News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:39AM (#19522585)
Or twenty drones with fairly modern radar and air-to-air armaments. Or if they're cheap enough, 45-90 drones...

There are downsides to drones (loss of control is a worry), but without the need for a cockpit, you can make the plane much smaller with a much better thrust to weight ratio, and also capable of pulling off maneuvers that would render a pilot unconscious.[1]

Quantity has a quality all it's own. I would bet against a F-35 even if it was up against 30-40 P-51 Mustangs from WWII. The sheer amount of lead they could fill the sky with (for a short time) is daunting.

1: I remember 5-6 years ago someone on HN commenting that an F-16 (I think?) was capable of enough forces exerted on a pilot to easily break their neck, and was limited.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by nominatronic on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:48AM (#19522677)
The word you're looking for is "missiles".

The idea of dogfighting drones makes very little sense. If you build a lot of expendable tiny planes with a high thrust to weight ratio and high-G maneuvering, there's no point having those then try to shoot some secondary projectiles at the target. It's far simplier to just fly them into it or detonate them close enough to cause fatal damage.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:52AM (#19522708)
The concept here is the equivalent cost of machinery to a single F-35 going against an F-35. How many missiles does an F-35 carry? Drones carry missiles as well.

The older planes were just to drive a point home. How does an F-35 defend against 20-40 times as many adversaries attacking? If the F-35 is attacking, it might be faster and be able to go around an intercepting force, but that's a big if, and it's more dangerous because it may put it closer to other defensive armaments that the original path was routed to avoid.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by ulkhf on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:12PM (#19523568)
You seem to have an unrealistic idea of how much a "drone" would cost. If you mean some lightweight slow Cessna 172 class vehicle, those are around $300K. But kind of useless in a conflict against the US.

A propeller driven MQ-9 Reaper cost over $16M in 2006.

If you mean an F-16 class vehicle capable of catching an F-35 (supersonic) and carrying half a dozen missiles, then you're in the F-16 cost range. Not having a pilot might only save a few hundred pounds.

But why use a drone to carry missiles. The US can launch missiles from Navy ships or B-52s under the control of the F-35 super AWACs.

As someone else said, the idea is not to defend against an attack by 20 drones, the idea is to blow up the drone base.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:17PM (#19524670)
> You seem to have an unrealistic idea of how much a "drone" would cost.

It depends on the role. Probably a few million at least, you're right, but when comparing to ~90 million dollar planes, comparatively cheap. The Air Force actually already has plans for this, and the F-35 makes a bit more sense in light of that, as it can help control a swarm of drones and they can take advantage of it's enhanced sensor suite.[1][2]

> If you mean an F-16 class vehicle capable of catching an F-35 (supersonic) and carrying half a dozen missiles, then you're in the F-16 cost range. Not having a pilot might only save a few hundred pounds.

Not having a pilot would save a few hundred pounds of flesh. Having a vehicle that isn't designed around a cockpit allows for a different fuselage, with a smaller cross section, which is more aerodynamic and uses less material.

That said, the drone I referenced above cruises at close to the same speed as the F-35 from the info I've seen, and at one of the articles notes that the stated cost is $2-$3 million each.[1] It's not currently specced for any air-to-air armaments, but I imagine if they see a benefit, they'll alter it as needed.

1: https://www.businessinsider.com/air-force-tests-xq-58a-valky...

2: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonmarkman/2019/03/27/killer-dr...

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by TheCoelacanth on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:39PM (#19523206)
That seems like a scenario from a video game, not a scenario from an actual battle.

Anyone who has an F-35 on-hand would have a myriad of other resources that would be more effective in dealing with a swarm of P-51s. Why not send those out instead?

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by SEJeff on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:53PM (#19525018)
Yeah just 1 patriot missile battery (land or sea based) and all 30 of those mustangs would be spiraling in.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by ben7799 on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:56AM (#19522753)
WWII era Mustangs would have no way to target a modern fighter at all unless the pilot of the modern fighter was acting like a kid playing a video game. All they could do is spray in it's general direction with a hope and a prayer. Mustangs had no targeting except the pilot's visual efforts. Human visual aiming does not work well at the speeds jet operate at most of the time. This was a huge problem by the Korean war.

The F-35 would fly by unnoticed most likely to go hit it's target. If it was noticed the F-35 would not engage the enemy fighters. The Mustang could get to ~40,000ft but wouldn't perform at it's best there, it can't travel anywhere near it's max speed at that altitude and it won't be able to maneuver very well at all. Any modern jet fighter could just sail on by even at 40,000ft without a concern.

