The problem is that there are no serious consequences in this industry. Ad fraud isn't a technical problem, it's a business problem, one that most companies are not incentivized to solve or prevent.
So you're saying the standard practice is to let the malicious ad buyers from your network run arbitrary javascript on our sites...
"Yes that's what our publishers do..."
The main issue today is because advertisers want viewability tracking (which safeframe has a minimal but poor API for) and they want it with their own independent providers. Also prebid.js used for header bidding does not support safe frames.
Things will improve though because IntersectionObserver is now built into modern browsers and even works in cross-domain iframes. There's also the Open Measurement SDK[1] from the IAB to standardize viewability finally, and Prebid.js is also working on using SafeFrames.
Is the CFAA only for fleshers? Why so?
The "why" is because it's a 12-figure global industry including two of the most valuable companies in the world with unlimited resources and lobbying power, combined with highly technical mechanics and a complex network of business relationships that no politicians have any real understanding of.
I must add that there's also a (sometimes irrationally) strong reaction by those politicians and many others to working with anyone in adtech to even attempt to solve these problems which clearly doesn't help.
Several of the ad tech companies have pressed law enforcement to prosecute some of these people, but mostly unsuccessfully. They're often in places that are difficult to extradite from like Russia, hiding behind some botnet: https://adexchanger.com/online-advertising/why-the-doj-final...
Your 2nd statement is what I'm saying: no consequences refers to the lack of oversight, regulation and enforcement in the industry. That's why there's barely any prosecution. For example, Buzzfeed did an expose last year about Newsweek/IBTimes committing ad fraud, except it was already well known by everyone in adtech. People like getting paid and they're not going to stop on their own.
Btw, I personally know the founders of all those companies. If fraud was eliminated then they would go out of business. They're not interested in solving the problem even if they could.
But if you ask them, it's not their fault, but the ad company (Google), which in turn will point to a different company, etc
And in the end, people are scammed and Google gets a bit richer, but it's nobody's fault or responsibility
https://www.reddit.com/r/adops/comments/b0n57e/its_embarrass...
Man, yesterday I read a New York Times article in a view without ad blocking... I was actually embarrassed for them as a company. It's difficult to read an article when there are so many ads that there's doubt as to if there is more article below the next raft of ads.
Scummy AdSense ads are harder to pin down, of course, because of the live bidding and personalization.
EDIT: There's another one at the bottom of the page too. And they're randomized, some make it clear you aren't downloading Paint.net (such as the "Free Mac PDF Reader") but others aren't at all.
And people ask me why I block ads.
I'm not sure if these ads specifically target Android devices but it wouldn't surprise me.
It may be the manufacturers fault, but the person who sold it to you (the provider) is liable.
Should be the same here
Now in the particular case of ads in applications, I think there are surely many developers who fail to do their due diligence when picking advertisement partners, but without a doubt there are also advertisement companies who excel at duping the developers they work with.
Excessive trust is negligent. Let the market decide how to mitigate risk, but eliminating the risk creates opportunity for profiting from malfeasance.
Imagine you are a shop selling cola in can.
If coca cola company put some unhealthy stuff in, you are not liable just for selling it. But if you made the stuff unhealthy because you stored it in direct sunlight long time, you are liable.
I bought "child's toy" and sold you "child's today", you expect seller to check every toy if there is "secret camera" ?
I don't think that's true unless they knew it had this behavior or were negligent in some way.
I'm not sure what to call allowing any old shit to run in your app under the guise of ads other than negligent. The fact that it's so common should not be an excuse.
In situations like this perhaps it would be more productive if we had a system that focused more getting everyone to clean up and prevent this from happening again first, and then look at the liability part.
I do believe that this is the innate human response, the desire to "do the right thing". Most of us have the right mixture of nature/nurture to want to do that. But if the system doesn't enable that behavior or punishes that, that behavior will get suppressed and we end up in a miserable situation for everybody.
I dunno, it's not exactly an easy question or it would be solved already, and bad faith actors will exploit the goodwill of others too.
Take that line of thinking one more step. If a user installs a "free" app that is ad-supported, the USER is responsible.
I tell my kids this when they bitch about needing a new phone because theirs is too slow and the battery drains too fast. I say look at all the crap you installed on it. Clean it up don't be so dumb.
