News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by tc on Monday November 29, 2010 @05:32PM (#1952094)
"On November 22, after being informed by Comcast that its demand for payment was 'take it or leave it,' Level 3 agreed to the terms, under protest, in order to ensure customers did not experience any disruptions."

Leave it. Level3 set a terrible precedent here by paying the shakedown money. Even with their subsequent complaints, they've now put Comcast in a much better position by implicitly acknowledging (whether true or not) that Comcast brings more value to the table by providing access to its subscriber base than content-providers bring to the table by supplying content to subscribers.

Like the old Churchill story goes, "now we're just negotiating the price."

(See PS #4 below for a more benign interpretation.)

--

PS #1: Yes, of course it might have been expensive for them to play hardball here, with respect to the short-term harm it might cause their customers. That's exactly the point. By acknowledging that the harm to Comcast would be lower (which I actually doubt), they've significantly strengthened Comcast's position against other carriers and perhaps even with regulators.

PS #2: Game theory would suggest that it's critical for Netflix to repel this assault now, even at the cost of short term pain. Once this precedence is established, Comcast will be able to extract nearly all of the profit from Netflix sales to Comcast customers. Each time Comcast raises the toll, it would be in Netflix's rational self interest to go along so long as they are still making some net profit on the channel (modulo opportunity costs and whatnot).

PS #3: It's not uncommon for carriers to play hardball. The big Tier 1's have been trying to prevent the ascension of Cogent into their club for years, which (along with Cogent's aggressiveness) resulted in some nasty peering dispute stalemates in 2005 (with Level3) and 2008 (with Sprint), each time "breaking the internet."

PS #4: It's also possible that Level3 is representing this as a net neutrality issue when in reality it's just a peering dispute. Traditionally local ISPs have had to pay for transit across the networks of the big carriers. When a local ISP becomes a large regional or national one (Comcast), they have enough leverage to extract no-charge ("settlement-free") peering agreements with most of the major carriers. This is probably the first case, though, of a cable-company ISP becoming large enough to extract transit fees from a big international carrier. That's noteworthy, but if it is content-neutral, it's still the way the internet has always worked.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by ghshephard on Monday November 29, 2010 @09:12PM (#1952753)
I don't think I've ever seen anyone cherry-pick various points from other posts without attribution before. Anything wrong with responding in the the thread instead of constantly updating your post with other people's (including mine) comments?

Editing a post is typically for the purpose of fixing typos, making your (own) thoughts more concise or clear.

It's not for the wholesale amalgamation of other people's posts, as useful a function as you think you might be serving.

Let your original post stand on its own merit, or don't post it.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by tc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:46AM (#1953465)
This was simply a case of simultaneous editing. I saw your comments only after writing the substance of my updates (and in the case of wmf's comments, only because of this meta-point). I don't want anyone to think that your comments were copied from mine, though, so I'm sorry if it might otherwise appear that way.

I've operated an ISP, and I'm deeply familiar with the issues involved here. I posted my main comment quickly and updated it as I thought more deeply about the press release. To my mind, a legitimate use of the editing feature is to improve a comment upon reflection.

Again, I want it to be clear on the thread that I'm comfortable that your (and wmf's) comments weren't copied from mine, but neither is your accusation fair. I expect that we've all simply worked in or around the same industry and have seen similar things.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by wmf on Monday November 29, 2010 @09:33PM (#1952798)
He's at the top of the thread, so those other comments will appear to be duplicates of his post. :-/
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by ghshephard on Monday November 29, 2010 @10:54PM (#1953007)
Agreed. I recognized " This is probably the first case, though, of a cable-company ISP becoming large enough to extract transit fees from a big international carrier. " as being _your_ comment. The thing is - I learned that from _you_. So I'd kind of like to remember who I can trust to provide useful insight into these topics.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by mwcremer on Monday November 29, 2010 @05:39PM (#1952118)
Unless Level 3 had commits to their customers (e.g. NetFlix), in which case it could be very expensive to drop Comcast users.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by run4yourlives on Monday November 29, 2010 @06:00PM (#1952206)
It's pretty easy to change internet providers when you suddenly lose netflix. They should have called Comcast's bluff.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by irons on Monday November 29, 2010 @06:23PM (#1952271)
Oh really?

