News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:23AM (#1953987)
> In fact, the one constant in South America is how much they hate the US

I am not sure where you have been or what you have experienced, but I wouldn't call it a constant. I never noticed this widespread hatred towards the US you mention in Brazil, Argentina or Chile. I understand most of the northern Latin America may harbor strong negative feelings towards the US, but I can tell you Brazilians really don't care that much.

Besides that, it's really childish to hate a country.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:43AM (#1954028)
Sorry, you're correct. I was inaccurate with my claim. The antipathy towards the US is much stronger in Central America and the Andean regions (Bolivia, Peru, Ecuador, etc)

As for being childish, the US has done a whole lot to earn that enmity. I'd recommend reading Open veins of Latin America, by Eduardo Galeano. It's a difficult read, due in no small part to the author's support of the Cuban Revolution and Castro's government. It helps, however, to recognize that the book was written in 1971, long before it became apparent that the Cuban experiment with Communism had some serious humanitarian costs, despite its successes. At the time, Cuba was the only real counterpoint to American economic imperialism in Latin America, so it's easy to see why he would offer such strong support for that regime.

Despite that, the book is meticulously researched and cited, and many of the events it details are frankly despicable. It's also by no means an attack on the US, as it covers 500 years of history since the Spanish invasion of the continent. It really is a good read.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by masklinn on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:50AM (#1954049)
> As for being childish, the US has done a whole lot to earn that enmity.

That's quite an understatement.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:40AM (#1954380)
Some people have done a lot, sometimes with government support, but those are a tiny minority when compared to the people they represented.

You shouldn't judge a people by the actions of their leaders.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:27PM (#1954827)
"Some people have done a lot?"

-CIA backs military coup in Chile to overthrow democratically elected president. Cue almost 20 years of brutal military dictatorship. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilean_coup_of_1973

-Funding and arming right-wing paramilitary militias in Nicaragua to overthrow another democratically elected government http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaragua#Sandinistas_and_the_C...

-Hell, blanketting the entire damned continent in brutal military dictatorships. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_America_%E2%80%93_United_...

-Overseeing said brutal dictators' plans to assassinate political dissidents http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor

-Training the armies of said dictatorships in the methods that made them notorious http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_of_the_Americas#Human_ri...

And that's just before the "War on Drugs" era. The US has earned the enmity of Latin Americans the honest way.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @04:49PM (#1955716)
How many people were really involved? A hundred? Two hundred? A thousand? Is that a significant part of all other Americans who didn't know what their government was doing?
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:17PM (#1956788)
They think they live in a democracy and are even willing to export it, therefore they should be responsible for the actions of whoever they voted (or didn't vote).
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @06:05AM (#1957499)
I understand what you say, but I maintain that most of them cannot understand what is going on. They were educated this way and are no more responsible for their government actions than are North Koreans or Iranians (or Portuguese, Greek and Irish) for theirs. They have been lied to for generations.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by alex_c on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:55AM (#1954455)
> You shouldn't judge a people by the actions of their leaders.

That becomes a difficult argument beyond a certain point. Especially if the leaders are (in theory, at least) representing the people.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:27PM (#1954828)
The point is that "in theory" a democracy represents the ideals of all its people. Usually, a democracy represents a fraction of the will of a people. Plus, the fraction that agrees with everything the leader does is even smaller.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by potatolicious on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:47PM (#1954885)
The problem that line of argument runs into is that the American people has also failed to hold its democratically elected government responsible for the shadier things its done (I'll stop just short of calling them atrocities, though some of it crosses that line).

Hell, the sorry state that much of Latin America is in right now is largely directly attributable to the direct intervention of the USA (see redthrowaway's post re: coups and installation of brutal military dictatorships friendly to US interests). These crimes have essentially gone unpunished, or hell, unanswered entirely back at home.

