For urgent matters, please call me at <phone number>."

It's worked wonders. I can choose to respond whenever I choose to check my messages, and for anything truly important people do call. It's happened maybe a half a dozen times over the past year that anyone's actually called, and typically whenever I'm non responsive in chat (because I didn't see it) I'll get an email instead, which generally has more detail in it anyway.

This, along with using mornings to square away most correspondence, has worked wonders for my concentration. My afternoons are now mostly focus time, despite people texting and emailing. I just get back to them later. Maybe tomorrow morning.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by zapzupnz on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:16PM (#19649540)
> turn off all notifications

For people whose job it is to be notified of things, likely the author the website included, how is this relevant?

Not everybody has the liberty to choose when to check messages or respond to them, especially those who are using a chat system which usually demands an instantaneous response. People collaborating on projects, people working to a deadline, companies which favour Slack or similar systems over email, and in my own example, people on IT helpdesks.

While I'm glad that you've managed to regain control of your routine, I'm not sure I see how it's relevant to the scenarios applicable to those hinted at through the context of the website.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by geofft on Friday April 12, 2019 @08:20PM (#19650211)
Agree - as someone in the position where I do need to respond urgently to some messages, I find it very helpful for chat to interrupt me. For that to be productive, the interruptions need to be meaningful. Saying "no interruptions" doesn't solve my problem.

And I do get some blocks of time when I can ignore all interruptions, in which case I just don't even open chat, instead of having it open and disabling notifications.

(My job isn't weird; I'm an SRE on a support rotation. When I'm on support I need to see things urgently; when I'm not I can focus on project work and escalations can take the form of someone finding me and pulling the headphones off my ears if needed.)

More fundamentally, not being around on the medium that most people at your company use in order to focus on project work is a great way to get left behind in terms of being aware of what the business is doing and what it values. People will slowly see you as the person who's great at finishing their own projects but not usefully responsive, and start treating you that way. Including when trying to assign new projects or during performance review season.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by ehsankia on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:49PM (#19649345)
The problem isn't even the wait between the two message, sometimes they won't even ask the question until you confirm that you are there. I want to look at the question, then decide if it's something I can answer now, or if I will get back to them later. It depends on many factors such as how busy I am, how complicated the question is, and so on.

I could reply "Sort of, depends on your question", but realistically I'll just not reply if they don't ask a real question.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by Kaveren on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:32PM (#19649224)
Maybe I don't check [chat app] every time someone sends me a message. Let's say someone sends me a "hi" at 3:00 PM. I check it at 3:30 PM. I reply back. Person replies at 3:35 PM. I see this at 4:00 PM. An hour wasted!

Maybe now I'm less available than I was, or want to stop working. This is why the "hi" alone is a waste of time. I do not want to be compelled to check [chat application] more often than I want to.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tripzilch on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:52PM (#19661308)
> You could just switch to some other activity while the colleague finishes typing their message.

> With a very basic policy change to how you receive messages, you can totally avoid all inefficiency.

That's nice, but not everybody's attention/focus works the same way.

I can't do this, for instance. If I get a "hello" message, I can try and return to the task at hand, but the anticipation that I'm going to get another notification any random time now completely ruins my concentration. Trying to regain my focus and continue work takes me at least a minute or two of active effort ignoring that nagging feeling until it's quieter. During that time, of course, comes the second notification with the actual question. Replying to that will of course require my full attention anyway. So I don't usually spend the futile effort to regain focus and rather just zone out for a bit until the other person gets to their point, I can answer, and everything is over.

And like everybody says, you can just put your "Hi!" in the same message as the question. I do that always. In fact I would feel I was being purposefully irritating if I sent a "Hello" first, wait for a reply, and only then get to my point.

It's a bit different if they expect it to be a longer chat or complex question. Then asking "Hey, do you have time"[1] is fine, because it's a genuine question that I could answer with either "sure" or "be with you in 10 mins". Then I am in control again and can focus finishing up until I get to them. I think that's the key here, being without control in that limbo zone between "hello" before finding out what the other person actually wants from you.