Mustangs held about 1800 rounds of ammunition. If they were trying to "fill the sky with lead" they'd expend all their ammunition in about 30 seconds. 72,000 rounds doesn't fill that much sky either.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by stcredzero on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:55PM (#19523376)
WWII era Mustangs would have no way to target a modern fighter at all unless the pilot of the modern fighter was acting like a kid playing a video game

I think two Tuskeegee Airmen shot down German jet fighters with their guns and K-14 gyro compensated gunsights. But to get that shot, they had to be in a "furball" and they were shots of opportunity.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by ben7799 on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:42PM (#19523869)
Big difference between the first Jet fighter which was barely operational and a modern fighter.

IIRC quite a few Me-262s were shot down by P-51s. But Me-262s had a bunch of weak points and were very immature.. IIRC some of the shoot downs were when the Me-262s were taking off or landing or otherwise vulnerable.

Real life the better plane doesn't always win. P-51s would have no trouble shooting down a marine F-35 if they snuck up on it while it was trying to do a vertical takeoff or landing.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by stcredzero on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:51PM (#19523953)
IIRC some of the shoot downs were when the Me-262s were taking off or landing or otherwise vulnerable.

My understanding was that stalking the Me-262s on landing was kind of a "thing."

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by massivecali on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:23PM (#19523034)
And WW1 biplanes would travel too slow for the modern jet to engage with no heat signature for a2a missiles. I feel I saw this in a movie.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by adolph on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:57PM (#19524004)
Which makes North Korea's fleet of 1947 AN-2 biplanes a potent threat [1].

1. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/13851/north-koreas-rec...

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by lostlogin on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:05PM (#19523495)
Just flying near one would rip it to shreds.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by baseballdork on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:11PM (#19524599)
Then you shoot at it with a radar guided missile instead.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by dragonwriter on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:25PM (#19524738)
WW1 biplanes, IIRC, were mainly wood frames with cloth coverings. I imagine the radar returns are going to be minimal.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by baseballdork on Saturday March 30, 2019 @06:12PM (#19532239)
I think you'd be surprised how much of a return machine guns and radial engines will create...
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by javagram on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:36PM (#19523175)
This led me down a few google searches and I eventually found a link to a discussion of tests the British did comparing a supersonic Cold War-era jet to a WW2 fighter, the Spitfire. Very interesting https://defenceoftherealm.wordpress.com/2014/12/11/the-spitf...
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by ulkhf on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:00PM (#19523435)
How would a P-51 ever catch up to an F-35, or even see it at night or in bad weather?

Know what's a good drone? A dozen Navy SM-6s launched from a destroyer, cued by a nearly invisible F-35.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by notfromhere on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:43AM (#19522632)
planes don't dogfight, they lock-in targeting from miles away and fire missiles
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:48AM (#19522680)
Yes. But does an F-35 have 20-30 missiles? If not, then it's incapable of dealing with a swarm of 20-30 different adversaries. There's then the option to close and attempt to take out more with the built in 25mm guns, or retreat.

If attacking, it could definitely circumvent older planes (but newer drones, maybe not so much). If defending against an attacking force, it doesn't seem all that effective.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by thunderbird120 on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:08PM (#19522859)
F-35s are specifically designed to act as flying sensor and communications nodes. This means that information passed from an F-35 can be used to target missiles fired from another aircraft or even a ship. Small, cheap drones lack a lot of capability and electronic warfare disrupting long range coms is a concern. The solution the airforce wants to use is to have each F-35 control a bunch of these small, low cost drones directly. The XQ-58 Valkyrie is one such example of this type of drone[1]. It can carry 8 weapons (missiles or small bombs) totaling a maximum of 550lbs in a stealthy configuration and costs about the same as a high end cruise missile ($3-4million) so if it gets shot down it's not a big deal. These cheap drones lack expensive hardware such as high powered AESA radars. A drone swarm consisting of exclusively this kind of aircraft without an F-35 would be detected by the F-35s sensors before the F-35s swarm was detected by it. This would probably result in the total destruction of the opposing drone swarm. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XQ-58
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Saturday March 30, 2019 @12:09AM (#19527685)
> This would probably result in the total destruction of the opposing drone swarm.

My point is, at $3-4 million each (or $2-3 million as I saw in some sources, which I included in another comment here, that's still 20+ of these drones to to each F-35 in equivalent cost. So:

- Can the F-35 actually mount enough long-range weaponry to attack 22 separate targets?

