News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by piokoch on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:48AM (#19512685)
I am not sure I understand the way Fair Housing Act is enforced. Facebook allows ads targeting. This is how it earns money. Apparently some people decided that they want to advertise houses to white Christians population, which is illegal in the USA - shouldn't be HUD after those who configured such criteria, not Facebook?

Facebook provided only a tool. Nobody is after hardware store because a hammer bought there was used to kill someone.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by mastax on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:10AM (#19512938)
42 U.S. Code § 3604.

...it shall be unlawful—

(c) To make, print, or publish, or cause to be made, printed, or published any notice, statement, or advertisement, with respect to the sale or rental of a dwelling that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap,familial status, or national origin, or an intention to make any such preference, limitation, or discrimination.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:16AM (#19513003)
Yep.

>or cause to be made...

Key words here.

Sure, the government should be going after individual advertisers too, but selective prosecution or not, Facebook is clearly in violation.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by syntheticcdo on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:22AM (#19513078)
Exactly, and the net effect of a single action against Facebook is greater than hundreds of actions against individual discriminatory landlords.Facebook can clean up it's act and prevent (to the best of its ability) legally discriminatory ads, which would deal a huge blow to those individuals who would have committed future discrimination.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by randyrand on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:31PM (#19513791)
How did Facebook cause this to be made? The wording implies that it's meant to address the administrators that demanded such an ad be made. The ones who decided to make it. Who caused it to be made.

Facebook is just the hardware store in this sense. They provide tools. And you make the billboard. They did not cause this to be made.

edit: They still may be responsible for publishing it, which is illegal. I would think its a much better argument to go after them for that then the 'cause' to be made' argument.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by kyrra on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:35PM (#19513848)
It's really an argument of platform vs publisher. Google, Facebook, and others have been treated as platforms (it's really what the DMCA protected). But as they have been grown larger, governments want to treat them more like publishers and hold them accountable for the content that they put on their site (treating them more like publishers).
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by notyourday on Friday March 29, 2019 @07:22AM (#19520645)
It seems to me that Facebook, Google, Twitter, etc all want to be treated like a publisher -- they keep making publisher like decisions on who can and who cannot use their platform in whatever way that they decide.

Sort of like CBS or Fox can and do decide what kind of ads they would or they would not air.

I think Facebook/Google/Twitter/etc are going to find out that by being a publisher one has to actually act as a publisher all the time and not just when it is convenient.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:38PM (#19514566)
Probably some truth to that.

Also likely the reason you'll start to see a shift over time in Facebook and Google's business models. They won't just allow any old thing on their servers any more.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by munk-a on Thursday March 28, 2019 @04:38PM (#19516357)
Providing the tools to specifically do terrible things makes you liable.

This comes up rather often but the "disruptor economy" style business that try and replace existing things that are burdened by regulations and other boring things with shiny new things with Vue, rounded corners, blinking lights and a lack of those regulations are, in fact, totally responsible for their failure to adhere to those regulations.

I feel like D&D and friends are ultimately partially to blame here, and their long (and wonderful, I'm not knocking table top RPGs) history of encouraging pedantic rules lawyering. The US legal code isn't like a tabletop RPG where if nothing specifically says your Thri-Kreen can't quadra-wield bastard swords with monkey grip then go ahead - when laws fail to specifically address situations then the courts are present to try and sanely interpret the intent of the original law and apply it to the new situation.

That's sort of like how murder is illegal, instead of it being illegal to hit someone on the head with a garbage can, hit someone on the head with a tire iron, hit someone on the head with a crow bar... "Murder" isn't an action you can take without a lot of abstract assumptions.

So perhaps Facebook is like a hardware store that sells the...

  Burgler Bundle - a complete set of a ski-mask, crow bar, knife and lockpick set
  (do note "Burgler Bundles" are not intended for burglery, theft, larceny
  or other crimes, by purchasing the markers of the "Burgler Bundle"
  are hereby absolved of responsibility for any law breaking committed)
Trying to manufacture or sell that in the store would probably get you arrested (unless done in a valid parody form I guess?) similarly Facebook set up tools here to make it absolutely trivial to break some laws "Oh but we didn't realize we were breaking any laws officer" - welp, that's why newspapers and such have legal departments that review ads being placed in them, skipping that step to save money doesn't absolve you from guilt.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by tantalor on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:52PM (#19514046)
> They provide tools. And you make the billboard.

