Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by StavrosK on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:16PM
(#19508172)
I will never stoop so low as to telegraph my own joke.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by labster on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:05AM
(#19509144)
I couldn't agree more. The joke construction was a bit weak though, when you miss a good part of the audience. Add something like, "I mean, could you imagine the chaos it would cause if IE told websites it was really Mozilla?" and you demonstrate mastery of the subject matter, which should be enough to let other experts know you were facetious rather than ignorant. Unless you have timing issues... or need the comedian's plausible deniability.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by StavrosK on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:09AM
(#19510764)
I don't find that as funny, I think making the sarcasm more obvious makes the joke less funny as well. I prefer to take my chances than to go overboard and neuter the joke.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by shhehebehdh on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:28AM
(#19509255)
I like the original more without your embellishment. The addition sounds like every attempt at follow up humor on reddit.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by labster on Thursday March 28, 2019 @02:15AM
(#19509706)
Yeah but it's not Reddit, it's HN. You have to know your audience, read the crowd. On Reddit it's 90% sarcasm so there's no fixing it. Here it's the reverse and people take things seriously without a tell. You just have to bury the tell in another joke or it will ruin the funny.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 28, 2019 @03:22AM
(#19510033)
"given that software can't [ridiculous thing no one has ever claimed]" is plenty for a tell.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by Aeolun on Thursday March 28, 2019 @09:12AM
(#19511820)
Just the fact that this “fix” exists tells you some people believe differently.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by rujuladanh on Thursday March 28, 2019 @05:10AM
(#19510505)
If you can’t discern the joke, the joke isn’t for you to begin with; so it doesn’t matter.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by kowdermeister on Thursday March 28, 2019 @09:32AM
(#19511992)
Sir, your assessment of this particular joke is excellent. We should start a joke approval committee to avoid further confusion.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by craftinator on Thursday March 28, 2019 @02:12PM
(#19514932)
Yes, very well, as first action of the Joke Approval Committee, I propose that this august body instantiate the Recursed Approval Subcommittee, whose role will be to instantiate the Recursed Approval Subcommittee.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by kowdermeister on Thursday March 28, 2019 @02:20PM
(#19515016)
That's a perfect example you should post to JAC before. It would not pass, please never post this "joke" again.
Welcome on board :)
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by craftinator on Thursday March 28, 2019 @10:35PM
(#19518662)
As soon as the subcommittees hit their break condition (0), they'll break for coffee and donuts, and I can submit my "joke" to the JAC. And I don't make a habit of repeatedly posting the same joke, but I cannot make the promise in this case.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by labster on Thursday March 28, 2019 @06:20PM
(#19517207)
It puts the motion in the basket.
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by thayne on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:11PM
(#19508859)
In textualform, sarcasm and ignorance look the same. otoh, it can sometime be quite funny to see responses from people that take it seriously...
Re:Cisco Fixes RV320/RV325 Vulnerability by Banning “curl” i...
by dmix on Thursday March 28, 2019 @01:21AM
(#19509490)
I've never posted sarcasm online without at lease one person (that guy) who takes it seriously and decides to reply. But I think it's worth it because the people who get it will get it. If a small group doesn't then who cares (if everyone doesn't then you did a bad job constructing a joke).