Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders
by jules on Saturday November 27, 2010 @09:02AM
(#1944945)
Can you provide a formal definition of murder? I take it you cannot. Does that mean that we should allow murder?
That a law with a different name is protecting money is irrelevant. The point is disallowing manipulating atoms in a certain way. Another one: can you give a formal definition of what constitutes a $1 bill? Again, you cannot. Does that mean that we should allow copying money?
A formal definition is not necessary for something to be put in the law.
If we had the technology to make copies on an atomic level, I believe this would indeed pose a fundamental philosophical and legal debate, especially for patented things like manufacturing materials and drugs. With money, however, intellectual property has nothing to do with it, and (at least in the US) counterfeiting is a completely separate orthogonal crime.