The main thing is that unless you're paying really really close attention to the JS that you're executing, you can't trust this any more than you can trust Mozilla and the security of whatever computer is serving their pages. I wouldn't use this for sending data that you're trying to hide from a nation-state, but it looks like a great option if you want to send a video to your grandma without posting it publicly on the internet or teaching her how to use GPG.
I have Signal running on my Linux computer and on my Android phone. On the Linux computer it doesn't have root access, but it does have access to its own files, so in theory there's nothing to prevent it from making a network request and updating itself. Additionally, I don't ever check Signal before installing a new update, I just blindly do it.
On my Android device, I also have auto-update turned on, because my only option is to turn it on for every app or none of them. So there's nothing to prevent Signal from updating itself and changing the crypto. If I were on an iOS device, I wouldn't even have that option -- to the best of my knowledge you can not turn off app auto-updates on an iPhone, but maybe someone can correct me if I'm wrong. In any case, it doesn't matter that Signal is updated "rarely". An attacker only needs to install one back door, they don't need to update it a hundred times.
So for an extremely typical user like me, who has been taught for as long as I can remember that the most secure thing you can do on an OS is install updates as they come in when they come in, doesn't Signal have the exact same problems as Mozilla? If someone compromises Signal's servers, can't they add a side-channel just as easily?
In theory, I could disable auto-updates and only update Signal when I looked at the source code, just like in theory I could examine the JS that I'm executing every time I connect to a site. But in practice, I don't.
When I read tptacek's rant nowadays, the immediate thing I can think is, "The web is malleable? Literally every single computing environment and device I own is malleable." It feels like if I were to take tptacek's advice to its logical conclusion, I would just conclude that ETE encryption in general is dead.
I would assume Signal to have a proper signing infrastructure in place, so that the keys used to sign new releases are not available to the server hosting/deploying the actual update files (or providing them to Google/Apple for that matter). So simply taking over that server would not be enough, as malicious updates could not be installed.
Assuming Moxie goes over to the dark side, however, you are screwed. There's nothing stopping your Signal app from bundling all your plaintext messages once you've entered your password and sending them off to China, save maybe a firewall you have in place. Google or Apple might stop such an update during their reviews, but I wouldn't bet on it.
Again, please correct me if I'm wrong, but Windows doesn't do anything with signing app updates, does it? Come to think of it, I'm not 100% sure my Linux version has this either, since Signal isn't being distributed as part of the official repos.
If Signal is being updated on Windows without validating any kind of signature, could a compromised server even pull off the "send a malicious payload to only one IP address" attack that people talk about with the web?
You can always implement signing yourself, though, without relying on somebody else's infrastructure. Just include the public key in the app itself and use it to verify your updates are properly signed by your private key before accepting them. I haven't checked but assume/hope Signal is doing this with their updated JS packages.
If none of this were to happen, however, then the answer to your last question is "yes", though with a caveat: If Signal's servers are compromised and push out a malicious update, then all bets are off, as the app running on your system has access to all your unencrypted messages. If the compromised server is only one of the messaging/relay servers, however, things are not as bad, as they don't have access to your keys and thus can't decrypt your messages. They can still forward them somewhere else for later decryption, but thanks to perfect forward secrecy this is currently rather unrewarding.
E2E encryption is still valuable, because assuming that the codebase is delivered/signed separately from its app servers, it decreases the number of available attack points. It's usually easier to secure code delivery than it is to secure your entire backend/database. It's even easier than that to secure a private key that you never put on your delivery servers in the first place.
JS has some additional concerns regarding stuff like Spectre and random number generation, but ignoring those for a sec, E2E encryption is in theory viable and valuable on the web, assuming you've split your backend from your code delivery endpoint and are taking extra steps to secure those specific code delivery servers.
But E2E encryption on the web could be improved a lot if we expanded code-signing for browsers. We download code over SSL, but that's just to make sure no one MITMs the server itself. We could, in theory, have some kind of signing system for raw assets that was completely unrelated to the connection to the server -- a "only allow Javascript to download/eval on this domain if it's signed with a key that's not even stored on the delivery server at all" policy. But we don't have anything like that yet.
Is that a reasonable interpretation?
Open the Signal store page and click the dots in the top right of the screen and untick Automatic Updates.