[1] personally I will always write "Hey do you have time to chat about <3-5 word summary of the thing>" because again it's the polite thing to do, not wasting the other person's time. Also it's easy enough, and helps me formulate the point concisely for myself. It allows the other person to decide whether chatting about <the thing> is something they have time for instead of just having time in general.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by zapzupnz on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:22PM (#19649585)
> You also avoid supporting the transparent money grab of a website dedicate to a needless complaint that is 90% ads

I don't begrudge the person running the site to want to cover their expenses.

Also, their complaint is not needless. It's a perfectly valid complaint. No need to be dismissive just because the site has ads, an issue unrelated from the core message imparted.

As others state, the very fact of switching to the chat application just to see whether or not the other user has sent a message is a block to one's train of thought. The colleague mightn't be finishing typing their message until you respond, they might even engage you in some banter first — so you can't just ignore their lonely 'hi', you have to actually engage with it, wasting both of your time.

The website manages to convey quite succinctly but not rudely a better way to communicate that one day could become a form of netiquette. There's nothing harmful with that.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by delish on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:12PM (#19649048)
I'm glad this is the top-rated comment--it teaches me that there are people who are totally different from me! I'm a remote worker who is sharply annoyed by "Hi" [send] "QQ" [send] [wait 30 seconds] "[question]". I find it impolite, and I am honestly (honestly, honestly!) surprised anyone feels otherwise. It's nice to be able to express this here; there's no way I could say it at work!
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by viraptor on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:05PM (#19649475)
As a full time remote, I really don't mind people doing this. I don't microoptimise my day to that extent. If it takes extra 30 seconds, then I can just wait for the rest of the message, chill, stretch, have a drink. If I get annoyed over 30sec delays at work, I'll take that as a signal something doesn't work well.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by xiphias2 on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:58PM (#19649418)
> there's no way I could say it at work

If you can't politely ask people how to address you on chat, it's a problem with either you, or the team / workplace.

You should be able to talk about things effecting your productivity, or switch job.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tunesmith on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:04PM (#19649820)
Honestly it taught me something too. Before I commented, there were a lot of comments, all practically unanimously expressing as you believe. So I'm as surprised as anyone that it's (currently) the top-rated comment. It's easy to forget that lurkers can believe quite differently than active commenters!
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by chronogram on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:26AM (#19651756)
Honestly, what kind of person comments on articles instead of looking at the page, scoffing, and going about their day. I do consider myself a bit out of the ordinary for doing that.

Then there’s also the topic of the discussion here. Topic: “don’t say hello”. Replies can be whole anecdotes of superstar developers who lost 10 seconds of their precious time, or something more mild, but there’s no anecdote in “I am okay with people spending a line in Slack/Teams to say hello.”

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by dennisgorelik on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:59PM (#19649797)
Why can not you express your frustration with distracting messages at work?
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by js2 on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:11PM (#19649038)
I'm a remote worker too and have been for over a decade.

Please, just put it all in with the message: "Hi. I have a quick question if you're available. Let me describe it as best I can here to start: ..."

This way even if I was not available to respond immediately, at least I have some actionable information when I do reply.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by loktarogar on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:50PM (#19649349)
yeah, this is it for me.

I worked for a company on the other side of the world and they'd often message me "hey, you around?" at like 5am in the morning my time. I'd get up later by that time many of them had gone home, meaning i'd have to wait for tomorrow to find out what they wanted. Which, as well as well as having to wait every interaction, also left the issue hanging over my head, fuelling anxieties.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by mrhappyunhappy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:13AM (#19651224)
I have clients who occasionally do this while we are half a world apart. It ends up wasting our time because sometimes I can’t get back to them while they are in the office and an entire day passes before I know what they want.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by GordonS on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:03PM (#19649458)
Please, yes!! It drives me nuts when someone IMs with "Hi" or "You got a minute?", when my IM status clearly says whether I do or not - just say what you want, and I have something useful to say when I do have time.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by reificator on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:32PM (#19649223)
> Sure, let's squeeze another drop of humanity out of conversing. Maybe it's because I'm a remote worker, but I don't mind the "hello" and "hey, are you available for a quick question?" stuff at all. I prefer it, I find it polite and collegial. I'm honestly surprised this bugs so many people. Maybe it's an indication that our working environments are asking too much out of us.

I don't think that's the takeaway.

The message is more about treating chat as a lightweight email rather than treating it like face to face or phone calls.