When the government purports to represent the people, the people rightly bear responsibility for its actions. While it is unrealistic to expect said government to do no wrong and always abide by the democratic principles on which it is founded, at the very least its abuses, once known, need to be reigned in by the very people who put them in charge. This is largely not happening.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @04:54PM (#1955733)
I agree apathy and ignorance, usually fueled by propaganda, played a role in this mess, but to blame all Americans for that misses the point. Americans should have held their representatives responsible, but they failed to even get interested. How many Americans can point Chile or Nicaragua on a map?
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:26PM (#1956807)
They get free public education for a reason. That was a fairly outrageous proposition back in the day. (More so than free healthcare would be nowadays). But they get primarily so they make rational voting decisions. Math and literature is nice as a side-effect but that was not the original intent.

Now when they see their kids getting left behind and brainwashed by the school system they should be doing something about it.

Otherwise they should be held responsible for being apathetic.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @07:53AM (#1957727)
> They get free public education for a reason.

It's obviously not working.

I never imagined I would one day say something like it, but we all need more lawyers and politicians.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:50AM (#1954683)
You should judge a people if they fancy themsevles a democracy (especially if they think their democracy is so good it deserves to be "exported" to other countries!)
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by Semiapies on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:58PM (#1956486)
Then it's time for judgement of the people of pretty much every democracy outside of Switzerland.

The US might have the most imperialist foreign policy on the planet, but many democracies have relatively fresh blood on their collective hands, and many more haven't washed off the dried blood.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by sigstoat on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:06PM (#1954744)
and should you judge the people if they fancy themselves a federal republic?
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:53PM (#1954908)
I see what you are saying. Technically we are a federal republic but that doesn't matter in this particular argument. We (US) are boasting at being a democracy to the rest of the world. In the propaganda domain we are a democracy. Our citizens have the potential of affecting the political establishmnt through voting.

This comes in constrast to say North Korea, China or Lybia. If their government does something outrageous, one can blame the people to some extent, but they should also get plenty of slack since standing up and otherthrowing the leadership would take a lot lives, blood, and suffering. It is not just a walk to the voting booth.

In general one can argue that the people of a country should be the responsability for their government's action in proportion to their ability to influence that government's actions.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbarooah on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @03:16PM (#1955415)
It's only one walk to the voting booth if there's an alternative available to vote for. Significant changes in US politics have cost lives, blood, and suffering.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @03:55PM (#1955547)
The first step is for the majority to recognize the dysfunction of our democracy. People have to realize that self-censorship and self-imposed oppression is keeping them down.

As long as the large majority are drinking the kool-aid they will just end up being manipulated powerful elites and they will vote against their own interests.

On the other hand, in US most people still have access to the voting booth, and to alternative media channels via the internet.

Aside from being added to various shadow 'watchlists' most American can (still!) join an activist group or can try to contant their elected official without a fear of imprisonment, torture and death.

But in more general terms, I was referring mostly to the propaganda domain, in which we project ourself to be a beacon of democracy. I was offering a potential contra-propaganda point that citizens of such self-professed democracies should be held accountable for the actions of their government. Whether we are an actual functioning democracy is another story (I don't think we are ...).

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbarooah on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @06:32PM (#1956050)
I am not sure why what a government says about its own qualities should determine the level of responsibility its people bear for it's actions.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:13PM (#1956780)
Because unlike other people, most Americans drink their own kool-aid, and most believe the fictitious qualities that the government tells them to believe.

When we grew up in Soviet Union, we knew propaganda when we heard it or saw it. We didn't criticize it in public, but in private we laughed at it.

I am surprised at how uncritical Americans are of their own history, political issues, external relations, and media bias,

Most believe they have the most objective and free press and the most democratic government system (they are even willing to export it!).

So if most feel like they live in a democracy and feel like they can vote and their vote can really count, then they should be held responsible for the result of their vote (or lack of).