I didn't know that, and there are a few apps that I definitely want to use this with. Why on earth isn't this part of the general settings?
In particular: you'd hope that WebCrypto would have changed things a bit, but, of course, it doesn't: it leaves all the cryptographic joinery up to content-controlled code. You're probably somewhat less likely to have side-channel flaws if you use it, but in reality timing side-channels are more talked about than seen. Who would bother, when they can just deliver a script that exfiltrates secrets directly?
I think you should consider hoisting more of this stuff out into standalone blog posts that you can flesh out and also update as circumstances warrant. I don't think I'm the only one who has learned a lot from reading you, but often felt myself wishing it had been dumbed down a shade for beginners.
Maybe the best argument for it is that blog posts remain mutable and you can add and expand as necessary, unlike these HN posts that are frozen in amber.
I'll work on it.
And, well, you may disagree but to me it definitely reads like a proper rant :-)
Please note that I chose the words "legendary rant" with all the love imaginable and I had hoped you'd interpret it as nothing other than a compliment. I much appreciate your contributions to HN and the internet as a whole.
mind pointing to or sharing them?
Your points around a compromised JS bundle are still possible but that has more to do with a company’s deployment/change management setup than JS itself imo
But that's the only point I intend to address here. If Pascal had been the language of the web then my question would have been about Pascal.
Therefore I don't see how SubtleCrypto changes matters much.
In short, if I get it right, the argument would be that in eg a mobile app, all the e2e logic (the core crypto plus the code around it) go through peer-review, then some release management process, then some review by Apple or Google, before it lands in my hands via their app stores' well secured delivery mechanism. In a web app, a single compromised server will compromise all security instantly. Generally I'm fine with trusting Mozilla's servers, but if I have to trust their servers then what's the point of end to end encryption?
This is only true if the server has access to the keys of your data. E2EE typically means that it doesn't, only you do.
Here's a site where you can test your browser's compatibility with many combinations: https://diafygi.github.io/webcrypto-examples/
1: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/SubtleCrypt...
> WHY CAN'T I USE TLS/SSL TO DELIVER THE JAVASCRIPT CRYPTO CODE? You can. It's harder than it sounds, but you can safely transmit Javascript crypto to a browser using SSL. The problem is, having established a secure channel with SSL, you no longer need Javascript cryptography; you have "real" cryptography.
In our case we aren't doing crypto inception where the cryptography is meant to secure itself. The crypto is being served securely (by ssl) and then used to solve the separate unrelated crypto problem of encrypting random files.
> WHAT'S THE "CHICKEN-EGG PROBLEM" WITH DELIVERING JAVASCRIPT CRYPTOGRAPHY? If you don't trust the network to deliver a password, or, worse, don't trust the server not to keep user secrets, you can't trust them to deliver security code.
I haven't looked at the details of how Firefox Send works, but if you can download and decrypt the file with nothing more than an https:// URL, it seems like you'd have to trust the server, either to handle the cleartext or to provide trustworthy code to handle the cleartext.
I suppose an alternative would be to generate a data: URL, but if it has to include all the crypto code, I wouldn't expect it to be nice and compact.
Sounds like a challenge for the code golfers.
Compare with native tools which you only download once, can check its signatures and which strive for reproducible builds so that multiple parties can verify them independently.
Now I see a similar issue with security experts preaching that merely possessing a single piece of software with a single thing they classify as a 'vulnerability' implies you will be murdered within the next 24 hours, and it seems they'll happily DoS your computer, get you fired from your job, take your second newborn, and blow up your computer in your face if that's what it will take to make you finally feel real danger. Not sure why it takes people so long to see that reality isn't black-and-white, but better late (hopefully) than never.
Humans are always the weakest link with the internet and someday, sometime, bad code (unknowingly) will be pushed and something will happen to someone.
What changed? Is that rant finally outdated? Couldn't Mozilla at any time serve a corrupted JS bundle (with or without their knowledge) which would leak the key somewhere, silently replace the encryption by a noop, etc?
I ask out of interest, not skepticism. I much prefer an internet where we can trust web apps to do proper crypto than one where we have to depend on some app store to somewhat adequately protect us.
[0] https://www.nccgroup.trust/us/about-us/newsroom-and-events/b...