- Do the drones even need to have an equivalent sensor suite in every instance? If defending, there may be ground stations with expensive sensor packages to help to coordinate. If attacking, the impetus is on the F-35 to destroy or render all units incapable of carrying our their mission. Destroying most of them and retreating without confrontation is useful only inasmuch as it prevents the attackers mission success, or lessens its impact.

That said, given the information you presented above about the F-35 being a drone coordinator, that makes it a much more useful and effective weapon in my eyes. If it can basically act as a force multiplier for the drones by providing a much more effective sensor suite, and coordinate them so it's like one large attack vehicle, then that's providing the benefits of both types while minimizing the downsides of each. For example, I would imagine an F-35 + 20 drones would be much more effective and deadly than either two F-35's or 40 drones.

In some ways, it's a lot like how Aircraft carriers worked in the beginning of or just before WWII. Having one in a battle group provided a much larger scouting range, and the ability to harass or incapacitate some types of enemy prior to the battle group arriving (they shifted more into an attack role as the war got under way, is my understanding. Prior to that there wasn't a lot of practical experience in using them in engagements).

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by hongseleco on Friday March 29, 2019 @09:35PM (#19527014)
The F-35 is the EA-35
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by uncoder0 on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:04PM (#19522823)
It's all about selecting the right tool for the job. You use the F-35's, F-22's and your long range stand off weapons from bombers to clear Surface to air threats and then use your F-15's, F-16's and F-18's which in some configurations can carry up to two dozen AA missles to clean up the low tech adversaries. If you're interested in getting a hang of how to deploy these weapons I recommend the Korean Missle Crisis scenario in Command. http://www.matrixgames.com/products/681/details/Command.Live...

Warning: Command is less of a game and more of a battlefield simulator and has a very steep learning curve if you're not used to the systems and tactics required to deploy modern combat power. I've been 'playing' it for years and without my background I'd have a very tough time. I can still only really play NATO scenarios as I'm not familiar enough with Chinese or Russian systems to use them effectively.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by yellowapple on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:52AM (#19522706)
Even assuming every single missile destroys its target, you only have so many missiles (this ain't Ace Combat where missiles magically respawn on their pylons). If each of your planes has eight missiles, but there are 10 enemy drones for each of your planes, then you're still stuck with a 2:1 dogfight.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by ben7799 on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:08PM (#19524577)
No you're not stuck with a 2:1 dogfight.

One or both adversaries can escape.. it can happen in seconds with two supersonic aircraft.

It's not like a video game where they exist in a modeled world where no one else is around and they both have unlimited fuel and radar works perfectly, etc..

If the two fighters "merge" at 600kts each and keep going they'll be 20 miles apart in 1 minute.

If one of them decides to light the afterburners and accelerates to 1000kts and go supersonic to escape the other one has to turn around and try to accelerate to catch up.

Not easy. The harder the chaser turns around the more speed they'll bleed off, and the more time it will take to reaccelerate. If they turn a wider circle they'll be further away and have more distance to make up.

Meanwhile the plane that has decided to "exit" might have flown into the cover of friend AAA/SAM sites or friendly fighters.

If you start talking about swarms of supersonic drones instead of an enemy fighter then suddenly the drones sound awfully expensive.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:25PM (#19524732)
> One or both adversaries can escape.. it can happen in seconds with two supersonic aircraft.

Which is mostly useless if the one escaping is in a defending role. Good job saving the aircraft and pilot. Unfortunately your adversary is now clear to proceed to the actual target.

In war, it doesn't just matter which soldier is better. It matters how quickly they can get to where they are going, how many of them you have to field, and whether they are defending or attacking, and whether they can be easily detected while moving. Different attributes have different values in different circumstances, but being able to field an order of magnitude or more covers up a lot of downsides.

What's more powerful, 1000 trained soldiers with combat gear and automatic rifles, or 10,000 conscripted citizens with hunting rifles? It depends on the specific circumstances.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by yellowapple on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:09PM (#19546266)
Exactly.

Even in an attacking role, if you're still able to be denied actual air superiority over your target after you run out of missiles (i.e. because you're unwilling or unable to dogfight and clean up the rest of the enemy's air assets), then congrats, mission failed, we'll get 'em next time.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by notfromhere on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:55AM (#19522738)
if said drones can't identify and position the stealth aircraft, then it doesn't really matter?
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:58AM (#19522766)
In some cases, yes. How much does stealth help you if you're defending, not attacking? Even if you can empty your payload and retreat without them discerning where you are, how many times can you do that before they've reached their target?
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by smacktoward on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:09PM (#19524083)
This was the conventional wisdom in the 1950s as well.

