Re:Lisp Macros, Delayed Evaluation and the Evolution of Smal...
by kazinator on Saturday March 30, 2019 @12:04PM
(#19530090)
If you tell students that Lisp macros are for delaying evaluation, you're a lousy teacher. Someone in the class will Google you out, send a few instant messages to a few others, and soon nobody will take your class seriously.
A good teacher is engaging and glib, and tells the right sorts of little lies at the right times to lead students through the steps of "Wittgenstein ladders"; but he or she can't be flat out wrong about the subject material.
Re:Lisp Macros, Delayed Evaluation and the Evolution of Smal...
by reitzensteinm on Saturday March 30, 2019 @05:27PM
(#19531976)
Yeah, I'm not going to take teaching advice from a person that walked me condescendingly step by step through an example to point out an inconsistency that wasn't there because they misunderstood what I was saying. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Lisp Macros, Delayed Evaluation and the Evolution of Smal...
by lispm on Saturday March 30, 2019 @04:14AM
(#19528409)
and I doubt your claim, that extending a meta-circular toy interpreter with some remotely macro-like feature will help any Lisp beginner to understand Lisp macros.
There is already a bunch of good material out there, teaching the use of Lisp macros for both beginners and for medium-level users. Advanced-level users will find a lot of teaching&research in the Scheme literature/...
Paul Graham himself has written a good and well-known book on it. it does a good job explaining macros and their use. It's called 'On Lisp' and there is no need to replicate its content here.
Now we have gone full circle, again.
Re:Lisp Macros, Delayed Evaluation and the Evolution of Smal...
by reitzensteinm on Saturday March 30, 2019 @04:26AM
(#19528442)
Yeah, there's no point continuing this discussion. Thank you for taking the time to reply in depth to my posts even though we could not find common ground.
Were I disagreeing technically, it would be a different matter and I'd have long ago hit the books to see where I fucked up. The combined lisp experience on this thread is at least an order of magnitude more than mine, and most of you are probably smarter than me to boot.