News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by everdev on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:44AM (#19389129)
Another topic Yang brings up frequently besides the Freedom dividend is retraining.

Automation in retail, driving, etc. has the potential to make jobs obsolete at a rapid pace. Rather than trying to fight to save jobs that can be done by machines the idea is to retrain people in these industries to do things machines aren't good at.

The idea is to not slow down progress but also not abandon people who happen to have built a life in a dying field.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by el_cujo on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:17AM (#19389392)
I listened to him talk a little bit on Joe Rogan's podcast, and it seemed to him that the UBI/Freedom Dividend is his plan explicitly because stuff like retraining these fifty year old guys who have been truck drivers or coal miners their entire lives to become computer programmers or something is really unrealistic. I guess it would be more possible to retrain the younger people that populate retail, but really I think retail is viewed as just something people do to put themselves through college or during highschool rather than a life-long career like truck driving. That's not to say there aren't people in retail who aren't going to get screwed by automation, but that's sort of the appeal of UBI, it's something that applies to everyone versus having to try and justify to someone that you deserve help for your specific circumstances.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by _red on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:27AM (#19389500)
>retraining these fifty year old guys who have been truck drivers or coal miners

While thats true, I think the premise is wrong. Techno-types love to imagine that automation is just going to sweep through these industries.

The devil of these things is in the details. Yes, perhaps the tech can get to approximate 90% of what a human can do. However, the real problem are outside of tech. Like liability insurance. Who gets sued when one of Elon's driverless trucks plows into a school bus? Surely not the "trucking company"? So the software company will have to assume that...Now, imagine there are 50M driverless vehicles on the roads, what does that monthly policy look like? What insurance company will underwrite that? What happens if a zero-day is found? etc. etc.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by ameister14 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:18AM (#19389979)
>Who gets sued when one of Elon's driverless trucks plows into a school bus? Surely not the "trucking company"?

Actually, yes, the trucking company gets sued. This is pretty well established. If your Toyota malfunctions and you hit someone, you get sued. You may sue Toyota afterwards, but you're going to get sued first.

This has literally happened before. It's not a what if. Toyota recalled thousands of trucks about 3 months ago because of a braking issue. I fail to see the difference between this and car insurance of the future.

Even if insurance were the issue, it's fairly easy to solve; in the contract you sign to use an automated vehicle, you'd assume liability.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by dragonwriter on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:15PM (#19393176)
> This is pretty well established. If your Toyota malfunctions and you hit someone, you get sued. You may sue Toyota afterwards, but you're going to get sued first.

It's not unlikely if the immediate crash investigation even hints at a product defect, you (all of driver, driver's employer if done in course of employment, and owner if different from the preceding two), Toyota, and everyone in the chain of commerce between you, plus the people up the chain from Toyota with regard to the part at fault will all get sued, simultaneously, in the same action.

The only change self-driving cars bring is eliminating the driver as a distinct target from the manufacturer and a whole bunch of upstream suppliers, but the person or company owning and the one (of different) directing the operation of the vehicle are still potential liability targets, as well as the upstream chain of commerce.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by _red on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:09PM (#19393117)
>If your Toyota malfunctions and you hit someone, you get sued. You may sue Toyota afterwards, but you're going to get sued first.

You extrapolating that future markets will work exactly like the past, because "its a car".

But its doubtful it will. The reason why the auto industry evolved the way it did (driver gets sued), is because 90+% of the time it is operator error.

Look at another example. Kraft distributes 10M packages of poisoned cheese, what happens: (a) All the local grocery stores get sued? or (b) Does Kraft get sued?

Obviously "B" would be the case, since the local grocery stores would say: "We had no way to test the cheese for poison, it was pre-packaged from Kraft"

This is very similar to what would happen in a 100% autonomous vehicle situation. The owner doesn't have access nor the capability to judge the engineering / code.

>Toyota recalled thousands of trucks about 3 months

Not the same. Toyota doing a recall to replace a $200 part doesn't come close to the potential liability that a autonomous manufacturer that had thousands of accidents...each potentially costing millions each.

>Even if insurance were the issue, it's fairly easy to solve; in the contract you sign to use an automated vehicle, you'd assume liability.