Which led to the huge, gun-less American fighters of the 1960s, the epitome of which was the F-4 Phantom II (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F-4_Phantom_...).

Which led to embarrassingly bad kill/loss ratios over Vietnam (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F-4_Phantom_...), when those big, porky fighters went up against smaller, more nimble, gun-still-included Russian planes like the MiG-17 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikoyan-Gurevich_MiG-17).

Which led to guns being hurriedly added back on to the F-4s, first in an external pod mounted on a hardpoint, and then internally on later production models.

Which led to the development of training programs to teach dogfighting skills like the Naval Fighter Weapons School at Miramar (the school immortalized in the 1986 film Top Gun), because it turned out that the conventional wisdom had sunk in so deeply that a whole generation of American fighter pilots didn't know how to fight with a gun, even when they had one.

Which led to the Lightweight Fighter Program (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightweight_Fighter_program), an effort to use the lessons learned in Vietnam to design a maneuverable, gun-included dogfighter affordable enough to produce in volume.

Which led to the development of two new fighters, the F-16 Fighting Falcon (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_F-16_Fighting...) and the F/A-18 Hornet (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F/A-18_Horne...), both of which have been hugely successful in service and make up the bulk of the US Air Force and Navy's fighter forces to this day.

But the people who learned those hard lessons over Vietnam are all retired or dead now, so when people say "planes don't dogfight" nobody challenges it.

Which is how the conventional wisdom of the 1950s becomes conventional wisdom all over again.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by jki275 on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:32PM (#19524282)
The only problem with that whole discussion is that nobody uses guns anymore.

The lessons of vietnam you cite really aren't as you claim. The gun was never the issue -- really poor missiles may have been. Better missiles fixed the problem, not the gun.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kaizendad on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:17PM (#19524156)
Although a significant cause of the kill ratio issue over Vietnam was restrictive rules of engagement, which prohibited beyond visual range engagement with missiles such as Sparrow, which the VPAF had no counters to whatsoever. These rules of engagement effectively required these turning dogfights, but would not have been present in a large-scale shooting war between NATO and the Warsaw Pact.

This does, of course, beg the question: how well would an F-35 do in a conflict with restrictive rules of engagement, such as might be found in future US-Iraq/Afghanistan-style conflicts.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by smacktoward on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:32PM (#19524290)
Well, Sparrow had problems of its own, namely absolutely dismal reliability and the need to maintain continuous radar lock on the target during the missile's entire flight time (e.g. no "fire and forget" capability). But that doesn't invalidate your broader point about dogfights being more likely under restrictive RoE.

The thing is though, if history is any indication, wars so total as to have completely permissive RoEs aren't the wars that we actually ever fight. Even if you imagine a war with a full-on peer competitor like Russia or China, it's not hard to imagine scenarios where RoEs are restricted in an effort to keep the scope of the conflict from widening -- an important consideration when both sides have nuclear weapons!

So I think the general point still stands. If the balloon ever goes up on World War III, we probably won't see a lot of dogfighting. But there's a whole spectrum of conflicts underneath that, and building an air force entirely around fighters that can't handle the rest of that spectrum at least competently is going to be a problem.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by openasocket on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:00PM (#19524512)
Also consider the massive improvements in avionics since Vietnam. You don't have to close to visual range anymore to confirm the target is a jet fighter and not a passenger plane.
Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by mikepurvis on Friday March 29, 2019 @11:57AM (#19522763)
The F-35 is the star destroyer in this analogy— it's got six missiles onboard, intended for taking out huge targets from far away. Star destroyers fared really badly against a large number of smaller fighters.

So the argument is that a small number of high performance fighters like the F-35 could very well not be a good match for a huge number of drones that individually are a fraction of the price.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by leetcrew on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:40PM (#19523220)
since we're making arguments by analogy to star wars, it's worth pointing out that, in universe, it is mainly just xwings that are surprisingly effective against star destroyers. they are too small to be effectively targeted by the larger ships guns, but the only reason they are actually a threat is because each craft carries a small number of proton torpedoes, basically the equivalent of a low-yield tactical nuke IRL. the primary fighter armament (lasers) is essentially harmless to such a large ship deployed in any reasonable number.

the analogy sort of breaks down at this point.

Re:F-35's Towed Decoys by kbenson on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:02PM (#19524522)
Well, you can take the analogy right back to where it came from, WWII and planes as an effective countermeasure to ships. Small cheap planes could carry armaments still very devastating to larger ships.[1]

It's not entirely analogous to the current discussion, because there's not really a commensurate difference in maneuverability of F-35 to the drones, but other similarities persist.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grumman_TBF_Avenger