News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by maxerickson on Monday April 01, 2019 @07:26PM (#19549425)
Isn't there a deep ethical difference when the human has autonomy and the animal doesn't?

I don't think it's immoral to keep livestock, I'm questioning whether the situations are analogous in an ethical sense.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by chongli on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:16PM (#19550157)
You're providing the animal with a space to live, safety from predators, safe food and clean water, and the freedom to roam a potentially large landscape.

Yeah, the animal is not autonomous. Do animals understand autonomy? Can they tell the difference? Maybe whales in capyivity can, but they are used to roaming the vast oceans. I think cattle would be perfectly happy in such an environment. Anthropomorphizing them is not helpful.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by maxerickson on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:18PM (#19550467)
I'm not anthropomorphizing the animal, I'm drawing a distinction between the ethical considerations when autonomy is a factor and when autonomy is not a factor. You compared them earlier, I questioned the value of that comparison (a human can give their milk; it is taken from the animal).

None of that is an argument that it is necessarily unethical or immoral to take milk from an animal.

Repeating the point: to me, the ethics of collecting milk from autonomous creatures that willingly give it are a separate thing from the ethics of taking milk from creatures that do not have autonomy.

Re:The Brain Needs Animal Fat by chongli on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:54PM (#19550947)
I'm not anthropomorphizing the animal

You are, actually. You're extending a human concept, with human morals and human judgement, to a non-human animal. It is not known whether non-human animals understand the concept of autonomy, let alone value it.

Given that many humans do not understand autonomy, I doubt that any non-human animal does.

But that's all beside the point. With these automated machines, if the animal chooses not to give milk, then no milk is collected from the animal. Since the animals do choose to give milk, it can hardly be argued that they are coerced in any way.