News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by laurencei on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:32PM (#19518646)
If you put a popular device, with a medical detection tool into the wider population, it would be logical that the device would pick up on patients who would other not notice the symptoms (at least initially, if any).

So then the question becomes what other daily device(s) could be made to do automatic health checks of certain specific indicators, which would give an early indication to the possible condition, thus improving life expectancy and quality of life, while lowering associated medical costs.

i.e. toothbrushes that detect cavities, sunglasses that check your pupils for certain symptoms, hats that monitor your EEG. These are obviously extreme examples, but you get the idea...

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by barry-cotter on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:50PM (#19519027)
This will lead to a massive increase in false positives, unnecessary treatment and worry; par for the course for precautionary screening and preventive medicine generally.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/29/upshot/preventive-health-...

> Preventive Care Saves Money? Sorry, It’s Too Good to Be True

> The idea that spending more on preventive care will reduce overall health care spending is widely believed and often promoted as a reason to support reform. It’s thought that too many people with chronic illnesses wait until they are truly ill before seeking care, often in emergency rooms, where it costs more. It should follow then that treating diseases earlier, or screening for them before they become more serious, would wind up saving money in the long run.

> Unfortunately, almost none of this is true.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by ultraluminous on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:22AM (#19519560)
Pretty much the entirety of the article you're selectively quoting is praising preventative care.

The byline is "Contrary to conventional wisdom, it tends to cost money, but it improves quality of life at a very reasonable price."

and the article closes with this

But money doesn’t have to be saved to make something worthwhile. Prevention improves outcomes. It makes people healthier. It improves quality of life. It often does so for a very reasonable price.

There are many good arguments for increasing our focus on prevention. Almost all have to do with improving quality, though, not reducing spending. We would do well to admit that and move forward.

Sometimes good things cost money.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by barry-cotter on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:04AM (#19519715)
I’m not arguing over affect, I’m arguing over truth claims. The article leads with the facts and then argues that despite being a poor use of money we should still pay for preventive medicine for the warm fuzzy feelings it gives us. Pay attention to the facts, not the argument that we should ignore the facts for the warm fuzzy feelings.

If we’re going to spend huge amounts of money we should spend it better than on preventive care, on areas where the money can do more good. That money could be spent on foreign aid, on saving lives, not improving them, on earned income tax credit, to encourage people to get back into work or gain more work experience, on basic research or subsidy to get us to carbon neutral faster.

And the article completely fails to note the false positives, the unnecessary tests and the worry caused by preventive screening.

Money spent on preventive medicine isn’t wasted but it could certainly be better spent.

> In 2009, as part of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Synthesis Project, Sarah Goodell, Joshua Cohen and Peter Neumann exhaustively explored the evidence. They examined more than 500 peer-reviewed studies that looked at primary (stopping something from happening in the first place) or secondary (stopping something from getting worse) prevention. Of all the interventions they looked at, only two were truly cost-saving: childhood immunizations (a no-brainer) and the counseling of adults on the use of low-dose aspirin. An additional 15 preventive services were cost-effective, meaning that they cost less than $50,000 to $100,000 per quality adjusted life-year gained.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by sgift on Friday March 29, 2019 @04:11AM (#19519936)
> I’m not arguing over affect, I’m arguing over truth claims. The article leads with the facts and then argues that despite being a poor use of money we should still pay for preventive medicine for the warm fuzzy feelings it gives us. Pay attention to the facts, not the argument that we should ignore the facts for the warm fuzzy feelings.

That's a very disingenuous summary born out of a "economics trump everything" mentality. If you believe that humans are more important than money it is wrong and the original articles byline is a better summary:

Contrary to conventional wisdom, it tends to cost money, but it improves quality of life at a very reasonable price.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by barry-cotter on Friday March 29, 2019 @04:37AM (#19520020)
Humans are more important than money; that’s why we should spend the money on saving human lives in the developing world, not making the lives of already healthy, wealthy first world inhabitants slightly more comfortable, why we should spend it on investments in the future not hideously wasteful consumption in the present. If we’re going to spend the money that inefficiently give people a tax cut instead. There are many better ways to spend the money than a tax cut but preventive health care isn’t it.

If we want to improve health outcomes we could do many things more effective than increasing preventive care. Nurse practitioners cost half as much as doctors and are just as effective at primary care. That’s a genuine huge bang for the buck intervention that could be done and isn’t. Never mind preventive medicine. Do something that actually works instead.

Primary Care Outcomes in Patients Treated by Nurse Practitioners or Physicians: A Randomized Trial. JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association. 283. 59-68. 10.1097/00132586-200012000-00026.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by joosters on Friday March 29, 2019 @05:30AM (#19520197)
There's a great (and short) video suggesting why it's not a good idea to run as many medical tests as possible, and it's not because of the cost:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7kQk9-KLPfU

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by DoreenMichele on Friday March 29, 2019 @03:09AM (#19519730)
Funny, that doesn't remotely fit with my experience.

I estimate I'm saving between $200k and $500k annually by doing things like eating right and getting enough exercise.

