News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by swozey on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:25AM (#19452003)
Funny timing on this, I just came across my grandfather's letter from the Apollo program astronauts thanking him for his testing prowess and awarding him the "silver snoopy" for professional excellence.

My other grandfather was the first shuttle launch director, the shoes we fill..

Might interest some.

https://lensdump.com/i/W1GAd0

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by sizzzzlerz on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:28AM (#19452027)
What did your grandfather do and which astronauts signed the letter?
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by swozey on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:36AM (#19452112)
It's signed by Ronald Evans of Apollo 17. Both of my grandfathers and a lot of my family worked for nasa for decades, though. We're all space coasters. A few pilots. My grandmother was a typist there for instance.

He was some sort of rocket propulsion engineer back then, I'm not sure what the actual title would have been. I asked him to write some memoirs a long time ago but I don't bug him about it. He doesn't seem to think it's very interesting. Guess that happens when it's your day job.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by EvanAnderson on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:47AM (#19452249)
I certainly wouldn't ask you to bug him, but you might mention to him that there are lots of people who would find anything he has to say about his involvement with Apollo (and the space program in general) fascinating. His stories are important and interesting, even if he doesn't think they are. I wish I had a pointer to somebody who is collecting this history before it's lost. (I wish I had the time and financial freedom to be doing that!)
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by japhyr on Thursday March 21, 2019 @10:15AM (#19452568)
You might be interested in a book called Moondust. The author realized in the early 2000s that at some point soon all of the astronauts who walked on the moon would be gone. He set out to interview each of them about their experiences at the time, and since visiting the moon.

It's a mix of space history and personal reflections on the perspective they got, that none of us will likely have.

https://www.amazon.com/Moondust-Search-Men-Fell-Earth-dp-000...

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by frosted-flakes on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:17PM (#19457419)
A Man on the Moon by Andrew Chaikin (1998)[0] is also a great read. The author explains in the forward that that was also part of his motivation to write the book. I have the 23 hour audiobook, which is also quite well narrated.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/896458.A_Man_on_the_Moon

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by mpweiher on Thursday March 21, 2019 @12:24PM (#19454144)
Can also recommend. All of them were changed.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by swozey on Thursday March 21, 2019 @10:26AM (#19452687)
He's very Feynman-esque. He'll definitely have some fun stories if I can get him a blog or medium going.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by packetslave on Thursday March 21, 2019 @12:45PM (#19454405)
If nothing else, see if you can get him to sit down and tell YOU the stories while you record them on your phone or a handheld audio recorder. Much lower barrier to entry.

It's not widely appreciated that Feynman didn't write either of his famous books ("Surely you're joking, Mr. Feynman" and "What do you care what people think?"). Both were compiled by his friend Ralph Leyton from audio recordings of Feynman sitting around telling stories.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by packetslave on Thursday March 21, 2019 @04:11PM (#19456729)
sp: Ralph Leighton
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by sizzzzlerz on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:48AM (#19453737)
Please try. Even if you don't publish his stories, you'll be glad to have heard them later on. I was fortunate to have lived through that era and watched all the landings. Now, I try and find and read anything by those who were actually there: astronauts, flight directors, flight controllers, and government or contractor personnel. It is a fascinating and important era and it is worth documenting.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by mpweiher on Thursday March 21, 2019 @12:25PM (#19454158)
Seconded. We've heard a lot about the astronauts and The Right Stuff. Would love to hear more about the Right Engineering. :-)
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by robotresearcher on Thursday March 21, 2019 @04:57PM (#19457242)
Ben Rich's 'Skunkworks' is along these lines, i.e. awesome.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Rich

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by titzer on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:08AM (#19453177)
Do an audio interview and record it.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by arethuza on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:11AM (#19453223)
A video would be even better - there are some superb interviews on YouTube with astronauts e.g. this one with Neil Armstrong from 2011:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJzOIh2eHqQ

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by titzer on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:53AM (#19453801)
Depends. A video can be a little intimidating to someone not used to interviews.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by hellofunk on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:29AM (#19452042)
You can read the letter yourself, which answers all the details.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by jacquesm on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:24PM (#19455632)
That's one hell of a memento, good luck with the filling of those shoes. At least you have something to aim for!
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by charliepark on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:08AM (#19451833)
This looks really interesting. "A series of eight articles … from the March 1970 issue of Astronautics & Aeronautics."

Quickly summarizing the table of contents and some of the internal content, these seem to be the main takeaways:

• Create design principles that stress simplicity.

• Test exhaustively.

• Develop mission rules, procedures, and plans for potential issues ahead of time; iterate as new information comes in.

• Execute rigorous post-mortems.

• Prioritize flexible yet disciplined management.

It's notable that this was published before Apollo 13. It'd be interesting to see what changes Kranz et al. would make to these articles after that.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by KineticLensman on Thursday March 21, 2019 @12:06PM (#19453928)
> Test exhaustively.

> It's notable that this was published before Apollo 13

One of the causes of the Apollo 13 service module explosion was damage caused during a pre-flight test. The SM included a pipe whose only role was to drain out oxygen after pre-flight launch-pad tests. It had no in-flight role. The pipe was damaged during assembly (nobody noticed) and failed to drain the oxygen tank. The test team instead decided to drain the tank by heating the oxygen using an in-tank heater and in effect boiling it off. The heater temperature gauge didn't show (it was badly designed) that the heater had in fact got so hot that it had melted electrical insulation on a fan in the oxygen tank. All of this was pre-flight.