Facebook caused the advertisements to not show for protected groups. The "tools" ran on their servers, not yours, so they are responsible for the outcome.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by Sebguer on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:35PM (#19513846)
Facebook likely restricts and prevents other kinds of illegal ads. Why shouldn't they be responsible for restricting and preventing this kind of illegal ad?
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by rock_hard on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:48PM (#19513983)
It's unreasonable to require a private company to do the governments job of policing and enforcing laws.

Nobody would consider forcing hammer manufactures to police their customers not to hurt people with said hammers either

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by Sebguer on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:52PM (#19514044)
This is a nonsensical comparison. Facebook is the party that is serving these ads, using their own proprietary methodology for targeting. It's not like these consumers are printing fliers and distributing them on their own. Everything that is happening is happening 'within Facebook's house' so-to-speak.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by redwall_hp on Thursday March 28, 2019 @04:12PM (#19516115)
Facebook isn't manufacturing hammers. They're offering their hammering services. If you say "sure, we'll hammer some people for the right price," you're offering illegal hitman services.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by dsr_ on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:04PM (#19514175)
It's unreasonable to not require a private company to adhere to the law. If you sell hammers, they must meet the laws about hammers, tools, and general goods. If the hammer is unfit for purpose -- say, because the heads are not firmly attached and a user might unwittingly hurt themselves -- that's the company's fault.

If the ad selection tools are unfit for purpose -- say because it allows a user to target/untarget recipients in a blatantly illegal manner -- that's the company's fault.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by moate on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:06PM (#19514191)
Fine, it's not their job to police the law. However, every time they break the law by publishing one of these ads, HUD fines them if they're caught. It's illegal to publish the ad, not just create it. They can't host illegal ads on their site.

Can we agree to this compromise?

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by scarface74 on Friday March 29, 2019 @07:33PM (#19526502)
There have always been specific laws governing what publishers could publish when it came to real estate and employment.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by jlmorton on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:34PM (#19513834)
The point is that it doesn't matter whether Facebook was involved in the creation of the ads, whether they support the ads, or anything else. They have a duty not to allow their platform to be used in this way, and until recently, they were failing to do that.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by randyrand on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:36PM (#19513857)
Maybe. Or maybe not. Can you find/cite the law that requires that?

edit: ah. tunnel vision. yes the other parts of the statute would cover FB as partially culpable here. particularly the 'publish' part.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by ams6110 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:42PM (#19513920)
It's right above in this subthread.

"To make, print, or publish, or cause to be made, printed, or published"

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by will_brown on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:21AM (#19513067)
>Sure, the government should be going after individual advertisers too

They probably will.

But in this instance it’s much more appropriate the end FBs illegal business practices, rather than continuing to go after ad creators in perpetuity. Turn off the water and fix the leak instead of catching the drops, similar theory to local police flipping low level drug dealers to go after the suppliers.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by kyrieeschaton on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:31AM (#19513172)
None of which is actually alleged. The allegation is that FB allowed ad targeting, not that they allowed ads that "indicated a preference... or an intention to make any such preference". It's classic regulatory overreach over the course of 50 years, from disallowing ads that explicitly forbid blacks, to forbidding advertising in venues that haven't paid their diversity tax.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by jakelazaroff on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:51AM (#19513377)
Targeting an ad specifically to avoid certain races indicates your intention to make such a preference. You're just telling Facebook you don't want those races rather than putting it in the actual ad text.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by kyrieeschaton on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:36PM (#19513859)
I forgot, legally you're supposed to take the upsell on your ad package so you can target based on a love of kayaking and golden retrievers. (This is what I mean by "diversity tax".)
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by legohead on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:03AM (#19512843)
Facebook doesn't have to allow you to target demographics. If you create an ad, mark it as type "housing", then things like race and wealth shouldn't be an option to target. It's illegal.

Using your analogy, when you buy a hammer you don't tell the cashier it's for murder.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bluedino on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:12AM (#19512956)
You're targeting a demographic with every type of ad. Sure, the radio station doesn't have checkboxes of who hears your ad, you just pick the radio station you want your target to be listening too.

Same goes for billboards. Suburbs? Subway? The highway 2 towns over?

Print media, TV time...the list goes on.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by whatok on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:21AM (#19513064)
The sticking point is that those advertisements are made to the public and everyone has relatively the same equal access to them. Targeted advertisements through social media completely remove any semblance of equal access.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:18AM (#19513030)
Well, they're free to litigate that question if they think it will help them. That's the beauty of our legal system.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by enraged_camel on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:55PM (#19514081)
You are looking at it from the wrong perspective. Laws don't have to be perfect. But they have to be enforceable.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by tzs on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:08PM (#19516620)
As far as I can see neither Federal fair housing rules nor any state fair housing rules would cover wealth. Federal covers race, color, religion, national origin, sex, family status, and disability. Many states add more categories to those protected classes.

