News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by mmastrac on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:50AM (#19543818)
As a former vegetarian (now a pesco-pollo-tarian?) the important of eggs can't be understated. Arguably the one source of animal protein and fats that can be ethically sourced without harming the animal [1].

[1] vegans disagree on this point, but that's a different debate

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by J-dawg on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:13AM (#19544135)
Unless you're referring to the very new "no-kill" eggs [0] (which AFAIK are only on sale in Germany), all eggs involve harming an animal. And that's before we get to any concerns about how the laying females are treated.

I eat eggs myself, so I'm not preaching. I just sometimes wonder whether I should.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/dec/22/worlds-f...

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by peteradio on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:18AM (#19544203)
I'd encourage you to find a local source. Truly an insignificant cost difference. You can see how the sausage is made and make your peace with it. The more bold could even get a couple chickens 3-4 would have a small family drowning in eggs. Maybe it's not the same everywhere but there are tons of people with chickens in the Midwest.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by J-dawg on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:25AM (#19544298)
With respect, that doesn't really affect the point I was making.

While I agree with you, the people/companies who supply those chickens to the local supplier still have no use for the male chicks.

So even if you're buying eggs laid by hens that have a great life, you're still causing animals to be killed.

Like I said, I have no right to be preachy. I just want more people to think clearly about this stuff.

I hope the "no-kill" method becomes widespread.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by peteradio on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:06PM (#19544790)
Oh I see, I did not consider roosters at all. Not really sure what you do about them. They are nice to have for protection in an open range setup. What exactly do they do with roosters in the no kill method?
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by J-dawg on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:11PM (#19544849)
They are never born/hatched - the new method allows the sex of an embryo to be determined while it's still in the egg. Effectively they are "aborted".

Some roosters would obviously be preserved as breeding stock, just as they are now.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by rootusrootus on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:20AM (#19544219)
I get my eggs from my sister-in-law's little flock of chickens, and they don't seem the least bit harmed by it. What am I missing?
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by kawsper on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:24AM (#19544278)
What happened to their brothers?
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by benj111 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:46AM (#19544561)
Surely in a non commercial setting (as I understand this situation to be) motivation matters? If primary motivation is eggs then maybe the question is legitimate. If they're pets? Not so much.

Or you get into a situation where harvesting crops is morally wrong because it deprives animals of food.

It does deprive them of food, but to me it seems theres enough distance between the 2 things, that harvesting isn't morally implicated.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by rootusrootus on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:29AM (#19544356)
I've never asked, but she kept at least one.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by sslayer on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:28AM (#19544337)
They were yummy.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by cromiium on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:36AM (#19544426)
I believed eggs were not fertilized, no?
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by J-dawg on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:25PM (#19545020)
The issue here is the eggs that are fertilized, to create the laying hens. The males are a waste product, and are discarded.

The only way to determine the gender of a chick (until very recently!) is a visual check done after the animal is born.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by cromiium on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @10:14AM (#19554273)
Huh never thought about that. Thanks!
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by toomanybeersies on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:23AM (#19544266)
As a (sometimes inconsistent) vegetarian who doesn't actively eat eggs (haven't bought them in a year), I'd actually argue that eggs (and diary) are actually less ethical than meat, with (pastured) beef and lamb being the most ethical.

It seems less cruel for an animal to spend its life standing in a field than for it to be stuck laying eggs its whole life or being milked twice a day for as long as its useful, only to be led to the slaughterhouse. In fact, commercial chickens are the most cruel industry, chickens are so cheap they are treated like a bulk good, rather than like a living animal. Even free range chickens live a shit life.

We talk about treating our servers like cattle, rather than pets. But cattle are actually treated very well, there's a lot of value in a single beast and it's worth looking after them when they're sick. Chickens are so cheap (they cost, what, $7 at the supermarket?) that if they're sick or injured, it's cheaper just to turn them into fertiliser.

Of course, that's just the commercial industry. Home raised laying hens tend to live a comfortable life.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by msandford on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:30AM (#19544363)
There are folks who have figured out how to do good farming with chickens that mimic natural processes in the same way that folks use mob grazing of grass-fed beef mimicking natural processes as well. In fact what they do is have the chickens follow several days behind the cows so as to get the most bug larvae from the manure.

If you can find eggs from birds that are used this way I think that's a fairly ethical thing. Yes the birds are being used but they're also living pretty close to how they would otherwise.