You'd never send an email that said hi, wait for the person to respond, and then respond to that with a question you wanted to ask them from the start. Chat should be the same way.

That doesn't mean no pleasantries, it means bundle them up into your message.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by mmaunder on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:18PM (#19649104)
And this...

"Short link to this page: http://nohello.com/. (If you see that as someone's status, please be prepared to be ignored if you only say "Hello!".)"

Is just a new way of being an asshole. Don't do that.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by reificator on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:27PM (#19649167)
> And this... [snip] is just a new way of being an asshole. Don't do that.

I agree fully with the message behind the page. Put your greetings in the same message as the question. A lot of people seem to think it's rude, but I'm convinced that it's the only polite option and not doing so is rude.

That said, I agree with you as well. Don't just set that as your status and ignore people. That's about the worst of all worlds.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by ada1981 on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:03PM (#19649456)
This is from 2013, so not that new.

And certainly not as bad as the folks who ask me to "please consider the environment before printing their email." Maybe even with some weird text-based tree art.

I dislike most email footer text.

Those privacy policy things are the worst.

I'd love to see some annual award for most ridiculous email boilerplate text actually in use.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by viraptor on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:21PM (#19649573)
Just keep in mind that most privacy footers are company requirements. They may even be appended to all outgoing mail. The people who send them may be as annoyed by them as you.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by ada1981 on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:25PM (#19649601)
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by ada1981 on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:26PM (#19649606)
Non-binding quasi-legalese. I'm not bound by a privacy agreement because I open your email. It's so silly and useless.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by viraptor on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:00AM (#19651056)
Yes. We both know that. It doesn't stop it from being a requirement.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by ada1981 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:15AM (#19652547)
I’d personally question the integrity and culture of a company that requires it.

It could prove to be a fairly useful “Brown M&Ms” test.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by raz32dust on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:24PM (#19649148)
You have to think from the point of view of a person doing their own work, while being pinged by 5 people on slack. It is super annoying because this is what happens:

- You're in the flow of working on your thing.

- Now, you see a notification. But you decided to continue working but now you have a thing at the back of your head that you have to respond to the message.

- Finally you take a break and decide to look at the pending messages, and you see just a hello. So now you have to respond with hello and know that you are going to be interrupted once again, because very likely, the other person is not looking at their slack at this time so they will respond later when you are busy again.

It doesn't say, "Don't say hello". It says, "Don't say just hello". Say your greetings but also give a brief overview of the question. Saves everyone time and it isn't any less courteous.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by alkonaut on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:27PM (#19649168)
That’s fine. This isn’t exclusive. If you have a long question to ask me, just type it in a text editor. Then chat “hello, have you got time for a question” I answer “sure”. Then you paste the question instead of typing for 5 minutes.

If the question is just 5 words or 100 words you can type them in 10 sec then sure I’ll wait. But that’s not how it usually works. You see it’s the people who are least used to chat and so both type the slowest that also misunderstand the greeting protocol. Greeting is fine. Greeting and then typing for 5 minutes is not.

Also as a remote worker something that really annoys me is when someone goes “hi, got time for a question?” and then 20 minutes later “sorry someone just walked in”. Don’t do that. If you sent a hello, always pay attention at least 15 seconds and be ready to interact. Don’t ping and then go for coffee. And please ask people who walk in to wait while we finish chatting, or just tell me someone walked in you need to talk to so I can go on with work.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by njepa on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:57PM (#19649406)
While I would think it would be annoying, I think the multiparter (like one sentence per message) works pretty well for work stuff. The people I work with type pretty fast however. Maybe someone should bring back ytalk ;)
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by jgvgkvljhvojg on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:39PM (#19649274)
I have ADHD and every interruption harms my productivity. If a co-worker emails me "hello" there are two possibilities:

1) Notifications are enabled, and visible/audible to me. If I'm working, I will likely be set back by multiple minutes by the interruption. I respond back asking what they need and it takes them a few minutes to formulate their question, at which point I've possibly managed to refocus and begin working again. There is a desperate struggle to switch context without losing the mental model I have been building of the problem at hand, before I have the chance to record it by writing some code, a comment or personal notes.

2) Notifications are disabled. I see the "hello" an hour later. I respond "hi, what's up?" and my coworker is now in a meeting or something and takes an hour to get back to me. They respond with "I was wondering if you could help me with something" and the cycle begins anew.