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by masklinn on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @01:07PM (#1954969)
Constitutional republics are a form of democracy.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by huherto on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:15AM (#1954290)
Indeed, there is a lot of hate in the Latin America which is harvested by many politicians for their own political gain.(in the same way that Palin and Co harvest hate against illegal immigrants) One day the U.S. will have to acknowledge to start the healing process. It is amazing, the other day I was watching "The history of the U.S" and they completely skipped how the U.S. took California, Arizona and New Mexico.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rdtsc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:53AM (#1954696)
You were probably watching "The history of the U.S. made in U.S." and there is the difference between that and the real history of the U.S.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by huherto on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:11PM (#1954767)
Sorry for the sloppy reference. I think it was in "The History Channel". They described the American invasion to mexico in about five seconds just showing how the U.S. suddenly grew. The show was very entertaining but skipped on one of the main passages of history.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:29PM (#1954839)
"one of the main passages of history."

A small correction of perspective: it's the history of two countries, and it's only a major passage for one of them.

This asymmetry is one of the main reasons of international disputes.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by huherto on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:01PM (#1955165)
Thanks for your reply. I know you mean well. I could argue that it is the history of California, and it is important just because of the relevance of California to the world.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @06:06AM (#1957501)
:-) Someday I must learn more about the history of other places.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by KaeseEs on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:28PM (#1954834)
It was clear quite a long time before 1971 that Castro's regime 'had humanitarian costs', as you euphemize'; note that Che did all his torturing and murdering before he died in 1967.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by sedachv on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @04:59PM (#1955749)
"It's a difficult read, due in no small part to the author's support of the Cuban Revolution and Castro's government. It helps, however, to recognize that the book was written in 1971, long before it became apparent that the Cuban experiment with Communism had some serious humanitarian costs, despite its successes."

I don't understand why leftists have gotten into the habit of apologizing for collateral damage. The US never did. You can be thoughtful of "Amnesty International morality" (http://www.lrb.co.uk/v26/n23/neal-ascherson/victory-in-defea...) but if it's your overriding criteria we'll all just end up living in Paul Treanor's democracy, and that's a depressing thought.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by zephyrfalcon on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:50AM (#1954050)
The number of times the US have tried to meddle in these countries' business may have something to do with it: http://www.zompist.com/latam.html
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by cabalamat on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:04PM (#1954736)
> Besides that, it's really childish to hate a country.

Perhaps, but it's rather mature to hate a country's government, particularly when that government is busily taking away people's freedoms, e.g. with the ACTA treaty.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by cabalamat on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:49PM (#1956608)
> it's rather mature to hate a country's government

On reflection, I think this is too strongly worded. Hating a government can be counterproductive because the emotion can get in the way of devising an optimium strategy to counter what one doesn't like.

"Never hate your enemies. It affects your judgment." -- Michael Corleone, Godfather III

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by Gupie on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:38AM (#1954022)
Distance makes the heart grow fonder
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by fabiandesimone on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:34AM (#1954174)
>I understand most of the northern Latin America may harbor strong negative feelings towards the US

That is what Chavez wants you to think. I agree there is some part of the population in Venezuela that does not like the US but I think is mainly because they are being told not to like them.

I believe that most of Venezuelans have always looked up to the US and are pro-yankee. Given the choice (specially Chavez supporters) will prefer the american way of life or the american dream over this new Socialism of the 21st century.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:37AM (#1954183)
Sorry, what? Was this intended to be satire?

The US has done a great many things to make itself very hated in Latin America, and that is far from limited to, or even primarily in, Venezuela.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by compay on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:22PM (#1954810)
Just curious, what's your experience living or traveling in Latin America? Have you seen or experienced this widespread hatred first hand?

I obviously don't deny that the USA committed terrible abuses in Latin America, but I have yet to see the widespread resentment you speak of; not everybody walks around with a copy of The Open Veins in their pocket down here. Latin Americans can be as ignorant or apathetic of history as anybody in the USA.

I am not a Chavez supporter, but the claim that he or many Venezuelans "hate the USA" lacks nuance to say the least. If that were the case, Johann Santana would be reviled as a traitor for playing baseball in the USA, rather then being received by Chavez as a hero.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:34PM (#1954857)
I wouldn't call it widespread hatred. I certainly didn't see any evidence of hatred towards individual Americans. It's more a widespread opinion that the United States is at best questionably moral. There are certainly many who think it is evil, and if you ask the average person on the street they'd probably have mostly negative feelings towards the US.

