News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by MrXOR on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:31PM (#19537301)
The main thing is "Why undocumented?", not threat model and physical or remote exploit.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by CodeWriter23 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:43PM (#19537399)
> The main thing is "Why undocumented?", not threat model and physical or remote exploit.

No, the main thing is if VISA is for qualifying chips on the production line, why don’t they burn a fuse permanently disabling it on chips that pass QA?

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by smalley on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:08PM (#19538034)
VISA isn't for qualifying chips as much as it is for debugging chips including customer returns. Long ago access to limited versions of the signals was given to some customers under NDA and customers had the ability to set customer fuses which would prevent Intel from unlocking the debug features. There's also an unsupressable "debug enabled" bit hardwire to a lot of these functions if I remember so the parent system can always see if somebody turned on the debug functions. Turning on debug functions also usually had the effect of disabling/corrupting important key material.

This said, its basically a giant signal mux system run into a main block, you'd be pretty limited on what preselected signals are available at a time. People were also reasonably careful not to give entire busses of signals at once.

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by MrXOR on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:48PM (#19537432)
Yet another main question, because ...
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by 0815test on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:39PM (#19537361)
Why undocumented? Because Intel is not RISC-V or even Arm. Do you expect other chip makers to document every internal detail of their chips? And yes, as chips grow in internal complexity, bugs like this one become inevitable - so perhaps we should be insisting on fully-documented designs.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by smolder on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:57PM (#19537506)
There was nothing inevitable about this particular one, unless you mean it at the level of "people will always make mistakes and there's nothing you can do about it"
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by userbinator on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:54PM (#19537495)
Testing/debugging features are intended for internal use only and can expose proprietary information about their implementation, so only Intel and possibly some motherboard manufacturers are allowed the knowledge.

Speaking of documentation, while not fully open, Intel/AMD are already ahead of many others when it comes to documenting things. Look at the SoCs used in smartphones and tablets, or the infamous Raspberry Pi. AFAIK, Intel is not in the business of making secure cryptoprocessors like the ones used in payment cards and SIMs, but once again even with those you are very unlikely to find public documentation --- everything is NDA'd.

That said, don't get me wrong, I'm not advocating for leaving things undocumented; just explaining how it usually turns out that way.

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by 0815test on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:31PM (#19537776)
> Intel is not in the business of making secure cryptoprocessors like the ones used in payment cards and SIMs

They have entered a rather comparable space with stuff like TPM and SGX (and are largely using it for nefarious, consumer-hostile stuff like DRM and remote code attestation, of course).

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by hedora on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:53PM (#19537939)
You can also use SGX for privacy-preserving enclaves, which makes the combined existence and secrecy of this debugging stack more concerning.

Unless there are countermeasures that we don’t know about, this is a huge backdoor for such systems.

With DRM, the attackers afe consumers. With enclaves, the attackers are Intel and government intelligence agencies.

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by 0815test on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:02PM (#19537991)
SGX always involved trusting Intel. It was Intel basically telling a third party "yup, this machine is running the binary code you expect it to be running". Which is exactly why it's nefarious, of course - a third-party has no business forcing me to run their proprietary binaries on my own machine in order to access their service. If they want that kind of trust, they're still free to establish that by sending me a physical dedicated-use device that can authenticate itself to whatever service they care about.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by rficcaglia on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:57PM (#19538681)
SGX only guarantees the isolated memory region remains isolated. It doesn’t guarantee the code running in it is secure or even leak-free. Microsoft Research has studies this and release a compiler for making stronger claims about code running inside the enclave but I think this is still very much an open problem.

You will always want layers of security and even then security is an illusion .... there will always be a way, just with different costs to exploit and thus risk/reward frontier.

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by dTal on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:46PM (#19538631)
Hm, while I completely agree about not wanting proprietary garbage on my machine, I'm not sure about this logic. A third party can stipulate anything it likes, in order to use their service - you're always free not to use that service. Arguably, the ability to certify that you, the user, are indeed running the code you say you are is a feature provided to you, rather than a restriction imposed upon you. Not a feature I have interest in using, but nevertheless it's possible to frame it that way around. The fact that such code tends to be proprietary is (again, very arguably) besides the point.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by 0815test on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:11PM (#19538757)
> you're always free not to use that service

Unless that service has monopoly power. SGX makes it far too easy for an entity to abuse monopoly power, by directly turning it into power over what their customers have to run. This is why this sort of thing should only ever be done via physical devices - "monopoly" over a single, dedicated device is far more obvious and less insidious.

Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by codedokode on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:23PM (#19538119)
The processor in a payment card doesn't have any valuable data that the bank doesn't already have, unlike computer's CPU.
Re:Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data... by dooglius on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:38PM (#19537358)
Based on the name, the tool likely makes it easy for others to figure out low-level details of processor implementations that Intel would prefer be trade secrets.