Yes, and the trucking companies will just say: No

Their insurance rates would skyrocket so high, that it would be cheaper to just continue to use human drivers.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by ameister14 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:35PM (#19394561)
No, people don't just sue the drivers because it's driver error, they sue because they have a chance to get money. People who get t-boned by a driver running a red light get sued by the insurance company of the driver that ran the light. It can have nothing to do with who is at fault, ultimately, just who is the easiest target.

In your Kraft scenario, the store would likely be sued, as would the corporation running the store, Kraft, and potentially the packaging company.

Here's a perfect example; the Romaine lettuce E. coli outbreak happens, right. A man eats a salad at a restaurant, gets sick. Who does he sue? Everybody. Has nothing to do with who is responsible, has a lot to do with who is going to pay his bills.

Why is the liability for a $200 part lower? If the cars can't apply the brakes properly and people die in car accidents, are they any less responsible?

Trucking companies won't say no, because it's extremely unlikely that all the cars will get into accidents all the time, and they don't have to pay more because the car didn't have a driver than they would if the car was being driven by their employee. Why would their insurance rates skyrocket? It appears there will be far less accidents with automated cars.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:09AM (#19389894)
It's not just trucks, though. He gives a lot of examples, some of which are observable today. Like a lot of work done by paralegals and junior lawyers is just research - plowing through books and writing summaries and references. It's slow, tedious, and error-prone. A computer can do it much faster and better. How about reading x-rays? Train an AI by having it review the results from millions of other x-rays. That's a lot of radiologists whose work is replaceable.

And that's really Yang's point. It's not just truck drivers. Any job that is basically rote work - even jobs requiring a high level of education and professional certification - is vulnerable to advances in AI and robotics. If your work isn't essentially creative, there's a good chance that it could be done cheaper, faster, and better by a robot at some point in the not-too-distant future.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by manquer on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:27AM (#19390065)
Unless you are a developer , while we built more abstractions and automation into our software engineering we also attempt more complex problems. I don't see dev being in lesser demand in the next 30 years
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:37AM (#19390196)
Sure. Software is essentially creative work. I'm not worried about our industry. I'm worried about what our industry will do to other industries.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by everdev on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:32PM (#19391448)
I think it will still affect software. Things can always be done faster. I think it'll be like farming where it won't go away but fewer people can do more work.

I can imagine a day where voice recognition can allow marketing folks to just say what they want changed on a website and AI makes the update and asks for confirmation before pushing it live.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:07PM (#19391782)
I'm not worried. I've been in this industry for 25 years now, and seen multiple technical revolutions. (Back in my first serious job, we were hand-rolling streaming data protocols with lex and yacc on raw sockets! There was no ssh, no xml, no json, and http was a lab toy in Switzerland.)

Requirements are hard. Understanding what needs to be done, and doing it all in the correct order, with buy-in from all concerned parties, is an essentially human, creative problem. It's not a simple matter of "marketing folks ask the AI to update the site", because they don't know how to ask it. Software is like all those tales of people getting their wishes granted by a genie or something, and regretting it because what they asked for wasn't actually what they wanted.

And who turns someone's dreams into something the genie will do correctly? Programmers. We're the interface between the world of human needs and the world of technical realities. We're doing craft. Our tools may change, but our problem is constant.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by gremlinsinc on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:50PM (#19392251)
Yeah, software devs will be the rich/elite in 20 years (we'll be the only ones employable).
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by krapp on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:54PM (#19392299)
Nope. Most software development jobs, along with many other "creative" jobs, will be automated as well.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by gremlinsinc on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:17AM (#19398962)
eventually, but -- creative will go AFTER doctors/lawyers/etc... I can't wait for politicians to go.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:48PM (#19391000)
The UBI of $1K a month is insane. This would be 320 million Americans receiving $1K a month per person? That's $320B a month...$3.8 Trillion a year. That's DOUBLE the current Federal government's annual expenditures. He argues, with hand-wavey logic, that this will solve our problems and we can tax tech companies and all of this...but no, there's not enough annual revenue at the big tech companies to cover this enormous welfare program.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:19PM (#19391890)
You don't know anything about his "hand-wavey logic", or you'd know right away that it's not "320 million Americans". It's only adults from age 18-65 (or whenever they choose to retire to Social Security, presumably).
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:04PM (#19393697)
It would be whatever bastardized form of it Congress passes and by the way, Social Security is already on the path to insolvency. It's still a multi-trillion dollar proposal, a huge economic experiment that could easily end in catastrophe and not be easily reversible (as people would come to depend on payments, try taking that away from them). It's batshit crazy.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:26PM (#19393949)
In his book, Andrew Yang points out that one of the major factors damaging Social Security right now is a sharp rise (like a doubling) in disability cases. And the amount of people on disability maps directly to areas of economic depression and underemployment. Basically, it's become an alternative form of long-term unemployment for people who are unable to find work. And worse, since getting a job will likely lead to losing benefits, it actively discourages employment and makes people think of themselves as broken failures.

