In my company nobody with a "C*O" title (including CIO and CTO) has any clue about tech so they are very susceptible to snake oil salesmen telling them things like "we must do ML". So they tell some random person to "implement AI" but nobody has any clear objectives or can make a judgement whether things go in the right direction. In most cases these things end up as expensive disasters. I am waiting for the "Blockchain Excellence Initiative" with a lot of presentations and shiny newsletters.
That's actually a really good business plan.
https://www.google.com/search?q=blockchain+center+of+excelle...
Being a CTO is less about technology and more about understanding the global technical landscape, accounting and legal implications to large budget decision making. If I, for example, choose Microsoft as a vendor will that impact our Pacific market and if so what is the cost benefit? These are not trivial choices. To an extent a lot of the job is risk mitigation, reducing liability for the company.
A good analogy would be a CEO of a shipping company not knowing how to sail. They will know costs of the voyage, costs associated with the voyage, etc. but not the day to day of how a ship operates. And they don’t need to. If anyone has worked with a micromanager they’d appreciate this.
And I feel like 100s of these decision are made everyday by executives who oversee but don't grok software.
* Infrastructure Manager
* Technology Visionary and Operations Manager
* External Facing Technologist
* Big Thinker
[1] https://www.allthingsdistributed.com/2007/07/the_different_c...
[2] http://www.brixtonspa.com/Career/The_Role_of_the_CTO_4Models...
I worked in a place with a CIO who didn’t know how to operate a TV. If you aren’t a tech company, it’s often a liability to have too much tech domain knowledge.
https://it.slashdot.org/story/17/09/15/1910200/equifax-ceo-h...
Sure, and in Amazon, you get a few tweaks that get the company a few bucks. It suspect the article wildly overstates the value of ML to Amazon.
Amazon's success seems to rest on: A. Attracting enough capital to get huge and stay huge with generally low margins. B. Being willing to slide into related businesses for extra-profits. C. Not jumping into one or another dumb trendy investments that would burn up all the capital they get from A & B.
Well, the memos might help B & C, for all I know.
Ten years ago, Amazon and Ebay split the ecommerce/storefront world. Ebay never managed to make themselves fully consumer friendly with hard guarantees and Amazon did. The auction-based, at-your-own-risk world is inherently limited and Ebay never escaped that - I wish they had 'cause then Amazon would have had real competition.
For me, this was evident from the fact that quite literally everything was automated:
Physical SKU distribution was allocated by an algorithm, optimizing for space density and picker path length. Pickers carried trackers to enable the data to constantly be gathered and algo performance reassessed.
Prices were automated in real-time
Inventory management and purchasing was automated and humans were there to override when necessary.
Kiva was purchased and applied to implement an inventory store that can self-reorganize in real-time
At least in my mind, this goes far beyond the token "we do A/B testing on UX" that other webshops do.
Worth also mentioning that Amazon did collaborative filtering on book recommendation way before it was trendy to do...
When I squint, it feels like Bezos had some image of some giant razor thin machine (quite literally) selling commodity goods, constantly capitalizing on competitors' inefficiencies. I can't help but feel this was inspired by his time spent at DE Shaw...
Edit: I suspect that what keeps an enterprise like Walmart or Costco from jumping into full competition with Amazon is that each of these enterprises wants to fish some high profit zone of the eComerce ocean while Amazon wants to be the ocean.
So Amazon is more than double but maybe not 10x? Amazon GMV is supposedly in the $250B range but they don't report it. And it's obviously hard to compare such different business models.
So you're comparing Amazon sales to eBay market value (total stock price). Yeah, it's completely meaningless comparison [Edit: I was wrong, it's Amazon sales versus eBay's gross merchandise value but it's still entirely off as a comparison].
Btw, my quickly googled references show eBay's net sales as 10.75B and Amazon's at $141.92B, which is indeed a more than 10x relations (when I think all other statistics show Amazon an order of magnitude ahead, not that I initially made any strong assertions about this but anyone looking has notice Ebay's star fading).
[1]https://amigobulls.com/stocks/EBAY/income-statement/annual
[2] https://www.digitalcommerce360.com/article/amazon-sales/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_merchandise_volume
eBay states there's here: https://ebayadvertising.com
The question is what is the GMV for Amazon's entire marketplace vs. their first-party Sales.
Edit: the ai part specifically.
Though very late to the party (modulo Alexa), Amazon has eagerly embraced AI and machine learning since 2015, but it lacks the leadership for formulating clear targets (see AutoML and AlphaGo Zero as examples of clear targets IMO).
A recent article in _The Information_ made the claim that their entire AI organization is making <$20M annually.
That is consistent with what I saw there: an effectively infinite number of codemonkeys throwing unprocessed data at randomly chosen AI algorithms downloaded off of github and hoping for the best. It's an interesting experiment, but it seems to be about as efficient as a monkey throwing darts to pick stocks (which is surprisingly better than many biased investment advisors admittedly). Time will tell, no?
https://www.theinformation.com/articles/demand-soaring-for-a...?
I think this varies by team. In my experience thus far, I've been receiving lots of feedback -- often actionable -- to improve my own narratives.
If your reviewers aren't pushing back on you when your paper lacks the required substance, that definitely needs to be addressed.
> OP1 and OP3 planning processes that are becoming increasingly cargo cult IMO
Businesses need operating plans to determine prioritization and funding. What's the problem with them, exactly?
Therefore they decided to destaff the effort and wait for me to prove them right rather than give me a couple engineers and enough rope to hang myself (which I wouldn't have most likely given my track record that established me as a "flight risk" apparently).
Can we say self-fulfilling prophesy?
Similar things have happened with the well-intentioned "bar-raiser" process as well IMO. I had bar-raisers in interview loops for my team who seemed more intent in blocking potential competitors to their niche than in hiring the best people, which was the whole point of said "bar-raising."
I think company culture & talent make a big difference here. At most companies this would run the risk of poorly shoe-horning ML into a bunch of applications and making everything needlessly complex & expensive without seeing improved results (same goes for blockchain).