News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by tudelo on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:49PM (#19446121)
> #27 in America for eight-year-olds

The granularity of this ranking is interesting.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by benatkin on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:59PM (#19446219)
I disagree. This isn't a contrived category, which is common in tournaments, to make them interesting. On chess.com and Lichess there are chess tournaments that are restricted to people with lower than, say, a 1500 rating. If a 1700 chess player plays worse on purpose to get the score down, that's called sandbagging. There is little room for sandbagging here. People can't just change their ages, or up and move to the US. There are age ratings and regional divisions in different sports, and it both makes things more fair and opens up more opportunity to compete.

This is a significant achievement and the boy is undeniably an elite chess player.

Edit: s/soundbagging/sandbagging/g

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by dlandis on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:52PM (#19446759)
What (if anything) stops people from cheating in online tournaments (by simply asking a computer for the best next move, given the current board arrangement)?
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by bluGill on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @05:16PM (#19447028)
After game analysis. When someone picks the computer best most from a position you can ask how likely it is they came up with that on their own. Expert chess players recognize computer moves fairly accurately in a lot of situations (this is easy to test, just take a bunch of positions, show the last move and ask if it was human or computer). From there human judges look at the game and decide how likely it is someone cheated.

Of course if you only cheat once you get away with it as nobody will be sure. However cheating once isn't enough to change a game - in fact it will probably change it for the worse on your side (without knowing what the computer intended you follow a bad line after the otherwise good move). Thus you can look at a series of games and concluded if the player cheated or not. From there you take after the fact adjustments which mostly means recalculate everyone's score as if those games didn't happen.

Interestingly enough, chess masters generally will score alpha zero moves as human not computers. It will be interesting to see how online cheating progresses once better AI based chess computers become available.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by V-2 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @01:01PM (#19454604)
There is more to it than that.

There are many giveaways than an algorithm can pick up. All intricate details of cheating detection algorithms aren't revealed for obvious reasons. But some of this stuff is fairly well known. For example it's about the time spent on moves. Cheaters will tend to make their moves at a fairly constant pace (because how long it takes them to check the position with the chess engine is constant). They come up with brilliant moves quickly, but take a bit longer for obvious or forced moves that a human would do without thinking. Cheaters generally don't premove, nor do they ever make moves real fast - which humans often do in time trouble. It's for the exact same reason.

There's also a thing such as blur rate - how often someone switches away from the game window. And certain other heuristics too (hold alert).

Obviously a cheater can avoid triggering some of the alarms, some of them are quite easy to beat (eg. for the blur, just have your chess engine run on a separate device), but in the long run it's difficult for them not to raise various other red flags at the same time. A smart person might figure out how to do it - online cheaters aren't that smart though, and unsurprisingly so, given that online cheating is essentially an exercise in futility.

This doesn't mean smart people don't cheat at chess at all. They do; at actual chess tournaments, where there's something at stake, be it prize money or real titles.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by dlandis on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @08:05PM (#19448240)
I see, that’s interesting. Although I also wonder if players cheat in other, more subtle, ways such as to just prevent blunders; not necessarily to choose the best moves.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by omegaham on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @08:50PM (#19448424)
Yes, they do.

The result is that time controls have shortened accordingly. It's a lot harder to cheat convincingly when you're playing bullet chess, whereas it might be easier to do so when you're playing 10 or 15-minute time controls.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by bjourne on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:23PM (#19447619)
People's honor and integrity. :) There are anti-cheating counter-measures but they would be trivial to defeat for someone who knows a little bit about how computer chess works. For example, Lichess is a free chess site and all the source code is open, except for the anti-cheating heuristics.

However, getting a computer to play realistically like a good eight-year old wouldn't be to easy. The computer-generated moves would stand out much more due to the skill differential than, say, if a grand master cheated using a chess engine.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by V-2 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @12:10PM (#19453977)
They aren't necessarily so trivial. I don't know about Lichess, but (commercial and much better funded) Chess.com employs very advanced, and continuously improved cheating detection mechanisms.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by claudiawerner on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @05:04PM (#19446900)
I believe that the site (popular chess sites anyway) can detect when someone is continually playing the best (or near-best?) move, and often it's hard to just use the chess engine for one move because they can play "strategically" too of course.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by travisjungroth on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:49PM (#19447785)
You disagree that it's interesting?
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by calvinmorrison on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:25PM (#19446473)
*sandbagging

it's a term across all sports

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by kibwen on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:38PM (#19446576)
Including esports, where my experience with the term implies a meaning of "to intentionally disrespect your opponent by playing below your known skill level" https://www.ssbwiki.com/Sandbagging
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by tbrake on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:04PM (#19446265)
> I disagree.

Was there an edit to the OP I missed? What are you disagreeing with exactly? It was clearly a statement of opinion about how they found it interesting.

You couldn't just elucidate more on the reasoning for the classifications, you had to first tell them they were wrong and then pedantically explain it.

Peak fucking HN commenting.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by benatkin on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:09PM (#19446313)
Yes, I'm disagreeing with the claim that it's interesting. Interestingness isn't entirely subjective. Mostly, though, I'm sticking up for the kid, whose sub-1500 rating shouldn't be scoffed at by any chess player who's more than, say, 10 years old.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by mbrameld on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:18PM (#19446399)
Did you maybe misread the first comment you replied to? What exactly is it you're saying isn't interesting?
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by zem on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:28PM (#19446492)
minor correction: "sandbagging". the term is common in the scrabble tournament community too, and i'd always assumed it was metaphorically "ambush by hitting someone over the head with a sandbag", but apparently that's only the presumed etymology, and there is at least one other theory out there: https://ridemonkey.bikemag.com/threads/anybody-know-origins-...
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by damienkatz on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:55PM (#19446808)
My understanding is it’s from car racing. Putting sandbags in during qualifying to make min weight. Then removed during the race to make the car lighter and faster.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by benatkin on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:28PM (#19446502)
just a typo :) thanks!

I think chess.com is actually writing code to combat sandbagging. I don't know if they're using machine learning for it yet, but it would certainly be possible for a deep learning system to spot probable sandbaggers, if they have enough history of their games.

Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by bluGill on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @05:18PM (#19447046)
It is a hard problem. People have good and bad streaks. People sometimes play drunk, which isn't actually sandbagging but has the same effect. People sometimes play tired and miss moves that would be obvious if they were more awake.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by birken on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:53PM (#19446156)
Well the USCF knows your exact USCF rating and your birth date, so it is very easy for them to make these lists. Though they should be taken with a grain of salt because, especially for young players who are improving quickly, their rating is very likely a lagging indicator of their current skill.
Re:8-Year-Old Refugee Wins New York State Championship by notyourday on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:43PM (#19446636)
One thing to remember is that someone who has no official rating enters a tournament as unrated. The "does not suck in chess but isn't any good" rating is about 1500. Union Sq has a couple of Asian kids who play 1600-1700 hustlers ( with their parents watching ) and do about even with the which would make them about the same range. I'm sure they are unrated according to the US Chess Federation.

Typically one would not want to enter an official tournament as unrated player while being a low rated player as that's the only time when one can compete in a low bracket and win a purse.