That all said, what is your alternative? Let huge swaths of the country degenerate into poverty and despair? Wait for them to vote an actual fascist into office? Or riot?

Given a choice between higher taxes and civil war, I will gladly choose higher taxes.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Saturday March 16, 2019 @12:46AM (#19406396)
Sensationalize much? Taxes wouldn't just be a little bit higher under this proposal they'd be double what they are today...in the name of social welfare. And when that ruins the economy, you'll be dealing with another Venezuela.

Social security isn't on its way to insolvency because of disability expansion...it's on its way to insolvency because it was designed in an age when we had an average of three children per female and life expectancy was shorter. Now that we're down to two and possibly dropping...there's less workers per retiree.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by r00fus on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:00PM (#19391130)
Is the UBI taxable income? Perhaps UBI would generate enough revenue to be cost neutral or even cost positive.

Exasmple: food stamps generate $1.73 in tax revenue for each $1 handed out. It's just good policy - to a point.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:55PM (#19391666)
From his interviews the UBI is not taxed, but the money comes from:

1. Consolidating existing welfare programs with large bureaucracies (500-600BN)

2. 10% VAT on companies which report 0 profits (800BN)

3. Projected economic growth leading to sales taxes (this is like the foot stamp example you shared)

4. Healthcare, prisons, etc (100-200BN)

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:08PM (#19393734)
1. What prevents the UBI from generating its own large bureaucracy?

2. VAT taxes come in the form of higher prices on everything. No such thing as a free lunch.

4. Healthcare, prisons is handwavey logic. Again, we already provide free healthcare to the poor via Medicaid. So there are no gains to be had there. He makes the wild guess that welfare payments would reduce crime, even though we saw the highest crime rates in the 80s and 90s prior to welfare reform (which reduced the number of people on welfare). So no, I don't buy any of it. There is no experiment of this being tried in the wild, at the city, county, or state level. Why would you take an epic proposal and immediately propose a huge shift of resources in the economy without any evidence to back it up?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:37PM (#19394035)
1. "The government is bad at a lot of things but it's great at writing checks to people on time", because there's no income cutoff or other eligibility requirements it becomes a lot easier to manage than existing welfare programs.

2. VAT is designed to capture value from companies which employ few people, generate a lot of value, but report little in profits, which are a lot of tech companies today.

4. We spend more on healthcare to worse results than other developed countries, a lot is institutional inefficiency.

There's definitely evidence out there to support that people are suffering more even though GDP goes up, look at the labor participation rate of working-age men in these swing states.

Epic proposal? Alaska has been running a UBI from the 60s, instituted by a Republican governor and it's wildly popular. A UBI almost passed under Nixon as well, passing the house and getting killed in the senate twice because democrats wanted the amounts to be bigger.

The way I see it, we either do this now or we continue to keep our heads in the sand while the country rots from the center.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:02PM (#19404732)
Apple earned $60B in taxable income in 2018. Amazon $2.8B. Amazon has a business model where they continue to reinvest profits in the business. Amazon employs 500,000+ people at minimum wage of $15 an hour. They do plenty for the economy as a whole. And if you tax them with VATs, they'll just increase prices on goods. There is no way around it. If you tax with VATs and extract value out of Amazon, you get less capital investment from companies like Amazon, which are highly efficient at capital allocation. That's the reason our economy grows in the first place. Redistributing capital to consumers only incentivizes and subsidizes consumption. To some extent consumption is good, but too much consumption and not enough production leads to a stale and stagnant economy.

