News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by tzs on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:24PM (#1944188)
> If someone else wants simply to distribute a list of the natural numbers in order, they would legally have to omit the numbers which represented patented/copyrighted works.

That is not correct. A list of natural numbers in order would not infringe any copyrights. If, by coincidence, one of the numbers on that (very large, completely impractical) list happened to match what you get when you take some copyrighted work and encode it as a number under some particular reversible encoding, it would not be an infringement, because it would not be a copy of the copyrighted work.

Copyright does not protect against independent creation. As a practical matter, of course, if a latter work B is similar to a prior work A, most courts will believe that B'a author had access to A and copied (perhaps subconsciously). However, if B's author could show that he really never had access to A, never had anyone describe A to him, and so on, so could not possibly have been influenced by it, then B would not be an infringement of A.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by baddox on Saturday November 27, 2010 @02:54AM (#1944568)
What you propose is inconsistent and vague. An MP3 file of a copyrighted work is literally a natural number. That's the way it's represented on disc, in memory, etc. If surrounding that number with predecessors and successors somehow makes the number not an infringement, then why don't we create a p2p network that does just that?