56 hours into the mission, the crew used the fan to stir the tank, causing sparks and the eventual explosion.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by openasocket on Thursday March 21, 2019 @10:26AM (#19452683)
All of these apply to software development as well, but especially that first point. I'm on a project right now that has a bunch of things that can be simplified. Some duplicated state, multiple code paths for computing the same thing, etc. When problems arise it's very tricky to debug and it's almost always caused by that complexity. The temptation is to just add another layer of checks or validation on top of it or make a slight tweak. But of course the best path is to just roll up your sleeves and work to remove as many moving parts as you can. Most of our bug fixes have actually resulted in substantially fewer lines of code. Anyway, the point is to always try and keep things simple, and even better to make sure that principle is followed in the initial stages of design.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by usermac on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:16AM (#19451914)
I've heard or read of this before, the first bullet, and can't help but to compare this to what has happened with the 737 Max 8 current issue.

From the PDF comes: "Apollo gains a measure of simplicity from features simple both in design and operation, complex in design but simple to operate, or simple by being passive in function. The concept of simple design and simple operation is best illustrated by the Apollo rocket-propulsion systems (fig. 2-2)."

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by sizzzzlerz on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:40AM (#19452155)
For a machine as complex as the Saturn 5 rocket, it is truly a credit to the builders that it never suffered a major failure in any of the manned missions. Same for the LM rocket which returned the astronauts to the command module. Both had to absolutely work and both did.

As John Glenn quipped "It's a very sobering feeling to be up in space and realize one's safety factor was determined by the lowest bidder on a government contract."

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by delibes on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:53AM (#19452321)
Gus Grissom, Ed White and Roger Chaffee :(

I do get your point, and it's amazing it worked as well as it did. Space is tough, and things are likely to go wrong, just as they still do with civil aviation.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by arethuza on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:09AM (#19453189)
Silly nitpick: Apollo 1 was a Saturn 1B not a Saturn 5.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_1

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by sizzzzlerz on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:40AM (#19453613)
It also wasn't a "mission". They were performing in a test. And, in any case, the fire wasn't a fault of the rocket; it was a fire in capsule.
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by robotresearcher on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:00PM (#19457266)
This document must be post Apollo 13. Copied verbatim from the linked PDF:

> Even the Apollo 13 oxygen tank rupture, by far the most critical problem of any Apollo mission to date, was overcome by relying on preplanned emergency procedures and the resourcefulness and ingenuity of the astronauts and the ground support team.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by tra3 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:18PM (#19455562)
Brady Heywood Forensic Engineering Podcast [0], has an amazing series on Apollo 13 [1]. It's 6 episodes, mostly narrated by Brady Heywood, with some audio recording from Houston as well as the Apollo astronauts. It's riveting.

[0]: http://bradyheywood.libsyn.com

[1]: http://bradyheywood.libsyn.com/episode-21-apollo-13-p1-head-...

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by bspammer on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:16AM (#19453306)
The very first sentence is confusing to me:

> On July 20, 1969, man first set foot on another planet.

Has the definition of planet changed over time?

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by Someone on Thursday March 21, 2019 @03:28PM (#19456324)
https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/planet:

”1.2 Astrology historical

A celestial body distinguished from the fixed stars by having an apparent motion of its own (including the moon and sun), especially with reference to its supposed influence on people and events.

‘the planets are presently influencing you in a positive way’”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_planet:

”In classical antiquity, the seven classical planets are the seven non-fixed astronomical objects in the sky visible to the naked eye: Mars, Jupiter, Venus, Saturn, Mercury, the Sun, and the Moon. The word planet comes from two related Greek words, πλάνης planēs (whence πλάνητες ἀστέρες planētes asteres "wandering stars, planets") and πλανήτης planētēs, both with the original meaning of "wanderer", expressing the fact that these objects move across the celestial sphere relative to the fixed stars.”

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by basseq on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:01PM (#19455352)
This question struck me. I, too, googled it, and came up empty handed. I then asked on Quora, which at the time of this comment, has 5 not-unreasonable answers.

My favorite answer is Joshua Engel's:

> It’s just a turn of phrase. He’s evoking the idea of “planet” as “one of the lights in the sky”, something people have long dreamed of.

> It was an awkward phrase even at the time, though. George Low may have been a great administrator, but he’s a lousy writer. My red pen itched at every word. (In the very next sentence he misspells “mankind”.) He meant to be poetic, but his audience would have been confused by it, and that wouldn’t be the last time in that document.

https://www.quora.com/Why-did-NASA-refer-to-the-Moon-as-a-pl...

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by daveslash on Thursday March 21, 2019 @01:53PM (#19455262)
I so wish that your username had been "Pluto" when you asked that question. Snarkiness put aside, I searched around online to see if maybe I was missing something. It looks like it was simply a misuse of the word. I would have suggested using "celestial body" or even "world" in place of "planet". Perhaps he was using it in the colloquial sense (in the same way a tomato is a "vegetable").
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by hguant on Thursday March 21, 2019 @04:48PM (#19457155)
>the main point is that a single man can fully understand this interface and can cope with all the effects of a change on __either side of the interface__

(emphasis mine)

This is a really great and subtle point, and something that takes a lot of rigour to turn into reality.

Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by wespiser_2018 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:37PM (#19455820)
From the article: "If the design has been verified and if a thorough test program has been completed it should not be necessary to make any changes. Of course, this idealized situation does not exist in any program like Apollo where design, test, and flight often overlap and must be carried out at the same time." Wow, these remind me of the Joint Strike Fighter program, where design/test/production all overlapped (concurrency) and cost overruns where a huge issue. No doubt, we spared very little expense in the Apollo program, cutting only the last two missions!
Re:What Made Apollo a Success? (1971) [pdf] by shmooth on Friday March 22, 2019 @06:22AM (#19461086)
Had to be Agile dev with CI/CD