Alaska has a budget crisis right now, and they owe back pay to their citizens on the PFD. Besides that obvious disaster, it's a variable payout based on oil money. How sustainable do you think that will be once, say, electric cars become a thing?

The variable payout has been as high as $2,000 a person per year...to as low as $800 a year.

Alaska has benefited, like many oil-rich nations (including Norway), from a relatively small population with relatively large oil reserves and huge markets to sell those reserves to. Alaska has a population of about 750,000. Smaller than most large U.S. metropolitan areas. If they had the population of Texas (28 million)...that oil dividend would amount to $54 a year (in its highest amount ever).

The U.S. is almost three orders of magnitude larger than Alaska in terms of population. A LOT changes at that scale. Especially when the U.S. is THE largest market on the planet. We are the market other industries strive to sell to. Wreck that market, and you'll wreck the world economy.

(https://www.newsminer.com/news/alaska_news/dunleavy-embraces...)

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by 9999px on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:31AM (#19390119)
I think "progress" is a culturally and personally subjective concept.

To me, a lot of the progress we're making is efficiency only for the sake of profit. We should be answering the deeper question of "what's the point of work?" Do businesses exist to make profit for a small group of people or do they exist as privately-owned community pillars providing services and wages to citizens?

Personally, I lean towards the latter. And that's as a business owner twice-over.

We should also be asking ourselves "why do we make the products we make?" Are we building and consuming to fulfill an urge created by advertising? If so, can we scale back advertising and thus consumption and thus waste?

Unionization and employee-ownership are other options for fairly distributing wealth based on effort. A shop that unionizes can vote to automate – or not – and thus control their own destiny. Granted we're not there yet legally; our laws skew heavily in the favor of business owners. So were a union shop to vote to _not_ automate, a shop that fired all of its employees and automated would more than likely succeed in the market.

And that brings me full-circle – is succeeding in the market and being profitable more important than keeping people employed in a democratically-controlled workplace?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by pxue on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:13PM (#19390597)
Here's my question about unions and worker controlled workplaces.. What happens when the entire shop becomes uncompetitive?

It's the same as when a country is happily going about their day and suddenly tanks show up at your door because someone else wants what you have.

that's just human nature, I don't see a way around it.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by 9999px on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:11PM (#19392492)
I don't believe it's human nature. I believe it's decades of prioritizing profits over civic results – we've warped our culture to the point of valuing monetary progress/success over humanity itself.

I'm sure this sounds very bleeding heart, but as a business owner, I'd rather give up stake in my own business to keep my employees and their families fed rather than opt for automation, firing my employees, and sitting in an empty office with piles of cash.

Business owners and shareholders need to learn empathy and start valuing the community at large over their own narrow interests.

To answer your question, though: I don't know.

The U.S. is an owner/exec-first economy, with labor holding very little political power. "At will" employment and "Right to Work" are inherently anti-union policies and although some states have successfully beat them back (Missouri for example), a majority of the country's labor is still without ways to organize.

It's a chicken and egg problem. A unionized shop probably couldn't compete against a full automated shop (depending on the industry). So until _most_ shops are unionized – which won't happen with rulings like Janus – it's almost an impossible task to organize the working class.

More reading:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2018/08/08/missouri-...

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/06/janus-a...

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chrisco255 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:43PM (#19390928)
Businesses exist to make a profit. Do you care that a washing machine or dishwasher replaces the work of what used to be a labor intensive activity? Do you care that construction workers are using backhoes instead of shovels (which would employ more people)?

Unionization made sense in part due to the very labor intensive work of the early 20th century. Conditions were poor and pay was low and you had massive numbers of people doing related work together. It made sense. Nowadays unionizing is like herding cats across disparate, ephemeral organizations.

I don't think you can take a 20th century approach to 21st century problems.