And by the way, I actually really like helping people with technical problems. I would sit around all day doing just that if I didn't have other work to do.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by president on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:11PM (#19649040)
It's hard to understand until you've worked at a place where you and all your co-workers are context-switching between 5 projects all due yesterday and everybody is pissed off. I didn't mind the "hello" at my older jobs where I actually wasn't stressed out.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by fmpwizard on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:51PM (#19649354)
I've been working remotely for about 13 years, something that I do with every new developer we hire, is to tell them that we are all available to answer their questions, no matter how "silly" they may think it is. I tell them not to worry about interrupting what we are doing, because if we are truly busy, we will not go into the chat app (flowdock in our case), but when we have a minute, we'll come to it and if the question is already there, we can answer it right away, instead of saying hi back and having no clue what the real question was.

And we are all very polite about it, we do say things like: "Hi, if you have a minute, how do I get this code working?"

And, we also have a "water cooler" room/flow, where we talk anything that isn't work related, weather, music, etc, and there sure, you can just say hi and nothing else.

In my case, it is not that I'm on a tight deadline, we make sure to have almost no tight deadline, my case is, I'm probably playing with my kids, or about to have breakfast with my wife, so if you need me, and post your question along with "hi", I can answer before I step away from the computer.

Hope this gives you an alternative view.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tripzilch on Sunday April 14, 2019 @04:39PM (#19661574)
Humanity is taking into consideration what the other person may be doing, whether you are disturbing them and whether it's nice to make them wait for your question after typing "Hi". It's a very cultural thing whether and how much greeting is appropriate (I've heard this varies widely even within the USA). But empathy for the other is universally cool and appreciated.

So you take a moment to consider the other, and you put your preferred greeting first, and add the question in the very same message. Bam! Best of worlds! Polite, nice, collegial and not making people wait and lose focus and switch context (which clearly is less of a deal to some people, but when it is, it's a big deal for some others).

Reading the comments in this thread from the people defending to split the "Hi" and the question into two messages, I really wonder what is their reluctance to just type everything in one go? Because I'm not buying that saying "Hi" in a separate message and then waiting is somehow more polite than saying the very same things but in one single message.

See, it sounds to me that it is them who don't like waiting. Sending a "Hi" first makes it more likely you have the other's (waiting) attention by the time you finished typing the question, so that you get an answer right away, not wasting any of your precious time. If you were to type your "Hi" and the actual question in one message, you spend your time and effort typing that question but the other person only gets the notification as you press <send>, and now it's you who has to wait in idleness. Much easier too, to quickly fire off a "Hi" first and only then start thinking about actually formulating your question.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by chillacy on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:33PM (#19649239)
Hey are you available for a quick comment?

...

In all seriousness, imagine if every response to your comment did that, and you had to reply and say Yes before they actually typed up their comment.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by biztos on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:25PM (#19649158)
I'm also a remote worker and have been for many years. Everyone else on my team is in a different time zone than I am, many of them quite far apart.

I get the "hello" message quite a bit on Slack, and I find it pretty reasonable, since the person hello-ing me is really asking "are you there? Because I expect you might not be, and I want your help with something."

I think "hello" is a polite way to check for presence. If I reply (and the asker is still online) then it's a green light for the conversation. If I'm not online then fine.

(I usually send messages like "Hi @coworker, can you please check the smoke alarm in the server room?" -- but the questions the coworkers have for me usually involve more Q&A than a one-liner would cover.)

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by alkonaut on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:30PM (#19649201)
> I think "hello" is a polite way to check for presence. If I reply (and the asker is still online) then it's a green light for the conversation.

It is. But typing a long question for say 5 minutes isn’t really “conversation” it’s just keeping someone waiting. That’s what the usual problem is. Not someone saying “hello” and then when greeted back they ask a 5 word question. In that situation it obviously makes no difference.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by GordonS on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:09PM (#19649498)
> I get the "hello" message quite a bit on Slack, and I find it pretty reasonable, since the person hello-ing me is really asking "are you there?

I haven't used Slack for some time now, but I presume it's like every other I'm service in that it displays your current status, such as" Available", "Away" etc?