The Comcast alternatives in Seattle are Qwest's elderly DSL, and Clearwire Wimax which can struggle to get over 1mbps. Compared to a lot of US cities, even those options look good. High-speed internet service in the US does not resemble a functioning market.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by Groxx on Monday November 29, 2010 @07:12PM (#1952445)
Only AT&T provided non-dialup access where I live, until (apparently) very recently when RoadRunner finally ran wires.

Swapping's not easy. I do work and research online - dialup isn't an option. I'm a student - pricier cell-based solutions aren't an option. I do a bit of gaming - ping time matters.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by amock on Monday November 29, 2010 @11:46PM (#1953115)
There are also a couple of very small providers who provide really cheap fast connections. If you have access to one of them you can get either 30Mbps symmetric for $40/month or 100Mbps symmetric for $60/month. Hopefully more of these will spring up if the bigger players don't change their ways.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by dedward on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:39AM (#1954190)
Those smaller providers will be paying for transit with someone larger, no?
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by amock on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @01:54PM (#1955152)
Yes, but I think that since the wholesale bandwidth market is more competitive it won't be as much of a problem.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by run4yourlives on Monday November 29, 2010 @07:01PM (#1952414)
But Quest is an option, as is Verizon and Earthlink.

The fact that Comcast may be the best option and the market state aren't the points I'm arguing.

Would you stay Comcast if it meant losing Netflix? I bet many times the answer is no.

I'm not arguing that it's a wonderful thing to you, I'm arguing that by pissing you off, you'll be much more likely to act.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by irons on Monday November 29, 2010 @08:49PM (#1952711)
Would you stay Comcast if it meant losing Netflix? I bet many times the answer is no.

Anyone in my area code switching to Qwest for Netflix will be disappointed. Friends a few blocks away with DSL can't finish a streamed program without dropouts and rebuffering. AT&T delivers better service to my phone. The "pretty easy" option you alluded to entails moving out of the city to one of the suburbs with FiOS.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by alttab on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:04AM (#1954090)
How crap, I haven't heard anyone say Earthlink in years. Next thing you know someone busts out Sprynet.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by brfox on Monday November 29, 2010 @11:18PM (#1953055)
I watch 1 hr of Netflix every evening in Seattle with Qwest and it is very reliable.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by qeorge on Monday November 29, 2010 @06:02PM (#1952213)
He's referring to NetFlix being a customer of Level3, not the end user being a customer of Comcast. NetFlix uses enough bandwidth that they'd have direct deals with Tier 1 providers like Level3.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by run4yourlives on Monday November 29, 2010 @06:05PM (#1952226)
I get that, but Netflix and Level3 not only just signed a major agreement, they have similar interests.

Level3 should have attempted to sign Netflix up for this fight and point the issue squarely at the consumer.. A big "You can't get Netflix because you are on Comcast" or "It now costs you $20 a movie because you are on Comcast" frames the battle back into Level3's favor.

All they did by backing down was show Comcast that they will back down when challenged again. You beat a bully by fighting him.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by dedward on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @09:41AM (#1954195)
That creates a real net neutrality issue, wheras the simple issue of rather imbalanced peers doesn't.

Free peering only works, and is only reasonably fair as long as traffis is, on average, about equal. If one network is really genreating 5x the traffic of another, why would the smaller one take the hit fo free?

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by ams6110 on Monday November 29, 2010 @07:35PM (#1952511)
Not for everyone. My options are Comcast, or dial-up.
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by 10smom on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @12:28AM (#1953203)
very limited in choices in "Small Town" USA when it comes to ISP
Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by mmaunder on Monday November 29, 2010 @07:53PM (#1952565)
On the peering front, interesting case study is MWeb, an ISP in South Africa. They have the opposite problem in that they recently refused to continue to pay other ISP's in the country for the right to peer with them. So all local traffic to and from their network is routed internationally since they have their own international links.

http://bit.ly/b8Bslu

Framing the argument as a peering dispute is an interesting strategy. But I think the differentiator is that if peering is not allowed, there is no alternative route to the customer. Whereas if it were a traditional peering dispute, the quality of the service would degrade with longer routes rather than be terminated altogether.

Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ... by ghshephard on Monday November 29, 2010 @09:03PM (#1952738)
"Whereas if it were a traditional peering dispute, the quality of the service would degrade with longer routes rather than be terminated altogether. "

Nope, if a pair of Tier-1 Providers De-peer, their customers can't communicate to each other unless the new intermediary receives some form of settlement. They won't do it for free.

See: http://www.renesys.com/tech/presentations/pdf/nanog43-peerin... for an example of this.