Workplaces aren't democracies.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by 9999px on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:12PM (#19392512)
> Workplaces aren't democracies.

Some already are (co-ops, worker-owned, etc.) and all _should be_ if we want to keep society from pulling itself apart.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by r00fus on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:56PM (#19391076)
> Businesses exist to make a profit. Is that their only purpose? Profit über alles?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:00PM (#19394262)
Sounds a lot like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism

Yang talks about coming up with a more wholistic measurement than GDP to optimize on which is more in-line with how we value people culturally: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2FnZPXjRyI&feature=youtu.be...

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by r00fus on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:54PM (#19391062)
> Do businesses exist to make profit for a small group of people or do they exist as privately-owned community pillars providing services and wages to citizens?

If that's your take on businesses, would you support a requirement for corporate charters to keep public as stakeholders?

Ie, removing the oft-repeated opinion that corporations have a fiduciary duty to their stockholders to make the most money possible?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by 9999px on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:16PM (#19392549)
I'd love to read more about this. Does this concept have a name? At face value, yes, some sort of contractual agreement that considers externalities of production, employee well-being, etc. sounds like a solid idea.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:33AM (#19389561)
Retraining is a ridiculous proposition to address this issue, which is what he says about the topic as well.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by jniedrauer on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:22AM (#19390007)
Just train all of the cashiers and truck drivers to become mechanical engineers. It's simple! /s
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by everdev on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:38AM (#19390204)
Why do you jump from blue collar to high tech in the retraining conversation? Sounds like an extreme that people aren't arguing for. I think retraining a cole miner to use similar tools or equipment (like in a quarry) would be what most people are talking about. Or retraining retail to be in customer service.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by rubinelli on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:03PM (#19390485)
The Green New Deal would create tens of thousands of blue collar jobs. Can a coal miner be retrained to install and maintain solar panels? I bet they can.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:24PM (#19391931)
So what if they can be trained to install solar panels? Are there going to be gobs of new solar panel installation jobs in their hometowns where the coal mine closed? This is a huge part of the problem. The brightest and most ambitious get out of dying communities and go elsewhere (heck, America is made largely of the descendants of people who did exactly that). But not everyone wants to move away from their hometown. Not everyone has the resources to start over somewhere else, even if they wanted to do so.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by dllthomas on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:41PM (#19394614)
> Are there going to be gobs of new solar panel installation jobs in their hometowns where the coal mine closed?

Maybe if everyone's, say, getting a $1000/mo UBI...

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:31PM (#19395302)
Is anyone silly enough to think even one former coal miner is going to spend their $1k on solar panels?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by dllthomas on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:44PM (#19396276)
I don't see why you're silly enough to think none would. I certainly agree that a former coal miner with no source of income but the UBI is unlikely to, at best. But a former coal miner re-employed, with an additional extra $1k, doesn't seem any more unlikely than baseline.

And if all the still-unemployed former coal miners in town have $1k/mo instead of $0/mo, there is much more opportunity for former coal miners (and everyone else in town) to offer them services.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by thanatropism on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:25AM (#19390043)
Retraining is literally the #learntocode meme.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by haukilup on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:40AM (#19390223)
That seems like a gross oversimplification. Retraining could fit as a component of a much larger plan to tackle the issues facing the job market and employability of people in these fields. Or maybe it can't. Either way, oversimplifying doesn't further the discussion.

It doesn't have to be from coal miner to software engineer, or some kind of massive transformation. Skills training and education for adults is more than that, IMO.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by Grue3 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:47AM (#19390308)
It's not a meme, it's a good advice. There is no person who will regret learning to code. Even if they end up doing something else, knowing how to code would definitely come in handy for something.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by everdev on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:05PM (#19390513)
I think the point of contention is that not everyone is well suited for it. Certain people are strong creatively but not analytically. If you love socializing and want to work with people or love being outdoors and working with your hands or tools there's no reason to learn how to code.

It's like saying no one will regret learning to farm or hunt. They're essential should for some of us but we become incredibly inefficient as a society if we all try to learn all of the important skills.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by thanatropism on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:09PM (#19390554)
My academic background and work experience is 95% outside the software field but I've always liked the idea of programming. Since a little kid with an already anachronic ZX Spectrum. I would write programs by hand in a notebook waiting for it to arrive.