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by gubbrora on Friday April 12, 2019 @08:02PM (#19650119)
Ime: available, away, busy - all mean "phone is on and person may or may not be available".
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by GordonS on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:33PM (#19660883)
I actually assume the status means what it says.

Where I work we use Skype for Business, and it automatically changes to away if their is no interaction for some time or I lock my workstation. Skype also has Outlook integration, so automatically switches status to Busy if it knows I'm in a meeting. I presume other IM software does the same kind of thing.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by geofft on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:31PM (#19649217)
I don't find it polite and collegial; I find it rude. I appreciate that the intent is to be polite and collegial, but impact matters more than intent for rudeness.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by Skunkleton on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:17PM (#19649094)
I personally refuse to respond when coworkers just send a hello when I know they are just going to ask a question. Waste of everyone's time, and I don't appreciate someone who would never talk to me otherwise pretending to care about me.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by CharlesW on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:22PM (#19649138)
> Waste of everyone's time, and I don't appreciate someone who would never talk to me otherwise pretending to care about me.

That's not what's happening. If there is a selfish reason (generally there's not), it's their handshaking protocol to discover if you're available to answer immediately.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by growse on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:13AM (#19652075)
I find that my availability to answer immediately depends on a number of things, one of which is the urgency or nature of the question.

Usefully, in my experience, nobody opens an IM session where they need my help on a production outage with just 'Hi'. :)

(I suspect I'm in a minority, but it's also why I hate answering the phone. An incoming phonecall is just a way for another person to unilaterally decide that they need my attention right now, which is often both disruptive and not true).

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by Skunkleton on Friday April 12, 2019 @08:08PM (#19650151)
I would guess it is because they haven't thought about what it is they are doing. There is a big difference between "hi" and "hi, do you have a few minutes to answer some questions".
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by JoeAltmaier on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:15PM (#19649084)
I'm maybe hypersensitive to the 'quick question' question. That's already a question, and the next one isn't going to be quick.

How about, just ask the question? Like "Can I get your attention today to help me figure out xxx?"

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by freyir on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:15PM (#19649080)
I get a few notifications daily from my manager: “Hi. You there?” Morning, noon, and night.

Maybe the intention is that I don’t have to respond. But every now and then, it’s about something important.

So I have to stop what I’m doing every time, respond, wait for the actual message to be typed out, and realize it’s something unimportant that doesn’t need to be discussed on a Saturday afternoon. Maybe this is humane, but it’s also annoying.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by dennisgorelik on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:12PM (#19649870)
> “Hi. You there?”

Just reply "Hi" or "Here" or even "Not here" (if your manager understands jokes and you are ready to leave).

You do not need to wait for the answer after that. Especially if it is not your work day.

Please understand, that your manager is trying to solve a problem, and getting your help -- is not the only option for your manager. That is why he may not want to spend his time explaining the problem to you if you are not available anyway.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by alistairSH on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:51PM (#19649363)
When I get those from my manger, it’s usually because he wants to discuss something private/sensitive, so cannot type out the question. It’s also stipulates always “r u there?” Followed by “come on down to room X so we can chat in private”
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by GordonS on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:00PM (#19649437)
Maybe it's because I'm not American (or maybe it's because I'm possibly low down on the autistic spectrum) - but I absolutely hate the fake "how are you?" at the start of every single interaction (unless of course it's a friend who actually cares).

It's even worse on telephone, Skype and IM, where any semblance of "personalism" is lost - someone starts a new conversation with "Hi, how are you?", and I have to respond to that before you'll just tell me why you're actually starting a conversation! How am I meant to respond? I invariably just say "yeah, fine, you?" - but I don't care, the other person doesn't care. It's just... awkward and pointless. I don't get what either party is meant to get our of this.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by dennisgorelik on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:06PM (#19649832)
> I absolutely hate the fake "how are you?"

Just interpret "how are you?" as "Hi" and reply "Hi" or "Hi. What's up?" back.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by GordonS on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:34PM (#19660888)
Thanks for the advice, I'll give that a try
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by groby_b on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:56PM (#19649399)
It's not "squeezing a drop of humanity". It's making the case that chat pretends to be a synchronous communication medium, but is actually asynchronous.

Somebody just saying "Hi", without followup, is saying "I expect you have nothing else to do, except wait for me". That's not "humanity", that's entitlement.

