News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by Ancalagon on Friday March 22, 2019 @01:58PM (#19465094)
If ever there were a reason to get politicians on the side of breaking up Google (or any other tech company), I imagine this would be it.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by vtange on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:25PM (#19465422)
Wouldn't a breakup/decentralization of Google, or any American multinational for that matter, just hand Chinese tech giants a massive advantage since the Internet as it is now heavily favors large, centralized organizations? I don't see people arguing for the breakup of the tech giants across the Pacific even though they hardly have a better reputation when it comes to privacy, etc.

By the way, I highly anticipate that the above argument will be made by said multinationals to prevent said breakup/anti-monopoly moves.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by CharlesColeman on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:29PM (#19465467)
> By the way, I highly anticipate that the above argument will be made by said multinationals to prevent said breakup/anti-monopoly moves.

Zuckerberg made that argument months ago, surprise, surprise:

https://www.recode.net/2018/7/18/17584482/mark-zuckerberg-ch...

> Mark Zuckerberg says breaking up Facebook would pave the way for China’s tech companies to dominate

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by coliveira on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:56PM (#19465724)
Not a surprise, this is the same argument the oil industry has used for decades to oppose any kind of anti-oligopoly legislation. Basically they state that the US curbing the size of oil companies will adversely impact national interests in the Middle East and in other regions.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by forgotmysn on Friday March 22, 2019 @03:05PM (#19465816)
does that invalidate the argument?
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by coliveira on Friday March 22, 2019 @03:50PM (#19466224)
It is a fallacy. If having a oligopoly is bad for the economy, it doesn't matter what other countries may want to do. Why weakening your economy, to satisfy the desires of an oligopoly, will be any better?
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by creato on Friday March 22, 2019 @04:07PM (#19466386)
For the local national economy, an oligopoly seems possibly worse. On the international stage, it seems blindingly obvious that breaking up your local oligopoly to compete with larger foreign oligopolies or stated owned corporations is worse.

Fundamentally, this is all about negotiating power, and the whole point of breaking up a monopoly/oligopoly is to reduce its negotiating power. But that's clearly a problem when interacting with foreign companies not subject to the same anti-trust action, and will have much greater negotiating power.

This is complicated, and the argument is not a fallacy.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by coliveira on Friday March 22, 2019 @05:51PM (#19467327)
Following your reasoning, we should just create and feed oligopolies to avoid, god help us, becoming "victims" of oligopolies from other countries... In other words, lets kill the competitiveness of the local economy, so that other countries won't be able to do just that. This is similar to the soldier who decides to commit suicide so that the foreign army won't have the chance to do so!
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by creato on Friday March 22, 2019 @06:18PM (#19467507)
You have a point. I'm just pointing out the argument you responded to is not a fallacy, it's a real concern as well. I honestly don't know what I would do if I had decision making power on this issue.

> we should just create and feed oligopolies to avoid, god help us, becoming "victims" of oligopolies from other countries...

This basically is exactly the strategy of China, at least with respect to international trade, and it's working absolutely wonderfully for them. In part, precisely because most of their competition is fragmented and paralyzed by infighting.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by coliveira on Friday March 22, 2019 @07:11PM (#19467810)
> This basically is exactly the strategy of China, at least with respect to international trade, and it's working absolutely wonderfully for them.

if that is the case, then the US has no grounds on requesting the Chinese to open their markets for US firms! If the US is itself committed to empower their oligarchic companies, we should not be surprised if the Chinese create their own mega companies and close their market to the American ones.

Essentially what I'm trying to say is that if we go the path of supporting mega companies, then we should just throw away the illusion of free market and understand that other countries will do the same, because they're not stupid.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by creato on Friday March 22, 2019 @10:00PM (#19468592)
> If the US is itself committed to empower their oligarchic companies,

I think this is a silly strawman and you probably know it. This argument exists on a wide spectrum, at one end is "not acting to break up large companies", and at the other is "outright state owned enterprises with unlimited funding to compete abroad". The fact that the argument applies to both does not make them the same.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by coliveira on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:31PM (#19471092)
It is not a strawman when we're talking about the US trying to "protect" giant and unhinged companies such as Google, Microsoft, Apple, ExonMobil, JPMorgan, and Goldman Sachs. In fact what happens is the opposite, these companies are in large part controlling the country, which puts us in a similar situation as the Chinese.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by ethbro on Friday March 22, 2019 @06:09PM (#19467458)
I believe you just described South Korea.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by forgotmysn on Friday March 22, 2019 @04:36PM (#19466649)
It's not binary like that. having an oligopoly in O&G is a negative for local economies, but it allows for more effective pricing in international markets. not only does that mean more American O&G is purchased, it means less (Russian or Syrian or Venezuelan) O&G is purchased, which is a strategic goal and may be more important to American goals than competition within local markets

The same may or may not be true of search engine or other technologies, but to look at it from a black and white perspective is not helpful.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by noobiemcfoob on Friday March 22, 2019 @04:39PM (#19466682)
To echo the point that decentralization of big tech might be an advantage to foreign powers, wouldn't multiple companies be harder to monitor in their exchange of IP across state lines?
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by CharlesColeman on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:04PM (#19465174)
I agree that a breakup of Google might be wise for a host of reasons, but how would a breakup help in this particular case? Some or all of the daughter companies could continue these kinds of relationships post-breakup.

I would think a government response to control this kind of activity would involve some form of deglobalization -- such as export controls or other regulations.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by acct1771 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:30PM (#19471089)
Scatter the cockroaches.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by EGreg on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:14PM (#19465279)
Not sure how a broken-up google would be sharing less with China.

The US military is a total centrally planned monopoly itself. Maybe the US military should not be spending so much money on bases overseas, and trillions of dollars unaccounted for. We have 800 bases and the rest of the world has 30. The taxpayer funds all of it, but has very little say or oversight.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by hodgesrm on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:14PM (#19465272)
If so that motivation would apply to politicians in many countries and not just the US. Multi-national companies are starting to look a lot less stable.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by paleotrope on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:28PM (#19465456)
That was always the flaw in the multi-national company concept. Even if you are completely in the cloud your people still have to live somewhere and perhaps more importantly, your money has to sit in some country somewhere.

And Switzerland isn't what it used to be for banking security.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by WallWextra on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:25PM (#19465411)
The smaller companies would have even less inclined to ignore a market of a billion people.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by darkpuma on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:07PM (#19465193)
That's optimistic. It could just as well be seen as another excuse to throw even more money at the defense industry. "Google works with China now, so we need to triple the size of our surface fleet."

Now ask yourself, which one seems more attractive to a cynical US politician who wants to bring in more jobs for his state? Does a senator from Texas or New York advocate for splitting up Google because it will open the market for other tech businesses that could choose to headquarter in Texas or New York, but will probably also choose California? Or will they decide to increase the size of the surface fleet, knowing they can get parts of those ships manufactured in their states? I fear the later is more appealing to this sort of person.

Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by jsnider3 on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:32PM (#19465489)
Honestly, the DoD should just take a dozen of its few hundred billions and spend them on making an AI workforce. That would be a hundred times better for national security than wasting it on garbage like the F-35.
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by acct1771 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:33PM (#19471102)
How could the Department of War (military industrial Congressional complex) profit from that?
Re:Google's Work with China Eroding US Military Advantage, D... by trkh0 on Friday March 22, 2019 @03:12PM (#19465878)
Breaking up "Google (or any other tech company)" is not a reasonable solution to any actual problem, I don't understand how people can casually suggest that.