I first heard of this from Joel Salatin, how exactly I stumbled onto that I have no idea. He's an interesting character for sure, but I can't help but have respect for the way he thinks about farming and what he calls honoring the animals.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by jrace on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:25AM (#19544301)
>(beef) and lamb being the most ethical. How is slaughtering an 8week old animal (young lamb) ethical?
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by svrtknst on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:41AM (#19544488)
Well, how is slaughtering chickens ethical?

For every egg-laying chicken out there, a male chicken is slaughtered, and both egg-laying and dairy milking harm the animals (for instance, compare avg. life span of a dairy cow with their natural life-span).

There's also the factor of number of animals killed - One lamb feeds a lot more people than one chicken, yet both are living animals capable of pain and suffering.

That's not to say that either is particularly ethical, but (as a vegan), I don't think you can easily say that eating eggs is intrinsically more ethical than eating meat.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by jrace on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:19PM (#19548351)
Not all eggs come from industrial slaughter farms. At least where I live farm fresh eggs from chickens who live cage free are readily available.

But the point of my comment us not that Lambs are less ethical than chickens...but killing and eating a few week old animal is hardly "more" ethical.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by toomanybeersies on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:06PM (#19545517)
It's not so much the act of killing that is manifestly unethical, but rather the life it leads before death.

Obviously the debate has a lot to do with your belief in consciousness and ego. Does a lamb have an ego and is it conscious of its own mortality (in the abstract sense)? Does the sheep suffer existential angst? Are these requirements for the industrialised raising and slaughter of animals for food to be unethical?

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by benj111 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:51AM (#19544620)
Could you not make the case that ending their (presumably) miserable life earlier is the ethical thing to do?

Is that not better than letting them suffer for a year?

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by Insanity on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:09AM (#19544071)
I'm a vegetarian not a vegan, and thus I eat eggs. But the 'ethically' sourced part is something I'm not that sure about. Sure they can be (and I get them from my grandparents who keep some chickens.. so that's ethical IMO).

If you buy eggs from a shop, I'd say there is a fair chance that the animals are not treated that well.

EDIT: I now realize many others have already made this point in other comments, oopsie.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by ravenstine on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:15AM (#19544171)
Most of what people think are "ethical" eggs that are sold in stores are basically a scam. Sure, they're eggs, but "free range" can mean the chickens have access to a little door and a puny plot of land for an hour, and "cage free" can mean the chickens never go outside. Pasture-raised eggs are your best bet, and that's all I'll buy, but even I'm skeptical because I've been burned so many times by believing my eggs were ethical.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by KozmoNau7 on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:03PM (#19546207)
It depends on local regulations, but here in Denmark, organic eggs must meet the following regulations:

-Maximum of 3000 chickens in a flock and a maximum of 6 chickens per square meter in the coops, which must allow daylight in.

-The chickens must have access to perches and nests.

-At least one third of the flooring must be loose bedding, such as straw or sand, to allow the chickens to dust bathe.

-The chickens must have all-year access to outdoor areas with at least 4 square meters per chicken. It must be covered by grass or other vegetation, and must provide shelter from wind/weather. An outdoor area must stand unused every other year, for parasite prevention and to let the vegetation regrow.

-Beak trimming is prohibited.

-Feed must be organic and must include roughage.

While it's not perfect, it's a damn sight better than battery caged hens.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by atombender on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:05PM (#19546217)
In the US, look for the Certified Humane [1] label; Pete and Gerry's, for example. Terms like "free range" and "pasture raised" aren't regulated and aren't trustworthy.

Under the HFAC standard, antibiotics are forbidden, mammalian proteins in feeds are forbidden, beak trimming has strict guidelines, etc.

Note that HFAC paradoxically/disappointingly doesn't require chickens to be have range, but if the package says free range, there's a 108 sq.ft.-per-bird requirement. Pete and Gerry's eggs are marked free-range.