I do draw a distinction to "hey, available for a quick question", because that is stating a request - the person sending it asks for a chunk of our attention. It's a deliberate request to move to synchronous mode.

And to forestall the "but isn't chat just like talking to each other" - no, no it isn't. Talking is 150 words per minute, and it's delivered as a continuous stream. Chatting is (if we're lucky) 50 wpm, and it's delivered bursty.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by chefandy on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:32PM (#19649225)
I like a happy medium. I usually have my question typed out but send a "Hi, how are you?" ahead of time and actually read the answer, you know, because humanity. But then I've got the question ready to paste right then. Best of both worlds.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by dennisgorelik on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:14PM (#19649885)
If you already spend time typing your question - why not send it as well?
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by chefandy on Monday April 15, 2019 @11:30AM (#19666024)
Because I care about the people I'm conversing with and want to know how they're doing. They aren't a search engine.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by rictic on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:16PM (#19649539)
Network effects create counterintuitive situations. If you pick a random one of your friends, that person probably has more friends than you do (this is true! for most values of "you" at least).

I bet that it's likewise true that when you ask someone a question, it will usually be the case that that person answers more questions than you do (again, for most values of "you").

I think the distribution of how many questions a person is asked is very nonlinear. Someone who answers five questions a week is going to have a very different experience, and want very different social norms, than someone who answers fifty, or a hundred and fifty.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by wetpaws on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:23PM (#19649145)
There is nothing about humanity, it's all about using communication tool right way. Phone is real-time. Chat is asynchronous. It's just as simple as this.

You don't put phone call on hold and reply next day. You don't use text chat to expect realtime communication.

Interestingly, people don't have this trouble with e-mail. No one sends an email with single line "hello" and expect a reply, because instinctively people expect email work like real paper mail.

With chat they expect it to work like phone, although it's pretty much works on the same principles as email.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tunesmith on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:01PM (#19649805)
I think this "chat is asynchronous" point gets abused to the point of being rather meaningless.

People often, and I would say usually, want to have a synchronous -ish connection when they engage in chat. They want a person-to-person session. It's like synchronous with a generous timeout, or to stretch it, maybe it's like asynchronous -ish but with a very limited thread pool.

But the point is it is mostly used to discuss as you would on the phone, except slightly slower so you can take advantage of other abilities, like the pasting of a code snippet or a log output or a screenshot, and so you can maintain the connection while you are doing some light multi-tasking or virtual pairing at the same time, or even just so you can avoid whatever minor social anxiety you might have.

But if you're in a work conversation with someone on chat, and then they disappear for twenty minutes with no explanation or transition, that's usually not the etiquette and it's usually annoying. More common is they'll say "brb" or "ok, gotta do this other thing" or whatever.

And even if you do have a question, it usually doesn't work to just drop the question in their chat, and then blithely expect an answer "whenever". They might have a followup question or a clarification when you aren't available, and then this simple exchange can stretch on for hours or days.

So it's not like this totally asynchronous thing where people drop singular notes into each other's mailboxes and then go on about their days. It's more often a very efficient and low-friction alternative to scheduling fifteen-minute one-on-one meetings with someone or going and interrupting them at their desk.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by learc83 on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:29PM (#19649190)
When someone says "Hey are there?" there's pressure to respond right now--many times they won't ask if I don't. If someone just asks the question, I can respond when I have time.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by Kaveren on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:13PM (#19649064)
It doesn't squeeze any humanity out of people to ask them to actually ask what they want, instead of just saying "hi".

The annoying part is that they will wait until you reply to the "hi" before asking the question, which is a waste of time.

It's not impolite to say "Hi. If you have a moment, can you tell me why I am getting this error in my JS on line 20?". Saves hassle.

I work for myself and am not at all overworked. Still annoyed by it.

You wouldn't send an email saying "hi" (usually).

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by laumars on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:16PM (#19660506)
The thing that irritates me about people who just say "hi" is it wastes my time. I stop what I'm doing to read their message only to find out that I now need to wait for them to ask that question - which isn't always quick because if you've not replied to them right away then they're likely off doing something else themselves. So my workflow has been interrupted for no good reason.

