Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu...
by krapp on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:37PM
(#19391494)
The argument for UBI is that society is going to write off the bottom half of the population anyway, so something is better than nothing.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu...
by anth_anm on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:08PM
(#19391793)
The counterargument is we could just not write them off.
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu...
by krapp on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:32PM
(#19392025)
We will, though. Globalization and automation aren't going to stop, and we're going to end up with an entire class of people rendered surplus to requirements whose labor value in the marketplace will be zero or well below subsistence levels.
Trump's populist promises to keep the coal mines open and auto factories rolling and dial the American economy back to the 1950s won't work, the world has moved on. Reeducation and retraining won't work at scale, especially not in the US where education means an unpayable private debt in many cases.
So if not UBI, then what?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu...
by beat on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:30PM
(#19391991)
And how do you propose we do that?
Re:Andrew Yang qualifies for first DNC debate with 65k uniqu...
by chillacy on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:58PM
(#19392345)
First it'll be the bottom half, then the bottom two-thirds, then the bottom 90%. Automation isn't going to stop at manufacturing, truckers, and retail workers: it'll hit radiologists, accountants, lawyers, etc eventually.
All 3 are popular with the HN crowd. Not surprising.