Would you want to allow people to print their own money? After all that's just arranging a series of atoms in a particular way. You can't disallow arranging atoms, or the world will come to a halt. Yet in practice these arbitrary rules seem to work fine.
If we had the technology to make copies on an atomic level, I believe this would indeed pose a fundamental philosophical and legal debate, especially for patented things like manufacturing materials and drugs. With money, however, intellectual property has nothing to do with it, and (at least in the US) counterfeiting is a completely separate orthogonal crime.
That a law with a different name is protecting money is irrelevant. The point is disallowing manipulating atoms in a certain way. Another one: can you give a formal definition of what constitutes a $1 bill? Again, you cannot. Does that mean that we should allow copying money?
A formal definition is not necessary for something to be put in the law.
IP protection might not always be required for innovation, but if you compare countries that have "fair and balanced" IP protection -- really, property rights generally -- against those that don't, you find that the former seem to do better in fostering innovation.
Certainly there are people and companies who create things for the joy of it, for reputation, for the indirect benefits that come from the existence of a widely-adopted standard, for purely-altruistic reasons, etc. Good for them; the world needs more of them.
But sometimes creators need to get actual money, from others who don't necessarily share the joy, to buy equipment, travel, hired help, and other things. And that usually entails a legal system that helps innovation investors recoup the 'capital' they put at risk.
--------------------
> ... a patent/copyright/etc. on a piece of software or a digital media file is quite literally a claim of ownership of a natural number.
Does that mean that JK Rowling is claiming ownership of the letters A, B, etc.?
I don't think that, in a world without IP protection, people would only create things for joy, reputation, standard adoption, or altruism. Companies would still want software, and would be willing to pay people to develop it.
Lack of IP protection isn't the same thing as the Free Software Movement. In a world with IP protection, you could still sell proprietary software without disclosing source code. There would still be an incentive for competing companies to constantly improve their software to outdo each other.
I don't understand your Rowling analogy. What I'm saying is that Rowling's copyright of one of her books is equivalent to ownership of, for example, the natural number equal to the ASCII encoding of the text of the book.
That is not correct. A list of natural numbers in order would not infringe any copyrights. If, by coincidence, one of the numbers on that (very large, completely impractical) list happened to match what you get when you take some copyrighted work and encode it as a number under some particular reversible encoding, it would not be an infringement, because it would not be a copy of the copyrighted work.
Copyright does not protect against independent creation. As a practical matter, of course, if a latter work B is similar to a prior work A, most courts will believe that B'a author had access to A and copied (perhaps subconsciously). However, if B's author could show that he really never had access to A, never had anyone describe A to him, and so on, so could not possibly have been influenced by it, then B would not be an infringement of A.
I disagree with your claim that intellectual property laws are a continuum and that a reasonable balance can to be found. When it comes to digital software/media, any intellectual property protection at all boils down to authorizing the ownership of an integer. I don't mean this metaphorically or rhetorically, I mean that a patent/copyright/etc. on a piece of software or a digital media file is quite literally a claim of ownership of a natural number.
If someone else wants simply to distribute a list of the natural numbers in order, they would legally have to omit the numbers which represented patented/copyrighted works. You might brush off this argument by saying "that's silly, since the numbers representing a song or operating system would be so large that it's highly unlikely for anyone to accidentally stumble on such a number." That's not good enough for me. People have constructed (discovered) proofs of concept of several illegal numbers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number