I now passively aggressively handle this by posting lyrics of songs that feature their greeting in, like "Hey Jude". It usually gets a laugh but also makes a subtle point that their "Hey" follow up comment was a little pointless.

I don't mind if people post something like this though:

  <13:00:00> Hi, hows things?

  <13:00:30> Did you manage to get that report sent?
In that instance it's still 30 seconds before the follow up but at least they open with something more conversational and they're not waiting for me to respond before getting to the point.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by cptskippy on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:49PM (#19649347)
It's odd but I don't find it polite. It's akin to calling someone on the phone and when they say "Hello", responding with "Hey cptskippy, let me put you on hold real quick."

If you say "<small chat> <actual question>", I'm perfectly capable of responding "<small chat> <actual question || delaying response>". There's no need to decouple the questions and making one contingent on receiving a response from the preceding question.

The downside to slamming a person with multiple questions is obviously aligning their responses to the questions asked. So there's obviously some thought that must go into formulating your questions. But I don't see any issue with opening your line of communication with small chat and your actual question as the responses would be easily distinguished.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by spurgu on Monday April 15, 2019 @03:48AM (#19663798)
Screw that.

I just wait for 10 minutes before I engage in that chat (wishing I could turn off notifications for individual people in Slack), let the person say "Hi spurgu", followed by "Hope you are doing well" (and whatever else they come up with), after which they finally type out what they actually wanted to say. When they're done going through this horribly inefficient, annoying and time-wasting procedure I just directly respond to their question, without any added social bs.

Then again I come from Finland.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by debt on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:42PM (#19649292)
We’re not conversing, we’re trying to run a business. Get to the point sooner so we can solve the problem sooner.

Let’s converse during non work hours.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by zerkten on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:42PM (#19649299)
In large organizations the person is likely "pinging" multiple people to see who is available to answer their question. This is deeply problematic because folks sitting next to each other look over, or comment on the usual suspect pinging each of them. This becomes an interruption for more than just folks on the end of the IM.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by dfischer on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:16PM (#19649090)
Yeah seriously, when I first read what this was about my reaction was concerning to say the least.

Keep the humanity alive!

We are not robots – yet.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by laughinghan on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:19PM (#19649115)
Can I ask what kind of remote work you do, tunesmith?

Perhaps some kinds of work are more sensitive to interruptions than others.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tunesmith on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:44PM (#19649719)
Usually deep work, backend integrations and distributed communications, architectural consulting and implementation. So at least generally for me, when I'm blocked, I don't tend to be entirely blocked, where I need my answer now now now or everything is ruined. :) Plus, it's very important to have collegial relationships with the people that I am working with.

I can see being more impatient with this if I were in Ops and everything was an urgent fire all the time. Sometimes you just need the information as quickly as possible and that's what you need to optimize for.

But for me, if someone asks, "Hey, you there?" I'm sort of thankful for the opportunity to say, "Hey! How's it going, what's up?" rather than think, "Just ask me the question already!" As a remote worker it's often more important to optimize for the relationship because that's how you stay connected to what's going on.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:12PM (#19649044)
Or maybe it's just that an asynchronous medium has different etiquette than face to face?
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by taoufix on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @08:29AM (#19673040)
What I personally do is to write my question down, copy it, say Hi, wait for a replay, then paste my question. And thus have the best of the two approches.
Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by SlowRobotAhead on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:18PM (#19649103)
>Sure, let's squeeze another drop of humanity out of conversing.

You sure you're not overreacting a little?

When I answer tech support questions, the first thing out of my mouth is "Hi I'm SlowRobotAhead, what is the problem you're having?"

Not what can I do for you today, not tell me the setup, not what it is I do here. Tell me the problem have - and we'll see from there. That's not rude or removing humanity. It's polite by acknowledging we're not going to waste each other's time because of a mutual respect we start off with.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by tunesmith on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:07PM (#19649837)
>You sure you're not overreacting a little?

Hehe... no. I wrote the comment, took it out, then decided it didn't really express what I was trying to put across, so put it back in. So I was clearly on the fence anyway! A fine line between pithiness and rudeness sometimes, I regret when I fall over into the latter.

Re:Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013) by wufufufu on Friday April 12, 2019 @05:35PM (#19649252)
As if there was any humanity to messaging someone as compared to face to face conversation?