Well, TBF, that's really for two people eating right etc. I, personally, am probably saving only half that.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by aiyodev on Friday March 29, 2019 @02:25AM (#19519570)
It's a trolley problem but I believe we should always choose information over ignorance even if it results in greater harm.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by dwhit on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:42PM (#19518699)
A toilet that monitored urine and stool samples would be a major lifesaver.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by tejtm on Friday March 29, 2019 @04:29AM (#19519994)
Continuing the ancient tradition of plumbers saving more lives than doctors (without even needing a Hippocratic oath).
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by brianpgordon on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:00AM (#19519261)
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by robbomacrae on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:07PM (#19518821)
Toilabs. Just started out doing just that.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by peteretep on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:29PM (#19518926)
This strikes me as an exceptionally difficult problem to solve. I'll be impressed if someone brings a workable solution to market in any reasonable time-frame. I guess if you can retrain people in how they use their toilet, you might be able to simplify some of the challenges, but many people use their toilet as a generalized soft/liquid garbage can.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by henvic on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:34PM (#19518958)
Hopefully not a Theranos lol

What if on major airports (or other similar venues) there were paid toilets where you could do whatever business you want to do there and exit, only to receive a test result later on if something weird showed up?

Could this be doable?

Perhaps by taking a photo of the solid & liquid expelled from your body and trying to eliminate or reduce water contamination from the solid parts, and collecting it as you usually do in a lab?

Sorry if this all sounds stupid. My experience with biology is close to zero, and I have no clue about what I'm talking about — just thinking out loud.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by paul7986 on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:36AM (#19519187)
Well that’s just it the UX of using a toilet would remain the same and the smart toilet wpuld collect the sample(as a toilet does now)/analyze it and send the data if it detects irregularities to your doctor. He/she then analyzes it and schedules a follow up appointment if needed.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by peteretep on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:42AM (#19519205)
Keeping the user experience the same — I suspect — will be excessively difficult
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by paul7986 on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:44AM (#19519211)
How so you use the toilet as you always would and everything is done automatically by the smart toilet.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by peteretep on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:22AM (#19519349)
Right, I also want a machine that magically makes me lose weight while I sleep, while not affecting my sleep and costing $5 ... that doesn’t mean it’s mechanically or physically possible with current technology though.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by wiggler00m on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:48PM (#19519013)
A startup in Japan is building this.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by electricslpnsld on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:30PM (#19518929)
> A toilet that monitored urine and stool samples

The nation of Germany?

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by gonzo41 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:38PM (#19518682)
I've read about automated phone calls to the elderly to build up data on response times. It was a dementia early detection tool. Seemed to be a pretty smart approach just to ring the home phone or mobile and ask for them to say a word. Takes no time.an requires recall and cognition. Also confirms the old person isn't dead.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by Latteland on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:46AM (#19519446)
Would you like this if you were an old person (maybe any person)? Faceless machine bugs you at home (were you napping?), rates you and you can't speak to a human about it.

No one would like this. It is an interesting idea.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by w-ll on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:07PM (#19518819)
I think this is an interesting idea, but it also reminds me of this youtube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=760uy8Oa_XM

The lady complains but I think she enjoins it. It's fun to complain and be heard, even if it seams minuscule annoyances to any observer.

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by jchw on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:54AM (#19519469)
As someone who suffers from a bit of health anxiety: let's at least be very careful about false positives and inaccurate tests. The mere suggestion of health issues have sent me down spirals before.
Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by dehrmann on Friday March 29, 2019 @01:54AM (#19519471)
> thus improving life expectancy and quality of life, while lowering associated medical costs

Be careful with this. Look into the result of increase PSA testing:

> Although experts are somewhat split on the value of PSA tests as a screening tool, there is widespread agreement on two major points: overdiagnosis and overtreatment rates are far too high, and there is an urgent need to refine PSA testing to be a more effective screening tool. [1]

Or mammograms

> We conclude that the mammography FP rate in North America is in excess... [2]

Arguably, the issue is that we just lack good baseline data, but you have to consider all the false positives you'll get with more data collection.

[1]: https://www.health.harvard.edu/healthbeat/the-pros-and-cons-...

[2]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5124917/

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by paul7986 on Friday March 29, 2019 @12:29AM (#19519161)
What about the toilet ... can feces/specimen data be used to catch health issues early on? I know urine can.

The Smart toilet idea has been parodied a lot though and none exist as far as I know. Maybe it’s just not feasible?

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by azhenley on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:06PM (#19518811)
This is indeed an awesome area that I’ve barely ever considered. If I had to go do another PhD, it might be in this. I’ve seen research about using cell phones to detect drug use (and try to prevent the urge).

What other everyday objects could be utilized? What about my phone’s front facing camera to scan my face looking for muscle twitches or eye issues?

Re:I Now Have a Cardiologist by ordinaryradical on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:48PM (#19518728)
This take on wearables is way more exciting to me than AR. Unmediated reality and good health sounds like a much better future than the alternatives.