Unless the user taps the ad, no JS or HTML is involved, which eliminates the possibility of such tricks.
I looked for such a library a while back, but didn't find any.
Advertisers will give you double click (by google), atlas (Facebook), mediamind, etc tags m, to deliver as the ad. They will load in god knows what JS into their little space and (I cannot stress this enough), advertisers love their gimmicky little iteractable/expandable, engagement-filled ads.
To boot, they’re all laden with code to detect what publishers/sites/apps you’re displaying on, how much of the ad is viewable on screen and for how long, every scrap of code they can possibly fit in there to identify the user down to the finest grain they can manage.
You would think that things needn’t be this complex, but ad-tech companies have done a wonderful job of convincing advertisers that “targeted advertising is definitely better, and you definitely invest the extra cost in it, and definitely do all these other things because if you don’t then you’re totally falling behind your competitors, who are totally scraping every bit of data from their users, so you’d be a loser not to do the exact same thing and ~give all that dats to us.~ Sorry, make “valuable use” of all that data”.
Then it comes back to the Play Store. They like having all those free apps. It makes users feel like their Andriod phone has whatever they need. Google needs to make apps searchable based on privacy settings. They need to encourage people to pay for user respecting apps. I'd happily pay a buck or two for lots of apps if only they didn't have add or try to get me to buy add-ons. Just give me upfront honesty about what I'm getting and I'll pay you for it. Stop hosting crapware in the app store!
How much do you pay for your email?
$50 year because I actually decided to put my money where my mouth is and actually pay for a service I use. I don’t regret it one bit.
Why pay more for a worse product?
No other webmail service I've ever used has given me the lag issues Gmail has.
To me, if an ad network allows crap through, we have to take onwership and penalize the ad network and move on. But there is no accountability. It's everyone fighting for that next penny.
No one in the supply chain takes responsibility for this. That's how I, someone who works for a company that has ad-supported products, runs an ad blocker at the router level in my home. If people are going to actively try to harm me and my family by hunting for pennies, I am going to seek protection.
And because no one takes responsibility for this whole mess, the whole house of cards will fall. More and more devices are coming with ad-blocking built in. If we can't responsibly create ad-supported businesses, how can we honestly expect people to want to see those ads?
Digital advertising is so divorced from making users happy.
They know.
- You invited me to dinner, went to shopping, bought some stuff to cook, one ingredient was bad, I got poisoned.
In my opinion, here you don't have responsibility, because you acted with your best knowledge and good expectations from shop.
This kind of stuff is happening on google a lot too, this is not totally about some small shady company, working with another shady company.
The difference is due diligence. In picking ingredients and preparing them the host of this dinner has most likely taken care to use what they have good reason to believe a reputable sources and methods.
People placing add on sites and in apps are doing no such thing for the most part - beyond concerns of outrageously illegal adverts or those that might otherwise offend their audience directly, they are simply picking the provider that is likely to pay them the most. This is insufficient due diligence so they shouldn't be able to pass the buck, but they can because there are so many levels of indirection in the industry it becomes difficult to prove who failed most.
There is commonality with your food example: the recent meat source problems in Europe when cheap horse meat was unexpectedly found in many places it shouldn't have been. This highlighted how little due diligence was happening at various points in that industry and the fact that the many levels of supplier supplying supplier supplying supplier made it easy for problems to go unnoticed as no one thought it was them that needed to check.
This sounds like a lot of industries...
> If you use an ad service from a shady company
And what if they aren't shady? Something large from a well known, non-shady company, like Twitter? Because that's who is mentioned in the article: Twitter's MoPub.
And is the reverse true? If you use these shady companies (Twitter and MoPub) are you contributing to the success of shady companies?
Bad advertisers are real, and they really exist. But trying to say that the person who relies on that software equally responsible as everyone down the pipe is a bit of a stretch. Otherwise, I could make the same extreme arguments about pretty much every tech company, big and small, and all the people that use them.
Even you.
This fingerpointing points to one of the core problems of the ad industry: They created a system where nobody knows who's responsible for anything, so malware and fraud has an easy time.
But this mode of thinking makes no sense. If you put ads in your app YOU are responsible. If you use an ad service from a shady company that outsources to other shady companies then you're still responsible.