[1] https://certifiedhumane.org

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by dguo on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:17AM (#19544188)
I use this "Organic Egg Scorecard" to help determine if I should buy eggs from a particular brand: https://www.cornucopia.org/scorecard/eggs/
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by Insanity on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:21AM (#19544235)
That's handy, but it seems to only be for brands in the USA unfortunately! :)
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by seba_dos1 on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:55AM (#19543866)
The problem is that while it can be, it rarely is...
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by Cthulhu_ on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:58AM (#19543900)
If the labels and laws are not to be trusted, you can always have your own chickens and look after their welfare yourself.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by harimau777 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:26AM (#19544311)
In much of the US that's against the law (and that's not even including people who live in apartments without yards).
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by throwaway400 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:09AM (#19544069)
Take a drive out to the country sometime, you'll find farms that'll sell you eggs. They usually have a sign that says "fresh eggs".
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by seba_dos1 on Monday April 01, 2019 @04:30PM (#19547886)
Have you actually tried it? It's feasible if you occasionally eat some eggs, but if your diet is mostly based on eggs you simply won't have enough. The main reason of animal abuse on chicken farms is scaling the supply to reach the demand.

Not even speaking about the fact that it's pretty difficult for somebody who lives in a city and doesn't own a car.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by rootusrootus on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:59AM (#19543906)
But if it is important to you, then sourcing ethically produced eggs is not particularly difficult.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by greglindahl on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:10AM (#19544079)
People disagree about what's ethical.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by wool_gather on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:17AM (#19544190)
Regardless, whatever your "ethical treatment of a fowl" criteria are, you are fairly likely to be able to find eggs that meet it.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by rootusrootus on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:14AM (#19544152)
True. I could also probably find people who think cutting down plants isn't ethical.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by hudbuddy on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:03AM (#19543973)
Worth noting that if you refuse to get fats from animals, it's important to get your DHA through algae oil.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by hudbuddy on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:08AM (#19544040)
I see now that the article mentions this
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by chongli on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:24PM (#19549413)
Arguably the one source of animal protein and fats that can be ethically sourced without harming the animal [1].

I think dairy also applies. Yes, lots of dairy operations in business today are cruel. But they don't have to be.

There are dairy operations now that let the cattle decide when to be milked. The machines are fully automatic. The cattle need not be separated from their calves, either.

With all of those systems in place, there is no real ethical difference between the dairy operation and a human mother using a breast pump and donating the excess to a milk bank.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by maxerickson on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:26PM (#19549425)
Isn't there a deep ethical difference when the human has autonomy and the animal doesn't?

I don't think it's immoral to keep livestock, I'm questioning whether the situations are analogous in an ethical sense.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by chongli on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:16PM (#19550157)
You're providing the animal with a space to live, safety from predators, safe food and clean water, and the freedom to roam a potentially large landscape.

Yeah, the animal is not autonomous. Do animals understand autonomy? Can they tell the difference? Maybe whales in capyivity can, but they are used to roaming the vast oceans. I think cattle would be perfectly happy in such an environment. Anthropomorphizing them is not helpful.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by maxerickson on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:18PM (#19550467)
I'm not anthropomorphizing the animal, I'm drawing a distinction between the ethical considerations when autonomy is a factor and when autonomy is not a factor. You compared them earlier, I questioned the value of that comparison (a human can give their milk; it is taken from the animal).

None of that is an argument that it is necessarily unethical or immoral to take milk from an animal.

Repeating the point: to me, the ethics of collecting milk from autonomous creatures that willingly give it are a separate thing from the ethics of taking milk from creatures that do not have autonomy.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by chongli on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:54PM (#19550947)
I'm not anthropomorphizing the animal

You are, actually. You're extending a human concept, with human morals and human judgement, to a non-human animal. It is not known whether non-human animals understand the concept of autonomy, let alone value it.

Given that many humans do not understand autonomy, I doubt that any non-human animal does.

But that's all beside the point. With these automated machines, if the animal chooses not to give milk, then no milk is collected from the animal. Since the animals do choose to give milk, it can hardly be argued that they are coerced in any way.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by egwynn on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:36AM (#19544417)
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by rhacker on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:39AM (#19544470)
Nice chart didn't know existed ;) I actually was a Fruitarian once - basically just ate mangoes, oranges, apples, etc.. all day long for a month. It was incredible. Dad from India so a lot of vegetarianism in my blood I suppose. My wife on the other hand couldn't make it last too long.

I wholeheartedly recommend fruitarianism if you can make it work (might not be easy).

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by magic_beans on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:04AM (#19543979)
I'm the same, and I happily eat farmer-raised eggs and mollusks. Mussels actively clean out water!
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by benj111 on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:29AM (#19544355)
"but that's a different debate"

Is it? Seems quite central to the debate to me.