When the time came that my profession sort of blended in with data science (or rather that data science became a part of it and we'd rather keep the domain experts), I had/am having a great time. So I understand the tunnel vision.

The thing is that people have different talents and inclinations. Despite the outstanding role of economic necessity, liking or even being proud of something about one's work life is a psychological necessity that has to be much more common than enjoying code. I see construction workers on top of tall buildings to be, looking into the sky -- they must like this feeling, or the endorphins of hard physical labor, or the fact that something so tangible and durable is coming out of their muscle aches. Or something. There are easier ways to make a lower-class wage than work on top of buildings.

I don't like dealing with new people a lot, so I would be miserable working the cashier in a 24/7 store. But there has to be some psychological return to this work. Despite people resenting it and sort of being stuck for economic reasons.

Would these people have the same sense of accomplishment and belonging-in-the-world as middling coders in the typical death-march situations coders experience in real life?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday March 14, 2019 @08:34PM (#19395325)
It’s idiotic advice. It’s a meme to troll with. Nobody thinks that a 50 year old life long trucker is going to pick up programming. If they do think that, they shouldn’t be allowed to make any decisions for society. Hell, they probably shouldn’t even be allowed to vote.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by shanemhansen on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:52AM (#19390366)
Or maybe the new #learntoread meme?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by anth_anm on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:23PM (#19391358)
and UBI is an excuse to write off the bottom half the population.

All 3 are popular with the HN crowd. Not surprising.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by krapp on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:37PM (#19391494)
The argument for UBI is that society is going to write off the bottom half of the population anyway, so something is better than nothing.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by anth_anm on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:08PM (#19391793)
The counterargument is we could just not write them off.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by krapp on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:32PM (#19392025)
We will, though. Globalization and automation aren't going to stop, and we're going to end up with an entire class of people rendered surplus to requirements whose labor value in the marketplace will be zero or well below subsistence levels.

Trump's populist promises to keep the coal mines open and auto factories rolling and dial the American economy back to the 1950s won't work, the world has moved on. Reeducation and retraining won't work at scale, especially not in the US where education means an unpayable private debt in many cases.

So if not UBI, then what?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:30PM (#19391991)
And how do you propose we do that?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:58PM (#19392345)
First it'll be the bottom half, then the bottom two-thirds, then the bottom 90%. Automation isn't going to stop at manufacturing, truckers, and retail workers: it'll hit radiologists, accountants, lawyers, etc eventually.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:18AM (#19389406)
I don't read him as big on "retraining" at all. He's certainly critical of how it's usually expressed politically - "We'll just turn those 50 year old truck drivers into computer programmers!" It just doesn't work that way.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by Alex3917 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:04AM (#19389275)
He does frequently bring up retraining, but in the context that government-sponsored retraining programs have between a 0% and a 15% success rate. E.g. the graduation rate for former military employees who then go to college is 0%.

So retraining isn't a solution to jobs being lost by automation and even if we get significantly better at retraining it's still probably not a solution.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by eghad on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:22AM (#19389443)
You're going to need to provide a source for your claims that 0% graduate. A handful of my classmates from Carnegie Mellon were veterans (some with trauma) and all graduated within the typical timeline. The NVEST report from 2017 on student veterans [0][1] show an approximate 54% graduation rate within 6 years (18% were still enrolled, 28% dropped out) greater than the general averages. While the washout rate for 2 year programs is particularly high, your idea that retraining isn't achievable is flawed.

[0]https://nvest.studentveterans.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03... [1]https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/04/why-is...

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by Alex3917 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:37PM (#19395692)
Hmm apparently I'm just wrong. I could have sworn there was a Wired article about this from a few years ago, but I can't find any evidence of it online or in my notes or in my previous HN comments.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:57PM (#19391685)
If they got into CMU they're already the cream of the crop. The low rate covers all the other people who never made it to CMU, dropped out of the labor force and got onto disability.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by DuskStar on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:46PM (#19393520)
The NVEST numbers (54%) include everyone though.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:50PM (#19394170)
I see, I missed the part where it was veterans. I'm not informed enough to know why that program's success is so much higher than the ~37% success for manufacturing workers or Michigan's No Worker Left Behind (30% unemployment vs 40% for those not retrained).

