Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by Ma8ee on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:44AM
(#19625168)
Yes! This is something that I have wondered for a long time. Why do people buy a car that covers all possible usecases for all year around instead of buying one that is ideal for daily use and then rent a bigger car for the week or two when you need it? It would be better for the wallet and for the environment.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by Erlich_Bachman on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @11:20AM
(#19625565)
Because there are many great cars that fit all those requirements and that are usually cheaper than a current Tesla, better equiped than a Tesla (autopilot being the single exception, even though BMW, Porsche, VW and many others already have lane assist which is basically a little worse (but still comparable) version of Tesla's autopilot). Why bother with renting when you can just take your own car?
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by eclipxe on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @11:58AM
(#19625968)
"basically a little worse (but still comparable)". No, not even close. I had an M5 with BMW's latest lane keeping assist. Tesla's Autopilot is exponentially better. Especially in the last two weeks with unattended highway lane changes. It is night and day different.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by Erlich_Bachman on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @03:37PM
(#19628040)
What does it mean practically? What do you mean by "exponentially"? VW, BMW, have lane assist. It means the vehicle will stay in the lane. Autopilot will also stay in the lane. Let's say on a 30 minute drive, autopilot will disengage 2 times, VW will disengage 6 times. Is this about right? I don't see an "exponential" difference here, care to explain? I have tried several vehicles that have this, but for short periods of time.
The point is, none of the vehicles are truly automatic yet. I've seen videos of recent automatic lane changes too, there seems to be problems with proper speed and accurate changes, unless perfect road conditions...
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by eclipxe on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:55PM
(#19640121)
I mean exponentially as in the experience is radically different. VW, BMW, etc will disengage multiple times during a trip by itself. Autopilot does not. 99% of my trips, I do not have to take over from autopilot. It just works. Sharp curves, stop and go traffic. The intelligence of the system - Tesla will look at cars in adjacent lanes, detect a blinker and slow the car to allow a merge. Tesla will look at cars approaching from an on-ramp merge and slow down to properly zipper merge. Tesla will detect a car in a blind spot during a lane change and automatically steer to avoid a collision. And yes the automatic lane changes are even further. They don't require perfect road conditions and there are no issues with proper speed or accurate changes. For me in SoCal traffic, the car will drive onramp to offramp, changing highways and avoiding slow traffic without me doing anything. This is what I mean by exponentially different. It is night and day.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by Ma8ee on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @01:10PM
(#19626714)
I don’t talk about Tesla. I am talking about a small car, electric or not, that cost a fraction to buy, drive, insure and will be easier to park. And then renting for that fishing trip or long road trip when your small car won’t do.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by georgerobinson on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @01:49PM
(#19627095)
I looked at this for a fun car to use at the weekends twice a month but it wasn't cost effective.
To rent for a weekend:
- Rental: £300 (dependent on the car, but £300 was the cheapest)
- Fuel: £100
To do it twice a month, between April and October would cost £5,600. Instead I picked up a fantastic car for just under £10,000 with less than 50,000 miles on it.Man Maths has me at (over 12 months):
- Depreciation: £500
- Maintenance: £1500 (includ. tires)
- Insurance and tax: £750
- Fuel: £1000
which is £3,750 v.s. £5,600.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by drusepth on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:06PM
(#19627251)
One small tip for renting cars is to look around at a few rental places, ideally in lower-traffic or lower-population areas. £300 for a weekend seems pretty high (but comparable to e.g. renting from the local airport here), whereas I could take an Uber to an Enterprise just outside of town for ~$30 and get a "premium" car for $140 for the weekend (48 hours at $70/day).
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by georgerobinson on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:10PM
(#19627294)
This is for renting sports cars (fun cars) for weekend use. Enterprise and the like don't have such cars available in the U.K, it's more of a specialist market.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by Ma8ee on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:58PM
(#19627713)
If you actually use the cat like that twice a month for a big part of the year it of course makes sense to buy one. But most people use the car for that fun drive maybe twice a year (even though they of course dream about doing it all the time when they buy their expensive car).
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by wil421 on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:47AM
(#19625202)
I have a car payment, pay to maintain my car, and fees to drive it. Why would I buy a car knowing I would have to rent a car several times a year to go on vacation?
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by ryanhuff on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @11:12AM
(#19625473)
One reason I do is to avoid the mileage I put on a vacation car. I could travel 1,500 miles across several states while on a vacation trip. That’s 1-2 months of normal driving that I instead put on rental car for about $150.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by bluedino on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:18PM
(#19626151)
1,5000 miles * 0.50 = $750
even subtracting gasoline (25mpg @ $3.00/gal) $180
you're still coming out like $500 ahead vs wear and tear on your car
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by qubitcoder on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @02:40PM
(#19627558)
Plenty of rental car companies offer unlimited mileage (especially in the US, Avis in particular).
I spent nearly a decade as a consultant traveling extensively throughout the US and Europe--and unlimited mileage rentals could be had for a reasonable and often surprisingly cheap price. I never understood why people opted to pay by the mile.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by mcv on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @11:02AM
(#19625374)
Good point. Plenty of people choose to not own a car at all, and only rent when they need one.
Re:Tesla Model 3 becomes best-selling car in Switzerland
by 1123581321 on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @12:39PM
(#19626389)
Most people do not take several vacations a year that require long drives.