Re:Comcast demands Level 3 pay fee to deliver online movies ...
by ghshephard on Monday November 29, 2010 @09:03PM
(#1952738)
"Whereas if it were a traditional peering dispute, the quality of the service would degrade with longer routes rather than be terminated altogether.
"
Nope, if a pair of Tier-1 Providers De-peer, their customers can't communicate to each other unless the new intermediary receives some form of settlement. They won't do it for free.
See: http://www.renesys.com/tech/presentations/pdf/nanog43-peerin... for an example of this.
http://bit.ly/b8Bslu
Framing the argument as a peering dispute is an interesting strategy. But I think the differentiator is that if peering is not allowed, there is no alternative route to the customer. Whereas if it were a traditional peering dispute, the quality of the service would degrade with longer routes rather than be terminated altogether.