Comcast customers pay for internet access, but I doubt that agreement specifies anything about network topology. If L3 wants a special connection, and it's worth more to them than it is to Comcast, then I don't see what's wrong, in principle, with charging for it.
Regardless, the net neutrality thing certainly seems bogus. On the other hand, if L3 didn't go on the offensive with PR, they probably would have taken a larger share of the blame from users than they deserve.
HN: not just news, but a lesson in communication.
For comparison, there was a little discussion recently in the UK re: net neutrality. It is unlikely to go anywhere because of the ease of switching ISPs, and the fact that the BBC - probably the biggest bandwidth sucker nationwide - is 'highly unlikely' to pay ISPs for access. If the biggest player won't pay, who will?
Business is about extracting value, not recouping costs. Amoral, not benevolent.
Or consider just the part of the transmission that occurs within Comcast's network. Case 1: data is sent from Comcast-user-A to Comcast-user-B, both pay a share of the costs. Case 2: data is sent from Comcast-user-A to Level3-Border-Router, only Comcast-user-A pays.
Comcast is charging its customers for access to a nebulous (but commonly-understood) entity called "The Internet". If their pricing model doesn't anticipate that users would want to access bits that exist outside of Comcast's own network (and therefore originate from someone who doesn't pay Comcast), well, it's a wonder they're still in business!
Produces set the price, and retail outlets, with a markup, come up with a business strategy ot move that inventory to their customers.
Now - look at Wal-mart. They're big enough that they can go back to the producers and say "Hey, by the way, you're going to knock 1% off the price this year or we're going to drop you - and we can say that because YOU need US."
Same deal here.
These companies are swapping services. They both benefit from that. If one company thinks they have the power to do so, they can also extract additional payment. It's just a matter of the details on who has that power. Level3 can choose to pay transit providers (which Comcast can underbid), or they can cut off the Netflix streams (which likely pisses off Netflix quite a bit, and certainly cuts their own revenue). I suspect Comcast wins here unless the PR kerfuffle gambit works.
Paying for transits is easy to understand, and in a complicated topology paying for bytes-in as a peer makes sense because they may be transits.
For a leaf node network like Comcast, whose customers pay to receive bytes and pay to have their connections installed to then demand payment from producers for supplying those bytes seems unjustified.
The author tries to hang this on the relatively higher build out cost per customer Mbps of residential nodes compared large commercial drops, but that is just different businesses. The residential providers already charge many multiples higher for bandwidth, this is just haggling about the multiplier.