YouTuberLaw was working on a complaint to the FTC. There was allegedly some sort of collusion against their competitor SubscribeStar during a recent controversy, where SubscribeStar suddenly lost their payment processing.
During that event, people were trying to unsubscribe so they could delete their accounts, but Patreon was removing the pages with the unsubscribe control! (Looked like incompetence, not malice to me.) Based on what I've seen Jack Conte and other Patreon people say online, I don't think the officers of the company have very good control over what employees are actually doing. They actively contradict each other at times.
A “controversial” Patreon-account was banned over content not posted on Patreon.
A Patreon-representative leaked in a tweet that this was done on the request of MasterCard and that there was nothing they could do.
As a result he moved to SubscribeStar and asked his followers to move over (which seemed to work).
Now this is where things get interesting...
SubscribeStar uses PayPal for payment processing.
A former paypaler moved to patreon.
This person may have called some contacts/favors, because SubscribeStar suddenly found their entire PayPal account locked down and no longer received any payments from or for any accounts. Their business was effectively dead.
It’s not a smoking gun, but certainly enough to cause warranted speculation.
At best it’s PayPal not having good routines (and we know that already, right?), at worst it’s companies like MasterCard now policing what kind of internet-business or internet-content they will allow to be profitable, globally, unchallenged.
Either way, the situation leaves a lot to be desired.
Edit: This was actually discussed on HN until flagged (like too many interesting discussions). All I can find now is this link:
https://www.jihadwatch.org/2018/08/patreon-and-mastercard-ba...
But is it known that a competitor can kill your business with one short phone to PayPal without you having done anything to violate their TOS?
That seems like it could be the issue here.
To be fair, he does try to be controversial, and he says some hair-raising things. Basically, imagine that you went into a den of literal neo-Nazis, and you were trying your best to say things to shock and insult them. I don't think that's very smart of him to do.
Edit: This was actually discussed on HN until flagged (like too many interesting discussions).
This does seem to be a pattern around here of late. There's a lot of pushing of narratives all across the Internet, which amount to "this person is [something horrible] don't even read their material." Much of that is false. At the same time there are genuine [something horrible] going around in much larger numbers in the past few years than the decades before.
I think the real target is rational discourse itself.
If you ever have to go to the Patreon website after having become a patron to your desired creator, you're doing something wrong or they are. There is no reason in the world you should be leaning on patreon to serve content.
You're the patron, your creator is your content maker who should be using other means to communicate the content to you (youtube? other web hosting? soundcloud? There are many ways, I use all of those) and your pledge is the product: the creator is the customer, not you.
I truly don't care how silly the website is when they pay me my revenue like clockwork without issue. Patreon is not a web hosting service. Patreon collects subscriptions from patrons and manages that stuff, as well as anything else I've used.
If all they're doing is collecting and forwarding money then they're one of the most poorly run businesses and massively overbuilt even with their subpar product.
If I subscribe to a creator, then one of the first things I want to do is go through that creator’s content. Patreon makes this exceedingly painful.
Sending you the money is the niche use-case. Viewing the content is core to the UX of most Patreon users.
The difference is, on Patreon I can also give the content away to all and sundry, open-source it, and spend zero time or attention trying to police the digital copying of it.
People only being interested in Patreon as a mechanism to send me the money is 99% of my entire userbase, and everybody else's that has a significant revenue from Patreon. That mechanism is NOT as easy or trivial as people make it out to be on Hacker News, and I value it. But you've got it totally backwards, and your type of expectation is what's damaging Patreon and getting them to have dozens of managers and marketing staff. A lot of that headcount is about getting them to do the unwanted, unneccesary and unhelpful.
Anecdotally, I agree with this. Getting people to donate to stuff is hard. If they have to sign up for a brand new service and share payment information with them to do it, they won't do it. So as a creator, you're incentivized to put proportional amounts of work into proportional platforms.
As a user, part of the point of Patreon is to more efficiently distribute micro-payments. There really aren't any good ways to do micro-payments online. Pretty much everything either has fixed fees that make donations of <1$ incredibly inefficient, or it's just a pain to support. So as a user, you're highly incentivized to group as much of your donations as possible onto a single platform so they can be batch processed.
If there was a universal, protocol-based way to send someone micro-payments online that didn't come with any fees, I don't believe Patreon would be able to continue existing. It would be so easy for anyone to outcompete them on everything else.
But I dunno how close we are to something like that. Even in a magic world where bitcoin becomes stable, cryptocurrency still wouldn't solve that problem -- you still have fees associated with payments that make it advantageous to group payments together. Zelle? Maybe? There was an article a while back about cities starting to ban cashless stores, and while I'm normally fairly libertarian, I looked at that and thought, "wow, we should probably have at least one nationalized digital payment system."
The complaint is about forced inefficiencies that Patreon then foists onto its customers. They are balancing their books by upping their fees, not streamlining their business and they can only do this (in the short term) because they have a fairly captive audience.
We are about to see a whole sea of Patreon competitors.
I really hope so! I had been using Patreon as a "poor man's microtransactions" with $1 subscriptions (contingent on actually producing content, if possible) on something like 40 creators. I moved over to SubscribeStar, but they don't have the default $1 option.
A web app could aggregate charges to me, and aggregate payments out to content creators. Obviously. That's what Patreon was doing. Others could do it too. (If the allegations of collusion with payment processing are true, this would explain why this isn't done more.)
It’s unbelievable how slow Patreon is, given that “website that shows images” is a well-solved problem. Couple that with the all-dynamic-all-the-time, continuous-scroll-all-the-things UX, and it’s one of the worst websites I use. There must be serious network effects, if nobody has risen to eat their lunch.