If I had to guess, it could be because vets are younger and more able to learn new things, or it could also be that measuring graduation rates is different than measuring employment (plenty of college grads don't find employment in their field of study).

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by bazooka_penguin on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:17AM (#19389397)
Are there any retraining programs that have more than a 50% success rate? Has retraining ever been a realistic option for job loss? Seems more likely the next generation would make up for the lost jobs on paper
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by elliekelly on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:25AM (#19389487)
I always hear about these “retraining programs” but I’ve never met anyone who has done one. Where do these programs even happen? What are they training people to do? Is it offered to people who file for unemployment or meant to be more proactive?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by abecode on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:22AM (#19390015)
I teach data science at a masters programs (University of St Thomas graduate programs in software in the twin cities) and we have some students who are part of retraining programs. Apparently if a big company lays off a significant chunk of workforce and off-shores it, there are programs funded through corporate taxes that the laid off workers can use to go to school. The students in my anecdotal experience (2 semesters so far) are pretty good. I think there must be more than one such program because some students required a sign off from me but others didn't. It's just a few students that I know of so it's not a super large scale but it's nice to know that such programs exist at least.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by elliekelly on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:59AM (#19390445)
Very interesting, thanks for sharing. I'm pleasantly surprised to hear the programs include such high-level courses.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by notfromhere on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:23AM (#19389452)
People don't have that kind of elasticity on skills, the ability to retrain a 20 year old and 50 year old are very different
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:20AM (#19389421)
Nope. Retraining has never worked. Yang is quite explicit about that.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by eghad on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:52AM (#19389722)
And he's wrong. Retraining has been effective in several European nations like Germany, Sweden, and Switzerland, especially for older adults (there's a reason even DeVos and Trump name drop them). The fundamental difference (from the US programs attempted in the past) primarily lies in the amount of money per worker spent and the level of state control/centralization. Furthermore, companies there seem actively enthusiastic about ensuring they have a skilled population pool in the future regardless of the short term ROI.

Personally I think the 2017 tax cuts should be rolled back for a lot of industries and used as an incentive for companies to develop proper apprenticeship programs and collaborate with universities/community colleges/trade schools to teach the exact skills they're looking for.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by esahione on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:32AM (#19390124)
Lol @ software engineers complaining about ageism and at the same time thinking retraining a 50yo truck driver is a reasonable solution
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by haukilup on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:54AM (#19390380)
> Lol @ software engineers complaining about ageism and at the same time thinking retraining a 50yo truck driver is a reasonable solution

I'm not sure who these software engineers are. Anonymous online comments are unlikely to be a good source of determining how many people truly believe what you seem to think some of them believe.

Is retraining a 50yo truck unreasonable? Retraining them to become a software developer is probably unreasonable for most. But what about other jobs and types of labor? What about training them in more general skills that are valued in today's workplace and economy, as a part of a broader approach to tackling the issues facing the job market and economy?

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by drharby on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:18AM (#19389410)
I fear your military stat is inaccurate and taken out of context, making it meaningless for any inference on this matter.

Military population jas a selection bias for people with high thresholds of tolerance for difficult tasks amd by end of training usually have otjer confounding factors affecting their graduation, ie. Ptsd, lack of purpose, loss of fraternity, etc.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:18AM (#19389400)
Can you back that zero percent number up with any sort of data? This article https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/04/why-is... says that the number isn’t even officially tracked, though it’s probably low.

However, it also points out some places do manage to graduate a decent proportion of veterans, so it might be a matter of finding the right approach rather than an impossibility.

Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:41PM (#19394613)
I'd be interested to know how many of those vets end up getting a job after they graduate though, other retraining programs measure job retention as opposed to program completion.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu... by ousta on Thursday March 14, 2019 @09:55AM (#19389209)
that is in every program since dawn of 20th century: Here is https://www.axios.com/trump-workers-program-ivanka-automatio...