13 states (California, Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Oregon, Utah, Vermont, and Wisconsin) and DC consider "source of income" a basis for a protected class, and so you probably couldn't target ads in those states based on that, but I don't see anything that would cover wealth level rather than wealth source.

(Neat site with a nice way to look up which state protects what [1])

Since you can have a wealth requirement for renting (e.g., you can require that the person be able to afford the rent), there wouldn't be much point in prohibiting targeting based on that.

[1] http://lawatlas.org/datasets/state-fair-housing-protections-...

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by notacoward on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:14AM (#19512971)
> shouldn't be HUD after those who configured such criteria, not Facebook?

Indeed they should. This is basically like going after the phone company because somebody else was using number prefixes as a proxy for race. Even though this is a fundamental property of any system that doesn't explicitly preclude such targeting, Facebook already took steps to limit this type of discrimination in ads for housing or credit. That was good enough for the ACLU, Fair Housing Alliance, and others who have a sincere interest in the matter. It should have been good enough for HUD too, which brings us to the real crux of the matter.

Sufficiency of the new limits on targeting was not the sticking point between Facebook and HUD. The sticking point was HUD's demand for all user data, without any safeguards. It's a fishing expedition. What would HUD do with that data? It's not a stretch to believe they'd use it to further this administration's own discriminatory agenda. HUD is not fighting against discrimination at all. They're on the other side of that battle. Rejecting their demand was IMO the right thing to do.

[dead]
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by notacoward on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:16PM (#19513634)
Are you seriously trying to argue that an administration focused on border walls, ICE raids and entrapment, de-funding minority focused programs[1], and providing inspiration for racist killers around the world doesn't have a discriminatory agenda? Because that's just sea-lioning and I don't have any patience for it.

[1] https://thehill.com/policy/finance/334768-here-are-the-66-pr...

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by techntoke on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:56AM (#19512767)
I guess you don't remember Backpage getting taken down?

Facebook creates the market for these types of targeted advertising to exist, and they should have at least a basic understanding of the laws and not permit companies to advertise to certain demographics when it would be in clear violation of the law.

That's like saying, oh we were too oblivious to understand how the platform we created could be used while we still profited significantly from our mistakes in the meantime.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by thinkingkong on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:00AM (#19512816)
Yeah and Ill argue that in todays current environment thats the “correct” business decision because thats how all the forces line up to push you.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by reaperducer on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:08AM (#19512908)
Facebook provided only a tool. Nobody is after hardware store because a hammer bought there was used to kill someone.

Your analogy is faulty.

People, governments, and law enforcement agencies go after gun stores that sell guns that are used to kill people.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by empath75 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:28AM (#19513139)
They're actually not allowed to do that unless the sale was illegal.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by reaperducer on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:53AM (#19513397)
It depends on how you define "allowed." Gun stores are pressured out of business and zoned into extinction all the time. There's a reason people from Chicago go to Indiana to buy guns.

Also, note the "kill people" phrase in the message you're responding to, and the context of this conversation: committing crimes.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by mcguire on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:53AM (#19513401)
They're specifically not allowed to do that because the gun manufacturing and sales industry's lobby realized it would essentially kill gun sales.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by CompanionCuuube on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:54PM (#19515923)
Yes, that would be the consequence of allowing frivolous lawsuits to be brought against companies simply because you don't like the product.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by SkyBelow on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:34AM (#19513206)
>Nobody is after hardware store because a hammer bought there was used to kill someone.

s/hammer/gun/ and you'll find some who are. Not agreeing or disagreeing, only raising the point that some people do seem to judge different tools by different standards based on some criteria that is not immediately visible/available to me.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by jdavis703 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:00AM (#19512824)
These platforms can be overrun by a majority of discriminatory ads. I remember using Craigslist about a decade ago to rent housing in Virginia. Over half the ads easily contained some kind of gender, age, family or religious discrimination (interestingly enough I never saw an ad that explicitly listed race, I suspect that is because explicit racial discrimination is so taboo people used more implicit means of discrimination).
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:04AM (#19512859)
>interestingly enough I never saw an ad that explicitly listed race...

???

That must've just been Virginia? Where I lived in Houston, they listed unacceptable races all the time. (I suppose they didn't have to though, it was always the same two races listed.)

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by briandear on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:12PM (#19513601)
> Where I lived in Houston, they listed unacceptable races all the time.

