So, like Google Plus. Except that an "open" publishing tool is at least more useful than an entirely proprietary one! Let's face it, Google dropped the ball here.
Google Plus never had an API for incoming content.
Buzz allowed one-click connection to Twitter. Great idea, but people would use it to publish straight from Twitter, and wouldn't engage on the Buzz platform.
This was a terrible experience - you'd miss the conversational aspect of Twitter, and be ignored if you tried to have conversations on Buzz.
Google dropped the ball here.
Maybe, but it isn't clear to me what they should have done differently.
This comes with the territory of having a fledging social network - it's not "terrible" if it's good enough for users. You grow from there by encouraging some niche communities to congregate using your system, that's how true "engagement" can start. Even Facebook itself grew from a very small community, namely students at a particular college, then college students more generally.
The problem was that the product was working as designed - it was the importing of external feed that was both the key feature and the problem.
It might have worked if two-way-comment feeds were a thing. But there is no reason why Twitter would want to implement that.
This almost became a problem on Mastodon with Twitter crossposters. Enough people pushed back hard to keep them from taking over timelines. People still use them, but they generally engage on both sides now.
Not sure what "too smart for its own good" means exactly. It was a pretty vanilla feed, with no fancy features.
This narrative misses a lot. The most important part was the purchase of FriendFeed by Facebook and the failure of Google Buzz (the more open predecessor to Plus).
The narrative I've heard is more like this (It goes back over 10 years, so the context is much different. Google was much smaller, and there were many doubters about Facebook).
Facebook was founded in 2004
By 2007 it was clear that social networks were a thing, but there was a very strong feeling among technologists that they should be more open.
During 2007 a bunch of pretty well credentialed Googlers left to start a more open social network called FriendFeed. This aggregated open sources of content from all over the web.
This worked fairly well technically, and people at Google were generally supportive of it (there were many Googlers on the service, and they were actively working on things like PubSubHub[1] to make open aggregation services work well.
However by 2009 it was clear it FriendFeed had product issues. It was being used just as a republishing tool (primarily from Twitter) and they ended up selling to Facebook.
This upset a number of people at Google, who were relying on it to create an open alternative. These people were involved in the creation of the (mostly forgotten) Google Buzz[2], which was basically a clone of FriendFeed.
Buzz failed as a consumer product, so then Google attempted the pivot to Google Plus.
[1] https://github.com/pubsubhubbub/PubSubHubbub
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Buzz