At least with simple "mother's maiden name" type questions, you could, if you were concerned by its insecurity, choose to use a secret value. With the automation of the process, that is not an option, while the security value of this pseudo-secret information will be eroded by its inevitable over-use.
That is, indeed, the problem that these questions are supposed to avoid, but they only offer sort-of security to the extent that the information is sort-of confidential. Anything that the automated validation service can find from public sources can also be found by the black hats, and the more common these automated services become, the more worthwhile it will be for the black hats to similarly automate their search for them.
The end result is that real security that is based on something you know has to depend on secrets.
I have both recorded in password vault and both are random.
The benefit is it they've reset my password for some reason or it was hijacked. I've been able to recover accounts. Not because I forgot a password but because it was essentially a harder to change 2nd "secret"
Given how bad the credit companies are at distinguishing me and my father (we share a name), I don't have much faith in this process either. What if you don't have a credit history?
Realistically most businesses don't have a need to pin an identity to a real-world person.
The assumption that you have, that the system "just works" is awful. Because when it turns out the system actually doesn't work, it's a fucking clusterfuck just to get someone to listen to you because they don't believe you are who you say you are, and government issued ID is apparently insufficient.
And the government seems to think I am the same person as my deceased father and grandfather because we share a name, and holy fuck is it frustrating come tax season (I have never in my life had my taxes accepted the first try and have had to physically visit the IRS before) or any time anybody tries to do any sort of background check on me.
It could be the same one I use for 2FA to the website. Or, an entirely offline flow would work too where they sent a dead-tree mail with the shared secret in QR code format.
So clearly it can be done. Swedish banks have been doing it for at least 20 years.
Their founder is going to jail but the tech was OK - take a photo of your ID with your phone and look into the camera. Do the faces match?
Cool!
Other systems require you to record a video of you saying a particular sentence which is then checked (presumably) by a human. And others require a video call to a real person.
None of them were true, because when I was first opening my credit karma account was when I first got a credit card; up to that point I had no credit history at all. When it asked me these questions, and I believe it implied one of the questions was true, I assumed my identity was stolen and got a report from transunion and equifax.
Turns out my identity was never stolen and credit karma was just being obtuse.
The best systems I have seen are the ones that use your credit history to ask you several questions like "Which one these four streets have you lived on?" or "Which one of these four employers have you never worked for?", but even those are gameable with some research. There has to be some better solution out there.