Definitely going to need a citation for this. I grew up in Houston and never saw an add specifying "unacceptable races" -- perhaps 50+ years ago maybe. My parents were in the rental business and we spent a lot of time looking at (and placing) ads -- never was race listed on an ad that I've ever seen for as long as I can remember (since the mid 1980s.) That doesn't mean it didn't happen, but there'll need to be some proof that the practice was widespread or common if you're to come on a forum and essentially libel a city as racist.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 28, 2019 @02:02PM (#19514827)
Woah.

Calm down guy.

The original comment was saying that, in Virginia, ...CRAIGSLIST... would not openly mention the desired or unacceptable races for rentals. My only point was that, again, CRAIGSLIST ads certainly did have desired or unacceptable races listed in Houston.

The fact is it's happened in Houston Craigslist, just as it's happened in Craigslist in lots of other places in the nation. There was a class action, as well as several individual lawsuits, filed. My memory is hazy, but I believe Craigslist prevailed in all of this on the fact that they were acting only as a provider of publishing services and not a publisher themselves??? (Not really sure about Craigslist winning, but I seem to remember that they did. In any case, it's easily Google-able if you're really that curious as to whether or not all of this really happened.)

In other words, the comment is about Craigslist. Houston and Virginia are incidental to the story of what was happening, all across the nation, on Craigslist at the time.

Also, come on man, I lived in Houston. For a long time. A time period that, coincidentally, saw me doing a lot of renting. (And using Craigslist to do so, because that's what you did in those days.) Houston Craigslist was certainly not magically immune to this issue. I was there. I saw it. Further, the fact that there were lawsuits all around the nation makes me feel confident in saying that this was very likely not a problem limited to Houston.

I'll take at face value your assertion that YOUR parents didn't post discriminatory ads. That said, the point of fact that discriminatory ads were placed on Craigslist on a systemic and nationwide scale was not in question in any of these lawsuits. The only question was, "Was Craigslist responsible?" Put another way, even the government, courts, and lawyers all across the US agree that racist ads were placed in Craigslist all across the nation. All parties accepted that as fact based on the evidence. They simply disagree on who was responsible.

So I'm not really sure why you're trying to say that racist ads never appeared in Houston like they did everyplace else? My sense is that you believe what you're saying, so my head is telling me that you must not have lived in the social strata of people who had to check Craigslist for cheap apartments or new roommates.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by 6cd6beb on Thursday March 28, 2019 @04:55PM (#19516501)
You can't be the "???", italics, and caps guy if you're gonna be the "Woah. Calm down guy." guy.

Either you're the one reacting strongly or you're the one chiding people for doing so. Doing both is poor form, to an extent that it stops mattering what else you type.

Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by Consultant32452 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @11:59AM (#19513467)
Sorry, but I'm curious. I'm guessing white and ???.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by scrumbledober on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:42PM (#19514624)
I'm guessing white was not one of the UNacceptable races. Being that it was in Texas I think it's fairly obvious which two races they were referring to, but it's not something I'd like to type out.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by dave5104 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:52AM (#19512727)
Using your analogy, this is probably more akin to somebody going after a hardware store specializing in hammers to kill people. Sure, the government could spend the time trying to track down each individual patron and bring individual charges against each of them, but it's probably easier to go after the supplier and cut everyone off.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by gmueckl on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:58AM (#19512790)
For that, the shop must be in violation of a law. I am not a lawyer, but there are plenty of cases where the crime is punishable, but goods and services involved are not, even though these are clearly designed to facilitate.
Re:Facebook Accused by HUD of Housing Bias Over Use of Targe... by highdesertmuse on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:35PM (#19513839)
Very clever, but alas, Facebook stopped being a hammer when they started censoring and manipulating content to support their political agenda. If the suit is successful, Facebook will be the official owner of all content on their platform under U.S. Law and be required to exercise due diligence in upholding the law or face the consequences. This will open the door legally to monetizing the value of Facebook's algorithm to the political campaigns it supports which is good news for conservatives in 2020 as Facebook is heavily biased toward the Democrat Party. The new attorney general, Bill Barr, served on Verizon's board of directors and said, during his confirmation hearing, that he intended to address the issue of political bias on social media platforms. Asked, would he use antitrust law? His answer, no, probably something else. Over the past few weeks Congressman Devin Nunez filed suit against Twitter for libel, and now HUD is filing against Facebook for discrimination in housing, also content manipulation. Finally US law is beginning to address the oversized impact of social media on politics, culture, finance, et.al.