I haven't been to the Middle East, but I imagine the sentiment to be very similar. People have an odd way of resenting you when you back brutal dictators that kill thousands of civilians.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by compay on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:43PM (#1954876)
I asked if you have lived in or traveled in Latin America, but you didn't answer me. Does that mean you have not actually been here?

I ask you because I do, in fact, live in Latin America and my experience has not been what you describe.

> People have an odd way of resenting you when you back brutal dictators

Actually people tend to first resent the brutal dictators themselves. The person paying the hit man isn't usually as hated as the guy who actually stuck a gun in your face.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by redthrowaway on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:48PM (#1955327)
I've spent time in Argentina, Bolivia, Peru, and Ecuador. I never claimed Latin Americans blame the US for all the things that the juntas did, merely that there's a fairly strong undercurrent of resentment towards the US there.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by fabiandesimone on Thursday December 02, 2010 @08:01AM (#1961989)
I'm sorry... I give you an insight about the country I was born and raised for 30 years and you see it as satire and the general opinion is that I need to be down-voted?

Honestly don't know what to make out if this.

Anyway have an up-vote, because in fact the US has done many things to be hated... as well as many things to be loved.

I, like many, many of my fellow Venezuelans, are very much, pro-USA.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by flog on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:42AM (#1954200)
How about we ask the audience? There must be at least one South American on HN willing to comment.
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by compay on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:19AM (#1954299)
I can only speak from my experience as an American living in Argentina for a little under 10 years, who was a Spanish major in college, and has travelled a fair bit around the continent.

The idea that people in South America "hate the US" has never been my experience. People in the USA on both the right and the left seem to have a paranoid fantasy that everybody everywhere hates Americans. Right wingers think people are jealous of us, while left wingers think we have pissed people off too much because of our abuses of power. I think both of them suffer from the same root problem: the delusion that people everywhere are obsessed with the USA and Americans.

In my travels, people I meet usually see the USA as just another country like any other - they may have a more or less favorable opinion, but Americans are lumped in the same category with Bulgarians and Poles as "foreigners." I've also observed that people are usually smart enough to separate the USA's government from its people. When Bush was in power, people used to sometimes ask me about him, usually in the context of "wow, I really feel sorry for you having a guy like that as your leader." Keep in mind that Bush was extremely unpopular here in Argentina.

I know this may be hard for some Americans to come to terms with, but while there are things that make us a wonderful country, and also some terrible aspects of our past... we are really just like everybody else, and at least in my experience that's just how people here have treated me.

Your milage may vary. :)

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:43AM (#1954396)
> I think both of them suffer from the same root problem: the delusion that people everywhere are obsessed with the USA and Americans.

I wouldn't be able to say it any better.

> Bush was extremely unpopular here in Argentina.

I really can't imagine a place where he was popular... Poland, I was told, but a statement so unbelievable required more proof than I had at the time.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:46AM (#1954417)
Considering the downvotes, Poland and HN...
Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by GFischer on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:37AM (#1954362)
I'm South American (from Uruguay) and there are many more here on HN :)

I'm not representative of my country, and my country is atypical by Latin American standards, but that said, there is quite a bit of animosity against the US, particularly by the old-school leftists (those that were adults during the US-sponsored military dictatorships in the 70s).

The newer generations and the old-school right-wing people bear no such animosity here.

I haven't seen much hatred against the US in Argentina or Brazil either (in Brazil they actually want to measure against and compete against the US in the global stage, not hate them), and there's quite a bit of envy involved.

All Latin American countries consume a lot of US entertainment and media and culture, too.

Re:Ecuador offers WikiLeak's founder Assange residency, no q... by santimt on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:11AM (#1954276)
I'm from Uruguay. Here US is hated by only a few, left ideas oriented people. I think the reason that make US to be hated is because its support to dictatorships and its imperial behavior over almost every country. But trust me, it is hated by only a few (at least here and the surroundings).